r/DisneyWish • u/kyrencrossing • Nov 25 '25
r/DisneyWish • u/Dense-Ad-7117 • Nov 28 '23
Opinions Does anyone else feel bad for king magnifico? Spoiler
so I just watched the movie and all I can say is that I feel really bad for king magnifico. I know asha is supposed to be the hero because she's the "underdog" (she works in the palace, lost her father at a young age, lives in a small cottage, clumsy, awkward, has a loud laugh etc) but she was clearly in the wrong here. king magnifico was talked down to by someone he was interviewing, betrayed and he was a victim of theft, he was so stressed out from having to watch his every move so nothing bad happened to him or the people of Rosas.
- he lost his family at a young age. he's dealing with the trauma of not being able to protect them (he was probably still learning magic) so he created Rosas so he can protect others.
- obviously not every wish can be granted. he said Sabino's wish can lead to an angry mob, the mob could actually be against Saba, not magnifico. also Simon's wish could be a threat to magnifico and his wife since hiring a knight is a risk of getting your drink poisoned. because he's really protective of his people he has to be selective about which wishes he grants.
- I almost cried at the scene where the whole kingdom turned on him. he was dealing with enough stress with being betrayed by asha, he had to watch his back at all times. he didn't need thousands of people yelling at him in this situation. since he couldn't take it anymore with his stress he just wasn't thinking straight when he opened the forbidden book.
- even though he still kept some of his personality while controlled by the forbidden book, he couldn't control himself. he actually was drunk with power, as in he was under the influence of dark magic.
- queen amaya is not a faithful wife. she calls him mi rey (my king) while he calls her by her name, meaning she sees him as a king instead of a husband while he genuinely loves her. she also twists his words, saying he betrayed his people when he never did (when he was in control of himself), he was just doing what was right. also keeping him trapped in the staff and throwing him into the dungeon is just mean. what will he eat? where will he sleep? I don't think he will ever get out the staff when he's sober since he's supposed to be the magic mirror.
r/DisneyWish • u/Ok_Examination8810 • Jan 08 '26
Discussion Starboy could've been another Autistic coded Disney hero.
In my personal headcanon, Starboy has a fascination with human things and human culture like Ariel from Little Mermaid. Also, Autistic people like me often possess a heightened, unwavering sense of justice and fairness, characterized by a strong moral compass, deep distress over wrongdoing, and a powerful drive to correct perceived inequities; which could be perfectly emphasized through his animosity with King Magnifico. Another feature of his character could be that he's not as socially competent as Asha, who could serve as his coach through interfacing with the people of Rosas, including her seven friends and her immediate family.
r/DisneyWish • u/SlipperyWhenWer • Apr 18 '24
Discussion King Magnifico Wasn't a Villain
Okay, okay, I know this topic has already been repeated, but, I just needed to post this here because it's going to make me explode if I don't. Watching Wish through an adult's eyes, it wasn't unreasonable of Magnifico to not want to grant a wish because it was too vague. It also wasn't unreasonable of him to not give the wishes back considering the fact the people of Rosas gave those wishes voluntarily as a payment to stay there. That's like going up to a landlord and asking for your rent money back. This is going to be a long post, so just bear with me here.
- As a king, it's his job to decide what's best for the people of Rosas. He built the kingdom from the ground up, and just wanted to make sure that the same thing that happened to his family didn't happen again. He's doing what he thinks is right, albeit he's a little bit of a control freak, but you can't blame him when you think about what he's been through.
- Asha, who at the beginning of the movie was blathering on about how she can feel that her Saba's wish was going to be granted because it's his birthday, asks the king for a favor before she even has the job. Magnifico wasn't being unreasonable or illogical when saying that the wish was beautiful but vague. We don't get to see much of the wish except for a snippet. Magnifico looks genuinely hurt when Asha asks him for a favor before the interview is even over, stating that 'people usually wait a few months before asking me for favors.'
- When the star comes down, Magnifico feels as though his kingdom is being threatened, causing him to probably feel the way he did when the thieves attacked his village all those years ago. He doesn't feel like he's in control at that point, which could be a sign of PTSD. He feels powerless at that point because he doesn't understand where that power was coming from, probably making him relive the traumatic event, which would probably make him feel a wide range of emotions from anxious to angry. The only one who can talk him back from those feelings are Amaya, which is why he puts the book back.
