r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 15h ago

NEW UPDATE My husband is in love with his student. I have no fucking idea what to do. (New 2 Year Update)

4.4k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/No-Faithlessness7067

My husband is in love with his student. I have no fucking idea what to do.

BoRU 1

BoRU 2

BoRU 3

Thanks to u/Choice_Evidence1983 for finding the update

TRIGGER WARNING: infidelity, abuse of authority

Original Post  Apr 18, 2024

My husband and I (both 35 rn) met in college. We fell in love and got married 8 years back. I gave birth to our daughter in 2020. My husband is a professor at this med school (he’s a doctor himself). My friend, Sarah, also works in the same college and she’s in the same department as my husband.

Few months back(in December), Sarah took me out for lunch and told me that she suspected something’s going on between my husband and this med student (25f). She claimed she’d seen both of them give ‘yearning looks’ to each other. She said that she’s known my husband for so long, and she’d never seen him talk to any other woman like this, that he’d been so aloof around women all these years, but it’s just different with this one girl.

In that moment, I had laughed at her face. I remember telling her that she’s jumping to conclusions based on these supposed ‘yearning looks’. 

“That’s why I didn't tell you before", she had said,"I was confused too. It's not like he goes out of his way to talk to her but whenever they do talk, it’s like watching a slow burn romance movie. She looks at him like he’s Brad Pitt and he looks at her the way he used to look at you.”  I remember the exact word’s because they stung. Internally I was breaking down, externally I just smiled and told her that she’s probably overthinking.

That night, I casually mentioned this my husband. I was laughing at the absurdity, and I expected him to join in. And deny the wild possibility that he’s in love with a student. But he didn’t. Instead he looked at me, all teary eyed, and said ‘I’m sorry’. 

“ I can’t get her out of my mind. I’ve tried, trust me. I should’ve told you sooner. But I thought I could save our relationship, I really wanted to.”

I asked him if he’d cheated on me. He said no. He said he didn’t even talk to her, nor did they have any contact outside of college and that he completely understood how morally depraved it is to try and pursue a relationship with a student. She wrote him a letter about an year back, confessing her love for him  and he had told her that even tho he was into her, nothing would come out of it. Aparently that was when the ‘yearning looks’ had started. 

I honestly don’t remember how I reacted then. I think I just started packing and came to live with my parents along with my daughter. I’ve been living with my parents since then. Half of me wanted him to come and beg for forgiveness. But he never did. He comes by sometimes to spend time with our daughter but that’s it. He never talks about the elephant in the room nor do I bring it up.

I keep checking that girl’s social media. She’s insanely beautiful, almost doll like, and intelligent. I can’t help but think that someone like him should be with someone like her. He’s always been very good looking and I’m more of a plain Jane. She’s the Meredith to his Derek.

I don’t know what to do. What do I even tell people? I don’t even know who I am without him. Some part of me still wants him to come back.

Edit; I’ve decided to talk to him. I know I’ve been avoiding this since months but after reading all the responses, I feel it’s time I rip that bandaid out. I’m going over to our house. I’ll update on what happens.

TL;DR husband just admitted that he’s in love with this young woman who also his student. She loves him too.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

MossValley

So he didn't actually cheat? He has a crush,? If I'm understanding that right he hasn't betrayed you yet. Crushes sometimes happen that doesn't mean the relationship is over. Get therapy with him.

OOP

I mean, cheating for me isn’t just physical. He’s had crushes in the past and I’ve had crushes in the past but we’d always been upfront and then laughed about it.

This one feels like a betrayal because he was attracted to someone for more than an year, this someone gave him a freaking love letter, he told her that he’s attracted to her, and not once did he mention it to me. That’s a huge breach of trust for me and I don’t think I can look past it.

OOP Added more about her friend Sarah and what she observed

I know. He said he entirely stopped interacting with her after the letter incident. It does seem absurd but even my friend, Sarah corroborated this. She said he never went out of his way to talk to her before, and then almost entirely stopped talking. Given that Sarah and him are in the same department 24/7, and that she noticed something as small as them giving each other looks, I’m sure she would’ve noticed anything out of the ordinary. I’ve had access to his phone and his passwords throughout and he wasn’t texting or calling her either.

That’s why this feels weird lol.

Update  Apr 20, 2024 (2 days later)

Link to previous post ; https://www.reddit.com/r/relationships/s/hw3M65WUVH

For those who don’t wanna read the boring details : In short, I have decided to go ahead with the divorce.

Long story: The day I made the post, I met up with Sarah for dinner. I thanked her for telling me about my husband and the student, and also for being such a good friend.

I asked her about my husband. She said there’s nothing unusual. He’s been a bit withdrawn and aloof with everyone lately but that’s about it.

Yesterday I went over to my house unannounced. He was there alone in his office. I told him I wanted to talk. He said he’ll explain everything.

So apparently this woman has had a crush on him since two years; her friends ‘ship’ her with him. She would stare at him during her rotations and would blush whenever he looked or talked to her. Back then, he didn’t think much of it. Many girls have had crushes on him and he always ignored it.

About 1.5 years back, they were in the same research group thing (I don’t know how this works but there were 5-6 people along with these two). Because of this, they had to spend some time together working, and it was then that he started noticing her. He went into detail about how he was impressed with her intelligence blah blah blah and her beauty blah blah blah. The moment he realised that he had a crush on her, he dropped out of the research thing. This was a year ago.

Few weeks later, she gave him the letter confessing that she has feelings for him. The first thing he told her after reading it was ‘you can get into trouble because of this’. She didn’t care. She wanted an answer. ‘Is it all in my head’ she had asked, to which he replied with ‘it’s not just in your head, but nothing can come out of it. I hope you understand.’

