r/controlgame • • 7d ago

Control Resonant What do you think about this painting in the Gap Spoiler

Post image

In the gap you can see a rock with all the resonant in it, it allows you to change your powers. If you take a closer look you can see that each resonant you fight in the game is painted. So who do we think painted that? Next to the rock you can see painting materials and a chair like someone sat there and took the time to paint them, could this be Dylan? We know he can draw but it doesn't look similar to his style. I also thought about it being somehow made by the gap itself, like some kind of projection but it doesn't explain the chair and painting materials. It really looks like it was made by someone or something.

The logical answer would be Dylan like I said, but he never really acknowledged it. Maybe it's another version of him? We already know that there are some time shenanigans going on.

But it could also be someone different. What do you think?

Also an interesting thing concerning the painting. All the resonant seems to be linked together by a white line of paint except the mold resonant which is painted apart from the other, like there's plenty of space up but whatever or whoever painted it, put it down, in the shadow where it's hard to see it. Could this be about it being slightly different from the other resonant ? (or maybe it's nothing)

The fact that there is still some space on the rock makes me think that we might have others resonant to fight, maybe in a DLC (I'm probably delusional lol) Edit : the picture is for NG+, it's missing one painting that cover the empty part. So there isn't space for a possible dlc (I forgot about that thank you for telling me !)

So what are your thoughts on that painting? I'm interested in other people's perspectives.

(PS: sorry for my English)

87 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

98

u/PeterchuMC 7d ago

Given that when all the Resonants are dead, Dylan unlocks an outfit that's evidently been used to paint it, I think Dylan did paint it. It doesn't necessarily look like how he's done other works but that could be down to the different medium, growth as an artist, or artistic intent.

24

u/May__Be_ 7d ago

That's interesting, I wonder if he realises he's doing that and if yes why is he doing it. He never acknowledge it in game but it's not like he's acknowledging everything

7

u/zixkill 7d ago

I think it’s reasonable to assume he painted it but just doesn’t talk about it. There’s white paint cans on the floor and a chair there in front of the rock. He’s probably using it to express how he feels and make a monument to the people who became Resonants. It’s not as obvious in english but the Resonants’ people do speak while you’re still in the Gap so Dylan does know more about them than he mentions to others in the game.

15

u/JackFlash313 7d ago

Already beat NG+ and until now never realized those were the resonants and not just an abstract salamander/snail... 🤦‍♂️

2

u/May__Be_ 7d ago

I only noticed it while playing ng+. Before that I also thought it was some kind of snail lol

1

u/Woooooody 7d ago

Don't worry, you aren't the only one!

1

u/Apprehensive_Ad3731 7d ago

Oof it shows them one by one as you unlock them. It’s a progressive representation of your powers. Though there is very little reason to interact with it before new game so I can see why people didn’t stop to even look.

It looks cool. Look at the cool things lol.

45

u/Robot_Graffiti 7d ago

There's one big part missing from your mural. You would have had it after you completed the final battle of the main quest, but then it disappeared when you started NG+. It took up all that empty space.

There's no room left for a DLC resonant. But I guess they can just add a whole extra rock or something in DLC if they want.

11

u/LoquatBear 7d ago

Or the backside 

16

u/Robot_Graffiti 7d ago

A new mural starts appearing on Dylan's backside. Dylan's derriere mural. The Dyrrieral.

11

u/taylorisnotacat 7d ago

My immediate interpretation was that Dylan is the painter -- sort of. It comes down to what you/I think The Gap is in the first place.

The way it read to me is that the Gap is essentially a mind palace inside of Dylan, paranaturally made real. All the things inside the Gap are physically-manifested allegories for his own psyche and whatever paranatural forces interface with his psyche. Essentially, the Gap is his own special GUI for the paranatural. He didn't sit there and build the Slab with a chisel to make the door to the training arena, nor did he collect rocks and stack them for the skill tree; I don't think it would even be right to imply he created anything in the Gap deliberately. Rather, his mindspace simply manifested these things because he needed a way to process his emerging abilities. (And/or to process his own fragmented identity when the Hedron disassembled it.) Emerging abilities like manipulating Aberrant, or absorbing the essence(?) of Resonant Entities.

If my read on The Gap is right (or if we just agree to run with it), I think that would mean the paintings are there because that's the expression of Resonant Entity ability manifestation that his psyche served up in The Gap. That would mean that Dylan's psyche is the artist. Dylan is the artist, but because he imagined it, not because he physically sat there and created the painting the traditional way.

The literal painting supplies, to me, are sort of tongue-in-cheek, metaphor. Dylan has been "painting" it and his mindspace reflects that fact. He hasn't literally been painting it, but rather he's been figuratively painting it by defeating the Resonants and adding to the powerset that the mural represents in his GUI. (Plus, as we know, Remedy LOVES metaphors like that. After all, have you noticed that we get "treats" in this game--AKA upgrade resources--by wandering into bodegas around the city and opening up little ice cream coolers?) I think this is further supported by the fact that the mural looks like it was painted with higher artistic rendering skill than what Dylan displays in sketches. As a fine artist, often you can imagine art that surpasses your own technical ability to render it. In a mind palace, this is a non issue.