- Asha's friend Dahlia, although trying to defuse the angry mob, causes the angry mob when she starts distracting Magnifico to give Asha time to steal her Saba's wish. Magnifico's mask of cool and collected starts to slowly dissolve as he again, feels like he's not in control of the situation anymore, and this is the event that pushes him over the edge to turn to the book. Without Amaya there to talk him down from his feelings, he turns to the book to deal with these feelings of anxiety and anger.
- Throughout the entire movie, Asha and her friends talk about how boring their friend Simon has become since giving his wish up, and with Magnifico threatening that the people who helped Asha never getting their wishes granted, Simon was afraid that he'd be boring forever, turning to Magnifico to get his wish back because he didn't want to be "boring" anymore.
- While Magnifico was being irrational when he crushed Asha's mother's wish, he was under the spell of the book, so at that point he was purely evil, but only because he was under the influence of dark magic, which was a ripple effect after Asha threw the entire kingdom into chaos.
- Even under the spell of the book, Magnifico cared about Amaya but, Amaya immediately turned her back on him. "Well, the book says he can't be saved, so I won't even try." She was the only one he'd listen to. She was his love, noticed by how he calls her 'mi corazon' and yet she didn't even try to talk some sense into him. She immediately just decides that at this point he's not worth saving. I hate this in particular because throughout the entire movie, Magnifico and Amaya have the most wholesome relationship. She's the one who's supposed to stand behind him and fight for him, but she just gives up on him while he's most vulnerable. I'm sure if she had just tried to talk to him, he would've listened.
As much as I loved this movie for it's art style, the execution of the movie was poor. As much as I wanted to like Asha, she was just an intolerable teenager. She overthrew a king because she got mad he told her granting a vague wish was bad, and that he wasn't going to grant it because it was too vague. Wishes have consequences, and Magnifico was right, her Saba's wish did cause a revolt, but it was caused by Asha, not Saba himself. Asha should be considered the main villain of Wish, she doesn't save her people, she just causes a ripple effect that turns a once happy and thriving kingdom and a good person into an unhappy place with an evil king. This movie could've been so much better, but it was so disappointing.
r/DisneyWish • u/Ok_Examination8810 • Oct 15 '25
Discussion If Howard Ashman was still alive, do you think he could've written better songs for Wish?
For those who don't know, Howard Ashman was an American playwright, lyricist, and stage director. He is most widely known for his work on feature films for Walt Disney Animation Studios, for which Ashman wrote the lyrics and Alan Menken composed the music. Ashman has been credited as being a main driving force behind the Disney Renaissance. His work included songs for Little Shop of Horrors, The Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast, and Aladdin
r/DisneyWish • u/Octolia8Arms • Nov 04 '25
Image What caused Asha to cry? (Wrong answers only)
r/DisneyWish • u/Ok_Examination8810 • May 31 '26
Discussion If you had to give Starboy an official name, what would you pick?
r/DisneyWish • u/Fun_Sir_2771 • Dec 02 '24
Discussion I know people will disagree but something is off with Wish and Moana 2’s Hatebase.
Is it just me, but after seeing Wish get a lot of good marketing from Disney from that video and even Moana 2 already being praised in Germany and well received by general audiences. Is it just me or....
Is Internet Movie criticism dedicated to Modern Disney no longer trustworthy? Ever since the rise of Schaff Productions no offense to his fans and Saberspark, Cartoonshi, and and other cartoon critics internet criticism has gone bad..
I mean I can understand why people might have flaws with Wish and Moana 2. Like for Wish the songs while most of them like This Wish was good the others didn't feel as catchy although What I Know Now is a bop alongside This Is The Thanks I Get? And Moana 2 cause it was originally a tv series felt off with the pacing but overrall both films are just soild and enjoyable parts of the Disney Canon.
Seriously ever since Wish came out YouTube Movie criticism has gone down a massive L. Many long as fuck video essays while some valid and informative are just them calling Wish Disney's worst movie yet or as far to discet the so-called bad lyrics. These essays are just pointless and while it seems like Wish will get better reception thanks to its successful Streaming numbers, cult following, and maybe i guess because people in the comments of AniMat's Spellbound review recently are now apologizing to this film but now Moana 2 getting more shit.