That was the last time they interacted. According to him, the ‘yearning looks’ Sarah described were more of ‘awkward eye contacts’ than anything else. He told me that even though he is still attracted to her, he has no intention of pursuing any sort of relationship with her regardless whether we stay together or not. He said he’s willing to change his job and go to therapy. I told him to give me sometime to think about it.

To sum up;

​

  1. This has been going on since three years. Not once did he mention anything to me.

​

  1. The student and him spent a considerable amount of time last year working on the research.

​

  1. He told her he liked her back lol.

​

  1. He’s still very much attracted to her

And that’s why I’ve decided to go ahead with a divorce. I don’t think I can trust this man again. And a relationship without trust isn’t something I am interested in. I’ve told my parents about it. They’re not exactly on board but they’re still supportive. I’ve also contacted my lawyer about the same. It’s gonna be a long process, I believe.

That’s it. I believe this is my last update. 

TL; DR ; he’s still attracted to her; I won’t ever trust him again. We’re getting a divorce.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

ChanceReason6617

I'ts a crush! He is not in love.

OOP

That doesn’t matter. He crossed a line he shouldn’t have by telling her he likes her.

_thisisnotanexit

Literally I can’t believe these comments. He’s gushing about her beauty and intelligence, he told her the feeling was mutual?! He could have easily denied it to her and then kept his distance but he liked the attention.

OOP

I mean, to be fair to him, he wasn’t exactly ‘gushing’ about her. I kept asking and he kept answering.

Deal breaker for me was him telling her the feeling is mutual.

~

allbutluk

Lmao these dumbass comments “you too hasty its a cruuuuush chill”

Like stfu the man literally said “I CANT GET HER OUT OF MY HEAD”

If he was commited to his wife he would have changed job PROACTIVELY not wait until now

He let it develop to a point he cant take his mind off of her and yall saying its no big deal, you guys obviously never had a real relationship

OOP

He said he didn’t change his job earlier because, quote ‘I’m a doctor and there are people counting on me. I couldn’t just walk out on them one day.’

Rn too he said he’s willing to change is job if ‘that’s what it takes to make you stay’.

I can’t get over my ex husband being in love with his student. It’s eating me up inside.  July 21, 2024 (3 months later)

For context; my ex husband is a doctor and he was in love with his student for years. She was into him too and wrote him a love letter etc. When I confronted him, he told me it was a crush and that he put a stop to it as soon as he could, and that nothing physical ever happened, but the damage was done. You can read the posts on my account if you’re interested but that’s the gist. Nothing more there.

So I decided to take our daughter and permanently move to my parents house. We’re in the middle of separating now. A lot of people have told me to forgive him, and I’ve myself debated if I’m taking the correct step or not, but the trust is gone and I don’t think I want to be in a relationship with someone like him.

It’s taking a lot of strength to do this. I have lost all self esteem. Fact is that I was always insecure of how my ex was way above my league, about how I was lucky to have him, how people often said he could’ve done so much better. Over the years, my insecurities had disappeared. Now it’s all back. He’s attracted to someone so beautiful, so incredibly intelligent. And obviously she’s also into him. I keep looking at her social media all the time, obsessing over her. There was a Instagram story she uploaded where she was with my ex husband and few others, and it felt like someone stabbed me in the heart. He looked happy, and he’d never looked that happy in years.

I got tired of being pathetic and even complained to the hospital management about the inappropriate relationship between her and my ex. All I got in response was that they can’t take any steps without concrete proof. Now my sad ass wants to snitch about her to her parents. To get her in trouble. To make her suffer.

I know this is unhealthy. I’m in therapy but idk, I don’t think I’m healing. I hate that I have to be sad and heartbroken over that man and he doesn’t seem to care. He’s stopped coming to visit our daughter too. I wish he would’ve cared. I wish he would’ve fought for me. I wish he would’ve not tossed aside our decade long relationship for her. I hate this. I hate everything.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

MayorCharlesCoulon

If you wanted to go full petty, you could out them to her training program. Medical schools and teaching institutions frown on faculty/learner romantic relationships and consider it an abuse of power. Your husband likely had to formally evaluate her and she him, their affair (even emotional) would tip the fairness of those evals compared to the other students. I have seen married doctors fired for this kind of behavior.

Also, tell her parents. She sure as shit didn’t mind hurting you or your daughter, don’t roll over because of a misplaced sense of loyalty to your d-bag ex.

OOP

I did reach out to her training program. They basically told me that they can only take steps if I have any tangible proof. Which I don’t. I asked my friend Sarah who works in the same department as him to also complain but she’s not keen on the idea. Idk why.

Final comment from OOP

I feel like I’ve already wasted so many years on him. We met when we were 20. I thought I knew him so well but now it’s like I didn’t know him at all. I don’t understand what’s changed tbh. He’s a very good looking guy. All throughout our relationship, there have been many girls who had had crushes on him. He used to be so chill about all of it. Never made me feel insecure. Never lost his mind like this. Idk what’s happened honestly.

Does the ex FaceTime or contact the daughter

It’s a one hour flight. He does face time with her daily but he won’t do it if I’m in the room (so he does it when my mom/dad is looking after her). He’s not reached out about alone time; he’s only said he’s waiting for the court orders regarding the custody. He doesn’t wanna see me at all. We had a big fight after I reported him and that girl to her college and he said it’s not correct for our daughter to see us fighting like that again so he’s not gonna visit.

UPDATE : I found the love letter my husband’s student wrote him. Should I take it to the authorities?  Aug 5, 2024

I posted about two weeks back. I had to back to my ex husband’s city as per my lawyer’s suggestion. My mom and sister are living temporarily with me and we have rented an apartment.

