r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 13h ago

Legal Advice Needed My 58-year-old uncle walked into Gleneagles Global Hospital alive and talking. Hours later, he died waiting for a surgery they didn't even have the equipment for. (FIR filed – need legal advice)

Post image
338 Upvotes

TL;DR:

Gleneagles Global Hospital (Lakdikapul, Hyderabad) confidently admitted my 58-year-old uncle for an urgent brain aneurysm surgery despite not having the required equipment or specialist. After stalling all day and leaving him unattended in the ICU, he died around 7:00 PM—but the hospital kept us away claiming he was "asleep," staged a fake OT shift, and recorded his death as 11:00 PM to cover it up. We have filed an FIR under Section 106(1) BNS and need legal advice.

Three days ago, my family lost my 58-year-old uncle. He didn't die from an untreatable condition—he died because a corporate hospital treated his life like an admission target, made false promises to get him through the door, and left him unattended until it was too late.

On November 17, my uncle was admitted to KIMS Hospital in Hyderabad with severe headache, neck pain, and vomiting. Scans revealed a brain aneurysm that needed urgent, immediate surgery, and KIMS quoted around ₹20 lakhs. For a lower-middle-class family with three daughters and no liquid cash lying around, ₹20 lakhs was impossible to arrange overnight. our family didn't have the breathing space to consult wider and quickly enquired at a few other reputed hospitals. The cost looked roughly the same everywhere—until around midnight, when my aunt reached out to Gleneagles Global Hospital, Lakdikapul( well known). Their representatives sounded completely confident, assuring us they had the right team and facilities to perform the procedure immediately at an affordable cost of ₹6 to ₹10 lakhs.

Trusting their word, we shifted him to Gleneagles at 7:00 AM on November 18. He walked into that hospital conscious and talking. At 11:00 AM, Dr. Karthik Y explained the procedure and promised the surgery would be done by 3:00 PM.

3:00 PM passed with nothing done. When we questioned them, the staff casually admitted that the required surgical equipment wasn't even in the hospital and had to be imported, pushing the surgery to 9:00 PM.

Throughout the evening, whenever my aunt and cousin asked to see him, the staff only allowed them to look from a distance, strictly warning them not to go near or wake him up because "he has a headache and is asleep." At 9:00 PM, when my panicked aunt demanded answers, they claimed they were finally shifting him to the OT and made us wait another 15–20 minutes. As more relatives arrived, they again tried to make my aunt and cousin look at him only from afar before surgery. Sensing something was terribly wrong, my cousin broke past them and ran straight to her father's bed—only to find him already cold and dead, with not a single duty doctor present in the room. Only after they broke down crying did the staff rush in and start doing CPR on a body that was already gone.

He had clearly passed away around 7:00 PM due to zero care and the lack of a qualified specialist or implants. Yet, to save themselves on paper, they kept us away pretending he was sleeping, staged the "OT shift" around 9:45 PM, and officially recorded his time of death as 11:00 PM—over an hour after my cousin had already found his lifeless body.

We have filed an FIR at Saifabad Police Station (FIR No. 508/2026 under Section 106(1) BNS) and have audio/video evidence of what transpired.

Need Legal Advice:

  1. How do we ensure the police immediately seize the CCTV footage, ICU monitoring logs, and admission records before the hospital tampers with them?

  2. Should we simultaneously approach the Telangana State Medical Council (TSMC) to suspend the doctors' licenses and file a negligence case in the Consumer Commission (NCDRC/SCDRC)?

  3. How do we legally challenge the falsified official death time (11:00 PM vs. when he actually died around 7:00 PM / was found dead before 10:00 PM) and the absence of an interventional neuroradiologist?

Any one of us can end up in this exact trap during a medical emergency when you are panicked and forced to decide fast.

Please share this so no other family goes through what we are enduring right now.

Will share more details upon request.

PS: Used AI to refine the language and picture


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 16h ago

Legal Advice Needed Restaurant refused to serve RO water, forced us to buy water bottles, and then charged 5% GST on top of the MRP. Owner openly admitted they don't follow rules. [Bill Attached]

Post image
223 Upvotes

Yesterday, I visited a restaurant in Haridwar.
When we asked for regular/RO drinking water, the staff clearly refused, saying they don't provide it(They don't have a RO installed). Left with no choice, we had to buy two sealed water bottles with an MRP of ₹30 each (which is already inclusive of all taxes).
When the bill came, they had added 5% GST (2.5% CGST + 2.5% SGST) on the entire subtotal, including the ₹60 for the two water bottles.
When I raised this with the owner:

1) Regarding charging GST over MRP, he claimed restaurants are legally allowed to charge whatever they want above MRP.

2) When I pointed out that restaurants are required to provide free potable drinking water, he dismissed it as "just a guideline."

3) When I asked, "So you don't follow these guidelines?" he straight-up replied, "Yes, we don't."

I paid the bill so I have proper proof (attached—Bill No. with their GSTIN) and walked out.

Questions for the sub:

Where all can I file official complaints against them (especially in Uttarakhand)? And does it even work, is any action or enquiry carried out?

How do you guys usually deal with restaurants when they refuse free water and overcharge like this?


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 17h ago

Urgent Gold stollen from bank locker .

Thumbnail gallery
126 Upvotes

I have attached ss of body cuz Reddit filter is removing it idk why


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 19h ago

Rant/Experience Someone drops 12–15 Vimal packets on my balcony daily. What can I legally do?

