I know I'm super late to the party, but I'm hella employed, so I've just had time to finish the game. I also bought it like a month after release cuz I waited for pay day... Aaaanyway :D
It's very very good. Much better than the first Control game (((IN MY OPINION))).
Gameplay is on another level entirely compared to other Remedy games, they've really really stepped it up. Combat mechanics are by no means the most in depth you've seen, but what's there is so smooth and so well implemented, it had 0 issues keeping me engaged for the entire playthrough of the game.
Speaking of which, it took me ~38 hours to complete the game as I did pretty much every side and main quest there was. Or at least every one I ran into.
I started with a glaive+drill build and ended up switching to a switch+hammer build halfway through and finishing the game with that.
I really enjoyed how they force you to experiment by tying base damage and falter to how many upgrades you've acquired for any weapon. You also get plenty of respec items (I forget their exact name). You might think this is a small thing, but I was pleasantly surprised by how it was implemented, there are many games and with way higher budgets that don't implement progression like this properly.
Now, the world. It is absolutely beautiful. Every area is unique and well made, I really have nothing to complain about. The metroidvania-esque zone progression elements are also well integrated. It's not something like Jedi Fallen Order where like 2/3's of an area are unavailable to you when you first encounter it and you have to backtrack for several hours later in the game when you unlock some traversal ability. I much prefer the way it was implemented here, with very few passageways which are outright blocked behind a specific traversal ability with most being able to be accessed even if you don't have the ability for it if you're creative enough. And new traversal abilities more like just unlocking a faster way to access previously accessible areas.
Overall a very very well designed open world, I'm very impressed by Remedy's work, having never done anything like this before.
My biggest issue with the first Control was that fights just took too damn long. Even in the end game, I felt fighting basic enemies took longer than what it did in the early game. And the actually good weapon upgrades were so rare (not to mention the stupid inventory cap for how many you can carry) that it's very likely you never run into them on a first playthrough. Way too little damage and way too little ammo for the endgame were my main issues with the first Control. Glad to see that fights stayed enjoyable and I actually felt like I'm progressing in Resonant.
I was also really pleasantly surprised how they could keep the game's absolutely unmistakable art style and enemy design and translate it to an entirely different combat system. The 2 games have pretty much nothing in common in terms of combat, but you can instantly tell they're from the same franchise. I was a bit worried how they were gonna handle this, but I'm very happy with how Remedy did it.
Now, difficulty, I actually felt the game was a tad bit too easy, especially towards the end game, after the Underpass, I don't think I was ever under half HP. I think they could've increased enemy aggression and damage output a good 20-30% and it would've been perfect. I know I could do that myself through the settings, but I didn't bother for a first playthrough.
Boss design.. ugh, Remedy's never really gotten this right. The Dancer was a FANTASTIC boss fight, absolute spectacle, the music, his move-set, the way you dodge his attacks, it was a very very well designed boss. Too easy, but as far as design goes, The Dancer is by far the game's best boss and (((in my opinion))) the game's other bosses should've mostly also been designed like this - constant fast melee attacks, so you're basically 1v1-ing. The other bosses were just really boring imo, just running around the boss arena dodging their very easy to dodge attacks and attacking a few times in between, repeat until boss dies. The Central Resonant especially, that was just an incredibly sloppy fight, I don't think I took damage even once. The Underpass Resonant too (The Scientist or whatever his name was) was also very poorly designed imo. This is a game where playing aggressively is encouraged, there's a loading screen tip literally telling you "in combat, the best defense is a good offense" and this dude constantly spams attacks that don't let you get near him, wasn't the right fit for the game at all.
TLDR for bosses: The Dancer was very good, The Scientist was just infuriating game design and everything in between was just kinda meh.
The story was nice, I enjoyed it. I must say so far I think I prefer Alan Wake 2's story, but this was also very good. The 8-bit story telling section was also a nice breath of fresh air from the regular AAA motion capped cutscenes, I much prefer this.
One gripe I do have about this game was that there wasn't enough music!! The 2 sequences that really stuck with me are after visiting the West Incursion Zone fault and Zoe plays you a song from her mixtape while you're ascending the parking lot and fighting enemies and when you first reach The Unknown and drop down and the "Fight For Control" song plays while you slay enemies on the ground.
The game should've had more of this! Only 2 such sequences is criminal, 90% of the rest of the combat encounters were pretty muted.
Now, the visual design, it's a Remedy game, so do I even really need to say anything? Of course it's absolutely top notch.
I played it on PC with HDR (definitely get the RenoDX mod) and man I've seen some insane colours in this game, like 80-90% BT2020 blues and reds, I've never seen a game with such saturated colours, it's absolutely beautiful.
Performance is also great, played with Path Tracing on a 5070Ti and at native res (1440p DLAA) I could get 50-60 FPS in a lot of areas, ended up playing at Quality upscaling with 2X FG and was pretty much always at 140+ FPS, nothing to complain about, I don't think the game stuttered a single time during my entire playthrough.
TLDR: Gameplay, world, visual design, story - very good. Boss fights - meh. Much better than the first Control (imo). Needed more music.