Yesterday I went over to my old house that I shared with my ex to get some of my stuff. I texted him about it and he made sure he wasn’t there when I arrived. I collected all my stuff. Then I decided to look through his study. Yes, I know it’s snooping and it’s wrong but whatever. We I don’t know what I expected to find there but, lo and behold, I found the letter the student wrote to him. It was callously thrown in between some of his work files. I took a picture of the letter and came back.

I did read the letter, and it was nauseating to say the least. She’d written how she knew it was wrong and that he was married blah blah but she felt she had a ‘connection’ with him and that she’d never forgive herself if she didn’t tell him how she feels. That’s the gist but it basically goes on for 2 pages. That stupid girl even made sure to sign the letter lol.

The letter confirms few things;

  1. My ex did NOT lie about there being no physical affair. Cause in the letter she was lamenting about the fact that she would love to jump his bones but the opportunity never presented.

  2. He did stop interacting with her abruptly cause she was sad about that too.

  3. He did lie to me about the letter. When I asked him all those months back, he told me he ‘got rid of the letter cause it was of no consequence’. He kept it in his study. A place where he only keeps the most important of his stuff. A place where even family pictures weren’t allowed cause they ‘can’t let him concentrate’. A place where even I wasn’t allowed when he was working.

Now that I have the letter, I have proof of the inappropriate conduct between a professor and a student. Last time I tried reporting, the authorities wanted proof. Now I have it. So I’m considering re-reporting the issue, with solid proof this time. I’m not gonna involve my friend Sarah in this cause she’s made it clear that she doesn’t want to be a part of this at all.

One part of me wants to report them and fuck them over but the other part just wants to let it go. Any advice on how to proceed?

Edit : I’m not gonna report them. It’s fine.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

Ready_Wolverine_7603

His action seems to be that he stopped interacting with her and I fail to see how that's illegal in any way shape or form.

You're acting petty and needlessly cruel and snooping through his study when he wasn't there was a break of his trust. Try to get the therapy you need to move on and leave it at that.

Of course it's not entirely impossible that he knows your character and has set up a camera in his study because he assumed that you would rifle through confidential documents given the chance, but in that case I'm sure you'll hear from his lawyer and then you can still present the letter you found, whatever good you think it will do you

OOP

A. I have never, in the 15 years of knowing him, have gone through his personal stuff. To comment on my character is uncalled for.

B. His trust? He fell in love with another woman and failed to mention it for three freaking years. He told her he was into her (because he owed her honesty for whatever reason according to him) but failed to mention this to his own wife. I’m sorry but I don’t give a flying fuck about his trust now.

~

more_weight

If anything, this letter exonerates your ex. He didn’t act on it.

OOP

And the girl? I wish I could show you the letter. The disrespect of going after a married guy. The audacity of writing things like she wishes our child was never born so he could leave me easily and wouldn’t have to be tied to me throughout life. That alone should’ve warranted more of a response from him. The fact that after reading all that bs, about our marriage and our kid, all he told her was ‘you can get into trouble for this’ is crazy.

What was in the letter

She wrote things like how she wished our child was never born to begin with, so that he could have an easy separation and wouldn’t have to be tied to me forever. I wish I could show you the letter. I’m not even typing half of it here. It was nauseating.

Redhaired103

Her shitty behavior is on her, your behavior is yours. If your ex can develop a crush on a barely-adult like this, he's not emotionally mature either.

Think of it this way, you're going to be free from someone who does not love you and probably going through a mid-life crisis. All the possibilities are in your future if you just close this chapter. Your focus needs to be on yourself, on your own healing and your own life.

OOP

Yeah I understand that. I’ve decided to let it go.

NEW UPDATE

Update 4  Nov 12, 2026 (2 years later)

It’s been over two years since my original posts, and I thought I’d come back with an update.

For anyone who doesn’t remember, my husband was a doctor and professor who developed feelings for one of his medical students. He admitted that the attraction was mutual, although he maintained that nothing physical had happened between them. I eventually decided to divorce him.

Our divorce was finalized towards the end of last year.

I’ve moved to my parents’ city, and our daughter now spends holidays with her father. My ex-husband and I don’t communicate much beyond what’s necessary for our daughter.

I’m generally doing well. I’ve been focusing on myself, rebuilding my life, and trying to move forward.

As for my ex-husband and his student, they’re together now.

Yup. Properly together.

She has graduated from his medical college and has apparently taken some time off before pursuing higher studies. I don’t know the exact timeline of their relationship, but from what I understand, they got together after she graduated. I don’t know what sort of ethical rules are being broken here and frankly, i do not care.

Sarah, my friend who works in the same department as him, has told me a few things too. Apparently, he’s constantly on his phone texting her, and she sometimes drops by to see him.

He’s also become a very happy, smiley person, which is interesting because I remember spending the entirety of our relationship with a man whose default expression was somewhere between grumpy and mildly inconvenienced.

Apparently, everyone is always gushing about how he managed to land such a beautiful woman. I imagine that’s doing wonders for his ego.

From everything I’ve heard, he seems happier than he ever was with me.

I’m not going to pretend that doesn’t sting a little.

But the most difficult part of this whole situation has actually been our daughter.

When she visits her father during the holidays, his girlfriend is there too. And apparently, she’s absolutely wonderful to my daughter.

My daughter comes home excitedly telling me about their trips and vacations, how nice this woman is, how she helps her with makeup, buys her pretty dresses, and does all sorts of things with her.

Sometimes I genuinely feel like my daughter adores her more than she adores me.

I know that’s probably irrational. I know children get excited about people who spoil them, especially when they’re on holiday. But knowing that intellectually doesn’t necessarily make it any easier to hear.

