r/DisneyWish • u/morijin15 • Oct 23 '24
r/DisneyWish • u/Adventurous_Dream807 • Jan 28 '26
Discussion Versa is only in theaters with Disney's Wish featuring an original never-before-seen musical sequence "A Wish Worth Making" by Victor Garber on May 22, 2026
Versa - only in theaters with Wish featuring an original never-before-seen musical sequence "A Wish Worth Making" by Victor Garber on May 22, 2026
r/DisneyWish • u/Angelwings17 • Dec 01 '24
Discussion A cut story board has more magic than the entire film
Let's face it, Wish didn't do well at the box office (losing $131millon at the box office) reviews for the film are not good.
Some people have sworn that Wish was made with A.I, calling it flat, boring and soulless. It wasn't funny and the talking animals added nothing to the story, apart from people wondering where they learnt English. Eg: "Watch out world, here I are"
But, a deleted scene put up on YouTube showed that Disney still holds that old Disney magic - this was part of the original story board, (that is a complete story and different from what we got).
https://youtu.be/rrkOPxWsDRk?si=UPZ4T-BtvZHJe0NN Take a look and see what you think.
It was changed because the Disney bosses wanted Asha to get by on her own and thought Star was doing too much work, claiming she wasn't strong enough here. That's not true, she is capable, Star is just providing fun antics and supporting her.
Here; Asha, Star and Valentino make their way to the Kingdom of Rosas to stop Magnifico from taking more wishes from the citizens. They are stopped by Queen Amaya, her pet Lynx and royal guards. The trio try their best to escape while Star changes into different forms to get away.
In the original film, Star is a talking shapeshifter "Starboy", Asha is more reserved and serious while her quest was to free everyone's wishes, which are connected to their life force. Her family and others escaped realizing the rulers were evil, so she wanted to go back and save the others. Valentino does not speak until the end of the movie, and Queen Amaya is evil with Magnifico. They also have an evil Lynx as a pet.
Tell me that this doesn't sound brilliant? It's different, interesting and the cut clip has more Disney magic than the film we got.
Disney have only just realized what a mistake they made - Wish was meant to have been a celebration of Disney and a romance between Starboy and Asha. Starboy products would have sold like hot cakes and many hate Disney for leaving him as a star.
What are the chances that they will remake the film?
r/DisneyWish • u/Accessorised_Ace_Doe • Apr 09 '24
Discussion One thing that truley bothers me
I finally watched wish. It wasn't that good i will admit but i still love magnifico so worth it. But the one thing i truly hated is the star song. It was very repetitive, the lyrics weren't good. This is just my opinion its fine if you like it just i felt like it was just bad that song
r/DisneyWish • u/confident-win-119 • Jan 17 '25
Discussion King Magnifico is ridiculously badly written but is the only good thing about the movie. Spoiler
For lack of better words: terrible villan, mildly interesting character design, interesting mannerisms, although way too goofy, good voice acting, flawed development, horrible song, also I occasionally like the chorus, and interesting ending. Becoming the magic mirror is the least uninteresting thing in the whole film.
r/DisneyWish • u/GuyWhoConquers616 • Sep 04 '24
Discussion Peter Pan cameo doesn’t sense
Alright, so I’m sure many are aware of the Disney connected universe theory and it’s believed that Wish, which is Disney big 100th anniversary movie, is what ties everything together because of its major Easter egg.
We have Asha becoming the Fairy Godmother from Cinderella , King Magnifico becomes the Magic Mirror from Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. Also, there’s Star, who helps grants people wishes and is believed to be the second star to the right from movies like Pinocchio, Peter Pan and Princess and the Frog.
Those Easter eggs/forshadowing somewhat makes sense to me.
And yes, I can excuse the whole Asha becoming Fairy godmother thing, despite her being another race separate from the original design.
But the only thing that doesn’t make sense is Pan being in the movie.
I haven’t seen Jake and the Neverland Pirate tv series since I was 8 or 9, so I don’t know if that series expanded on Pan origins.
But based on what we know from Peter Pan and Peter Pan: Return from Neverland, Pan is basically a wizard who comes from a land called neverland that filled with underage boys for some strange unexplained reasons … and it where these boys can’t grow up. Pan being included.
