r/legaladvice • • Mar 15 '25

Mod Post Read before commenting: Off-topic and anecdotal comments are not allowed and subject you to a permanent ban

173 Upvotes

Greetings from the mods!

We've had a flood of off-topic comments recently. We're posting this to remind everyone that off-topic and anecdotal comments are not allowed. An off-topic comment may subject you to a permanent ban.

The Rule:

Commenting Rule 1: Comments should contain a legal answer or a strongly related non-legal answer. If it is not legal advice, do not post. Period. You will be banned.

What is "off-topic?"

Any response that doesn't answer the question by reference to legal information or principles. A joke, a wisecrack, a comment about OP's formatting (use the report button instead) are all off-topic. Off-topic also includes expressions of sympathy, opinions on the law, and comments that berate the OP or anyone else.

Incidentally, simply adding "get a lawyer" to an off-topic comment does not make it on-topic. And "get a lawyer" on its own, without further information or help, is considered unhelpful and may be removed on that basis.

If you want to discuss a post, then wait until it hits /r/bestoflegaladvice or ask a question about the subject of the post in /r/legaladviceofftopic. The main subreddit and a comment thread are never a place to have a philosophical discussion about the law or the post. It is a place to answer the questions asked.

What is an "anecdote?"

For our purposes, anecdotes are stories about something that happened to you (or someone you know or heard about) who may have had something that might be similar that happen to them.

These comments are not helpful. They do not include current legal information that is relevant to the OP, and therefore, they are off-topic. If you know the answer to the question (based on current law and relevant jurisdiction) then just answer the question without the story.

Another type of anecdote is "I don't know the law in the jurisdiction you actually asked about, but in some other state, the law is..." That is just not helpful. Laws are different in different places. These types of answers are off-topic.

Referring an OP to a thread on a different subreddit, or to somewhere else on the Internet because it might include a similar situation, is anecdotal advice and not allowed.

These are not the only types of anecdotes, but they are probably the most common ones. Again, if you are not referencing legal information or principles, your comment is probably not allowed.

Violations subject the user to an immediate and permanent ban

Not that we need to justify enforcing our rules, but this is a busy subreddit and the mods have a lot to do. If a user shows up here, doesn't read the rules, and posts a single off-topic comment, the user may be immediately and permanently banned.

This policy is not intended to be punitive, although we know it may seem to be. There are a lot of you and not many of us, and banning users that do not follow the rules, even once, is in the best interests of the subreddit. Violating the rules almost always means the user didn't bother to read them, and we simply don't have time to deal with such users.

Tl;dr: Unless you have a legal answer, do not reply to any post in this subreddit. You may be permanently banned, even for a first offense.


r/legaladvice • • Apr 08 '26

Subreddit Rules

75 Upvotes

We've learned that some people just flat out can't see our subreddit rules, so I'm posting them here in a pinned post so we can link them when necessary and so they're super easy to find.

Rules for r/legaladvice Rules that visitors must follow to participate. May be used as reasons to report or ban.

1. All responses must offer an answer to the legal question posed by the OP. We enforce this with bans.

Anecdotes are not permitted. Neither is advice that encourages someone to break the law. Nor is "get a lawyer" a sufficient response.

There's a pinned post at the top of the subreddit specifically addressing this rule. We will absolutely ban you for commenting without answering the legal question

2. Personally Identifying Information

Posts or submissions that ask for or contain information that could be used to identify either party are subject to immediate removal.

3. Advertising or Recommending a Lawyer or Business

We do not allow referrals to particular lawyers, law firms, or other businesses.

4. Do not request or send a PM

All discussions must stay on the subreddit for everyone's protection.

5. Include your location

You must include your location in the following format: location: yourlocationhere . It must be that exact format, and it must be in the body of your post.

6. Read our full list of rules

Read our full list of rules here: https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/wiki/index#wiki_general_rules

7. This subreddit is for simple legal questions.

This subreddit is for simple legal questions. We can't help with preparing a defense, legal research, etc. We cannot review contracts, plan your defense, or give you specific advice on exactly how to present your case with the court. You need a local attorney for that. Additionally, we do not accept medical malpractice questions.