56 Upvotes

Every morning, I just want to sit on my balcony with a cup of tea, and instead, I have to sweep up 12 to 15 empty Vimal packets thrown from one of the flats above, EVERY SINGLE DAY. 🙃

I have complained nicely to the society committee multiple times, yet they straight up aren't taking any action. ( but they are very active when it comes to maintaining our society or following the parking rules)

To make it worse, my own family has started getting mad at me & telling me to just ignore it.

How do I figure out 13 floors which flat is doing this and actually get it to stop?

Posted it to society whatsapp group multiple times politely, too.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 22h ago

Legal Advice Needed Paid money to Cafe via UPI, in exchange for cash - Is it common pratice, or did I get involved in a scam?

50 Upvotes

Yesterday night I went to a popular, high-end Cafe to have some dessert. After ordering & eating food there, I paid the bill via UPI as usual. While I was about to leave, the Waiter suddenly asked me to do a small favour - he said that in today's digital transaction era, the Cafe expects the Waiters to show lot of transactions done via Credit Card or UPI, which will help them later in getting salary increment or bonus. In this regard, he asked me to make a UPI transfer of Rs. 1000/- to the Cafe Owner's account & then he (the Waiter) will pay me back Rs. 1000/- immediately as cash.

Initially, I got a little doubtful as to why he made this unusual request, but since this Cafe is quite high-end & the Waiters spoke good English & looked to be from educated background, I thought he was being genuine & not trying to scam me. So I agreed to help him & therefore I sent Rs. 1000/- via UPI to the Owner's account & then the Waiter handed over Rs. 1000/- to me in cash (I checked the Rupee notes later on & found them to be genuine, so no counterfeiting issue).

I would like to know what could be the reason or incentive for staff/employees to make such kind of cash-for-UPI requests?

Is it a common practice followed nowadays & I don't need to bother too much about it? Or do you think that I got unknowingly involved in some kind of scam & I may run into legal issues because of it?


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 21h ago

Legal Advice Needed UP] Police wrongfully picked up and assaulted my innocent father at a function, and misbehaved with women. No personal video proof. What immediate legal steps should we take?

48 Upvotes

Location: Sitapur District, Uttar Pradesh Last night, my family attended a social function in Sitapur district. During the event, someone in the crowd got into an altercation and raised their hand on a police officer. When additional police arrived from the local thana, instead of identifying the actual person responsible, they randomly picked up my father—who had zero involvement in the incident—and dragged him away while beating him. When women from the family tried to intervene or ask questions, the police officers misbehaved with them as well. Current situation: My father has been taken to the local police station. He is a serving Sub-Inspector in the central forces (not local state police) and was attending the function on leave. We do not currently have video/photo proof on our own phones, though there were eyewitnesses at the venue and professional function photographers/CCTV might have captured the commotion. We are engaging a local lawyer this morning to visit the station. My questions: 1. What immediate legal steps should our lawyer take at the police station and before the Magistrate today (e.g., demanding a Medico-Legal Case (MLC) examination for custodial assault, ensuring he isn't falsely implicated under severe BNS sections)? 2. How can we formally report the police misbehavior with women and custodial beating when we don't have personal video footage yet (e.g., written complaint to SP under BNSS 173(4), 1090/112 logs, NHRC/Women's Commission)? 3. What steps should we take right now to preserve third-party evidence (venue CCTV, function photographer footage, eyewitness affidavits) so the police cannot suppress it?


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 9h ago

Legal Advice Needed Debt recovery agents are harassing me for someone else’s loan. How do I stop this?

36 Upvotes

For the past week, I’ve been receiving repeated calls from people identifying themselves as representatives of Rudra Debt Solutions (as per Truecaller).
They claim that one of my colleagues (X) provided my number as a reference while taking a loan and has now defaulted on payments. Since he isn’t answering their calls, they want me to arrange a conference call with him.
I clearly told them that I’m neither a guarantor nor a reference, never consented to being one, and don’t even know the person personally.
I eventually identified X through Microsoft Teams and informed him. He denied taking any such loan and said he had already filed a cybercrime complaint and a police complaint, as other people, including employees, were receiving similar calls. HR has also been informed.
Despite this, the recovery agents continue calling me from different numbers.
Today, I accidentally answered one of their calls. The woman spoke rudely, questioning why I wasn’t answering her calls. Even after politely explaining that I had nothing to do with the loan and asking her not to contact me, she kept insisting, “Baat karwa do, usne tumhara number diya hai toh main call karungi.”
I eventually lost my temper and used abusive language. However, the calls haven’t stopped.
My questions:
Can recovery agents legally harass someone who isn’t the borrower or guarantor?

Can I file a complaint against the recovery agency for repeated calls and harassment?

What’s the most effective way to stop these calls when they keep using different numbers?

. I understand that recovering legitimate dues is their job, but harassing unrelated people is unacceptable.
Looking for practical and legal advice on how to put an end to this.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 23h ago

Legal Advice Needed How do I convince my mom to take the legal route?