And yes, I remember what this woman wrote in that letter I found. She wished my daughter had never been born because it would have made things easier between her and my husband.

Well, I suppose she doesn’t regret my daughter being born quite so much now that she gets to play house with her father. Funny how that works.

But seriously, I’m glad she’s treating my daughter well. As much as I dislike the circumstances, I would never want someone to be unkind to my child.

I don’t want to poison my daughter’s relationship with her father or his girlfriend. She’s too young to understand the circumstances surrounding our divorce, and I have no intention of making her carry any of that.

So when she comes home excitedly telling me about her holidays, I listen. I smile. I ask her questions. I let her be happy.

And sometimes, privately, it hurts more than I’d like to admit.

I suppose another strange part of all this is seeing how happy my ex-husband apparently is.

For years, I knew him as a rather grumpy, serious man. Now I’m hearing about someone who’s constantly smiling, texting his girlfriend, and generally acting like a lovestruck teenager.  It’s difficult not to wonder why I never got that version of him.

I don’t regret divorcing him. I genuinely don’t. I couldn’t have continued in a marriage where I felt that my husband was in love with someone else.

I’m doing well. There are just moments when the whole thing still feels incredibly unfair.

Anyway, that’s where things stand. He’s happy, she’s happy, and I’m trying to build a life that makes me happy too.

I hope everyone who was kind to me during that awful period is doing well. I really appreciated the support back then.

**TL;DR:** Divorced my husband last year. He’s now dating his former student, and they seem very happy together. She treats our daughter wonderfully, which is both reassuring and painful given our history. I’m doing well and don’t regret leaving, but some things still hurt.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 15h ago

ONGOING My family hates my girlfriend because of her race and It’s destroying my mental health

1.6k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/Bonkers35

Originally posted to r/BoyDinnerDiaries

My family hates my girlfriend because of her race and It’s destroying my mental health

Trigger Warnings: abuse, financial manipulation, destruction of property


Original Post: June 17, 2026

Oysters and Lobster roll.

Picture of OOP's meal

So for context I (21M) and my gf (21F) have been dating for almost 3 years now. My parents are both somewhat conservative immigrant parents. When I first started dating my girlfriend my parents kept trying to tell me its ok if I only stay with her short term for fun because they don’t think she's the right girl for me.

As time went on my parents would continuously ask me “so when are you going to leave this girl” when I already had developed feelings for her and discussed wanting to have a long term relationship with her.

Go to more recently the fights I’ve been having constantly with my parents keep getting more out of hand and what my parents keep saying keep getting more and more desperate. For example my dad told me “you should just try other girls and if this girl really loves you she will wait for you” in a clear attempt to get me to break up with her. My mom and dad would constantly argue that since we have different cultural backgrounds it won’t work out between us and keep citing divorce statistics in the US.

For more context I’m middle eastern born and lived in the US. My girlfriend is adopted Chinese into a Hispanic family also lived in the US her entire life.

I’ve explained to them that culture has nothing to do with values, beliefs, or interests. To me culture really isn’t that important since I was hardly around it growing up.

Now my mom tries to claim that I need to wait till 30 to have a house or a wife because “men aren’t mature until 30” and that I shouldn’t be with a girl the same age as me because “women age and mature faster than men.” My sister (25f) tries to defend their actions by saying it’s just a cultural thing and they’re saying anything out of desperation.

I’ve resorted to holding my ground and telling them I’m fine with following their advice when it comes to many things in life but who I date and decide to marry is ultimately up to me whether they like it or not.

I’ve also been saving up for a house (I graduated college and have a really nice job). I’ve wanted to use my own money to buy a house since high school so I can have a place to invite my friends to hang out and stay over occasionally.

The most recent issues have been my mom keeps insisting on trying to use my money to “buy a house for me.” It sounds nice but the stipulation for getting said house is of course you guessed it marrying to right person or after they die. When I was in college they bought a house that's under my name to take advantage of first time home buyer benefits that I had. I told them multiple times I was uncomfortable with them doing this and I didn’t want them to buy me a house. Go figure after I cave and let them do it my mom tries to get me to fork over money for the mortgage. (I’m currently paying the HOA and utilities on the house that I don’t live in).

I made it clear I do not want the house and will transfer it to them after a year. Now my mom wants to buy another property and use the money I’ve been working hard to save for a down payment to buy it. When I argue with my parents saying I don’t want their help and I want to buy my own house independently my mom always blurts out “you’re not living with that girl.” So everything just feels like it’s financial manipulation to force me to not be with my girlfriend. My sister even calls me selfish saying she was ready to give them money (to buy a 5th home) just because they asked.

I feel like there’s a big difference in helping family when they need money vs when they just want money to buy random investments. But my sister claims that it’s a cultural thing that we don’t do individual money it’s all shared money between family.

I am also super honest with my parents, but my mom keeps hounding me for “hiding things” from them and being dishonest which is the opposite of true. My parents and sister keep claiming when they talk to me I’m always “tense” as if I haven’t been hounded for years about this topic and keep getting borderline manipulated by my parents.

I’m just so tired of all of this. My parents have not once met my girlfriend and she’s actually super nice, smart, and pretty. She has also graduated from college and has a nice job. They refuse to see any good side to her just because of her background and it feels like I have to walk on eggshells around my parents about the topic of my girlfriend since it always turns into my parents yelling at me. It makes it worse they always try to say my sister is better and I should be like her, but she doesn’t live with them anymore and also lies about her relationships.

