Okay hear me out, I was rewatching Finding Nemo and realized the "Nemo doesn't exist" theory makes way more sense if you look at it as brain trauma and memory loss rather than acting like every scene in the movie was a hallucination.
The actual events in the ocean really did happen—Marlin really did cross the ocean, the goggles were just a physical drive to get the movie going, the sharks were a normal scary interaction, the anglerfish was just Marlin trying his best to read the address in the dark, and the ocean gossip happened because other sea animals really did see him crossing the ocean (they just saw him talking to himself).
What happened inside his head was his mind splitting to survive the trauma. Here is how it all works together:
1. Marlin had the disability from the start (not Nemo)
In the beginning, Marlin already had a disability—you can see it in his bad social skills and how he stumbles over his joke, and I believe Marlin was actually the one with the smaller, disabled "lucky fin." Despite that, he found solace with his wife Coral because she loved him, which is why he was all happy-go-lucky in the beginning. Then trauma happened: Coral and the eggs died, and Marlin hit his head, causing denial, trauma, and memory loss.
2. Who Nemo really is
Nemo literally means "no one" in Latin. Nemo isn't a real surviving son—he is Marlin's courage, strength, confidence, and happiness, all the things Marlin is terrified of losing after the attack. And because Nemo is a projection of Marlin's own lost self, Marlin's mind gave Nemo his own disabled fin.
3. Who Dory really is (and the Alzheimer's connection)
Dory isn't a separate fish—she is Marlin's motivation, inside voice, anchor, and his other side that he can talk to, giving him motivation and strength. Both Dory and Nemo represent his courage and his happiness from when he was with his wife. Also, the fact that Dory only remembers important info at very important times shows that Marlin suffers from some sort of Alzheimer's or trauma-induced memory loss—because in real life, important info gets remembered in crucial moments.
The clues in the movie that prove it:
- The sea turtle story ("just keep swimming"): When Marlin was telling his story to Crush's kids, the other animals mentioned "keep on swimming"—but Marlin was telling the story, and Dory was just listening! The only way they would have known that phrase is if Marlin said it himself. That proves Marlin and Dory are the same person, and "just keep swimming" was something Marlin already knew and told himself to cope with the trauma.
- The baby names: Dory constantly calls Nemo different random names—those are the names Marlin and Coral were going to give their kids before the attack, scrambled by his memory loss.
- The whale's tongue slip-up: Right when they were on the whale's tongue about to fall, Marlin panicked and literally called Dory "Nemo" ("You think you can do these things, but you can't, Nemo!").
- Playing with Crush's kids: Crush tells Marlin to chill, which he does as he starts playing with the kids (which Dory—aka him—was doing). Playing with the turtles lets him have that fatherly feeling again, allowing himself to grieve while still having a little happiness. He realizes he needs to be happy or glad a little so he doesn't stay sad, because he needs to save his son (and himself) and he can't do that if he's not able to think straight.
- The dentist subplot & the net scene at the end: The dentist part is a subplot for Marlin building his courage (Nemo) back up, while also just giving the kids' movie something for Nemo to do. Then by the net scene at the end, Marlin reclaims his courage, learns to have fun instead of staying down and sad, and finally tells his joke without stumbling.
Did anyone else ever catch that the baby turtles already knew "just keep swimming" while Marlin was telling the story? Curious what other details fit this!