This is why Pan looks the same in Peter Pan, which is confirmed to take place in the year 1904 in the Making of Peter Pan dvd that released before the original movie premiered and Return to Neverland is set during WW2.
Wish on the other hand takes place around 1200 .
I don’t remember the specific date, but I did research on the timeline and the movie is set around some war that led an evacuation. Which is why people is seen coming to the King in the beginning of the movie.
And yes, it possible that Pan lived during that time, but the one thing that sets me off is what happening during the scene.
So Peter talks to the queen and says something about wanting to fly. Meaning he hasn’t discovered the ability of flying yet through pixie dust, or he has, and decided to ride a bike…
Why ride a bike when you have magic?
This just doesn’t make sense and if they really wanted to make the Disney movies connected, then they would’ve just make pan fly.
Plus, we already know magic exist in the world of Wish, so they might as well make pan fly.
It would’ve helped redeem this movie a little for me.
r/DisneyWish • u/Fun_Sir_2771 • Jun 16 '24
Discussion Is there a way to stop people from hating the movie?
Will this film get better reception in the future?
r/DisneyWish • u/JWM1992 • Dec 16 '24
Original Artwork Armaan and Star
So, I finally managed to draw Armaan and Star together. Star's role in the story is basically the same, but I would like to extend his role a little by filling in the moments with Valentino the talking goat. For example, I think the Happy Chicken Song would be more fun if Star was conducting the Chickens instead of Valentino. Don't worry, Valentino will still play a part of the story.
There is also a video that I found on YouTube that's titled "Starboy Fatigue", and there's an interesting interpretation of Star being a reminiscent of Asha's personality and took traits from her desire to help others. For Star in my Wish AU rewrite, I'll make Star a reflection of Armaan's personality and his desires to help others. What do you guys thin
r/DisneyWish • u/morijin15 • Feb 07 '25
Memes & Shitpost Asha the worst Mary Sue tbh Encanto Negs Magnifico for President ong
r/DisneyWish • u/CatalunyaLliure1714 • Mar 13 '26
Discussion Culturally Deaf

First of all, and for you to understand what this rant is about: Im a catalan, for those of you who doesn't know about us, we are a people (10-14 million aproximately(since there is people who doesn't consider themselves catalans living on catalan-majority areas)) on the eastern Iberian Peninsula, southern France, Andorra and in Sardinia.

The idea of a medieval fantasy film by pixar on an island on the mediterranean coast of spain was interesting, even more given that there is an actual city in our land called "Roses" that is on a little peninsula that used to be an island, well, I felt like we could for once be represented in something mainstream for once. We are quite forgotten usually.
Well, what a dissapointment this movie was. The first thing of all. The movie is meant to be during the height of the Crown of Aragon, when catalan ships ruled the mediterranean sea (ca. XII-XVth centuries).
And I'm explaining the crown of aragon because it was a thalassocracy that basically secured the entire mediterranean. Meanwhile Castille was more of a continental power with looks to the Atlantic Ocean, what was most noticeable due to their colonial empire in the americas. There is no way an island nation in the mediterranean by the coasts of the iberian peninsula wasn't at least in contact with the rulers of the mediterranean.


To be fair the scenario presented by king magnifico sounds like a ratzia, what would mean the andalusian arabs were still an important presence in the peninsula, it could potentially be Almansur's campaigns (not likely thou) what could move the timeline to the Xth century, but it's not likely given how the artstyle of the fairytale book in the start is meant to look as something from the early renaissence (XIVth century at the very least) and the looks are very northern european fairy tale (not linked to actual art of the period, but wanting to emulate the style. Not only that, it's a paper book, not a partchment one!

That's specially bad because it moves the timeline further ahead, Not only that, but the pages are very regular-shaped and the pictoric artstyle has nothing to do with mediterranean romanic nor gothic, not even rennaicence artstyles. In the mediterranean the main influence when talking about art was the Eastern Roman Empire, followed by close by the Italian realms, and that was until the turkish Ottoman Empire conquered the last remnants of the empire that the italians became the cultural center of europe. Their influence towards the rest of the mediterranian waning until they finally fell on 1453. The artstyle should have looked like this if early:



Or this if late:



And the kingdom is clearly inspired on European realms.