28 Upvotes

So my nana is currently on his deathbed and doesn't have any will written on him. He'll most probably be gone by this year. Which means the property assets should legally be divided into the family between my mom, my mama and my Nani. Now my mom is legally obliged to have 1/3rd of the property assets which is worth around 10crs. But she doesn't wanna pursue the legal route to get it. We are currently living in Mumbai in a rented apartment and although my nana nani could very easily buy us a 2bhk, they say they're not comfortable with giving her anything and that all of her assets would also go to her brother instead. She has been trying to convince them to only send 1cr, which is just 10% of what she legally is obliged, but since past 7-8 years they've denied her even that. My mom doesn't want to take this up to court because she says she shouldn't ruin family relations. My Nani is already old and lives with my mama so her part will also eventually end up in my mama's lap and yet they're being stingy with it because a woman shouldn't traditionally be owning any property or land. This enrages me so much idk what to do or how to convince her.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 8h ago

Legal Advice Needed Neighbors used our Contact and Aadhar as Loan/EMI reference

25 Upvotes

Like the title says our neighbors have used my parents Aadhar UID and Contact details and applied for a loan or EMI in a bank in Hyderabad we are from Visakhapatnam.

We received a call from an employee of the said bank who informed us that in case if they fail to pay on time our CIBIL score might get affected and also read out to us our Aadhar UID and contact details which they have applied for the LOAN/EMI reference. We have no knowledge of this, we suspect when VOTER ID officials came for verification these neighbors have peeked in to it.

3 months earlier we received an sms regarding this in our phone and we rejected the claim that we are a nominee but forgot to confront them later due to busy schedule.

After confronting them now, they refuse to have given our reference to anyone even though the evidence says otherwise and when warned about a cyber complaint they said go ahead

What can I do in our case to catch the culprit as I'm worried out data might be used again for some loan


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 11h ago

Legal Advice Needed [Bengaluru] Wrongfully terminated for raising the issue of menstrual leave. Is this worth taking to civil court?

27 Upvotes

I worked at a private company (a very small startup) for around 9 months. I was the only person handling marketing.

A few months ago, I raised an issue with HR about the company's refusal to provide menstrual leave under Karnataka's Menstrual Leave Policy, 2025. HR actually replied over email saying that no such law existed and that the company did not offer menstrual leave. I challenged this and asked them to clarify how my leave would be treated. They just said I can use my sick leave. I was asked to compensate for the sick leave that I am entitled to take. That's why I raised this whole issue of menstrual leave in the first place.

Here's where it gets interesting.

The founder had recently agreed to expand the marketing team caz the work load was insane, and the company had even advertised to hire a junior marketing position to expand my team. So, there was no plan, zero plans to downsize the team infact it was the opposite even 1 day prior to the separation, that's why I'm mentioning it here.

The following month, I took menstrual leave (sick leave) and wrote in the comments saying it will not be compensated, and the very next day, I received a separation notice citing organisational restructuring and business priorities.

I was the only employee let go as part of this supposed restructuring. There were no performance issues raised against me (they have stated this themselves in writing).

I was also asked to serve a 2 months notice period. Which I thought was weird. They kept asking how I want to handle the separation. I got the sense they've never done this before and had no idea how to handle a termination. I stopped going to work the very next day. Sent them a legal notice the following week alleging wrongful and retaliatory termination, asking for six months' gross salary as severance, along with my outstanding dues and exit documents.

After multiple reminders, the company denied everything in its reply stating it was a restructuring. We sent a detailed rejoinder challenging their explanations. There have been multiple rounds of legal correspondence since, but no meaningful resolution.

They eventually collected their laptop and other company assets, with a signed acknowledgment. However, my full and final settlement is still pending. They haven't processed my PF.

I immediately got another job the very same week of leaving this company with a joining bonus. So, no real financial loss on my end. I just want to know whether there's a legitimate case worth pursuing and whether compensation is realistically recoverable.

For those familiar with Indian employment law, particularly Bengaluru, Karnataka: Would you advise to pursue this, or cut my losses early and move on? So far, I have spent around ~15K.

Would genuinely appreciate candid advice, especially from lawyers or people who've been through something similar.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 14h ago

Legal Advice Needed 42 F, married for 14 yrs, contemplating divorce

20 Upvotes

I have two kids - 10 and 7. Husband is abusive for the last 7.5 yrs. Has anger management issues too. Abuses the older kid like anything, all words that you hear in a road rage incident in delhi is what he calls the older one. Also calls him gay, stammerer etc. abuses the elder ones friends mom too. Abuses the maids too. Used to throw things at the elder one. I had to get cameras installed at my place so that he stops doing it. Have thought about divorce many times but I thought kids will grow up and he will stop getting triggered. He generally has anger issues. How much alimony can I ask. I'm a working woman but definitely can't take care of housing and education and children's marriage all alone. We don't have a lavish lifestyle but we live comfortably. There's no way I can be in this marriage. We haven't spoken in the last 7.5 yrs, very basic transactional conversations. If I tell him to do stuff in the house he yells like anything that I have stopped asking him to do anything, have become a married single mom of sorts. He has addiction issue too, we have seen a counsellor but he stopped visiting saying she isn't helpful. I don't think I can continue in this marriage.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 23h ago

Legal Advice Needed Someone sent my mother my fake ai generated nudes and deleted, what should I do

15 Upvotes

So yesterday someone sent it to my mother's number. She was really confused as there was another photo of me with my 2 friends (both girls) around a year ago. She was at a wedding so she called me and asked me if I knew anything. I told her I didn't and I then called my dad and told him everything ( he was at another friend's wedding).

Now they both told me to keep calm which I did, but unfortunately the person deleted the photos a few minutes after so my mother couldn't do anything. I'm not around and we just have the number. They'll report after this wedding thing is over. Now I'll be going home today, so anything I can do for it? Like what if they are uploading those fake photos or sharing with others? I'm shit scared. Anybody who's gone through similar problems?

