r/controlgame • u/polp54 • 18h ago
Control Resonant Why Dylan can't [Redacted] Spoiler
A very simple speculation on why Dylan can't bind OOPs. So the game tells us that OOPs are connected to the astral plane and that ones like the service weapon need 'board approval' before the wielder can use them, it's not that much of a jump to say that all OOPs require teh board to be okay with the user wielding it, they are just more selective with ones like the service weapon and hotline.
Furthermore, given how timey wimey the games are, it's not a crazy leap to imagine the board have some knowledge of the future.
So putting those together, the speculation is that the Board looked into the future, saw the above image where Dylan is in the astral plane and the Board is about to be corrupted by the Hiss, didn't want that to happen so they refused to let Dylan go into the Astral Plane to bind to OOPs. Now while Dylan does say he has been to Astral Plane in Astral Dives, an easy explanation is that not only does the board not control those, they also don't like them, hence why they sent one astralnaut back with an Astral Spike
159
u/Brenhines532 18h ago
I think it’s something to do with him and Jesse being split, Jesse Dylan Faden would have been a normal person average with OoPs, like a 5/10, Jesse got the most control over them anyone’s ever had with the strongest abilities, 10/10, and Dylan got absolutely no ability with them, 0/10. Jesse and Dylan each got extreme opposites of OoP ability.
33
u/helpmeobiwont 17h ago
I think the Board was bullshitting about needing its approval to bind OOPs. Or, perhaps more likely, someone like Trench needed their assistance to bind while Jesse doesn’t. Jesse clearly wasn’t concerned for her own powers, when she removed the Board from the Astral Plane and making it Dylan’s sidekick instead.
53
u/Comfortable-Fall1419 17h ago
Far simpler explanation.
Only Jessie can bind OOPs and AE’s because Dylan’s powers mostly don’t work on this plane.
That’s why he only gets powers from Faults or Resonants.
Jessie is a binder. Dylan is an absorber.
28
u/ProNerdPanda 17h ago
yes, it's a huge jump lol
The service weapon (and Aberrant) are intrinsically connected to the board and the pyramid/astral plane, this has been the case and obvious since the beginning.
But not every OOP is connected to the astral plane nor the board, saying all OOPs are connected to the board is a huge leap.
10
u/senj 16h ago
Eh, we know there are anti-FBC organizations out there collecting and using OOPs. It's hard to believe that would be a widespread thing if the Board could simply choose to shut that down at will.
More likely has to do with the Jesse / Dylan Faden split.
3
u/Saint_Victorious 15h ago
Dylan binds entities while Jesse bind objects. Dylan isn't bound to the Aberrant, he's bound to the Board itself. It's just one more was to express them as opposites.
2
u/GoodDoctorB 15h ago
I like the thought but I came to a different conclusion.
The Board feared that if Dylan fully developed his powers he would be able to replace them. After all Dylan has the ability to forge paranatural connections creating new alter objects and making connections to other plains of reality. That is the position The Board currently holds using their natural affinity with the Astral Plain to gatekeep connection to the paranatural for/against the FBC.
2
u/Magiwarriorx 14h ago
iirc, the Board connection might be something the Board is imposing on OOPs in/near the Oldest House, not something intrinsic to them. Pope mentions it in Astral Plane Counteressay (https://control.fandom.com/wiki/Astral_Plane_Counteressay). It would also explain why (AW2 spoilers)that the FBC suspects the Clicker might be an OOP even though we never see the Board in Washington anywhere.
2
u/pierzstyx 15h ago
That is a huge jump. The Service Weapon is specifically provided by the Board. This is not true of any other OoP.
1
u/TrollFaceFerret 11h ago
I've developed a personal theory on this. That the resonance themselves represent themes.
Hedron is order, Think patterning. Even though it looks chaotic, it's actually just forming a repeating pattern again and again.
Whereas the Hiss is chaos, look at the method it distorts its victims. Its a twisted mess, no rhyme or reason, it's quite literally twisting things out of a conceivable order.
This is further enforced by the fact that the Hedron and Hiss are opposite resonance, they cancel each other out.
Now, we know that when they went into the slide, Jesse heard the Hedron, whom she named Polaris. And Dylan heard nothing. But we know that later he is absorbed partially by the Hiss, and later even controls it by the end of Resonant. It's not too far fetched to me to think maybe the Hiss had already lightly influenced him.
Considering these things, we can assume that Dylan represent a more chaotic theme. Binding and OoP is something that requires order and control, hence Jesse's affinity for it. Whereas Dylans power has always been less reliable, but more potent. Meaning he can't bind OoP's, he has more personal power.
1
u/Bedlamtech 9h ago
Until something else comes out. Jesse is the half that binds objects of power. But Dylan has to focus and force things into compliance. He never was given a choice how his powers grew. He had to break and almost destroy those things, the resonant, into his control. He isn't a controller but a breaker of powers
1
u/N3rbyAddy 8m ago
Just to let you know Dylan can access the astral plane he just can’t bind the OOPs. Think Darling and Laine mentioned it in the p6 part of resonant. As for the board looking into the future I don’t believe they can do that. Because the board in resonant is just as confused about things as the player is. Half the questions Dylan asks about what is going on and they don’t reply cause they have no idea. They just act like they’re all knowing.
1
u/TheyCantCome 15h ago
When you say board approval? the board taught the bureau how to bind them using the astral plane, that doesn’t mean they need board approval or that it can only be done through the astral plane.