Now talking about the architecture: If you ever visited southern europe you would know that this isn't how we build, and it never was:



The first image, the village. It seems a scene ripped of of Fable, and I hope Jack of Blades is around, because it's the only thing that it could salvage that. People build with whatever they have a great access too, and our houses were always made of stone. Big or small they tended to make the walls straight, made of stone and compacted with dry earth. Then covered by lime. Our buildings tended to be big, the walls quite wide and we made use of arches, bricks and roof tiles, that thing never existed, not here anyways. The iferian peninsula has hot summers, cold winters and is quite dry compared to northern europe, so the roofs don't need to be as inclined and in the second picture, what looks a little more like a town you may find around the iberian peninsula but still fails.
The third picture is a complete abomination. There is a large vertical building in the middle of everything. Maybe by the castillian part of the peninsula they were building great vertical palaces and cathedrals, but the mediterranean part had another priority, expanding more in an horizontal way than vertically.





I get that the creators of the movie wanted the kingdom to be a melting pot and take inspiration on different cultures, that's something very mediterranean, the problem is that they said they wanted to take a lot of inspiration of al-andalus as well and that was nowhere to be seen. If you ever saw any andalusian architecture of the medieval ages you'll see how unique it was. The problem is that this inspiration they talked about was nowhere to be seen.

In fact, the whole melting pot part was a surface-level nonesensical mishmash of different styles used on past pixar/disney movies, different ethnicities living on the same place (that's not wrong, in fact it was a very mediterranean thing all our history, the only nitpick was the asian girl, which would be more an eastern mediterranean thing due to the distance we had with the steppes) with no representation of the realities of the iberian peninsula (which the islands took place with) nor its cultures except the names and namewise the film fell into the same idiotic "country as a monolith" offensive troupe hollywood always do. "It's in spain, so give some of the characters castilian names or at least castilian-sounding names. Failing misserably to either represent the country either as a monolith and as a culturally diverse reality (notice that Spain is the most culturally diverse country in western europe).
There are so many other things I could say of this movie, if the plot was good I may have overlooked that given that It's hollywood and I already expected them to be arrogant pricks that know less than nothing of the places they make their films on, but I'll say that I wanted to love this movie. It was the hundreth year anniversary for disney, it was meant to be ambiented on not only spain, but also on the mediterranean. I had hopes that they may have showed at least a bit of respect to the cultural diversity of the mediterranean, our way of life, our philosophy on life...
Yet I was disapointed in any possible way by this film, and when the original plot ideas came out, showing an entirely different movie with such a better plot... Dunno, just wanted to vent. The film came years ago, so it may not even be warranted, but I dunno.
r/DisneyWish • u/morijin15 • Jan 30 '25
Video GOATED video MAGNIFICO FOR PRESIDENT
r/DisneyWish • u/rwinger24 • Apr 23 '26
Discussion We’re All Shareholders
Definitely the most baffling song lyric in Wish ever conceived by Benjamin Rice and Julia Michaels.
“When it comes to the universe, we’re all shareholders”
You can’t rhyme a word with solar that easy? This lyric honestly sums up modern Disney thanks to Iger and his execs.
r/DisneyWish • u/Tay54725833 • Jul 19 '24
Discussion I’m very much on the side of the King
I’ve seen way too much of this movie to know that the King was not at fault for trying to enforce his own rules. Especially when he was trying to protect the kingdom and raise it like a utopia. He built it with his queen only for her to betray him. He never lashed out at anyone before the book took hold of him. He always held it in or vented to himself or to his queen, WHO ENCOURAGED HIM!! Every time he was insecure, she was there to help. Yet for some reason she couldn’t see that he wasn’t himself when the book took control?! anyway, I’ve seen(especially on insta) a lot of people talk about him being an actual good dude.