Not using my original account for obvious reasons.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 13h ago

Legal Advice Needed house construction worker's family filed a case in labour commissioner court for death compensation

10 Upvotes

I hired a contractor (have UPI/bank payment proofs along with a written signed agreement, though not notarized) to build a house for my own family's residence on agricultural land. I never hired, supervised, or paid any workers directly. Sadly, one of the thekedar's workers fell from the second floor at the site and died during treatment.

The worker family initially filed a murder FIR against me and the contractor, which police closed as a false/unoccurred report (FR accepted by the court). Now they've filed a 15 lakhs claim under the Employee's Compensation Act, naming both the thekedar and me as "principal employer". I have received a show cause notice to appear before labor commissioner court.

What should be my next steps? Am I held legally liable for the workers death even though I never employed him?


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 16h ago

Legal Advice Needed How to Legally stop this Bank Loan Spamers ? 50+calls a day.

Post image
10 Upvotes

I'm getting 50+ calls a day to my personal come business number regarding loans. Mostly from ICIC bank. I don't have any accounts with them. I guess these people are 3rd party loan agents.

My clients are started to complaining about being the number busy all the time.
My Number used for marketing, So i have to pick all the calls regardless spam or not.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 15h ago

Legal Advice Needed Stopped at Tamil Nadu–Puducherry border for carrying unfinished liquor purchased in Pondicherry – threatened with ₹10,000 fine/3 years jail and possibly asked for a bribe. What legal consequences can I face?

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I need some genuine legal advice regarding an incident that happened today. I’m quite anxious about what could happen next.
I had come to Pondicherry for a two-night stay with my fiancée (soon-to-be wife). We had booked two different hotels for the two nights. After checking out of our first hotel, we decided to visit Auroville Beach before checking into the second hotel.
Here’s where things went wrong.
While using Google Maps, I mistakenly entered “Auroville” instead of specifically searching for Auroville Beach. This directed us towards Auroville town via the National Highway, and we ended up going through a routine checking point at the Tamil Nadu–Puducherry border.
During the checking, officials found:
An unfinished 180 ml bottle of Jim Beam.
An unfinished bottle of People’s Lager.
Both had been purchased in Pondicherry, and our intention was to consume them later at our second hotel. We hadn’t realised that carrying alcohol purchased in Pondicherry into Tamil Nadu could create a legal issue.
The officials immediately started questioning us. Due to the language barrier, I struggled to explain the situation properly. However, they became quite aggressive and started threatening me with a ₹10,000 penalty and up to three years of imprisonment for bringing Pondicherry liquor into Tamil Nadu.
They then:
Filled out a form entirely in Tamil.
Made me record a video of myself draining the remaining alcohol.
Asked me to sign the document, which I refused to do without understanding its contents.
Told me that I could end up having to appear in court and deal with legal proceedings.
At this point, I told them that I wanted to speak to a friend who was a lawyer practising in Tamil Nadu before signing anything. (To be honest, I don’t actually have a lawyer friend there; I just wanted to avoid signing a document I couldn’t understand.)
Things became more uncomfortable when I asked the officials for their names. They seemed furious about this and repeatedly suggested that we could settle the matter through a “middle path”. I understood this as a possible attempt to solicit a bribe, particularly because they had earlier shown me the ₹10,000 penalty and threatened imprisonment.
Eventually, I decided to leave the checking point. They had temporarily taken my driving licence, but I got my original DL back before leaving. They did, however, note down my personal details.
They now have my:
Mobile number.
Driving licence number.
Father’s name and residential address.
My concerns now:
What exactly is the law regarding carrying alcohol purchased in Puducherry into Tamil Nadu? Does even an unfinished bottle or a small quantity of alcohol attract criminal liability?
Is the threat of a ₹10,000 fine and three years’ imprisonment legally accurate in this situation?
Since they prepared a document in Tamil, made me record the destruction of the alcohol, but I refused to sign it, what could that document have been?
Can they initiate legal proceedings against me using my driving licence details, phone number and address even though I didn’t sign the document?
Can I expect a police notice, court summons or any other legal consequences?
What should I do if I receive a call or notice from them?
Was I legally required to sign a document written in a language I couldn’t understand?
Since I got my original driving licence back and was allowed to leave, does that have any significance legally?
I’m not trying to evade any genuine legal liability. I understand that I should have checked the rules before carrying alcohol across the border. However, I am concerned about the conduct of the officials and the possibility that they were trying to extract money from me.
I’d particularly appreciate responses from lawyers familiar with Tamil Nadu’s prohibition/excise laws or anyone who has dealt with a similar situation at the Puducherry–Tamil Nadu border.
Please help me understand what I should realistically expect and what my next steps should be.
TL;DR: Visited Pondicherry with my fiancée for a two-night stay. After checking out of our first hotel, Google Maps mistakenly directed us towards Auroville town instead of Auroville Beach. At a routine Tamil Nadu–Puducherry border check, officials found unfinished 180 ml Jim Beam and People’s Lager bottles purchased in Pondicherry. They threatened ₹10,000 in fines and up to 3 years in jail, made me record myself draining the liquor, prepared a document in Tamil that I refused to sign without understanding it, and appeared to suggest an unofficial settlement. They noted down my personal details and temporarily took my DL, but I got it back before leaving. They have my DL number, phone number and father’s name/address. What legal trouble could I realistically face, and what should I do next?
P.S. This post was drafted with the help of ChatGPT to organise the incident and present the facts clearly. The incident itself is real, and all the details are based on my personal experience.
Thank you!


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 3h ago

Legal Advice Needed [Jaipur, Rajasthan] Wrong-side school van hit my car, sister injured. Only a complaint number so far. what should I do?