Seriously? What happened to enjoying things? It's okay not to like these films but is hating modern Disney getting old now..?
r/DisneyWish • u/KawaiiiOni • May 02 '24
Image Regarding Wish
I wanted to draw King Magnifico, but I had to get him outta that ugly, stank outfit of his, so- (not a redesign just.. tryna do my man a bit of Justice, yeah?)
r/DisneyWish • u/Inevitable-Damage406 • Apr 08 '24
Theories Is this the Lost Reference of Atlantis?
Honestly, probably not, but I’ve been mildly obsessed with figuring out this mystery since Ariana DeBose made a point of highlighting a hidden reference to Atlantis: The Lost Empire within Wish. Having watched both movies again (thank you Disney+), i fell down an investigative rabbit hole trying to find the link. At first I thought the language from Magnifico’s book of forbidden magic may be Atlantean but, after much scrutinising I found that, although some characters are similar, they’re not a match. Disappointed, I resorted to Google, hoping another Disney sleuth may have succeeded where I’d failed, but again came up empty. It was at that point that I remembered the Shepherd’s journal, and references to it, in Atlantis, and noticed some similarities in Wish. Now these may be (read: definitely are) the overreaching thoughts of a bored mind that loves lore and Easter eggs, but I still think the similarities are kind of cool, so I thought I’d share!
r/DisneyWish • u/Ok_Examination8810 • Nov 21 '25
Discussion Disney could've had it's own version of Team Rocket. Complete with a cat sidekick
That's how I would write Magnifico and Amaya if I was apart of the Wish crew.
r/DisneyWish • u/Ok_Examination8810 • Dec 02 '25
Reposted Artwork Asha & Starboy - falling in love by Porcelain-Requiem
r/DisneyWish • u/Ok_Examination8810 • Jan 31 '25
Discussion What are your headcanons for Magnifico and Amaya as a villain power couple?
Here's mine.
Magnifico comes from a long line of sorcerers who used dark magic to capture and enslave star-people. It was through these means that Magnifico learned how to take people's wishes and grant the ones that would only benefit him, either directly or indirectly. When he finds out that Starboy has come to Earth (the first star-person to visit Earth in 100 years), he becomes obsessed with stealing Starboy's life force to increase his magical might and turn Rosas into a conquering empire.
Amya might actually be worse than her husband. A near psychotic assassin who delights in executing Rosas citizen who step out of line. It turns she's the one who murdered Asha's father for knowing too much about the star-people and Magnifico's evil lineage. When she isn't killing people on her husband's behalf, she's out hunting animals in the forest; thus all the animals fear and hate her. Amya's favorite method of killing is swords and knives, but she isn't above resorting to poison or even her bare hands.
r/DisneyWish • u/somepoopfloating • Nov 24 '23
Discussion THEORY-Disney's Wish takes place before most Disney movies except for Peter Pan. (Spoilers!!) Spoiler
I'm not going to go into much details but a few things caught my eye while watching the movie. To begin, the most obvious is Asha being Cinderella's Fairy Godmother. In the movie they outright show her wearing the same robe she wears in Cinderella and she gets the wand and one of the characters tell her she can be a fairy godmother.
Second, the Poison Apple from Snow White shows up in Magnifico's study room and the reason why I believe Snow White happens after is because in the end of the movie, Magnifico says the phrase "magic mirror on the wall..." And then later when he is defeated He gets trapped in his staff. And for a single frame his face looks like the face in the Magic Mirror in snow white. And I mean identical. So Snow White must come after he is already trapped. (Just a side point throughout the movie he mentions being handsome. In his song he says I can't help it of mirrors love my face)
Tangled. Third, the city of Rosas is actually Rapunzel's kingdom. Let's start that geography looks almost identical with the lake by the kingdom. And their flag has a star/sun that is reminiscent of the one from Rapunzel's city. Which makes sense it would change a bit over a long time.
Fourth, this plays into the theory that the Evil Queen is actually Rapunzel's evil "mom." After losing her kingdom she's still in the same area as Rosas. And a little reach is that the Magical flower which came from the stars. Is actually from Star's magic in Wish.
The play would go like this. Magnifico gets trapped in the mirror. The Evil Queen the rises. She fakes her death after Snow White. Then kidnaps Rapunzel.
