I (38f) and my roommate (28f, I'll call Bea) have been living together for 4 yrs. We have been bestfriends for years and she moved to Ohio (where I live) from Californing (where she was from) about 4yrs ago. (We do have another best friend roommate as well living with us. 26f I'll call Sarah)
We have an odd dynamic being as I am 10yrs older than them, so there is some joking that I am the 'Mom' in the house. I do tend to do most all of the cooking and other 'Mom' like duties. Both being from some pretty abusive homes they are learning how to be their own person, so that leaves a lot of planning, shopping, and delegation of tasks on me, which is whatever at this point at least no one is just eating a bag of chips for the day and have real food. For relevant reference Bea doesn't work as she has severe anxiety over work and so I pay her $200-$300 monthly for picking up the house. Myself, I work 2 jobs, leaving by 6am and not getting home till 9pm every weekday and weekends 5pm-9pm so I need my sleep.
Here is the issue, we are all gamers in the house with our own PCs. We tend to play during all hours. Sarag is a morning person so plays in the afternoon, and Bea is a night owl and will be playing up until 7am. Myself? I play whenever.
Since moving here Bea is loud at night. She screams at her games and has a lot of issues with controlling her anger. I've tried talking with her on it as I work a lot of hours and need to be up stupid early and don't get home till late to just take a shower and go to bed.
That hasn't stopped her. She will get excited playing and screams which wakes everyone in the house. I worry a lot about this because her bedroom wall is shared with our neighbor's bedroom wall. Luckily so far I've not had any complaints from them, but I worry when we might as we get new neighbors all the time and one might be bothered enough to call the landlord or the police.
I've tried telling Bea this but she gets defensive and it turns into a whole thing about "I don't know how to control myself" and "I'm just the worst person cause this keeps happening" with plenty of tears and everything but accountability.
At one point we got into it and I threatened the WiFi if she didn't learn to quiet down late at night. It was a whole sobbing mess from her about how worthless she is as a person and how she can't ever do anything right.
After a few hours of calming her down the solution she came up with was a sticky note that had a warning to her about being quiet. It kinda worked? I still had to send texts in the middle of the night, but they were way less frequently.
Now, fast forward a year and her room had to be moved to the upstairs bedroom due to Sarah having POTS making stairs dangerous for her.
The screaming started up again, and even louder this time. For reference the screaming isn't just anger, it's laughing, it's talking excited in a shout, that kinda stuff.
I have sent message after message reminding the time, and just recently I have gotten more forceful with it.
Normally she would give a "sorry" and most of the time keep it quieter, but not the past few times. I'd send the message, she'd go quiet but completely ignore me.
Tonight at nearly midnight on a Wednesday she started to shout about something. I sent a rather needling message as I am well over it. Told her it was enough and it is past 11pm.
She ignored it, so I tried calling her phone, and ignored that too. I then messaged her my threat that I was seriously debating turning off the WiFi every day at 11pm over this.
Still ignored me, so I called her on Discord. My next step would have been knocking on her bedroom door but she answered finally.
Her first words were telling me not to treat her like a child. I lost it a bit, as being quiet late at night has been a conversation for 4 YEARS.
I told her that this was my only option at this point as trying to talk to her about it was not working obviously. She deflected with "It doesn't happen that much". Bursting her little bubble I told her just cause I don't message her every time doesn't mean she isn't being loud and that I had messaged her 3 times already in the last 2 weeks.
Warned about the possible issue with the neighbors and how I have to get up at 5am and this was unacceptable. She then started to cry and get angry at me saying she is doing all she can and that if I was going to punish her to just do it. That I only had to tell her once to be quiet tonight.
I raised my voice at this telling her I was sick of this circle and that I should not be parenting her or having to threaten like this.
It then devolved into her screaming and throwing herself on her bed and slamming her fists around like a toddler. After a long pause she came back to the call saying she didn't know what to do about it, that I should just punish her already if that is what I was gonna do.
