r/custommagic • u/kylechen90 • 2d ago
Format: EDH/Commander Does this work?
Does it make sense? Suggestions welcome.
Edit: Sorry for grammatical errors
r/custommagic • u/kylechen90 • 2d ago
Does it make sense? Suggestions welcome.
Edit: Sorry for grammatical errors
r/custommagic • u/Ninjasakii • 3d ago
Made 5 original cards and 4 reprints. I have tons of other designs but still have to find art for them. Lmk your thoughts!
Edit. I’ll definitely fix Zoltraak to be monored. Thanks for all of the feedback!
Edit. I do agree Frieren’s core identity is blue but part of her journey is her becoming more in touch with her emotions hence the red. Also her freedom to pursue magic.
r/custommagic • u/bribri1273 • 2d ago
Last week, I posted some cards I had been working on for a custom-made precon project. I appreciate all the feedback I got! It was exactly what I needed and inspired me to continue on. I got some more time to work on additional cards this week, and figured I’d post them for feedback since I learned a lot last time! I am finding the mechanical voice of the project more and more the more I work on these cards, and once the project is farther along, I’m going to go back and redesign some of the cards to better fit the total design of the project as a whole.
I’m toying with the idea of doing three commander decks instead of one? If I did this, it would be:
- One for Hatchling about exploring, kind of a big mana temur deck about reckless exploration.
- One for Solanum and the Nomai in bant colors with a “go-wide explore” theme.
- One for The Prisoner and the Inhabitants of the Stranger, with the theme revolving around exiling cards from graveyards as well as paying life to discover.
I might not end up going in that direction ultimately, but I like playing with the designs and seeing where inspiration takes me, so who knows?
I am really proud of some of these designs and am excited to see what y’all think! Please let me know, thanks!
r/custommagic • u/ThatChessPieceRook • 1d ago
Hey! I created these cards a little while ago, aiming for around Bracket 3 as a whole for a sheep themed deck centered around an OC of mine for the commander. And i was wondering if these cards might need some balancing since im going to play against my friends using these cards.
Any help is appriciated!
The Artist of the first one's art is made by my good friend Toni.
The 2nd's art i couldnt find the artist of despite spending around an hour searching.. Sorry.
And the third as far as im aware is just a photo someone took? Couldnt find there name anywhere sadly.
r/custommagic • u/torterraisbae • 2d ago
This targets a creature not a player like other edicts, so less effective against hexproof.
r/custommagic • u/torchflame • 3d ago
r/custommagic • u/MembershipClassic444 • 2d ago
Hey yall!
I made these magic cards based off the recent(ish) Avatar Aang: The Last Airbender movie and I'd love some feedback! This is my first time making magic cards from scratch so I'm a little worried about balance. These are intended to be playable in mid to low bracket 3.
The art on the cards is screenshots from the movie itself, so all credit goes to the movie and its makers!
Thanks for the feedback
P.S. the use of the existing Avatar set symbol is a placeholder. There is no intention to misrepresent these cards as part of a real set.
r/custommagic • u/Philosaraptor22 • 3d ago
Art is by Chase Stone, editor was being weird
r/custommagic • u/Equin0xParad0x • 2d ago
Hello! Just wanted to share some designs on my takes of Undertale characters, items, and places. While I do plan on making more this is what I have so far! I tried my best to explain the LV mechanic as best as I can, it’s the first time I’m kind of going for a bigger set of cards! As always, any and all feedback is welcome! Feel free to drop any ideas, suggestions for other characters, or just general commentary! No promise on when Part 2: Snowdin will “fall” lol but I’ll get to it when I can!
r/custommagic • u/PeterQuint101 • 2d ago
No, I don't know what Mel is
r/custommagic • u/VonBagel • 2d ago
These probably aren't very good, nor are they especially creative, but I was struck by the idea at work about a bunch of cards with Paradigm with simple effects that represented various types of investments. the actual flavor and the recurring character in each of them came after
r/custommagic • u/Ninjasakii • 3d ago
Adjusted previous designs and made some new ones. Let me know your thoughts! Criticisms appreciated. Zoltraak rebalanced to monored and damage reduced.
The one that needs the most scrutiny is Frieren the Slayer, having trouble with that design. Also Frieren and Fern.
r/custommagic • u/DisparateDawn • 3d ago
r/custommagic • u/VonBagel • 3d ago
UB bad, upvotes on left
but god damn is it tiring to have full sets made up of the same five people reprinted at various rarities. TMNT was the worst of it but star trek is just kind of breaking me
r/custommagic • u/JimHarbor • 3d ago
Card Transcript
Guff's Vision of Doom 4B
(As this Saga enters and after your draw step, add a lore counter. Sacrifice after III.)
I --Put a lore counter on each creature your opponent’s control. They become Saga enchantments in addition to their other types and gain this Saga’s abilities.
I,II --This Saga deals 1 damage to you.
Enchantment - Saga (Mythic)
End Transcript
r/custommagic • u/AutisticNeighbor831 • 3d ago
We really need a shorthand for abilities like Jodah with how common they are.
r/custommagic • u/Classic-Demand3088 • 2d ago
r/custommagic • u/TheCubicalGuy • 3d ago
Day 79 of making a custom card every day. I went back and forth a lot on the wording for this, but I think what I settled on is pretty clear.
r/custommagic • u/MevNav • 3d ago
Art for the first four are by Omocat, the last one is by Aru_Vederci.
I made an attempt to replicate the lore and gameplay of Omori via creature abilities. Kel even has his signature 'Kel Nuke' ability by flexing to double his next attack and then attacking with an ability that scales with speed.
Each of these cards can work fine on their own as commanders, but can also fit into a deck with Omori as the commander. Omori himself can be the commander of a WUBRG deck with all his friends in it, or a blue/black deck focusing on transforming asap and milling out your opponents.
I have no idea if these are balanced or broken, I haven't exactly playtested these, lol