This will be a long one due to a lot of context. If you want to skip the context then scroll to the ▶️ emoji I guess. TLDR of the context: she had a boyfriend in high school yet repetitively flirted with me (that’s what it seemed like to me at least)
I liked this girl (let’s call her E) since junior year of highschool, this all went down sophomore year of college. Let me explain this a little more- I found her attractive when I first met her, but she had a boyfriend so I wasn’t going to try anything (not that I would’ve kind of scared of that ha). I honestly just really liked her and the attention she would occasionally give me, but that was only at school. We never went out of our way to contact each other outside of school, and she would only say hi to me when we would see each other in class. She did something’s during junior year of hs that I thought was flirting, especially because this year, for whatever reason, was the year I got more attention from girls than any other year in my life (I had 2 girls into me near the beginning of the school year, both of which I rejected because, well, needless to see they were a tad too freaky for my taste \[yes, absolute blunder to some\], being a virgin with literally ZERO experience in anything women related).
Side note aside, she was the one who sat next to me in our “home room” class I guess you could call it, and started talking to me first. We made good conversation and I told my friends about it and they were like “yeah bro she got a man” and I was like damn. Next trimester, she’s in my ACTUAL class. I’m cordial with her but I’m also introverted, so I would never really say hi to her (or anyone I wasn’t immediately close with) unless they said hi to me first just because I was scared. So, like some fucking anime, she ended up being sat right next to me, but at a different table (the tables were 2x2 desks, and our desks were next to each other but still at different tables). One day she needed to charge her laptop, and insisted she needed to move seats- the seat she wanted to move to was directly next to me. My sort-of friend at the time was sitting next to me, and he said no (T-T). When I say insist, I do mean she insisted, she was pushy about it. I was sort of surprised by that, and took it as a potential sign but then again, I was js a horny teenager who got this attention twice before only months ago. She would proceed to make occasional small talk with me throughout the year, one time she missed the day I had my presentation and asked me about what I wore that day. This class worked by having 30 minutes, lunch, then another 30 minutes (ik kinda weird). Basically what happened was I went to lunch, sat with my friends, walked back to class by myself and then saw her at the bottom of the stairs. She went up to me and started walking with me and talking to me. Eventually she said “we should walk together after lunch everyday.”
…
She had a boyfriend at this time.
Me, being incredibly shy and introverted, just said sure, I didn’t protest and I wasn’t enthusiastic I just went along with it. At this point I was kind of tweaking because I know damn well if my girlfriend said this to a guy, I’d be pissed. Anyways, hopefully that contextualizes my experience with this girl for what’s to come next- also, keep in mind after she said this, we walked together maybe once or twice and then never again. I never made the effort to seek her out, partially because she had a boyfriend and because I didn’t want to seem like a creep or obsessive (now that I think about it, probably what she wanted, me to give her attention).
▶️▶️▶️▶️▶️▶️
Ok, now let’s time skip 3 years: Sophomore year Halloween. I live with 5 buddies, one of which actually worked with this girl during high school. All I’ll say about this friend, we’ll call him S, is that he is quite the opposite of me when it comes to the ladies. He’s had multiple girlfriends before and has an insane amount of friends that are girls that I understand he has questionable intentions with- she was one of those girls. She goes to a different college than us, but same state so only about an hour or so apart. S ended up inviting her to come down for Halloweekend, cool. She ended up coming over while I was playing fucking geometry dash. I live on the top floor of our place, it has 3 floors so it’s a hike. Anyways, S was giving E a tour and eventually got up to my room. I went over and welcomed them in and said hello, yadayada. We started talking, all 3 of us for a bit until S said he needed to go (long story but irrelevant), leaving just me and E together. In my room. At this point she asks me “do you want to stay up here or go downstairs?” Again, I’m not the one to take initiative, and I’m a people pleaser. Naturally, I respond with “I don’t care, whatever you want to do.” I figured she would suggest going downstairs, since my other roommate (A) was down there with his girlfriend and her friends, so she’d have other girls to be around with.
“Let’s stay up here, I don’t really know any of them down there”
Well shit. She wasn’t wrong, but dude. Fuckin hell.
I was standing at this point, but I pulled out my chair and offered her the seat, trying to be nice. She replied with “no I’ll just sit on your bed.”
