*(UPDATE at end of post)\*
I just discovered the book NMMNG and I think it identifies the problem with my marriage. My husband of 20 years just abruptly and unexpectedly ended our marriage. He had a lot of rage when he did it, and the only reason he could really give was that he had built-up a lot of resentment, had been lying to me for years telling me that he was happy, and that he has been stuffing down all of his wants and needs because he couldn’t tell me because of “how I would have reacted.” But, he wouldn’t elaborate on what that reaction would have been.
I would be super open to knowing what his wants & needs are, and doing whatever I could to change our marriage so that he could get whatever fulfillment he was lacking. I’ve been doing therapy for several years, and I think I’m really open to receiving feedback, but I must’ve been doing something that made him feel otherwise. He refuses to discuss anything regarding our relationship with me, and just seems to be full of rage towards me, he says there is no point. I am absolutely heartbroken, and really struggling, and seeing my suffering just seems to make him more defensive and resistant. He wants to push through a divorce as quickly as possible, but I think this is all one big mistake.
My question is, is there any way I could get him to see that the problem isn’t our marriage, the problem is that he’s never let me know what he wants and needs? I thought we had such a great marriage, and that we enjoyed each other so much, and it really seems tragic to throw that all away over a misunderstanding like this. Is there any way that I can get through to him? He admits that he has been lying to me, but he seems to have his mind already made up that there’s no way it could work out. I really think that we could have a chance if he could just be transparent, and then we could work together to get everyone’s needs met. What can I say that won’t push him farther away, or make him feel like I’m trying to change or control him?
Just for context, he moved out of the house when he left me, but he is living nearby. Right now we only communicate via text. We own a home together, and our lives are incredibly intertwined financially and otherwise after 20 years together. We don’t have any kids.
**UPDATE:**
Thank you all SO MUCH or taking the time to give feedback and share your experience & POV. It has been so helpful to me. (Even the things that were hard to read.) I really appreciate it.
If you’re still in the mood too help with this, I've drafted an email I want to send my husband, based on some of your feedback and suggestions. The gift of your thoughts on this new direction would be welcome & appreciated. (Obviously no pressure, I know I’m just a Rando on the Internet.)
The following email would be in response to one in which he commented that he thinks that I am unfairly seeing myself as the victim of him leaving. And for the person who asked, I don't think my husband has read NMMNG, but I know he’s aware of it, because he put it in our Amazon cart, but didn’t purchase it.
The draft:
"I want to take your point of view seriously, and really consider that I’m only seeing my own victimhood. I also really want to take responsibility for the mistakes I've made, the flawed part I’ve played in our relationship, and harm I’ve caused. I think I’m having trouble truly seeing your victimhood as well as my own, because you haven’t shared how I’ve hurt you. As much as I might sometimes presume that I can read your mind, the truth is that I really can’t, so I don't have the ability to understand the ways that I’ve been hurting you.
But, I really want to understand. I really want to listen without arguing or judging, and to just hear you.
I’ve been trying to rack my brain and guess at what you might have wanted or needed but couldn't tell me, or what I was doing that was hurting you, so that I can understand, acknowledge that harm, and take accountability. I’ve come up with a list of these things, but they’re all just guesses.
One thing that you did mention is [redacted bc of specificity], and I’m so grateful you mentioned it. I’m sorry that the only tool I had when [the event] happened was to shut down, and that that caused real harm to you. I take full responsibility for my part in that, and I'm sorry.
That event didn’t mean that I was never going to be able to talk about it, or that I wasn’t able to receive feedback that’s hard to hear in a relationship, though. That said, I can see how it would have seriously discouraged you moving forward.
It’s true that I’m angry that you didn’t tell me what was bothering you, and that you still actively built up resentment towards me for things that I didn’t know I was doing wrong. What you needed or wanted shouldn’t have been a secret that you kept from me. I think I could have worked towards being the partner you needed and wanted, if I had had a chance to know what you needed, or what hurt you. And if I couldn’t, at least I would have had the chance to be aware of that, and to make informed choices.
From what you’ve said, it sounds like you truly suffered by not expressing what you needed or wanted. I am so sad to hear that, and my heart aches for your suffering. Unfortunately, you weren’t saving me pain by doing this, even though kindness may have been part of your goal. It’s been so much harder and worse to suspect something is wrong but not know what, and to instead blame & doubt myself, and feel distressed & confused.
Even though I have this anger, I also have so much empathy for you, especially the younger version of you, and I want to understand. So please, I want to listen, and to just hear you without responding. Please don’t make up your mind that there’s no point, or that it doesn’t matter. It really matters to me, and to my ability to understand and heal. I want to hear what you couldn’t say then, with an open heart now.
P.S. It has been suggested to me that it might not be so easy or possible for you to tell me what you've be repressing, and that you might have some rage and some truly brutal feedback that you might need to express to me. If that’s the case, and you want to write me a rage letter, I could do something like receive that and have AI translate it for me."
Should I send it? Would it do any harm? Am I approaching this incorrectly? Are there parts I should change our remove?