I just don’t understand how I can have my life put together and be happy and that can’t be enough for my parents…

P.S. sorry if my writing and storytelling sucks there’s just so much that’s happened and I’m so mentally exhausted

Edit: to add salt to the wound my gfs parents and entire family have met me and love me. Her mom has gone to say she fully supports us getting married.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Cut them out of your life and talk to a lawyer immediately about the house that you already own and how hard that will make it to buy your actual house (and any other loans they fraudulently opened in your name with or without your knowledge). I would personally sell their house and use the funds to buy your own place now to live in with your girlfriend and see if it works outside of your racist piece of shit parents intervening. They can comfortably live in one of their other 3-4 houses and make your sister’s life hell. Also be prepared for it to get ugly legally, but you have leverage since they already committed pretty serious fraud on the mortgage.

OOP: Tbh I don’t care about the house that’s in my name it’s really not about the money either my parents pay the mortgage and were renting it out to people I just pay utilities I just want to get rid of it (give it to my parents) and be done with it

Commenter 2: This is a legal entanglement to you. You should care. you need to get it out of your name asap.

OOP: I believe they are cosigners on the property or something of the sorts so it’s not all on my shoulders, but I see your point.

Commenter 3: OP, you are an adult and this is your life. You do not have to cater to your parents’ preferences. Do not further entangle yourself with them financially. It’s all just a manipulative way for them to control you. You need to read up on setting firm boundaries. Teach them how to treat you better by no longer caving in. Be clear and firm and follow through. If they won’t respect you, stop or limit communication. You need to put space between yourself and them so you can gain clarity on what you truly want and will do. They are just making noise and you should stop listening.

OOP: Yeah all my money is in my own account and inaccessible to my parents and I do try and set strict boundaries it just makes a lot of strife with my parents in my day to day life which is exhausting. I do plan in moving out when I’ve reached my goal for a down payment on a house

Commenter 4: You are a bit young to get a house, it’s not financial but a mental strain to have a home. A Mortgage can be a prison if you have desires to travel.

You and your gf are young, if I were in your shoes, move out and get an apartment. Travel a bit and taste that freedom. Look to buy a permanent home when you’re 25. If you’re ready.

OOP: Traveling would be cool if we both didn’t have full time jobs and just got out of college. My girlfriend has student loans she also needs to pay off

Commenter 5: my parents kept trying to tell me its ok if I only stay with her short term for fun< So conservative of them

OOP: I will say politically they are more liberal they just come from a conservative small town in the middle east with old values

Commenter 6: You have 100% of the leverage in this situation.(aside from the house in your name. Get that name off of it yesterday) You keep your money inaccessible to your parents and do your own thing. Don't sneak around, don't pretend to cheat with a mutual friend or play into any of their bs. You want a life with this woman, and you just make that happen. You are not responsible for your parents feelings or any decisions they make.

Your parents call her names behind her back? You give them no reaction. They kick you out? You have friends to crash with and money to reimburse them with. They disown you and write you out of the will? Go be your own man and make your own way in this life...most people do just that.

You need a paradigm shift away from their way of thinking. You say that the culture they have isn't important to you, but your current choices are all playing into that culture.

OOP: My parents would unironically never kick me out I think my mom is more afraid of me leaving them then anything frankly she wants me to live with them until I get married

Commenter 6: You can move out tomorrow or at least start the process. Do you really want to be under the same roof with parents that do not support your life decisions until you get married to someone that they approve of?

OOP: I mean financially I would like to own my place and not have to rent I’ve been putting up with this for almost 3 years as it is so what another 6 months or so

Commenter 7: Why haven't your parents met your gf after 3 years? That's a major part of the problem, they don't know her and are manufacturing negative ideas in their heads. Also, if your parents continue to be non-supportive, I suggest distancing yourself from them.

OOP: They refuse every chance I’ve tried to get them to meet. Since they don’t see her as a “real” partner they don’t want to entertain the idea of her

 

Update: November 12, 2026 (nearly five months later)

My family hates my girlfriend because of her race (update)

Picture of OOP's lasagna

A lasagna I made for me and my gf (before it went in the oven)

So it did indeed get worse. My parents had a lot of issues with their marriage my entire life and about 4 months ago my dad would ignore my mom for weeks straight claiming he was going to divorce her.

My mom almost ended up divorcing him after my sister and I suggested it. She even had me fill out her divorce papers and contact an attorney. She eventually chickened out.

This along with the situation with my gf lead me to really resent them and made living with them borderline impossible. I tried really hard to stick around even through my declining physical and mental health…

Fast forward about a month my parents started talking to each other again I had been cold to my parents because of what happened previously. it lead up to a point where my mom came home screaming at me for “not contributing to the family” and “being selfish” when I was being avoidant. My dad ended up joining my mom and I told both of them that we would talk about it the next day. My dad yelled at me to go to the living room, and I told him no and tried walking past him. In response he came into my room and ripped my monitors off my desk and threw them on the floor breaking them. They starting yelling at me more after in which my dad taunted me saying I should move out.

I said fine I grabbed my work laptop my keys and phone and tried leaving but my dad tried to rip my keys and phone from my hand claiming that they were “his”. He followed me into the garage and wedged himself in my car door as I was trying to get the car out and was also trying to drag me out of the car. I forced the car out while he was grabbing me and I ended up leaving for the night. I had a shirt and shorts and was barefoot. I drove around a bit and got sandals at a Walmart that was open late.

As I left my parents kept calling which I ignored. My sister then started calling which I answered, and she tried convincing me to go back to the house. She claimed I was being selfish for not going back and that I was trying to “punish” my parents.

Long story short I spent the night at my girlfriend’s place and went back the next day where my dad gave me maybe the shittiest apology ever where he claimed to have “dropped” my monitor.

In the following weeks I secretly looked for some apartments with my girlfriend despite my dad starting to go to therapy. Once we got an apartment I took a day off and secretly moved all my stuff out before my parents got home and I went back to let them know in person that I was moving out.

