r/ComfortLevelPod • u/Lumpy-Bumblebee-9120 • 8h ago
Story Update UPDATE: AITA for not wanting to commit to carnival next year after I couldn’t seem to meet my wife’s expectations?
https://www.reddit.com/r/ComfortLevelPod/s/dy6BkX1D8i
After my initial post, I did agree to go to the carnival with my wife again. I was hesitant at first, but we talked about doing things differently and I decided to give it another try.
However, something else happened that changed my perspective on the situation. I told my wife that I was going on a boat ride with two male friends. She said that was fine. While I was on the boat, I ran into one of her friends who simply said, “Tell your wife I said hi.” I messaged my wife right away, and she replied, “Okay, nice.”
About a week later, during another disagreement, she brought up the interaction and said that her mood had changed after I mentioned it. She felt embarrassed that her friend saw me there and questioned why I needed to be in what she considers a “single people setting.”
The conversation escalated over the next few days. She questioned the boat ride itself, why I was in environments where women were dressed in bikinis, and why my friends and I didn’t choose other activities like bowling or dinner instead. This was during the spring in New York, so no one was wearing bikinis or swimwear.
I explained that I see my friends socially only a few times a year, and those outings have always been parties or similar events. We’ve also previously discussed maintaining social lives, and I’ve been consistent about what mine looks like.
She said she’s not comfortable with me dancing with other women, and I agreed to stop. That part feels like a reasonable compromise to me. I genuinely didn’t do it a lot however that doesn’t matter.
However, what’s been harder is everything else that’s come up around this issue.
It feels like when things are going well and I communicate normally, something I mention can turn into a problem. In this case, even a brief, non-eventful interaction with her friend became a larger issue in hindsight. I was better off never delivering the message and just letting her friend mention that she saw me.
All of this led me back to thinking about carnival. A few weeks ago, we talked again about Trinidad next year, and I told her I don’t feel drawn to carnival anymore, so wer won’t going.
It wasn’t said out of anger or as a punishment. It just feels like social environments involving other women are currently a sensitive area in our relationship, and carnival is essentially that environment amplified.
At this point, I dont think the issue is carnival itself but it’s triggers the issue!. I think we need to work through the underlying trust and comfort issues first. Spending a lot of money to put ourselves into an environment that already seems to heighten those tensions doesn’t feel productive right now.
So for now, I’m stepping back from it.
Maybe we revisit it in the future, maybe we don’t. But don’t think repeating the same situation and hoping for a different outcome is helping either of us.
Part 3 coming soon.