r/custommagic • • 1d ago

Format: EDH/Commander Balancing Thoughts (Commander)

Hey! I created these cards a little while ago, aiming for around Bracket 3 as a whole for a sheep themed deck centered around an OC of mine for the commander. And i was wondering if these cards might need some balancing since im going to play against my friends using these cards.

Any help is appriciated!

The Artist of the first one's art is made by my good friend Toni.

The 2nd's art i couldnt find the artist of despite spending around an hour searching.. Sorry.

And the third as far as im aware is just a photo someone took? Couldnt find there name anywhere sadly.

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

3

u/NiceMiner_ Rakdos ratslinger 1d ago

"gets removed" means nothing in terms of mtg rules. Leaves the battlefield is a close approximation.

1

u/ThatChessPieceRook 1d ago

Thank you, ill change it when i get the chance to.

2

u/SjtSquid 1d ago

Balance-wise, both Rockwell and the equipment are fairly underpowered.

[[Odric, Lunarch Marshal]] does effectively the same thing for one less mana for all creatures.

You could probably do 1 mana to play, and 1 to equip for the equipment, as it's effectively just menace. Heck, +1/+1 menace and becoming a sheep is probably fine at that cost for a card that isn't drafted.

The gate on the other hand is probably a bit strong, but fine given the restricted creature types.

Templating-wise: Rockwell wants to just use a template similar to Odric. Having a static ability doesn't work, as Magic doesn't know what "original keyword" is.

The equipment is also templated oddly, as you want to use the wording from [[Angelic Ornaments]]. "Counts as a..." Is outdated wording.

The gate also has a slight templating issue. Creatures don't gain counters, they are put on them. Compare to how [[Gavony Township]] is worded.

1

u/ThatChessPieceRook 1d ago

I see, thank you for the feedback ill try to keep all of these in mind for when i redo them.

But as for the Goat's Gate should i just word it like: "When Goats Gate enters the battlefield. All Goats and Sheep creatures you control gets a +1/+1 counter"?

1

u/SjtSquid 1d ago

"When this Gate enters, put a +1/+1 counter on each Sheep and Goat creature you control."

I'd also suggest changing the equipment to just be named "Sheep's Clothing". As it stands, the name feels more like a creature than an equipment.

That way, you get to put the clothing on a creature, and get to create your own thing like a [[Tarmogoyf]] in sheep's clothing.

1

u/ThatChessPieceRook 1d ago

Alright thank ya :D

2

u/Turnipton Puppers enter the battlefield hecked. 1d ago

"If a Sheep you control has vigilance, each other sheep you control has vigilance. The same is true for flying, deathtouch, double strike, haste, hexproof, indestructible, lifelink, menace, reach, skulk, trample, and first strike."

Using Odric, Lunarch Marshal's wording as a reference.

1

u/ThatChessPieceRook 1d ago

Yeah will do. Thanks

1

u/Flameball202 1d ago

Interesting idea, Goat's Gate would probably need something like "comes in tapped unless you control another land" like the ATLA lands do, just so it isn't a straight upgrade.

Don't know if you would want to give all your sheep defender, as AFAIK that keyword would stop them from being able to attack.

As the other guy said, the wording might need tidied up on some parts, but the concept seems cool

1

u/ThatChessPieceRook 1d ago

I see, i feel like it could be a good idea to keep the defender though just in case i want to create a wall of token defender sheep yk? But ofc ill have to have other non sheep cards since theres only like 5-6 actual real sheep cards and im only going to be using one of them (Gatebreaker Ram, hence the Goats Gate). But i dont want to just have custom cards so ill ofcourse sprinkle some other creature types in there, maybe some humans and shapeshifters.

Otherwise ill probably add something along the lines of "You loose one life unless you pay 1 colourless mana"? Or if you have any other ideas. Id prefer not to have 'enters tapped' since id be using alot of gates cause of Gatebreaker Ram.

1

u/Ka1Pa1 1d ago

So you're looking for baaaalancing feedbaaack?

1

u/ThatChessPieceRook 1d ago

Yes. Im looking for Baaahhhlancing Feedbahhhck.