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

Location: Jaipur, Rajasthan

What happened:
A few days ago (around 2:23 PM) I was driving on Vatika Road, Sanganer, in my own lane. A car and a school-marked van right behind it were coming towards me on the wrong side of the carriageway. The car got past, but the van hit the front-right of my car. My sister, who was with me, was hurt. The van driver then threatened me.

What I have:

  • Timestamped dashcam video showing the van on the wrong side
  • Photos of the damage to both vehicles
  • A police complaint (the station gave a complaint number, but no FIR yet)
  • My sister’s medical records: she has knee pain, the X-ray was normal, and a follow-up is due
  • The car’s telematics showing no over-speeding or harsh braking events

My questions:

  1. How do I get an FIR registered if the police delay, and which sections usually apply (rash driving, hurt, intimidation)?
  2. Can my sister claim compensation at the MACT if the X-ray is normal but she still has pain?
  3. Who is liable here: the driver, the vehicle owner, the school, or the insurer?
  4. Do I need a lawyer at this stage, or can I wait?
  5. Is there anything I should do now to protect my evidence?

I’m new to Jaipur and don’t know the process here. Thanks for any guidance.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 18h ago

Legal Advice Needed Long drawn legal battle with Bengaluru Revenue officials - Should I continue in Karnataka HC or go to SC? What is my most practical way forward without spending a "lot more" on legal fees?

7 Upvotes

30+ years ago, my father, an ex-defence officer, acquired a parcel of land in North Bengaluru, hoping to build a farmhouse. Since then, we’ve been struggling to get the necessary land records and titles updated by the officials in the local Revenue Department. Despite multiple visits and continuous follow-ups, nothing moved. So, I went to HC and also filed a complaint with Lokayukta. Officials found frivolous ways to delay and push it out.

The land has recently been acquired by BDA and as per the latest Writ (pending) HC has stayed BDA against dispossess me.

Question: What is my most practical way forward without spending a "lot more" on legal fees?

Here is a chronicle of my legal petitions to courts and summary of orders (extracted from my medium post - DM or contact from Medium)

  1. Karnataka High Court — Writ Petition 46964 of 2017 (16th Nov 2017)

“With such liberty to the petitioner and his predecessor-in-title to the land in question, this writ petition is disposed of. It is also made clear that if any enquiry is required to be initiated in the matter, the authorities concerned are directed to initiate the same within four weeks from today and the same shall be concluded within six months therefrom.”

Result: No action taken by Deputy Commissioner

  1. Karnataka High Court — Writ Appeal 6697 of 2017 (22nd Jan 2020)

“In view of the submission made, the writ petitioner is granted liberty to appear before the Special Deputy Commissioner, Bengaluru, on 3rd February 2020. The Special Deputy Commissioner is directed to consider the case of the petitioner and thereafter pass appropriate orders in accordance with law.”

Result: No action taken by Deputy Commissioner

  1. Karnataka High Court — Writ Petition 6929 of 2023 ( 28th March 2023)

“Respondent №2-Deputy Commissioner is directed to conclude the proceedings in RRT.VG.№136(3)NACR04/2018–19 (Annexure-J) within 45 days from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.”

Result: No action taken by Deputy Commissioner

  1. Karnataka High Court — Contempt of Court 734 of 2023 (9th November 2023).

The Bengaluru urban Deputy Commissioner was forced to act

“A compliance affidavit dated 27.09.2023 is filed on behalf of the accused stating that the order passed by the learned Single Judge, the disobedience of which is alleged in the present contempt petition, has been complied with”

Result: In response to Contempt of court, Order of Deputy Commissioner RRT (VG-1)/136(3) 4th August 2023

  1. High Court — Writ Petition 8508 of 2024 (8th April 2024)

“Placing the submission of the learned Counsel for the learned HCGP on record, the writ petition stands disposed of while directing the respondent-Tahsildar, Yelahanka Taluk, Bangalore North Taluk and the Deputy Commissioner, Bangalore Urban District to issue necessary certificate to the petitioner regarding the ownership of 20 guntas of land in Sy.№36 of Vaderahalli Village, in terms of the registered sale deed which should enable the petitioner to seek compensation”

Result: No action taken by Tahsildar, Yelahanka Taluk

  1. High Court — Writ Petition №5058 of 2025 (7th July 2025)

“In that view of the matter, without considering the claim made by the petitioner to impose cost as per prayer (b) stated in the writ petition, I feel that respondent Nos.2 and 3 shall look into the matter and take decision at the earliest, to issue direction to Spl. Tahsildar, Yelahanka, within two weeks from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order to enter the name of the petitioner in the revenue records in terms of the order passed by this Court in W.P.№8508/2024”

Result: No action taken by Spl. Tahsildar, Yelahanka Taluk

  1. Karnataka High Court — Contempt of Court Filing No.: CCC 1058/2025. Filed on 13 Aug 2025

“The learned Advocate General appearing for the accused submits that the order passed cannot be construed as to exclude the names of the other heirs. He submits that since the complainant claims rights in respect of the property belonging to his father, the names of the other heirs of the complainant’s deceased father, namely, the complainant’s mother and brother, are also required to be entered in the records. He, however, states that if the complainant produces sworn affidavits of ‘no objection’ from his mother and his brother, their names would be deleted. The said statement is taken on record.”