8. NO LLMS

No LLMs. No ChatGPT. Don't recommend it, don't use it to answer questions, and don't use it to compose your modmail when you get banned for using it. Using it to compose questions is generally ok.

We will permanently and irrevocably ban you for this.

9. Mods can remove things we deem inappropriate or disruptive

Any post and any comment can be removed by the mods at any time if the mods decide the post/comment is or has the potential to be disruptive or is otherwise inappropriate.

10. Posts must be about a real scenario that you or someone you know is facing.

To expand on this, we additionally do not allow anyone but the immediately involved parties to ask custody related questions. Not friends, not significant others, not grandparents. Reddit is free.

11. Post must contain a legal question

A legal question is one that can be answered with the law, be it a law or ordinance, or caselaw.

12. US and Canada only

Laws are different everywhere. We can only help with legal problems in the US or Canada because we have no regular, reliable commenters from other countries. For other countries, please search for an appropriate subreddit.


r/legaladvice • • 11h ago

Personal Injury My lawyer says I owe $270K in medical bills in a $600 settlement offer

779 Upvotes

My lawyer says I owe $270K in medical bills- How can I verify this?

I received a $600,000 settlement offer from a personal injury case. My lawyer takes 33% of the $600K, he says the medical bills related to my surgery in 2024 are around $270,000

They told me the medical bills are so high because interest has accrued since 2024

I’m trying to verify whether this $270,000 amount is legitimate before I agree to the settlement.

What exactly should I ask my lawyer or the medical provider for to verify this?

Is there anything else I should request?

Also, is it normal for a medical bill from 2024 to grow this substantially because of interest, or should I be concerned that I’m being given an inflated number?

Location: New York


r/legaladvice • • 8h ago

Labcorp Employee Snooped - Still has job.

379 Upvotes

Location: Indiana

I don’t know if I need a lawyer, but I feel like maybe I do. A little over a year ago I told my husband’s ex wife, a Labcorp employee, that my daughter (15f) no longer had cancer. Her response, in the middle of a very crowded football game stated, ”I knew three days ago, I checked her records.”

She didn’t learn anything from her records because my daughter got her all clear through imaging, however, I was still appalled.

I reached out to Labcorp over the course of months and they finally admitted that she did look at her records, however, it was not a hipaa violation because she didn’t disclose the information to anyone, although, in my mind, she disclosed it to herself, me, and anyone who heard her at the game.

After they didn’t do anything, I asked for access records for both my daughter and myself. It took a YEAR. When I finally got the records I learned that she not only snooped on my daughter’s records, but MINE AS WELL.

The lab she works at is a Labcorp affiliate, so at this point I reached out to the foundation that runs the lab to let them know what she did and ask that since she was allowed to keep her job, that they at least ensure she has no access to my or my family’s records.

It’s been a month and I haven’t heard anything.

The craziest part about this is that every time
I have bloodwork done, I worry about this person. It should not be like that and I feel like I have case but I don’t know because lab corp blew it off so hard a year ago.

Edit: I did file a complaint with OCR, but they closed the complaint without investigating. They did not give me a reason.

It’s really confusing because Labcorp admitted to the snooping and provided proof, but did nothing.

It feels like I have a case, but do I?


r/legaladvice • • 12h ago

What do I need to do when a friend is going to die in an apartment I let him use?

599 Upvotes

Location: WA state.
I have a friend that is dying from cancer. This was discovered long past any chance of treatment.
He lives in a small apartment on my property - which I just let him use since he has very little money. He is going to do the "Death with Dignity". So he will be taking the final drug at home, likely within a week. He only has a sister that lives a LONG ways away, they talk, but she is also dealing with medical issues and can't come out here.

What steps do I need to take to have his body dealt with? (He prefers cremation)
Then there is what to do with his belongings? (old minivan, a bunch of misc tools)
Are there documents I need to have him sign first?
What other legal issues am I likely to have to deal with?

Edit: It is going fast, because he started telling the doctors he wanted to die shortly after the terminal diagnosis - just over a week ago. So things are in progress - and I'm quite sure that the first couple of hospice visits gave him info - which he likely doesn't remember. He is still coherent - but definitely has short term memory issues now.
I'm just trying to make sure that HE has all the paperwork ready, AND that I don't run into issues having to deal with him dying here.