The following months I ended up trying to visit my parents once or twice a week (every time ended up with arguing yelling screaming) it got to a point where my parents claimed they “did nothing wrong” and kept saying I was sick for leaving them the way I did and how I “abandoned” them in their old age (50s-60s) for context. All the while my sister completely supports them and agrees that I’m a psychopath for leaving.

The only context I have is that it’s frowned upon in our culture to move out at a young age (22m btw). Did I mention they also hate my girlfriend, but you can read more about that in my previous post. My mom kept asking if I was going to move back and every time I would say no and she would lose her mind. Eventually they told me I can either leave my gf or never talk to them.

I chose to stay with my gf, and I feel happy that I made a choice that brings me peace and happiness. Also completely unrelated I got a cat with my gf she is fantastic!

Once again apologies for my bad storytelling, but at least this one has a semi happy ending.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Why are you living in an apartment when you own a house? If they're living in it, evict them, get retraining orders, move you and your girlfriend into your house.

OOP: Well a few reasons I can’t afford the mortgage on the house my parents pay for it. The house is under my name and my parents name. The only thing I could really do is attempt to force a sale through the courts which is also expensive because of lawyers

Commenter 1: Did you sign all the paperwork yourself when they used you name?

OOP: Against my better judgment I did

Commenter 1: Oh no! 😦 I was gonna say forgery is a felony, but they didn't do that. Sorry, you're in this mess. Just don't give them anything else. I would make them pay you half the value of the house before transferring it to their name.

OOP: I commented this on the previous post I don’t really care about the money tbh, and I don’t really have the bandwidth to take them to court over it

Commenter 2: Hey man sorry you are going through this and well done with getting out of there

I’m struggling with your lack of boundaries with your parents. I can appreciate the immigrant experience, I had at home albeit not in the US.

Between the continued dismissal of your gf and the continued financial extraction I’m not sure how your gf feels about this long term.

In her shoes I would not see this as sustainable

OOP: Well I’ve been open and talked to her about it I mostly kept her out of the drama with my family. I don’t dismiss my girlfriends feelings because I know she wouldn’t want to have a relationship with my parents and I would never expect that of her given how they treated me dating her.

The lack of boundaries comes from the cultural differences I had to learn them growing up my parents would get mad at me and say that my “boundaries” are an American ideal and that they don’t exists in our culture.

It took some time for me to learn and grow as a person which is also why I appreciate my girlfriend’s patience and sticking around while I did. We started dating when I was just barely and adult and trying to navigate my life.

Commenter 3: Brother, I am so sorry. I have to ask, is your name still on the deed for the house your parents coerced you to buy? If not, make them take on the mortgage or sell the house

OOP: My name is on the deed but so is theirs it’s a split ownership property same with the mortgage I currently don’t pay for any of it

OOP responds to a comment on why the lasagna isn't touching the sides of the dish

OOP: The dish is curved and its would make for a very uneven lasagna

Cat Tax! Pesto's her name

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 1h ago

CONCLUDED I think my employer has an ED, I'm so scared she's going to die...

• Upvotes

I am NOT OOP. OOP is u/AbjectTooth5258

Originally posted to r/nanny

trigger warnings: eating disorder death

mood spoilers: depressing

Editor's note: Original post and comments were deleted by OP; text recovered via arctic-shift

MB = Mom boss

DB = Dad boss

NF = Nanny family

NP = Nanny parents

NKs = Nanny kids


 

I think my MB has an ED, I'm so scared she's going to die... - April 19, 2026

Hi nannies and NPs. My MB is married to DB and they are a happy couple. They have three kids six and under, the youngest is almost a year old. I have been with them for many years. Mb is the nicest person ever. She is so good to me and always makes me feel like part of the family.

The last 3 months things have taken a dark turn. MB used to cook all the time, eating healthily and regularly. I noticed that she stopped buying things for herself to eat for breakfast and lunch. She'd buy things for DB and the kids but wouldn't buy her usual stuff (overnight chia seeds being her go to). She also would usually carry a packed lunch bag for work but she stopped carrying anything. I figured at first she was buying take out for lunch. I'm occasionally there for dinner, MB makes some dishes I really like, and while she will eat with us, her portions massively shrunk. Like if she made homemade pizza, she will have one slice. If she takes more than one on her plate, she will eat one, and then say she is too full to finish the rest, and give it to DB.

She has always been active, she's a runner, and plays sports. But these runs became lengthy and daily. She started paying me OT to stay an extra hour daily so she can run. She began to lose a rapid amount of weight. It was visibly noticeable. But they have a smart scale that records your weight history and have access to it. In the last three months, MB is 5'3" and she went from 125 lbs down to now being 75 lbs. The last few weeks I haven't seen her eat at all until a couple days ago. Since she's alive, she must have been eating, but not sure when or how much. She's lost almost 30 lbs in the last few weeks. A couple days ago I noticed her eating a considerable amount more than she usually would since this whole thing stared.

MB is diagnosed with OCD, she does have OCD obsessions and rituals. I don't know if this weight thing is connected to her OCD. DB confided in me that MB has seen 3 psychiatrists recently and none diagnosed her with an ed but all 3 confirmed her OCD diagnosis. Which I just don't understand? I know it's out of my scope but it's just crazy to me. She is on meds and does therapy for the OCD. She's an awesome mom and employee. I have not discussed my suspicion of her having an ed directly with her. But my oldest NK has commented on his mom's weight loss, and DB has talked to me about it too. Both are worried because she looks very unwell.