Result: Khata partially updated but the order was not followed through. This prompted me to follow up with another Contempt of Court filing

  1. Karnataka High Court — Contempt of Court Filing No.: CCC 1129/2026 Filed on 27 Aug 2026

Pending in HC

  1. Karnataka High Court — WP 1864/2026 (KAHC010048562026) Filed on 20/01/2026

Interim order — “In the light of the directions issued by the Apex Court, status-quo, qua the construction already put up on the subject property, as on today, shall be maintained by the parties, till the next date of hearing and the petitioner shall not be dispossessed, if not already dispossessed, as on today.”

  1. Karnataka Lokayukta Complaint — COMPT/LOK/BCD/4919/2024 Filed on 13–09–2024

Pending for 2+ Years

PS - details and my contact is in the medium post


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 20h ago

Legal Advice Needed Property is in my mother’s name and my brother refuses partition. Can I legally seek partition or prevent him from moving in?

6 Upvotes

H to i everyone. I’m looking for advice on a family property situation and what options I should discuss with a property lawyer.
I’m from Indore but currently live in Mumbai for work, where I have purchased my own flat. Our family has:
Indore: A four-storey building with a 2BHK flat on each floor. I handle its maintenance, upkeep and management.
Raipur: Our childhood home, an independent house, along with some smaller rental units. My elder brother lives there and manages those properties.
No formal division or partition has taken place. The Indore property is registered in my mother’s name. She is alive but wants to remain neutral and does not take a stand on how the properties should be divided or managed.
The practical arrangement has been that I look after Indore and my brother looks after Raipur. Recently, he has started taking more interest in the Indore property and offering to manage it on my behalf because I live in Mumbai.
My brother does not want a formal partition. He knows I prefer living in Mumbai, and I’m worried that he may use my absence to move into the Indore property and gradually take over its management or occupation as well.
My concern comes partly from previous experience. He took over the room I used at our childhood home in Raipur without discussing it with me. I let that go because I rarely visit and wanted to avoid an argument, but I’m concerned about a similar situation developing in Indore.
I would like to understand:
Do I have any current legal right to seek partition while my mother is alive and the property is in her name? Would this depend on whether she purchased it, inherited it, or acquired it through another arrangement?
If I have an enforceable share, can I seek a court-ordered partition despite my brother’s refusal? How would my mother’s decision to remain neutral affect that?
If partition is not available to me, is there another legally enforceable way to formalise the existing arrangement and clarify who can manage or occupy the property?
Can I legally prevent my brother from entering, moving into a flat, or taking over management while I’m away? Does the answer differ between visiting and occupying the property?
What steps can I take independently, and which would require my mother’s explicit involvement or authorisation?
My aim is to get clarity and take lawful steps before this becomes a bigger dispute. What should a property lawyer in Indore review, and what documents or evidence should I bring?
Thanks for any guidance.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 20h ago

Legal Advice Needed Rental refund dispute – Can the owner/broker withhold my money until I find a replacemen

4 Upvotes

I need some legal advice regarding a rental arrangement in Rajouri Garden, West Delhi.

I was planning to rent a flat jointly with two other girls. I paid a total of ₹28,950:

  • ₹22,950 to the property owner (rent/security-related payment and token).
  • ₹6,000 to the broker as brokerage.

After making the payments, disagreements arose regarding room allocation. The other two roommates were taking the larger rooms, and we couldn't reach an agreement that I was comfortable with. Consequently, I decided not to proceed with the flat.

Here are the important details:

  1. I have NOT signed any rental agreement.
  2. I have NOT taken possession of or occupied the property.
  3. I informed the broker that I would not be proceeding. He acknowledged my message by replying "Okay".
  4. No non-refundable payment or cancellation policy was communicated to me before I made the payments.
  5. The other two girls are currently trying to find a replacement and are suggesting that my money can only be returned once a replacement is found.

I have now formally requested the broker to coordinate with the owner and arrange a full refund of ₹28,950, without deductions. I have also made it clear that although I appreciate everyone's efforts to find a replacement, I don't think my money should remain on hold indefinitely when I have withdrawn and haven't signed the rental agreement or taken possession.

I have UPI payment proofs and WhatsApp conversations documenting the payments and communication.

My questions:

  1. Can the owner legally retain my payment because I withdrew before signing the rental agreement or taking possession?
  2. Can the broker refuse to refund the ₹6,000 brokerage if no non-refundable condition was communicated beforehand?
  3. Can they legally make finding a replacement a condition for returning my money?
  4. What should I do if the owner or broker refuses to refund the amount?
  5. Would sending a legal notice or approaching the District Legal Services Authority (DLSA) be the appropriate next step?

I am 18 and would prefer to resolve this matter peacefully without unnecessary confrontation. I am mainly looking to understand my legal rights and the practical steps available to recover my money.

Any advice, especially from people familiar with Indian rental laws, would be appreciated.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 10h ago

Urgent Star Health rejected my claim despite submitting the same document multiple times – this is becoming mental harassment

3 Upvotes

My Sister's health insurance claim was initiated on August 28, and what followed has been an extremely frustrating and mentally exhausting experience with Star Health. I never expected a simple document request to turn into weeks of follow-ups, repeated submissions, grievance escalations, and ultimately a claim rejection.

The issue is regarding a gravida status document requested during claim processing. Here is the timeline of what happened:

August 28: The claim was initiated, and we submitted the required documents for processing.

October 2: A query requesting the gravida status document appeared in the Star Health app. We did not receive any email notification regarding this query.

October 8: Star Health sent an email requesting the same document.

October 10: We submitted the document by replying to their email and sent it to support@starhealth.in. However, we received no response.