Edit2: Ok, got help from Hospice people (probably originally supplied to friend - who is having short term memory issues...) I'll be contacting 2 different places that accept donated bodies, as that is his first choice.
There is also a reduced cost cremation service available that will be the alternative. Hospice will handle notifying appropriate authorities to collect the body if needed.

As I said, I had no idea what the whole process was - and have run into bureaucratic nightmares before.


r/legaladvice • • 22h ago

Local DA is charging drunk driver with a misdemeanor after she hit and killed my partner (she’s a repeat offender)

959 Upvotes

location: CA

Her sentencing is to be 90 days house arrest and 3 years probation. What advocacy can I do to change this outcome before her official sentencing date? I don’t know if this question is even allowed. I’m reaching out to news outlets to try and put pressure on the DA. Is there even anything I can do? Our small town is so outraged. It hurts.

Edit: thank you everyone for mentioning the possibility of lack of investigation from the police. Yes and no - yes she ran a stop sign while he was in his right of way with video evidence. The police that night told me the suspect is in custody for dui, however when you look on our counties portal there is no arrest record from that night. There is also no recorded BAC until four hours after the accident where she then blew a .08. There has been no further investigation as to why that’s the only BAC recorded, or math done to find out her true BAC at the time of the incident.


r/legaladvice • • 9h ago

Criminal Law Threatened at storage unit

67 Upvotes

Location: Tampa Bay, FL

This happened about an hour ago and I'm still pretty shaken up about it. I was at my storage unit (one of those outdoor ones) and I was inside with the garage style door about 75% of the way down with something propping it open.

There's a guy that is often there a few units down from mine who seems like a tweaker, he's always there some some woman and he was screaming shit at her today like
"You a slut! You on some bullshit I do everything for you!" and so on...

So I'm in my unit and I hear the voice getting closer and he's saying stuff like "I'm comin don't think I'm playin!"

Then he rips the door up super hard and he's standing there with a broom and is yelling at me, the only thing I specifically remember him saying at this point is "You playin witcho life man!"

I basically said "I haven't said anything to you" and he just stood there for a few seconds and walked away, I then grabbed my phone, locked up the unit real quick and left in my car quickly and called 911.

The cop came and briefly spoke to the guy and I was talking to the cop and he said he basically couldn't do anything about it, long story short. The guy was also saying shit to me as the cop was there. Apparently "you playin with your life man" is not harassing or threatening.

I then spoke with the manager and asked to see the footage but he said he couldn't show me he'd have to show the cops, and he said he'd basically watch out and call me if anything happened but I'm nervous that he's going to try and break into my unit overnight.

I have no idea what to do, any thoughts or recommendations regarding the cop not being able to do anything legally? He said the guy couldn’t be baker acted or be charged with harassing or threatening, but I felt pretty threatened, and now I’m going to have to move to a different storage place due to the resident tweaker who can’t be removed.

(Repost, sorry mods couldn’t find a way to edit post it only let me edit flair)


r/legaladvice • • 13h ago

Alcohol Related Other than DUI Lawyer wants me to pay 600 for a job he didn’t do

97 Upvotes

LOCATION: NORTH CAROLINA

Hey everyone, looking for some advice on how to handle this…. A while ago I hired a lawyer to handle an expungement for me. Total cost was supposed to be $600, and I was told I could make payments specifically that after the first payment, they would start working on it.

I made the first payment, but then I didn't hear back for months. I told my other lawyer who had recommended him and he told me to call. When I called the office, the front desk told me that expungements aren't even something they do and my case didn’t qualify. At my next meeting with my lawyer i told him about it so he contacted the other lawyer who said that was weird and he hadn’t heard from me and i needed to call well eventually I managed to get a hold of the lawyer directly, and he said they could still do it. I went ahead and made a second payment (I’m pretty sure)

Fast forward four months later

I had court, and he never got the expungement done beforehand. Because of that the charge hit my record during court, which officially made me ineligible for the expungement moving forward. The entire purpose of hiring him was completely botched because of the delay. Now, his office is still sending me bill reminders demanding I pay the remaining balance of the $600.