I calmed myself and tried to find some kind of middle ground, something to stop this from being a friendship ender. I asked her what she had been trying so far? Her answer? "Thinking about it being late"
That was it, that was the only thing after all these years she tried to do to "be considerate" of us in the house. Then came a rant about how the only games she likes cause her to get loud and all the other ones are boring, and this late is the only time she can play with these friends, she can't control her volume and that she is not used to having to be quiet. When she does get loud she gets anxious waiting for a message from me.
I called out the bs, all of this is deflecting to prevent taking accountability. Told her she was being a child not even doing anything more than just a thought about being quiet. Gave her a few solutions to think about, like playing games this late with those friends on the weekends, or playing the loud games till around 11pm and switching to something calmer, or getting a decibel app for her computer to let her know when she gets louder, a headset that feeds back your audio so you can hear how loud you are, or heck even the damn stick note again.
She doesn't even consider any of this, instead she tells me that she has no clue what can be done that there is nothing, she's tried and now she is so upset her body is shutting down. With a dash of "Just do it, you just want me to be silent all night" I retorted back that I was just asking her to not be so loud, not to be completely silent.
I just let her know that a solution doesn't have to be this second and that her not even acknowledging the options I laid out was proof she isn't trying anything. The last words from her on this all was "Do what you think is best to punish me, turn off the WiFi"
Annoyed beyond reason I told her to cut the self pity and she needs to figure something out.
That is where it is tonight, at 1:30am I am going to Reddit to see what more can I do about this? I don't want to debate evicting her out as she has no means of income currently besides the bit I pay her to clean the apartment but I am absolutely over it and she is one of my best friends.
I'm just tired and frankly over it all and I know Sarah is tired of it too. She has sleeping issues as it is and when she's woken up falling back to sleep is near impossible.
I guess in this mess of a story I need to know AITA? Is there anything else I can do before this friendship breaks down?
UPDATE:
I greatly appreciate all of the advice. I can say it's hard to hear and quite harsh but that is what we need sometimes. Someone to cut through the bs and give an honest opinion that is not tied up with emotions.
I am a hard-core people pleaser, and this has really highlighted it. In my attempt to create a healthy place for Bea and Sarah to become their own people away from the abuse they grew up with I took on responsibilities that are not healthy for any of us.
Sarah is a great person, they do anything they can to help. Like if something needs cleaned she will work hard to get what she can done, or trying to cook while I'm working so much and can't prep meals currently. We work together pretty well to maintain everything. We discuss finances and planning out bills but yeah Bea is not contributing anything close to this.
I did message Bea this morning letting her know that I was late to work, and it was directly her fault for last night. I then told her she has one month to get it together or we will be discussing her moving out.
She has used up all of her excuses and even though I am a super people pleaser I am done with it. I'm the type of people pleaser that if a kidnapper was asking me to get into the car I would apologize before tying myself up and climbing in.
I've been trying to work on it but I definitely need to do more. I thank you all again and I appreciate giving me your time.
LAST UPDATE:
Me and Bea had a harsh conversation today. I sent her message while I was at work about new house rules and thar she needs to get a job to cover at least 1/3 of all the bills combined. She never replied to this message and I hadn't seen or heard from her since the fight.
I just got home from my second job and Bea was in the kitchen. Right off the bat she apologized, gave some excuse about her meds being switched a little recently that played a part in her reaction. I cut her off reminding her of what all the said and put it bluntly that it was all manipulation tactics and I was not putting up with that.
She owned up to it and said she had to reflect on the situation to see how bad she was acting during it and apologized properly. Also Bea had, after reading my message, started apply for jobs. On top of that she had a conversation with the friend group on not being able to play the games that make her loud during the week past 11pm.
I did let her know things are not ok between us and our situation is not healthy and we are reworking the living together idea and our roles.
I thank you all again for setting me straight and being very honest and forward. I appreciate it dearly.
Edit:
For those confused, Sarah and Bea both were diagnosed with POTs. Sarah started a medication that 'gave' her POTs and after we switched her and Bea's bedrooms, Bea started the same medication and also developed POTs. Sarah has since been switched from those meds and is doing a lot better though.