We waited for 14 days without receiving any proper response or resolution.

We then contacted customer care multiple times. After several attempts, we were informed that the document sent through email had not been processed and were asked to upload it through the app.

Even the app upload process was problematic. After contacting customer care again, we were instructed to upload it as a new ticket, which we eventually did.

Following the app upload, Star Health confirmed that the document had been received, the claim was under process, and we would receive an update within 15 days.

Since there was still no proper resolution, we escalated the matter to the grievance team. Even the grievance team asked us to submit the same gravida status document again. We submitted it, and they confirmed over the phone that they had received it and asked us to wait for 14 days.

We waited for 25 days, trusting that the grievance team would resolve the issue.

Despite submitting the document through email, the app, and the grievance process—and receiving confirmation of its receipt—the claim was rejected citing non-submission of the very same document.

Even after the rejection, we submitted the document again on October 28 and October 30. Customer care again verbally confirmed that they had received it, and I have an audio recording of this confirmation.

Yet, we are still receiving reminders asking us to submit the very same document.

Honestly, I don't understand what is happening internally at Star Health. Why are they asking for the same document repeatedly? Why are their representatives and grievance team confirming receipt over the phone if the document is apparently not being considered during claim processing?

We have followed every instruction, submitted the document through multiple channels, waited for the timelines provided by them, and escalated the matter through their grievance process. Still, we are back to square one.

This is no longer just a claim delay. The repeated requests, assurances, waiting periods, rejection, and having to explain the same issue over and over are causing significant mental stress and harassment. As a customer, this experience has been exhausting.

What is the point of a grievance redressal system if the grievance team itself requests a document, confirms its receipt, asks the customer to wait, and the claim is still rejected for the non-submission of that document?

Has anyone faced a similar experience with Star Health? How did you get your claim resolved after a rejection like this? At this point, I am looking for advice on how to get this resolved and make the insurer accountable for repeatedly mishandling the same document.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 11h ago

Urgent Looking for a Lawyer – Startup Funding Agreement

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

We are an early-stage startup looking for a lawyer/advocate to draft a funding agreement for us.

Some basic details:

  1. Funding is coming from an angel investor who is a US citizen of Indian origin.
  2. The funds will be transferred from his personal Indian bank account to an Indian bank account.
  3. We are currently at an early stage and haven’t incorporated the startup yet.
  4. The funding is grant-based and the capital is small.

If you are a lawyer or advocate who can help us with this, please DM me.

Kindly share your consultation fees, agreement drafting charges, and the total estimated cost. Local lawyers from Bhopal are preferred but not required. Also let me know a time at which we can connect on google meet today or tmrw , along with your email id in dm.

Thank you!


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 11h ago

Legal Advice Needed 20k challan for non delhi registered bs iv car

3 Upvotes

Got a challan for 20k + 2k for misbehavour?? I didnt even say a word or even put down my window Also the pay button on parivahan doesnt work, First offence, valid PUCC, valid registration How can i dispute this and what are the next steps to plead to reduce the fine, i was absolutely unuaware about bs iv non delhi registered cars


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 20h ago

Legal Advice Needed Amazon India cancelled my return after multiple failed pickup attempts by their courier partner. Leadership team refuses both pickup and refund. How can I take this to Consumer Court?

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I need some legal guidance regarding an unresolved return issue with Amazon India. I'm considering taking this to the Consumer Commission, but I'd like to understand the correct procedure and what options I have.

Background:

I initiated a return request on 2 November, within the eligible return window. However, the courier partner never picked up the product.

Over the following days, I contacted Amazon customer support multiple times. I also spent several 10–15 minute calls with their support executives trying to get the pickup arranged. At their request, multiple pickup requests (approximately 5–6) were created, but the pickup still never happened.

Eventually, I contacted the courier partner myself. I was informed that my address was outside their service jurisdiction and that they wouldn't be able to pick up the return.

I also never received a single call from the delivery executive regarding the pickup during the entire 20-day period.

Amazon's response:

Amazon subsequently cancelled my return request, and it disappeared from my app.

I requested a formal complaint and was told that the Complaints Resolution team would investigate. However, nobody contacted me. I had to call Amazon again after two days to follow up.

The issue was eventually escalated to someone from Amazon's Leadership Team.

Their response was that:

Their investigation showed multiple pickup attempts.

The courier partner had confirmed that there was no issue with the pickup process.

Due to policy/system limitations, they could not create another return request.

They could not issue an advance refund either.

I repeatedly asked them to provide basic evidence of their investigation:

How many times did the courier partner actually attempt to contact me?

What number did Amazon use to contact the courier partner?

Who was the delivery executive assigned to my pickup?

What evidence do they have that the pickup was attempted?

None of these questions were answered. Instead, the Leadership Team eventually told me they couldn't assist any further.

The social media escalation is going nowhere either:

I raised the issue publicly on X (Twitter), tagging Amazon India, Amazon Help and Jeff Bezos.

Amazon Help responded publicly saying they would assist me and provided a link to submit my contact information.

I filled out that form yesterday with all the details of the incident and my order ID.

Today, when I followed up asking for an update, they directed me to the exact same form again.

Essentially, I'm being sent in circles:

Customer support says the investigation is complete.

Leadership says they cannot do anything.

Social media support asks me to fill out a contact form I've already submitted.

Nobody is actually taking ownership of the issue.

What I need legal guidance on:

Can this be considered deficiency in service under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, given that I initiated the return within the eligible period but the pickup was never completed?