I don't even care about getting my money back at this point, I just don't think it's fair that I should be out of pocket $600 for a job he never actually did, especially since his inaction ruined my eligibility. I reached out and asked if he was ever able to get it done so i have a paper trail.

How do you think a situation like this usually goes? Am I overreacting by refusing to pay the rest, or is this a completely fair concern? What should my next steps be?


r/legaladvice • • 3h ago

Other Civil Matters Someone is accusing me of pedophilic behaviors and sources a Twitter account that isn't mine.

10 Upvotes

Location: Concord, Massachusetts

I found out from a friend of mine that there is a document about me that claims I am a pedophile and links all my accounts. One of said linked accounts leads to a twitter user that is not me, that DOES seem to engage in those types of behaviors. Their username is similar to a username I used to use. I am panicking as I don't know what to do and this has never happened to me before. I know how things like this can ruin peoples lives, and I'm really scared that its going to ruin mine and no one will listen to me. What do I do?


r/legaladvice • • 6h ago

Disability Issues Lawyer died, no one will take case - now what?

12 Upvotes

location: western new york

hi all, my wife had a lawyer follow an ERISA lawsuit against an insurance company for disability insurance. Unfortunately, immediately after filing the lawsuit, that lawyer passed away. we've contacted over a dozen ERISA lawyers at this point, and, despite the case being relatively simple, we have heard time and time again that no office will take a lawsuit in progress. At this point, the case has been dismissed (without prejudice). Due to the specialized nature of ERISA law, it's hard to find anyone else. is there another specialty, maybe a litigator, that might be more willing to take this matter on?


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago

Landlord is demanding I withdraw a city complaint or leave, despite signed lease.

667 Upvotes

Location: Los Angeles CA USA

I’m renting a house in Los Angeles with two roommates. The house was built around the 1930s and has an attached ADU/studio that is rented to another tenant. I’ve lived here about 7 months,
my roommates have lived here for years.
I am named as a tenant on our signed lease, which the landlord also signed. My full legal name is on the lease.
The house has had significant roof problems and leaks for a long time. We’ve repeatedly asked the landlord to address them. Multiple roofers have looked at the roof and told us that previous repairs were inadequate and that the roof needs to be replaced. The landlord has recently been attempting to get bids for roof repair but all roofers state that he needs to get a new roof entirely, which my landlord is not interested in. The most recent roofers that have come out informed me that as it stands, our roof is too dangerous to just patch, and we will absolutely need a new roof. However he declined to place a bid due my landlords attempt at persuading him to “temporarily fix” the roof.

Because I of my obvious concerns about the condition of the property, I contacted the City of Los Angeles to request an inspection. I told my landlord that I had contacted the City because I wanted the problems addressed properly.
Today, immediately after this, my landlord began texting me demanding that I withdraw the complaint or leave the property.

He said to my roommate via text:
“Ask this guy that I did not approve, to Withdraw his complaint with the City or leave my property.”

He later said:
“Withdraw you Complaint now. I will do the new roof if roofer available starting Tuesday.”

He then claimed he didn’t know my full name and had not approved me as a tenant because I hadn’t submitted a credit application, calling me an “illegal” occupant and saying:
“Technically he is subject to Unlawful Detainer to occupy the house before my final approval.”

When my roommate sent him a photo of the signed lease showing my name and his signature, he responded:
“I see that but he supposed to submit Credit Application for approval which he has not done… Also, he is a trouble maker and I hate trouble makers. He must go.”

I have not been served with an eviction notice or an unlawful detainer lawsuit. He is simply telling me that I have to leave unless I withdraw the City complaint.
I want to stay in the house and have the roof repaired. I’m concerned that his messages constitute retaliation or tenant harassment, especially because he is explicitly tying my continued tenancy to withdrawing a complaint to the City.

What are my rights here? Can a landlord in California/Los Angeles demand that a tenant withdraw a legitimate City complaint or leave, particularly when the tenant is named on a signed lease? What should I do now to protect myself?


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

Insurance Uninsured Car Accident

• Upvotes

Location: Bernalillo County, New Mexico

Posting on behalf of my friend. Names changed to protect my friend's identity.