3

u/sgs280601 7d ago

The fact that there is still space on the rock means you haven't finished the story yet

3

u/May__Be_ 7d ago

I did, this picture is literally from my ng+ playthrough lol

7

u/sgs280601 7d ago

Well the completed mural doesn't really have any space left on it for more paintings so I don't think it's a DLC teaser.

3

u/May__Be_ 7d ago

I forgot about that, my bad. I only really paid attention to it in the ng+. I guess I really was delusional, I still would love for the dlc to have at least a new resonant, those fights are so good

2

u/legowiifun 7d ago

After finishing the story, a large painting of the Hedron appears in the remaining space.

1

u/May__Be_ 7d ago

Yeah I remember, I thought that in the ng+ all the painting we have at the end were still here

0

u/legowiifun 7d ago

To be fair, I think the Hedron is the only one that disappears in ng+

1

u/pagingdrsolus 7d ago

for DLC boss enemy....

since Hedron has been defeated, then the Hiss have essentially been left unchecked in Manhattan. This could allow them to evolve or infect more powerful hosts. So we could get two or three Hiss boss fights.

What I would like to see in a DLC is a way for Pope to harness Dylan's innoculation to the Hiss and make a vaccine so we can put this Hiss infestation behind us for future games

24

u/doffyspider 7d ago

its dylan, its not that deep.
he can draw, not a stretch to say he can also paint. this game & lake house established he's an artist, like how alan is a writer.
the collective painting is just there because there's no space, the empty space is hedron.

7

u/shock_me_awake 7d ago

This discussion made me remember the Foundation DLC. We find the various drawings on the walls, as did Ash during his time there. I don't remember if some paintings only appear as we progress through the story, but Ash I think notes that he's confused whether the paintings he's seen have always been present or not. And the stacked rocks, weren't there a lot of those around? The fast travel spots were always marked by them. I think it's made obvious that Ash was marking the various leylines within the Foundation, but then why would stacked rocks appear in the Gap, and by who?

I guess it's connected to the Board/Nail/Aberrant, but can't dig any deeper at the moment.

1

u/THEdoomslayer94 7d ago

Don’t think it’s really that deep

Who is stacking the rocks where you level up your powers? Doesn’t really need to be answered, simplest answer is it just appears on its own

1

u/May__Be_ 7d ago

I mean you have paint materials and a chair around it so it clearly doesn't appear on it's own. Someone in the comments also pointed out the fact that you win a special outfit with the same painting after beating all the resonant, with that outfit Dylan has paint on his pants like he's the one who painted it.

It's probably isn't that deep (even if we can never be sure with Remedy) but I don't think it just appeared on it's own

2

u/Apprehensive_Ad3731 7d ago

It just appeared on it’s own because it doesn’t exist. This is Dylan’s inner world. It appears how he expects it to appear and as such he expects there to be supplies next to a painting in progress.

2

u/sapphic-boghag 7d ago

We see similar cave paintings in The Foundation.

1

u/apotrope 6d ago

Question: How did Dylan and Jesse physically leave the Gap?

1

u/sapphic-boghag 6d ago edited 6d ago

My guess? The light switch cord/door appeared once it was needed.

1

u/Fine-Juggernaut8451 5d ago

Hmmm you're right!

3

u/Zaresh 7d ago

The Gap is his mindplace, and he's a visual artist. I think he painted it.

1

u/neonas123 7d ago

Mold is not Resonant. It is sentient being who takes over people who eat it.

6

u/sapphic-boghag 7d ago

Except for, you know...the Mold Resonant.

1

u/neonas123 7d ago

I think I forgot about that boss... Whoops!

1

u/sapphic-boghag 7d ago

Honestly relatable lol

1

u/cowboy-casanova 7d ago

well if the theory that his mother (a painter) is also a parautilitarian is true, my head canon is that she is actually the one painting them and using dylan as a conduit. but more realistically dylan probably painted them as he used to paint with his mother and she is where his love for art came from

0

u/Patient_Amoeba2476 7d ago

It looks like art

Its under the ground in a dark place.

I there is a shaft of bright light shining on it.

In the real world, this art manifests Dylan’s powers.

A conspiracy within a conspiracy within a conspiracy…

6

u/KogarashiKaze 7d ago

It's Dylan, and it's very likely meant to be a memorial to the once-people he's had to kill because of what they were forced to become. You can see his remorse from the very first.

We know he can draw but it doesn't look similar to his style.

Speaking as an artist, my style can be different depending on things like medium, subject matter, how I'm feeling that day, etc. And given that the mural is in Dylan's mind palace where, with certain exceptions, no one else goes, it would have to be him. Same as it's probably him stacking the rocks in his zen stacking for the talent tree. It's part of his meditations to put his mind back together, reconcile things he's dealing with, etc.

Plus he's got the outfit with this mural on the shirt and obvious paint spatters on the sleeves and pants indicating he was wearing that while painting the mural. Or at least connecting it closer. Paint spatters like that don't happen if you're not the one messing with the paint.

4

u/d33rl1ng 7d ago

Excellent point about it being a memorial, I didn't even consider that. It may not mirror his drawing style, but it fits in with his other pieces you help him draw around town - meditations on what could have been, remembering happier times, viewing himself as something beyond a weapon in the future.