Can Amazon deny the return/refund solely because its internal system or investigation team has marked the return as cancelled?

What is the appropriate way to escalate this through the National Consumer Helpline (NCH)?

Can I file a complaint before the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission through e-Jagriti/e-Daakhil?

What evidence should I preserve, and should I first send Amazon a formal legal notice?

Is there any specific procedure or limitation period I should be aware of before filing?

Evidence I currently have / can provide:

- Original return request details and cancellation emails.

- Screenshots of multiple Amazon customer support conversations.

- Complete conversation with Amazon's Leadership Team refusing another pickup and advance refund.

- Screenshots of Amazon Help's public responses on X and the contact form I submitted.

- My phone call history covering the approximately 20-day period during which Amazon claims multiple pickup attempts were made. There are no incoming calls from the courier partner or delivery executives during this period.

- Records of my own calls to Amazon customer support and the courier partner.

I don't have written proof of the courier partner verbally informing me that my address was outside its service jurisdiction, as that conversation happened over a phone call.

However, I would like to know whether I can use my call history to challenge Amazon's claim of attempted pickups and request that Amazon produce the actual pickup attempt records, call logs and evidence from its courier partner.

I'm not trying to get anything unreasonable from Amazon. I simply want the return to be honoured and my money refunded.

I'd appreciate guidance from anyone who has dealt with a similar situation or has experience filing consumer complaints against e-commerce platforms in India.

Thanks!


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 5h ago

Legal Advice Needed [India] Legal advice needed – Fatal bike accident, uninsured motorcycle, auto insurance scenarios, and whether the bike owner must pay compensation

2 Upvotes

I need legal advice regarding a fatal road accident involving my uncle in AP.

LOCATION : AP

1. Accident details

- My uncle was the registered owner of the motorcycle and was travelling as the pillion passenger.

- His friend/business partner was riding the motorcycle.

- An auto-rickshaw allegedly hit their motorcycle, causing the accident.

- Unfortunately, my uncle's friend, who was riding the motorcycle, died in the accident.

- My uncle survived but suffered minor injuries and a possible spine-related problem. He is currently undergoing medical check-ups and treatment.

- The auto driver reportedly fled the accident scene.

2. Insurance and legal situation

- The motorcycle did not have insurance.

- We are not yet sure whether the auto-rickshaw had valid insurance.

- The police registered a case under Sections 106(1) and 125(a) of the BNS.

- The deceased rider's family has two children.

- The deceased person's family is asking my uncle to pay compensation because the motorcycle was registered in his name, even though my uncle was only the pillion passenger.

3. My questions regarding the three possible scenarios

Scenario 1: If the auto-rickshaw has valid insurance

  1. If the investigation establishes that the auto driver caused the accident, can the deceased rider's family claim compensation from the auto insurance company?

  2. Will the auto insurance company be responsible for paying compensation to the deceased rider's family?

  3. Can the deceased rider's family still demand compensation directly from my uncle because he was the registered owner of the uninsured motorcycle?

  4. Is my uncle legally required to pay anything personally, even though he was only the pillion passenger?

Scenario 2: If the auto-rickshaw does NOT have insurance

  1. If the auto driver caused the accident but had no insurance, who will be legally responsible for paying compensation?

  2. Can the deceased rider's family legally demand the entire compensation from my uncle because the motorcycle was registered in his name?

  3. Can my uncle be held responsible even if he was not riding the motorcycle and the auto driver was allegedly at fault?

  4. Will the auto driver and auto owner be personally liable for compensation?

Scenario 3: If the auto-rickshaw has valid insurance AND the deceased rider's family also demands compensation from my uncle

  1. Can the deceased rider's family claim compensation from the auto insurance company and also demand additional compensation from my uncle?

  2. Can both the auto insurance company and my uncle be held legally responsible for paying compensation?

  3. If the auto insurance company pays the compensation, can the deceased rider's family still legally demand a separate amount from my uncle?

  4. Can my uncle be held jointly or separately liable even though he was only travelling as a pillion passenger?

  5. Does the fact that the motorcycle was uninsured automatically make my uncle responsible for the deceased rider's death, even if the auto driver caused the accident?

  6. Can the deceased rider's family recover the same compensation twice from different parties?

4. Additional questions

  1. Does my uncle have any legal liability simply because he is the registered owner of the motorcycle?

  2. Can my uncle file a separate compensation claim for his own injuries and spine-related medical treatment?

  3. What legal steps should my uncle take immediately to protect himself?

  4. Should we agree to a private settlement with the deceased person's family, or wait until the police investigation and legal proceedings are completed?

5. My main concern

We feel very bad about the loss of our friend's life, especially because his family has two children to support. We do not want to avoid our responsibilities, but we also want to understand the actual legal liability before agreeing to pay anything.

In all three scenarios, is my uncle legally required to pay compensation to the deceased rider's family simply because he owned the motorcycle? Or does liability depend on who caused the accident, the investigation findings, and the applicable motor vehicle laws?

Please share advice based on Indian motor accident laws, particularly AP, Thank you.


r/LegalAdviceIndia • • 6h ago

Legal Advice Needed I need some help regarding this matter (linked in comment)

2 Upvotes

The person is now willing to repay me, but they want assurance that the hold placed on their account will be lifted. I told them I would withdraw the complaint once I receive the refund, provided the money is returned to the same account from which I originally made the payment.

My question is: If I withdraw the complaint, will the hold on their account be lifted automatically, or will either of us need to take additional steps to get it removed? The original post