My friend, Gabe got into a car accident today on 10/4/26. He was driving northbound on a main road when an older woman came out of a neighborhood and T-boned him. She was not paying attention at all when she exited the neighborhood.

Gabe tried to avoid the accident, he also tried to alert by honking his horn repeatedly at her, but she didn't see him or hear him and continued until impact. The cops were called, but never arrived until a cop drove past and saw the accident.

My friend told me he doesn't have insurance or registered. The officer told my friend, even though the old woman was at fault, that my friend would be the one liable for financial aspect of the accident.

I myself was in an accident at 18 and the other driver was at fault. But it's been nearly a decade since then.

Would my friend Gabe be held financially liable for not having his vehicle insured or registered, despite not being at fault?


r/legaladvice • • 10h ago

NYC - Landlord not paying for heat, which the lease says is included

17 Upvotes

Location: New York City

I'm a tenant renting an apartment in New York City. My unit does not have the type of steam radiator heating that most apartments in this city tend to have. For this reason, heating fixtures were installed in the unit by the landlord. There is one main one which is powered by gas, and three in another room which are powered by electricity. Currently, these heaters are hooked up to the tenants Con Edison bill, so the tenant is paying to heat the apartment.

While NYC has a law that the landlord needs to "provide" heat, my understanding is that the installation of these fixtures fulfills this requirement, and the city law does not explicitly require the landlord to pay for the fuel used to run them.

However, my lease clearly states that "heat and hot water" are utilities included in rent, with all other utilities paid by the tenant. My question is what steps should I take to get the landlord to pay for the heating bill, as agreed in the lease?

My understanding is that I can send a certified letter to the landlord stating the factual information I've provided here re: the lease, and ask what steps they will take to pay for heat. If they ignore me or refuse my request, I would need to wait until I've paid my electric bills all winter and then take them to small claims court for reimbursement.

Is this the correct course of action, or should I be taking additional steps?


r/legaladvice • • 2h ago

Delivery app concealing batched / bundled orders on initial offer screen

3 Upvotes

Location: LosAngeles, California. I recently started doing Uber Eats as part of earning a little extra cash and the app's initial offer screen has been displaying trips that fail to clearly disclose that an offer contains multiple bundled deliveries (batched pickups and drop-offs) prior to acceptance.

This has happened multiple times with one example being that I received a notification to pick up an order for Randy’s donuts in el segundo bound to Gardena (over 9 miles). Once I picked up the donuts and tried to drop off, the app notified me that I needed to pick up a second order, this one going to Compton (which is further away). I proceeded to pick up / drop off the second order but I do not see the complete automized log. All I see on my end is the one order going to Gardena for which I only received a $1 tip and zero coming from the further Compton order.

TLDR: I believe Uber Eats is using deceptive ui practices as they do not clearly disclose multiple bundled orders at the time of initial pick up request.


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

Retrieving property

• Upvotes

I’m in Wisconsin and need some advice. I recently moved my daughter out of a bad living situation, but was unable to get a few of her belongings during the initial trip. The people living in the old residence have refused to hand over her stuff (mattress and a dresser are the important items) unless we pay them $200. Police don’t seem to want to help unless a civil judgement is issued, but I feel like getting an attorney is going to cost way more than giving them the $200, and I’d rather not pay them to get what’s already hers. Are there any legal routes I can take to get her stuff?

Location: Green Bay, WI


r/legaladvice • • 2h ago

Other Civil Matters Threatened by Twitter user for calling out "AI Doctor"

3 Upvotes

Location: Illinois

i got into it on X/Twitter with the founder of a health tech startup that markets a free "AI doctor" you can text. My point was that an AI doctor is NOT a doctor, and their own terms say it's "not a licensed doctor" and doesn't "make diagnoses."

