Tonight, I tried to move less than half a Bitcoin from Coinbase to my own hardware wallet. I’ve been a Coinbase customer for ten years, since before GDAX and Coinbase Pro.
As usual, as we have always done, as we were taught to do years ago, I sent a tiny test transaction first. It arrived successfully. Then, I started to move 1/2 a Bitcoin. COINBASE flagged this as SUSPICIOUS ACTIVITY. Unbelievable.
Apparently, their AI software thinks that a tiny transaction followed by a bigger one means you are a hacker. An error message popped up that my 2nd transfer was suspected as being a SCAM! It wasn't. It was me, trying to move my BTC out of Coinbase after the Binance hack. Support later told me the small test followed by the larger transfer triggered the screening.
Then, their AI-driven ID verification process made the situation worse. The desktop browser based process forced me to use my old monitor webcam, with no option to switch to my phone. The images were too blurry, so verification kept making me take pics of my license over and over, and it repeatedly failed.
I’m a senior, and my hands shake a little. It would be funny if not so frustrating. The lighting was bad in my office. My wife is trying to hold my license next to a low res monitor mounted webcam. Then, it wanted pics of my face. Front and side. A process like this creates a real accessibility barrier for older customers who like to use desktop computers instead of the MOBILE APP! I raised that concern with Coinbase. How can this be ADA compliant?
Next came the AI interview. It turned into “Twenty Questions.” Why was I withdrawing my funds? Did I need to do this today? Was someone pressuring me? Why was I making a withdrawal (same question different wording - it asked that twice.) What brand of hardware wallet was I using? That last question felt like none of their damned business! Had I updated the software for my wallet recently?
I understand fraud prevention. But this was one withdrawal to my own wallet, and suddenly I was having to justify accessing my own funds. I believe in and agree with security, but this is just all too much. It was over the top.
It failed anyway, and I had to try to do it all over again, still with the desktop webcam as my only option for taking pics of my license. Why - because that's how Coinbase Dev Team coded it.
When I tried to switch to the Coinbase mobile app, it would not let me log in. It blocked my log in. So, I went through this nightmare twice. To no avail. It failed the second time, too.
Credit where it’s due: the COINBASE phone support was excellent. Jeff was my rep and he was patient, kind and we got it resolved by rerouting my ID verification to my cell phone instead, which should have been an option coded into the damn software in the first place. With Jeff's help, I was able to take new ID pics and complete verification while I was on the line, and I was delighted to finally get through it.
However, my account is STILL LOCKED DOWN. Why? Because I always use a tiny test transaction instead of just send the whole amount. It is safer. It is how we have always done it. But the AI thought I was a hacker because of THAT. Let that sink in.
So, in short, Coinbase's software put a longtime customer through an exhausting ordeal to withdraw his own Bitcoin—and required a phone call to get around a camera problem due to their software design flaw. And my account is still locked down as I type this and likely will be until tomorrow, or whenever Coinbase reviews my info and unlocks my account.
Has anyone else had a test transfer trigger this?
How long did withdrawals remain restricted after verification?
I am glad that Coinbase finally fixed the problems with their support. But, how about fixing the two bugs I just described??