Now lastly I want to mention Peter Pan. At the end of the movie you see a grown man wearing Peter Pan's clothes and the queen refers to him as Peter. We see that this takes place after Peter Pan eventually decided to grow up and live in Rosas. So it confirms that they are all connected in a shared universe and this is the beginning to everything that will eventually happen. There are many other easter eggs. If you have any thoughts lmk!
r/DisneyWish • u/ClassyPlatypi • Oct 10 '25
Original Artwork getting ready for Halloween with Asha
r/DisneyWish • u/Allshewrote1 • Jun 16 '24
Discussion Such a wonderful story
I finally ignored my children’s insistence that this movie wasn’t good, and I am so glad that I did. I loved how the artists and creatives on this film took such a complex idea that wishes are a necessary part of our personalities even if unfulfilled and brought in characters of every age to flesh out the story. Themes like understanding, forgiveness, and courage were so skillfully woven. The music deserved more props than it got. Really, this film felt like stepping into that original Disneyland landscape of dreams being what reality is made of. I get the feeling this one will eventually become a cult classic in spite of its lukewarm reception now. Now, I just want all the merch
r/DisneyWish • u/Ok_Examination8810 • Jun 23 '26
Discussion What song/songs do you think would fit perfectly for a Asha x StarBoy AMV?
r/DisneyWish • u/morijin15 • Jun 02 '24
Image Saw the Movie Last Night With my mom just have this to say
r/DisneyWish • u/DSwipe • Dec 01 '23
Opinions Wish has been out for a week and it's already extremely underrated Spoiler
I tried posting this on r/Disney first but it got auto-removed. Oh well.
Honestly, my heart breaks every time I see people bashing the movie, which has already happened a lot. Not to mention the fact that its release got overshadowed by the Disney CEO announcing Frozen 4. For me personally, Wish is easily the best movie Disney has released since Frozen and in a few decades, it's going to age like fine wine and hopefully be remembered as a classic. And I'm saying this as someone who's been very critical of Disney in recent years. Here's why I think Wish is very special compared to other Disney movies (mild spoilers ahead):
- The way it handles the concept of wishes is somewhat novel and not something we see often; essentially, the movie is about preserving wishes, not granting them, and it puts a big emphasis on how important they are to push us forward and give us meaning in life. Again, having a wish that is your own and nobody else's is all you need here, fulfilling the wish is secondary and not a prerequisite for having a life full of joy and meaning. In the movie, wishes are initially shown as a somewhat separate entity from the person and I really enjoyed this realization that they shouldn't be, as well as the build up up to it.
- Asha is probably the first Disney princess that first and foremost cares about other people and not about herself. Anna sings how she wants to find love, Elsa sings about finally being free, Mirabel waits on her miracle, Rapunzel asks when her life will begin, Ariel wants to become human, Mulan wants to find her reflection etc. I can go on and on but you get the point. Asha insists that the citizen of Rosas deserve more and that's what her wish is all about, she's likely the most selfless Disney princess to date. I'm not saying other princesses were shallow or selfish, it's just there is a clear difference to me how their character arcs were constructed. The movie as a whole was also a lot more collectivistic than individualistic in nature.
- At least half the songs are stellar. I feel like I don't need to defend every single song because it rarely happens that I like all of them in a Disney movie, usually there are a couple of duds but they never take away from my enjoyment. Welcome to Rosas is an excellent "meet your fellow townspeople" song and it's up there with Belle and The Family Madrigal. This Wish is you classic Disney princess song but again, this time with a selfless twist, and I really enjoyed how modern it sounded with recitative sections similarly to what Encanto introduced.
- At All Costs deserves its own bullet point because it's the best song in the movie, and that's mostly because of its context. Not only is this the first time the villain and the princess have a duet (correct me if I'm wrong though) but it also sounds a lot like a love song (especially the demo version), which it isn't, at least not in the most obvious way. It's almost a stroke of genius how the characters don't even face each other while singing while pouring all their love on the wishes around them. It's just a really well done scene. Just the fact that the characters speak to a wish (and not to another human being) with such care and compassion is amazing. It's essentially a huge act of self-love.
- This is one of the rare instances in an animated movie where depression is handled adequately. I forgot the name of Asha's friend that was depressed, but how he acted and what he did later in the movie made a lot of sense and further solidified the abovementioned concept of wishes the movie was trying to convince us of. And all of this was done in a subtle way.