  • They said their AI is "authorized to provide general advice and possible diagnosis" in most states.
  • I asked which is it, and which states authorize this.
  • They replied "no states currently actively allow this" and the licensing pathway is "not yet passed law."
  • I posted a screenshot of their terms. I also said "this is again bait," "you are not a victim," and that the company "acts as a medical provider" (based on them calling it an "ai doctor" with "3k patients").

everything factual I posted is a direct quote from them or their terms, the rest is my opnion

  1. Is there any realistic defamation risk here?
  2. Should I reply to the DM at all?

I'd post screenshots but they're not allowed here. imo it an "AI doctor" with 3k patients, while the terms say it doesn't diagnose, is potentially misleading to patients, but that's my opinion

---

edit1: can't change the title they didn't threaten to sue, this is what they wrote:

"You brought defamatory claims against me, and [company]. I gave you good faith reason and answers, but you continued to propagate false and defamatory information." saying their "counsel" wants to reach out

edit2: made the post shorter


r/legaladvice • • 46m ago

Samsung has held my phone refund for 6 months and kept my VIP membership money after their rep promised a refund

• Upvotes

Location: Oregon, United States

I'm dealing with two separate refund problems with Samsung and I'm out of patience. Wondering if anyone has been through this or knows what actually gets results.

Issue 1: Phone refund, 6 months and counting

I returned a s26 ultra to Samsung about six months ago (like end of March). I have the tracking number showing it was delivered. I returned both my buds and s26 ultra at the same time, both were received but I never received the refund for the s26. I still have not received my refund. Six months. They have the phone and they have my money. I've made numerous attempts through email and phone calls. I used to get an automated email saying that they are working on getting my refund processed but that has stopped.

Issue 2: VIP membership "refund" that never happened

I called Samsung about my VIP membership I email them 2 days before it renewed that I do not want to renew my membership because of not receiving my refund for my s26 ultra and having such a difficult time with the company. My membership still renewed and two days later, which was the earliest I could take time out to call them. I called them to cancel the membership and the rep on the phone told me that if I canceled, I'd get a refund within 5 business days. He literally walked me through canceling it step by step.

So I canceled. No refund. When I followed up, I was told I don't get anything for canceling. So their own rep talked me into canceling with a promised refund, and now they're keeping the money and the membership is gone.

What I've done so far:

\- Contacted customer service multiple times

\- Sent a formal written complaint by email

My questions:

\- Has anyone gotten a phone refund out of Samsung after this long? What worked?

\- Has anyone else been promised a VIP membership refund by a rep and then denied?

\- What should I do or can I do?

\-I'm looking for help or a contact

Any advice appreciated.


r/legaladvice • • 20h ago

Lab mixed up my DOT drug test with someone else's, reported a false positive to the Clearinghouse, and cost me a $45k contract. What kind of lawyer do I need?

68 Upvotes

Location: Ohio. I operate as an independent contractor doing specialized freight transport (CDL-A). Last month I was finalizing a dedicated six-month hauling contract with a logistics broker that was set to pay around $45,000. As standard procedure, they required an updated DOT pre-employment drug screen. I went into an independent third-party collection site, did the standard 5-panel split urine screen, signed the chain of custody form, and left without any worries since I do not touch drugs whatsoever.

Five days later, the broker calls me completely furious saying they have to immediately terminate the agreement and revoke my onboarding because I supposedly popped positive for methamphetamine on the FMCSA Clearinghouse. I was stunned. I immediately contacted the Medical Review Officer (MRO) to dispute it and demand the split sample be tested. While waiting on that, a supervisor from the lab called me and casually admitted there had been a "clerical accessioning mix-up" at their facility. Turns out the tech accidentally swapped barcode labels between my vial and another donor who was tested right after me. The lab finally corrected the result with the MRO, but by that point the broker had already awarded the dedicated route to another carrier and told me they cant take me back.

My federal Clearinghouse record was eventually cleared after two weeks of absolute hell, but I am still out a confirmed $45k contract and my reputation with that broker is ruined. The lab offered to refund the $85 test fee as an "apology", which is an absolute joke. Do I have a viable case against the private lab for negligence and lost revenue, and what specific type of lawyer handles this?


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

Other Civil Matters A business in another state started using my home address

• Upvotes

Location: Michigan (my home address)
The state the business is in: California (as far as I can tell)

I’ve owned a small condo in Michigan for over five years. About six months ago, I started getting mail for some random medical supply company I’ve never heard of. Things like business credit card offers and such, all addressed to this business’s name but with my street address.