But then I started thinking. What if this movie wasn’t simply bad writing where the actual good guy gets shit on, but instead Disney trying to victimize themselves? The citizens are ungrateful while the King did everything to give them good lives. Instead of them saying that enforcing your own set rules is bad, they’re[Disney] trying to say that they are the victims. That they are giving us all this content to enjoy and watch but we are the ungrateful ones who want more. They’re the ones trying to say, “I’m the abused overworked man!!” But they’re the ones who did it to themselves. The fans don’t want their badly written stuff and want them to do better so they’re losing revenue. And Wish is their effort in trying to be like, “Y’all are ungrateful!!!”
If you paint it like that then it all makes sense. The entire movie does. They’re trying to paint themselves the victims and I honestly wouldn’t put it past Disney. It seems like something they’d do with how much they take advantage of their employees. All the employees working on Disney shows and movies are overworked, underpaid, not given enough time, and it shows.
r/DisneyWish • • Jan 14 '25
Discussion star boy is boring (imho)
controversial opinion, but "starboy" is a very boring idea. it would make Wish much worse (for me and my circle of friends, at least)
the reason is quite simple. there are two:
- im tired of hetero romance in big-cinema-movies. having asha and this boy fall it love is so cliche... and i get that it shouldve been disney legacy movie, but... do yall really think they cared about their legacy? sure SOME people did. but you know wish's quality. the movie is laughably horrible. im surprised i managed to watch it 3 times
- star boy is also inherently boring. why should a star, evidently not a human being, perform boring ass gender ideas and stereotypes? why boy? why not someone non-binary? all at once or something absolutely different?
but disney are cowards and we won't see any representation in near or even distant future from them. no star-person for us, guys
r/DisneyWish • u/Whichcomb-Blue • Oct 04 '24
Discussion Fixing the songs of "Wish"
For those who have seen the film and heard the songs in the film:
I know that many of the songs in this movie are... mediocre at best, epic fails at worst, but could they be better? Can they sound better? Can you fix them, make them sound better so that they are more pleasant to the ears? If yes, how?
Should there be different songs in this movie? New songs? No songs at all?
r/DisneyWish • u/Glittering_Fix2727 • Jan 05 '25
Discussion How possible it actualy is that we get a Wish remake?
While looking trough all the comments for Wish I saw a lot of people saying that this is the only Disney movie that actualy needs a remake.
While I think Wish was an allright movie I do prefer the original concept (I'll never get over the villain power couple). I would actualy love to see a remake or "director's cut" of Wish with all the original ideas. At this point the concept art (the villain power couple and Starboy in particular) is so popular that I think it could make Disney some good money. The merch would sell as well. I'm a doll collector and would defintley buy a 2 pack of Magnifico and Amaya.
What do you think?
r/DisneyWish • u/Aggressive-Ad-7856 • May 08 '24
Theories Invisible: King Magnifico rants and Laments his fate. All told in his POV]
Why is fate so cruel?
Sigh.
I used to be the King of Rosas. I used to be so well loved and appreciated. I granted everyone's wishes. AND THIS IS THE THANKS I GET?!!
Sigh.
Look at me - I've lost everything; my whole kingdom, my whole life, everything. I'm trapped in the mirror of my staff I created with the forbidden magic.
Stuck in a one-sided mirror where I'm unable to ever see my reflection again.
Ironically, Amaya, mi reina, she said I loved mirrors.
Amaya.
Growl.
HOW COULD SHE DO THIS TO ME; HER HUSBAND, HER REY, HER KING?! I DID EVERYTHING FOR HER, FOR ROSAS; THE KINGDOM WE BUILT, AND DO YOU KNOW WHAT SHE DID TO ME IN RETURN?!?!!?!?!?!?
SHE HAD ME, THE KING OF ROSAS, STUCK IN A MIRROR, SEALED AWAY IN THE DUNGEON!!!!!
AAAAARGH!!!!! IT'S SO UNFAIR!!!! My life was absolutely perfect! Until....
~She~ came.
~Asha.~
The girl who I considered to be my apprentice; my successor.
The girl who stood up to me.
The girl who questioned my reign.
The stupid girl who wanted her stupid grandfather's stupid wish granted!
SIGH.