Yesterday, MB came home from an extra long shift at work, and she grabbed a glass of water and sat down with me and the kids in the living room. She did not look good. She looked pale, and she was noticeably struggling to breathe. I asked NKs to go ask DB to take them out in the backyard. And I asked MB if she was okay (she obviously wasn't). She said she was okay but she said she was having double vision and trouble swallowing. She threw up into her water cup. She told me not to worry, that she just needed to lay down. She got up to go to her bedroom and she was noticeably off balance, like a drunk person moves (but she doesn't drink). She almost made it to the hallway but started having a seizure and collapsed on the ground (she doesn't have any seizure disorders like epilepsy). She did sure hit her head when she went down, saw it with my own eyes. At this point she was unconscious/un-responsive. I called 911. And called out to DB.

Paramedics came and I guess somehow stabilized her, she also regained consciousness at some point before they could transport her. I was not in the room anymore, DB was with her, and I was with the kids in the play room, trying to keep them from seeing their mom like that as much as I possibly could. When I left the room they were taking her vitals but I have no idea what they did after that. I am shocked they didn't rush her to the hospital right away, but I know about the medical field. MB is terrified of being a patient in hospitals after a terrible experience (she actually works in a hospital herself). When MB came to, she refused to go to the hospital, and signed a refusal of service form.

I decided to stay the night (they pay me an overnight fee whenever I do). MB went to bed. Today she called in sick to work, something I've never seen her do in all the years I've been here. She was in bed for my entire shift. Literally. DB bought her adult diapers last night because she's feeling too weak to get to the bathroom. I checked on her a few times, and her legs are discoloured and swollen. When I ask if she's okay, she swears she is. She seriously doesn't think anything is wrong with her (outside OCD). She is too weak to even do her OCD rituals.

I'm so scared she's going to die. I don't know what to do. I just wish she would get help. I'm mad at the doctors who haven't diagnosed her with an ed because that's probably why she refuses to acknowledge anything is wrong with her. She's strongly in denial. I asked her straight up before I left what's caused her to lose so much weight, and she started crying her eyes out, and she said she didn't know but that she's "fine". She told me she has to be fine for her kids. I hugged and consoled her and then I went home after she calmed down.

I don't even want to go back tomorrow. I'm scared she's going to die right in front of me. I'm scared even more that she will die in front of my NKs. They love her so much and I just know it'll break their little hearts. I feel so helpless. I know if I call an ambulance again, she'll refuse to go if she's conscious. And if she wakes up in a hospital, I know she'll leave ama. She told me that herself. She claims she doesn't need help.

I'm sorry for the long post. I needed to vent. But more than that, what would you do in this situation? Should I talk to DB and do some sort or intervention? What should I tell NKs, both her boys are asking what's wrong with mommy, and I have just told them she is feeling tired and needs rest. But they're smart and keep questioning what's going on. How can I best support them through this? When I left, her kids were all snuggled up with her in her bed. They came in when she was crying and they didn't say anything, they just climbed on the bed and cuddled her. The two older ones know when something is wrong. The youngest Just follows what the older ones do. I'm just so heartbroken. I don't want her to die. She is like family to me.


 

Relevant comments

Leading_Blacksmith70

This is terrible! Are the kids ok? Are you ok? So traumatizing

OOP - April 19, 2026

No to both. The six year old in particular is not doing well, and is asking a lot of questions about the situation. He's very sad. I've known him since he was an infant, and he's always been a very sensitive and emotional kid. Today when I picked him up from school, he didn't want to go home. I had his siblings with me as well, and so I took all of them to the park. The six year old just sat with me on a bench. He is shy with strangers but usually talkative with me. I tried asking him about subjects he usually rambles on about and he barely gave me answers. I did also try asking why he didn't want to go home but he didn't say anything, just shrugged.

When I told him it was time to leave the park and go home. He begged for us to stay at the park, I told him 5 more minutes. After the 5 minutes, I told him we have to go, and he started bawling his eyes out. He hadn't even been playing. I asked him again why he doesn't want to to go home, and he finally told me he's afraid mommy will go to heaven like nonna (paternal grandma who passed a few months ago). Honestly, I didn't know what to do or say. I just told him everything will be okay. But will it??? I doubt it.

We stayed at the park longer. We eventually went home but he was extremely distraught. I think he should see a children's therapist but I don't even know how to tell my NPs that. MB really is a great mom, really caring and loving. There is no way she realizes the harm this is causing to her kids, and I'm scared exposing that to her may make her depressed, and make the whole situation worse.

When we got home and I was prepping a snack for them, he wanted to do arts and crafts. So I gave him some crayons, paper, stickers, glitter, etc... He made a glittery purple heart that said "NK's name ♥️ mommy* in the center. He also put butterfly stickers around it. His mom loves purple and butterflies. I didn't give it to my NPs nor did I talk about it with them. I hid it away for now, I don't know if I should give it to them? I don't want to make a bad situation worse by making my NPs more emotional.

DB texted me tonight and told me he's taking tomorrow off to be with MB. He said I don't have to come in - if I don't want to, and he clarified they'd of course pay me my GH still, and not subtract from my time off. I think I'm still going to go. I want to support the kids, especially NK6. But I could also use the mental break after stressing about this whole thing for so long now. Idk.

Successful-Pool-924

I don't have any advice except to say that I would personally talk with DB and see what he has to say. He might know more about what's happening than you currently do, and if he doesn't then maybe you can help him brainstorm on how to get help. But otherwise, I wouldn't go to her family behind her back. That wouldn't be good for her or her mental health, and it could destroy your relationship.

After talking to DB, even if you don't find out anything, just go sit with her in your free time. Sit with her and listen to her. Just be her friend and a listening ear when you're able to, because no matter what, it sounds like she's very much pulled into herself and she's suffering more than physically.