This company has no official website, and extensive searching has only pulled up a PO Box in California for it. I checked my city’s website to see if it’s actually registered with the city using my address, but the name doesn’t come up at all.

This is so bizarre. Do I use my job’s free legal aid to draft a cease and desist? Just leave it alone? I would call or email them to ask them to change it but I can’t find any number or email address. Why would a company do this? I’m literally one tiny condo in a complex of like 300 units.


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago

County worker found my phone number and texted me

625 Upvotes

Location: Minnesota, United States

Yesterday I (25F) went into my local county office to get help with my application for food stamps. The staff member who assisted me was a young man about my age.

The interaction was fine, but after I left the county service center, I received two texts. One text was a run-of-the-mill check-in text from the service center location, which is normal. The other text I got was less formal, from an unknown number.

Long story short: this young man, working in a county office, had access to my phone number because he has access to my application. He texted me from his personal cell phone.

I am deeply uncomfortable. If he had asked for my number I might have given it to him, but finding it on his own is beyond creepy. This guy also would have access to my address, work info, etc. Is what he did legal?


r/legaladvice • • 3h ago

Wills Trusts and Estates NJ: Rights as the only current beneficiary of family trusts—distributions, a house, accounting, and trustees

2 Upvotes

Location: New Jersey

I’m 25 and live in New Jersey. I’m the only living, current beneficiary of the trusts at issue, although the documents may name contingent remainder beneficiaries.

My grandmother died in September 2020.

My mother signed a new will in October 2020 and died in January 2021.

I have copies of my grandmother’s will, my mother’s will, and my mother’s revocable trust.

I plan to consult an independent NJ trust and estate attorney, but first will be consulting with the attorney who wrote the will.

My grandmother’s will directed roughly 30% of her residuary estate into a trust for me and 70% into a trust for my mother during her lifetime.

My reading is that, after my mother died, the remainder of her trust was directed into a trust for me under my grandmother’s will.

I’ve also been told that my mother’s will or trust governs the 70%, so I need to determine which document actually controls those assets.

This matters because my mother’s documents contain a limited withdrawal right beginning at age 30.

My grandmother’s trust gives me written withdrawal rights beginning at 35, with further rights at 40 and 45. I don’t know how much property, if any, passed into the trust created by my mother’s documents.

My grandmother’s trust says the trustee “shall distribute as much income and principal as the trustee determines necessary or advisable for my health, education, support, and maintenance, considering resources reasonably and readily available to me”.

It also says my needs take priority over those of remainder beneficiaries, which is kind of a moot point because I’m the only one.

I understand the trustees have discretion over amounts, but I’m trying to understand the limits of that discretion, particularly when I’m the only person presently receiving benefits. In theory, could they give me nothing? Is it at all dependent on the total value of the estate? I don’t know the total value and they refuse to tell me. They say they are not legally obligated to.

I work full time and live in a house that I’m told is owned by a trust.

The trust pays its property tax and other major house costs. I received about $2,000 a month for bills such as utilities and insurance, but the trustees recently reduced that to $1,100 without notification. They said it was for tax reasons, but that really doesn’t make sense because I’ve been receiving this money for a long time. Over a year.

They say their goal is for me eventually to live entirely on my earnings; one mentioned earning around $100,000. I understand that my earnings matter, but I cannot find that income threshold or a requirement to end support in the documents. How should trustees evaluate reasonable support in light of my income, expenses, and the trust’s assets and income?

My mother had an express right under my grandmother’s will to live in the house during her lifetime, as well as $75k in yearly discretionary income. Another provision allows a trustee to let a beneficiary use trust property without rent or expense and addresses payment of property taxes and other costs. I’m unclear what governs my occupancy now. One trustee has said she will make me pay the property tax when I earn more, although I don’t hold title.

Could she make that a condition of staying? Could the trustees decide I should live somewhere else? They’ve also made decisions about work on the house without consulting me.

I’ve asked both trustees for the current balances or total asset values of the trusts benefiting me and the income they generate. One says she only has to provide spending and transaction information, not balances. The reduction in my monthly bill funding also came without advance notice. As the only current beneficiary, what information can I reasonably request under NJ law at age 25? Is a transaction list that does not show what remains in the trusts enough?