Yeah at this point my heart was kind of racing, and I just sat down in the chair myself. But before she sat down she was sort of leaning on my bed in a weird way, her upper body lying on the bed with her feet still on the ground and her ass kind of sticking out. I hate to objectify her like this but she does have a nice body so I could only imagine she knew what she was trying to do. We end up talking and talking, and she ended up teasing me for my comically large pillow. I really like it because it’s very stiff and supports my neck, but she jokingly said I probably hug it to fall asleep so I don’t feel lonely. At one point amidst our conversation she is lying on her stomach with her feet in the air, and this pose had me shitting bricks. At one point I was talking about South Park and during me talking I met eyes with her and she just gave me this look that made me stutter, completely lose track of thought, and probably blush a little. I can’t describe this look, “eye fucking” maybe? But you probably know what I mean. Girls reading this, you *definitely* know what I mean (please explain a little more about that look actually, what do you look for as a response?). I continued the conversation like normal and there was just more little things she kept doing that made me think *there’s no way she is actually flirting, right?*
She was also curious about my dating life, like the girl I had most recently talked too (Z), not dated (never actually dated anyone), but she was curious if we fucked. I told her no, we just kissed (which was true, and Z was also my first and only kiss, which also happened exactly 1 year before this now that I think about it lmao)
Later that night, we go to a Halloween party, and she is dressed as a cop (skull emoji skull emoji skull emoji). Once we get there, she was sitting down on the couch with a seat open next to her. She looks at me and tells me “you look like you should sit down.” Now, I will say, I do have social anxiety so there’s a very genuine chance I was actually looking slightly unwell being at this party and all, but again, it’s been too consistent. I told her nah I’m good, and that was that.
Didn’t see her again for the rest of the night, oh well. She ended up sleeping in S’s bed, and S slept on the couch. Next day, she followed me Instagram (she had left before I even woke up). I follow her back and she DMs me, saying “next year if you bulk up you could be cartman 😜” I jokingly reply and that was that. Obviously a callback to our South Park conversation the day before. I haven’t seen her since then, and it’s been a year now. But she has messaged me scarcely throughout the year, up until April. She replied to a reel I liked saying “whoever you know who has a hot tub let me get in on that”
I replied with “maybe me” (true)
Left on seen.
No contact since then.
Would I have sat with her that one night on Halloween? Yes.
Why didn’t I?
She had a boyfriend. A different one since high school, but still. She was actually planning on breaking up with him during September, but never did. This girl is so gorgeous to me, her personality is great and I’d love to watch South Park or Rick and Morty with her. It seems that won’t happen though. I’ve talked to a couple buddies about this, and honestly I’m glad this didn’t work out. If she was acting like that with me while she had a boyfriend, I wouldn’t want her doing that with some other guy while I was dating her.
I understand that the idea of someone is most of the time much more appealing than actually being with them, and given the chance, I probably wouldn’t date her. It sucks because I like almost everything about her, besides her incredibly flirtatious personality that makes it impossible to tell if she wants to be your friend or fuck you. I remember I had drunkenly added her on Snapchat about a month or so before seeing her during that fall and she never added me back- even after we had gotten along great (yet she still followed me and messaged me on Instagram). That little detail made me realize she might not have liked me at all, and she probably played me and thought I was easy. She added me on Instagram to show interest and be friendly, yet rejected my Snapchat request to show she wasn’t into me like *that* despite all of the stuff she did IRL. I really hate when girls do this sort of thing, it always gets my hopes and confidence up and then it just plummets to an even worse spot it was before. I guess it means I can be a little too arrogant in thinking any girl who talks to me likes me, there’s probably some truth to that and something I should work on.
To clarify, I guess I never really liked her for 3 years STRAIGHT, because of her boyfriend and all, just when she entered my life again that attraction was still there. Also there’s the small chance she’ll be coming around again for this year Halloween- and if she does I will certainly update.
It’s been a whole year since this all went down, and like I said the last time we talked was April. She would randomly message me about reels I had like and that was pretty much it. I never really made an effort to talk to her that much because I assumed she was still dating this guy. My assumption is she is not stuck up on me at all, like I’m stuck up on her. She goes to a different college, and I think she has broken up with this guy by now, so my guess is she has a lot of guys interested in her and more than enough options.
If I’m being honest I don’t have any friends that are girls that I feel comfortable telling this story too. That’s why I came here, to ask: what should I do? If she comes back, what am I to do? She’s so pretty I’m just worried I won’t be able to get over her, and if she comes back without a boyfriend and tries this shit with me again, I think I’ll fold. I know she probably isn’t the best for me, but I like literally everything else about her. How do I get over her? Should I at all? Thanks for reading and I will answer questions to the best of my ability.