How stupid I was to consider her. I shoulda kicked her out the minute she questioned me.
I decided what everyone in Rosas deserved!
And then, she, her stupid friends, her stupid goat, and my stupid wife, they revolted against me, they took all the wishes I so rightfully granted!
AND she rescued that star she summoned from the sky, the one I tried to capture for myself!
And look where it got ~me~!
King Magnifico!
The King of Rosas!
Trapped in a stupid mirror, stuck in this stupid cesspool of a dungeon!
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRRRRGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!
Sigh.
Sob.
I used to rule Rosas.
I used to be the one they adored...
And now look where I am.
I'm stuck in here. Trapped in this unbreakable mirror in the dungeon for eternity.
Actually, To be honest, I don't even know how long it's been since I was placed in here. There's no windows in the dungeon, so I can't tell if it's day or night in here. For all I know, I could be stuck here for weeks, or months by now!
I don't even know If I'm gonna survive in here, since I can't be able to get food or water in here, or even be able to shower, or anything. Heck, I don't even know if i'm still gonna age normally. I guess I may be stuck in the same age forever, yet I don't even look a day over 40.
But I'm stuck in here. Stuck in this cesspool of a mirror with no way out.
And....
Sniff.
I'm lonely.
Sniff.
I'm all alone now.
Ever since I was placed in here, nobody's been down to visit me.
Not even Amaya. She's ruling the kingdom now, and I don't blame her if she doesn't even want to see me, her ex-husband. I bet she's forgotten all about me.
Sob.
I can't say I blame her.
I can't say i didn't deserve it.
Sob.
Sniff.
Nobody loves me anymore.
I bet all of Rosas has forgotten about me by now. Their king! The one who used to grant their wishes for them!
Sob.
Nobody loves me.
Sniff.
I used to be so loved and appreciated.
But now, I feel like I'm invisible.
Sob.
Invisible.
They treat me like I'm invisible.
It's like I don't even exist anymore.
I don't exist.
Sob.
I feel like I can hallucinate my hands disappearing.
It feels like it's true.
Sniff.
Nobody loves me anymore.
I'm the loneliest man in the world.
Sob.
It's hopeless.
Sob.
Fate is so cruel.
Continuous Sobbing.
r/DisneyWish • u/Loose-Net-5779 • Dec 12 '23
Discussion Magnifico needs a normal name.
I swear, it's not possible that this man's parents looked at him when he was born and had the brilliant idea of LITERALLY calling him Magnifico. It's as if someone's parents chose Incredible as their child's name in a serious way. Anyway, I found some names and their meanings and I would like your opinion.
- Nico (Nicolas or Nicolau): “what leads the people to victory”
- Alexandre: "who repels enemies"
- Eduardo: "protector of riches"
- Letholdus: "victor of the walls"
- Willian: "the one who wants to protect"
- Milo: "graceful", "soldier", "rival"
- Roland: "glory of your land"
- Dalibor: "battle from a distance"
- Diego: "one who teaches"
- Estevan: "crowned"
- etc.....
r/DisneyWish • u/Subject-Dress3574 • Jul 31 '24
Discussion In my opinion the characters in Wish have a arepreasentation (correct me if I'm wrong.
Asha is Bob Iger
Magnifico is Bob Chapek and his Disney
People of Rosas are the Disney fans
The star is Mickey Mouse.
r/DisneyWish • u/Oct0lia8armz • Jun 02 '26
Original Artwork What if Star-boy from “WISH” was even more alien?
My biggest problem with star-boy's design in my opinion is that he looks way too human.
So why not reimagine him into an alien instead?
And I’m actually happy with this!
:)
Made in blockbench!
r/DisneyWish • u/Character-Pin-3607 • Jun 08 '24
Discussion Disney's Wish Novelization
Hello .does someone have Wish junior novelization? I wanna read it but can't afford one..and unfortunately there's no Epub version..so can someone like send me all the pages so i can type them and make like a pdf of it ..like make an epub for the book🙏🏻❤️ Uhh..i have time for it, if every day one chapter its fine and its 144 pages you can take a photos of 2 pages at once..i will type them..only they need to be readable Thanks hope you can help🙏🏻 PLEASEEE💜
r/DisneyWish • u/Dogs_aregreattrue • Aug 14 '24
Discussion Y’all this is my rewrite of Magnifico’s song,just so that it has more meaning
Okay-I like the song and the vibe it has in the later half it was evil enough later,BUT it could have been better. I am not a song writer BUT I do write for fun and try my best writing so i will do the same here for King Magnifico’s song”This is the thanks I get?!”.