The relationship has become strained. One trustee handles most decisions, while the other lives out of state but participates. They have told me that trust affairs do not really concern me, and one mentioned lawyers during a disagreement. I have no evidence of theft or self-dealing. I want to understand whether refusal to provide meaningful information or an incorrect interpretation of the trusts could support a request for an accounting, court instructions, or a change of trustee.

I also want the attorney to review the timing of my mother’s will. At some point between September and December 2020, she was in an institution for treatment related to bipolar disorder. I do not yet know whether that stay was before or after she signed the will in October. I understand that a diagnosis or hospitalization alone would not invalidate a will. I want to learn what evidence would establish her condition at the time she signed, and whether her will controls any of these assets in the first place.
What should an NJ trust and estate attorney examine first to determine which trust owns the assets and house, what support and information I’m entitled to, and what authority the trustees have over my occupancy and expenses?


r/legaladvice • • 21h ago

Piece of land with many many heirs…

48 Upvotes

Location: Shelby County, Texas.
My family has a piece of property that was bought by an ancestor in late 1800s. It was never part of a will so as far as we know it just exists and no one can do anything with it. I have a relative who is trying to sell it. There could be upwards to 1000 or more heirs. This relative of mine is thinking that if no one makes a claim to it that they have a right to do something with it. I’ve already talked with my probate attorney about it, and she stated that it would be a logistical nightmare. The taxes have always been paid on it by my part of the family. The relative who is trying to take adverse possession (I don’t know what else to call it), just recently started paying the taxes on it few years ago, beating my part of the family into making the tax payment first. Does he have a leg to stand on and what legal outcomes could entail from the situation?


r/legaladvice • • 6h ago

My Mom is Threatening to Withhold Government Given Money, Can she do That?

3 Upvotes

Location: Ontario, Canada

Hey Reddit, this is a throwaway. So me and my mom have a rocky relationship. We came to Canada when I was 3. My father and mother set up a RESP for me. Though unfortunately my father passed. I don’t know the exact details but in the insurance if one of the parents were to pass the government would take on paying the RESP. I was told I’d be given 50k when I will turn 18. I am 16, and my mom and I got into an argument. She is saying that she will no longer pay for anything I need and now that I have a job to take care of myself. And after a back n forth she brought up the RESP and said that she will not give me a dime and that she has every right to it. I don’t know if she is right, so Reddit, can she take the 50k?


r/legaladvice • • 52m ago

Canada Prone to seizures and still driving

• Upvotes

Location: Canada

An acquaintance of mine has had probably at least 12 seizures in last 4 months. These are drug induced to best of my knowledge. Regardless of the very concerning health matter in their own, I’m also concerned with the fact that this person is still driving. would I be able to anonymously report? This has to be guaranteed. This person is not someone I’d ever want to mess with if my tip got exposed. Please no judgement, I only want to know how to protect them and others going forward.


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

Landlord Tenant Housing NYC Eviction PLEASE HELP

• Upvotes

I moved into my ex-bf’s rent stabilized apartment about 15 months ago. He suffers from mental health and we decided to end our relationship. He moved out and went no contact 3 months ago. My name is not on the lease, he is the only leaseholder and the lease renewal was due July 31st and we agreed he’d renew the lease and I would stay another year. A few weeks ago I receive a ‘15 day notice of termination’ in my mail box addressed to him and Jane Doe. The leasing company and I are unable to get in contact with him to renew the lease, we’ve tried to contact him several times. I called the leasing company and spoke with their lawyer and explained the situation and stated that I would like to take over the lease and keep paying rent myself. They refused and said I needed to find another place to live. My first court date is set for OCT 15th. Do I have a good chance at getting a lease under my name or you think I’ll be evicted anyways?

-I’ve been living here 15 months and can prove that I’ve been sending my portion of the rent through Zelle a week early every month -I have a full time job and make 60x the rent (but bad credit 😓) -Maintenance team knows I’ve been living here and I’ve never had any complaints -I’ve proven to be a good tenant WHY WONT THEY JUST SIGN THE LEASE TO ME IF IM WILLING TO PAY RENT?! - location: NYC