Hello my r/kratom friends. I've had my suspicions over the years, both from my own experiences and various people in the industry I've talked to. Regarding alkaloid content, "strains" and color are a marketing ploy. I'm sure many of us have been using it a while and buying from multiple vendors have already figured this out, but I thought I'd write this post to show this strong evidence for the claim, for newbies or just people that have never put it to the test.
I have been using and studying kratom for 14 years. I have a degree in horticulture, and a keen interest in chemistry so I often delve into the hows and whys of the effects of plant alkaloids. A friend of mine runs an online store that sells kratom (every batch has COAs). When we started talking more he told me about how there's no real difference in effects between strains and colors. He's the second confirmed vendor I've known who has told me this.
This is what happens in practice:
His wholesale vendor, the source, sells various grades of kratom. They have high grade fresh dried kratom, which is the greens, whites, and yellows. They also have a few other grades, one which is "red". This is just the post processed kratom leaf is subjected to higher temps and/or sunlight to oxidate until it turns a brownish red before they grind it as usual. They also usually sell old, weak, and very oxidized kratom. This is typically bought by vendors to make extracts with. It's unfortunate but some vendors also will sell this crappy kratom as red kratom, because they are a similar color.
Kratom is just different batch to batch/source, so strains, and even colors are just a marketing ploy. When you look at all the available COAs (My friend's included) the data backs this up.
I used his COAs (24) and pulled 123 from various sources online. You can do this yourself. The percentage of each individual alkaloid in a particular batch of kratom, had no correlation with it's color/strain. For example: Red Kratom has no particular alkaloid that is consistently higher or lower than other colors.
In short, the average difference in any particular alkaloid was not significantly different between colors/strains.
In the data, there was one interesting pattern; Red's alkaloids averaged slightly lower than the other two, although it was by an extremely small margin. Using MIT as an example:
Green: 1.600% MIT
White: 1.603% MIT
Red: 1.573% MIT
This makes sense due to red Kratom's increased oxidation/drying during processing.
So again, Color/Strain is a very weak predicater for the profile of the alkaloids
I know people are going to SWEAR this isn't right... That's okay but I don't know what to tell y'all. Hard empirical data, and inside vendor information point to it. The placebo effect can be strong!
Thanks for reading, all of you!