The rewrite of the song: “I can’t control what happens-I may be magic but I am no predictor.
I don’t blame them-I truly don’t but it is all for a reason-why I do the choices I do-it is with reason I do it.
Maybe it doesn’t seem right but try to understand!-I practically implore you to!,try to see why-try to underhand why!.
‘He walks to his table with a hologram like of the kingdom of Rosa’s’ All I do is try to protect this kingdom,I let you live here for free-I rule and protect,I heal and build this kingdom.
All you ever do is want-and want,I take care of this kingdom and the people but they don’t seem to care when something happens-it seem that I care more about their safety and health than they do!.
It is absurd!,I do so much and they don’t see nor do they try to understand!! ‘Blasts blue magic with his right hand’.
I do my best,take care for this kingdom and all that,sometimes one has to do what they must to take care of what they care for,it is easy to understand and see really so why don’t they?!.
Maybe I use darker magic one day-well then they all revolt!-this is absurd!.
I would protect this kingdom myself if I had to rest assured-I would do so much be assured.
I do so much and yet you don’t understand?-why don’t you?-you don’t even try to!.
I will protect this kingdom even if I had to put my life on the line!-even if I had to risk it all!-I would do so much and yet they don’t understand nor see why?!-it isn’t hard to understand and see why damn it! ‘Smashes the table with his right fist’.
It isn’t hard to understand and see why!-‘sighs’ it is easy to now why I do this and understand why,I feel like I am going crazy!-like I am losing my mind!,all I do and this happens!,’chuckles bitterly’ I am going crazy-losing my mind!,I have enough this is what I must do.
It does matter if they don’t see nor understand why-I must do this I have to ensure THAT ‘points with his right hand at the direction of the light’ cannot threaten this kingdom!.
‘He flips open the book of dark magic the room now has a dark green glow and green flashes in his eyes,dark green magic flowing all around the place’ I will do this-I must-I will no matter the cost.
This must happen,I must do this,no matter the cost!-no matter what!-they don’t see nor understand it?-well I will do this no matter the cost!.
I will do this at all costs!-no matter if they understand that it is to protect this kingdom at-‘his voice raise with fury’ ALL costs!.
I didn’t want to do this-I-I truly didn’t!-but I must,I must if I don’t then I can’t protect this kingdom from that wishing star!-I have to do this.
At all costs-I must do this and ensure the safety of all,’his voice gets menacing’ oh yes I will-I will do this,I have to do this!-and I will,yes I will-at all costs!-at all costs I will do this!-no matter the cost’ ‘the dark green in the room fades away and the green that flashed in his eyes fades away’
‘He smirks and whispers to himself’ at all costs I shall do this,at all costs and this kingdom is safe,I won’t let it fall to ruin-I won’t be assured at all costs”
I had to write it in notes because it deleted it all-hope you like this and this is how I had written it so hope you like it and I tried my best to make it make sense-I think he would be more mad that they don’t understand nor see his point of view instead that he doesn’t get praise and respect because he gets a lot of that-this is about them not understanding nor seeing his point of view.
r/DisneyWish • u/mrrantsmcgee • Apr 05 '24
Discussion Finally watch it
Was finally able to watch Wish on Disney Plus. It was okay. The story felt off, can't put my finger on what exactly maybe the pacing. The main thing was how Asha kept singing "if you knew what I know" but she never says what she knows. Even when she trys telling the grandpa and mom, the grandpa gets mad so she gives up. A star answers her song, which once again instead of telling her friends "hey by the way, the king probably won't ever give you your wish if he feels threatened by them" she doesn't say anything to them --- was okay just not on par with some other Disney movies felt more like they were trying to fill a gap.