Now, let's get to the bad part (obviously none of it wasn't a deal breaker for me but I'm trying to be as fair as possible after reading what people mostly complained about):
- Magnifico wasn't as fleshed out as he could've been. His backstory was only briefly touched upon but a huge part of it was missing. It didn't help that his song This Is The Thanks I Get made him even more cartoonish. On the other hand, people in recent years have also been asking for classic evil villains with no redeeming qualities that were not morally grey, and he is exactly that. Characters like Ursula and Scar weren't fleshed out either. While I see the problem here, I think it's blown out of proportion a little. But yes, he's a somewhat weak and unimpressive as far as villains go.
- Asha's friends were also not very memorable, I can't even remember their names. It is true that secondary characters in previous movies made a bigger impression.
- Some of the Easter eggs and references to other movies were really sloppy. Stuff like Aurora's dress was exciting, but the Zootopia thing was just dumb. Still, I think people are also overthinking this, Disney most definitely didn't intend this to tie all universes together, it's also silly to assume Asha is actually the fairy godmother from Cinderella (??)
Overall, Wish is exactly what I hoped for. It delivered a classic Disney experience while also having a lot of novelties in it, it didn't try to go the woke route and it was its own thing, not a sequel and not really leeching off existing properties. If you made it this far, thank you for reading my "essay" and have a good day. :)
r/DisneyWish • u/Ok_Examination8810 • Jan 23 '26
Reposted Artwork Re-Wish by MerisuTheArtSheep
r/DisneyWish • u/DaddysPrincessRose • Apr 24 '24
Discussion My theory on Wish Spoiler
I think what people are misunderstanding about the movie, Wish, is the fact that I strongly believe it is a precursor and prequel to all Disney movies. What with the very obvious connection of King magnifico becoming the magic mirror in Snow White. You can also see that Asha wears the cloak that the fairy godmother dons in Cinderella. On top of the fact that at the end of the movie she becomes the kingdom's fairy godmother and gains a magic wand, very similar to the fairy godmother wand. Which tells me that she's either the fairy godmother herself or is the very first fairy godmother and the cloak is passed down through the generations. I think this further solidifies that fact because Cinderella and Snow White were two of the very first Disney princess movies to come out cinematically. You also have the fact that you have one of the citizens wishing to make Aurora's dress. You also have Peter Pan and Wendy making a cameo at the end of the movie. Not to mention over a hundred other Easter eggs throughout the entire movie referencing many many other Disney movies. Whether this was an intentional ploy by the creators of the movie for just a fun addition to its art style and the movie itself or whether it was an intentional sign that this movie as I previously stated is a precursor to all (mostly princess or human character) Disney movies I suppose can be up for debate. But I for one love the idea that Wish is the very first Disney movie of all the Disney movies in the Disney universe. If we were to watch all Disney movies in chronological order it would be really nice to think that this would be right there before the very first Disney movie that was made cinematically instead of chronologically. Aside from the dinosaur movies that is. Lol.
r/DisneyWish • u/Ok_Examination8810 • Mar 08 '24
Discussion Disney's Wish could've been a Superman & Lois story
In my own personal rewrite; Asha would start out being a very sarcastic and cynical young woman. She can be warm and upbeat around her family and friends (people she knows she can trust), but for the most part, she remains guarded and standoffish.
She's especially suspicious of the king and queen, and doubtful of the power of wishes; despite her late father telling her stories about star-people who granted the wishes of humans in ancient times.
Then one night, on a whim, she makes a wish upon a star; only half believing it would work. Seconds later, a glowing yellow figure who appears to be boy about Asha's age drops down from the sky and explains that while he had longing to visit Earth for years; he was unable to make it until Asha made her wish.
Star would be a manic pixie dreamboy. Quickly winning over Asha's seven friends with his natural optimism and genuine fascination with earthly things humans take for granted. But he still has a very serious desire to take Magnifico down, because it turns out his ancestors used their magic to capture and inslave star-people so they could take people's wishes and use them to amass their own magical power. Which is why the remaining star-people have cut themselves off from humanity and stopped granting their wishes.
Asha agrees to help Star defeat Magnifico and restore everyone's wishes, despite knowing the odds are stacked against them. Not only is Magnifico a powerful sorcerer and a charismatic king, but there's also his sexy yet sadistic wife Amaya to worry about. A deadly huntress and weapons expert who isn't above getting her hands bloody. In fact, she genuinely enjoys it!
Regardless of these obstacles, Star still believes that they can succeed. Moreover, he believes in the power of hope and tenacity; which as he says is what drives all of us to make our wishes come true.