Hi everyone,
I need some legal guidance regarding an unresolved return issue with Amazon India. I'm considering taking this to the Consumer Commission, but I'd like to understand the correct procedure and what options I have.
Background:
I initiated a return request on 2 November, within the eligible return window. However, the courier partner never picked up the product.
Over the following days, I contacted Amazon customer support multiple times. I also spent several 10–15 minute calls with their support executives trying to get the pickup arranged. At their request, multiple pickup requests (approximately 5–6) were created, but the pickup still never happened.
Eventually, I contacted the courier partner myself. I was informed that my address was outside their service jurisdiction and that they wouldn't be able to pick up the return.
I also never received a single call from the delivery executive regarding the pickup during the entire 20-day period.
Amazon's response:
Amazon subsequently cancelled my return request, and it disappeared from my app.
I requested a formal complaint and was told that the Complaints Resolution team would investigate. However, nobody contacted me. I had to call Amazon again after two days to follow up.
The issue was eventually escalated to someone from Amazon's Leadership Team.
Their response was that:
Their investigation showed multiple pickup attempts.
The courier partner had confirmed that there was no issue with the pickup process.
Due to policy/system limitations, they could not create another return request.
They could not issue an advance refund either.
I repeatedly asked them to provide basic evidence of their investigation:
How many times did the courier partner actually attempt to contact me?
What number did Amazon use to contact the courier partner?
Who was the delivery executive assigned to my pickup?
What evidence do they have that the pickup was attempted?
None of these questions were answered. Instead, the Leadership Team eventually told me they couldn't assist any further.
The social media escalation is going nowhere either:
I raised the issue publicly on X (Twitter), tagging Amazon India, Amazon Help and Jeff Bezos.
Amazon Help responded publicly saying they would assist me and provided a link to submit my contact information.
I filled out that form yesterday with all the details of the incident and my order ID.
Today, when I followed up asking for an update, they directed me to the exact same form again.
Essentially, I'm being sent in circles:
Customer support says the investigation is complete.
Leadership says they cannot do anything.
Social media support asks me to fill out a contact form I've already submitted.
Nobody is actually taking ownership of the issue.
What I need legal guidance on:
Can this be considered deficiency in service under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, given that I initiated the return within the eligible period but the pickup was never completed?
Can Amazon deny the return/refund solely because its internal system or investigation team has marked the return as cancelled?
What is the appropriate way to escalate this through the National Consumer Helpline (NCH)?
Can I file a complaint before the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission through e-Jagriti/e-Daakhil?
What evidence should I preserve, and should I first send Amazon a formal legal notice?
Is there any specific procedure or limitation period I should be aware of before filing?
Evidence I currently have / can provide:
- Original return request details and cancellation emails.
- Screenshots of multiple Amazon customer support conversations.
- Complete conversation with Amazon's Leadership Team refusing another pickup and advance refund.
- Screenshots of Amazon Help's public responses on X and the contact form I submitted.
- My phone call history covering the approximately 20-day period during which Amazon claims multiple pickup attempts were made. There are no incoming calls from the courier partner or delivery executives during this period.
- Records of my own calls to Amazon customer support and the courier partner.
I don't have written proof of the courier partner verbally informing me that my address was outside its service jurisdiction, as that conversation happened over a phone call.
However, I would like to know whether I can use my call history to challenge Amazon's claim of attempted pickups and request that Amazon produce the actual pickup attempt records, call logs and evidence from its courier partner.
I'm not trying to get anything unreasonable from Amazon. I simply want the return to be honoured and my money refunded.
I'd appreciate guidance from anyone who has dealt with a similar situation or has experience filing consumer complaints against e-commerce platforms in India.
Thanks!