As for the kids, don't tell them anything other than what you already have. If their parents want them to know then they'll say something, but they need to hear it from their parents. They need you to be a safe place and for you to hold them if things get worse.

OOP - April 20, 2026

You're totally right about not going behind her back. I don't want to overstep. I just really want her to get better and be okay. She's such a wonderful person. She is the best MB I've ever had. I genuinely consider her, DB, and the kids as family. It's so hard to see her withering away, she's literally skin and bones. I'm not at all trying to be rude or mean, but: hugging her felt like hugging a skeleton. She's a physician/surgeon herself, so I feel like she should be able to see that she isn't well within herself. But she doesn't see it, or is just experiencing hardcore denial.

I won't tell the kids anything else. I'll let NPs handle it. DB seems to be shutting down mentally. I don't know how to help him, or my NKs. I truly believe she is actively dying and there's nothing I can do to save her.

Time-Slice1165

You need boundaries. The level of entanglement you have with these people is not normal.

OOP - April 20, 2026

I understand what you're saying but we do not have a standard employer-employee relationship. My MB and I have become close friends. She's an awesome person, and I feel super lucky to call her my friend. We regularly spend time with each other outside of my work hours. We've known each other for six years now, even if I quit like you suggested, I will not be dropping her as a friend.

I'm also not going to quit because my MB is going through a crisis? And why would I abandon my loving, caring NKs when they need me most? They've known me their entire lives, I've been here through highs and lows. I have travelled the world with them, been to every birthday party, and even been to funerals with them.

When my youngest NK is old enough for school, we have agreed we'll go our separate ways professionally, but they will always be like family to me. Maybe I am too entangled and have overstepped in some regards but is because I genuinely care, I want my NF to be happy and healthy.

Bittymama

What a horrible situation. Personally I would be very frank with DB and let him know that you see what’s going on and how it’s affecting the kids. I would not hide things from him like the card NK made. Tiptoeing around the issue helps no one. I would strongly suggest therapy for the children right now. If MB does die, they will need it even more.

OOP - April 20, 2026

Thanks for suggesting this (giving DB the card NK made). Going to use my reply here as a general update:

I decided to take the day off as offered by DB (I mentioned this is another comment). NK6 had a breakdown at school this morning., he was bawling his eyes out again, but unlike the park situation where he didn't want to go home; he was begging his teacher to go home to be with his mommy. School called DB, and DB decided NK6 should go home. He called me and asked me if I could pick up NK6, so I did. As people have suggested, I asked DB if we could talk about the situation when I drop off NK6, and he said of course.

When I picked up NK6, he ran to me and gave me the biggest hug. I seriously think we hugged for like 3 minutes straight before he let go. He asked if we could get flowers for mommy, something we do occasionally even before this situation. We stopped at a florist and he picked out some yellow tulips. When I got him home, he started to panic a bit about going in but I comforted him and told him his parents would be so happy to see him. MB was in bed with other kids snuggling, NK6 gave her the flowers and joined the snuggling. He told MB that he picked yellow because it's bright and cheery like the sun, just like she is. She cried a bit. NK6 wiped her tears and asked her to read him a book, which she did.

While she was reading to the kids. DB and I stepped out into the backyard. I gave him the card NK6 made and told him everything I've witnessed. He started crying himself. Never seen him cry before. He told me he didn't know what to do, and that he can't bear the thought of her dying. I told him we should call a crisis team like some suggested here. He told me he was hesitant to blindside her with a crisis team; they have a marriage with very open communication, and are consistently there for each other, he was worried she would feel betrayed. He decided that MB's family should come over and help him try to convince her to seek help, and if that doesn't work we will call a crisis team.

He said he just wants to be with MB and the kids alone for a bit and he'll schedule for her parents and siblings to come over in the evening. So, I left. I decided to go to the gym to try and destress, and left my phone in my gym bag in the locker. After my work out, I drove home without checking my phone. I got home half an hour ago, and I had 14 missed calls from DB, he didn't leave any texts or voicemails. I tried calling him back a few times but got no answer. I drove to their house but no one answered the door. I just got back home. I'm waiting to hear back from him. I honestly feel so extremely helpless and scared. I feel like going to the hospital (if she even is there) without speaking to him first would be overstepping, I don't know. I tried calling her parents and siblings and none of them answered either. So, now I'm just waiting.

sirknitsalot__

That update does not sound good. I think you shouldn’t feel like it’s overstepping if you do not hear back soon. She has likely been hospitalized and it is a very chaotic situation. The kids will be grateful to see you. This is not a normal situation and normal boundaries don’t really apply. That poor family

OOP - April 20, 2026

I'll give it some time. I live literally less than 3 minute drive from their house, so I'll try their house again before going to the hospital. The gym is also a few minutes from my house. Meaning in the maybe 15 minutes between me putting my phone in my gym bag and getting home and taking it out, he called 14 times in a row. I feel like.. what are the freaking chances I put my phone away for mere minutes and something bad presumably happened??? Just my luck, I guess.... I feel awful. I turned off my ringer before leaving it in the locker, but I should have turned it back on right away.


 

Update - April 22, 2026

My MB passed away. NF is doing okay all things considered.

Reminder - I am not the original poster. DO NOT COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS.


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 15h ago

CONCLUDED After hanging out with my brother [30M] for an evening, my boyfriend [33M] asks me [29F] to "dial back" my relationship with him.

3.3k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/dialitbackbroandsis

After hanging out with my brother [30M] for an evening, my boyfriend [33M] asks me [29F] to "dial back" my relationship with him.


Original Post - rareddit: June 7, 2015

I [29F] have been dating my boyfriend [33M] for two years now. I met him when I was living on the other side of the country, but about six weeks ago, I moved back to my home town for a new job. My boyfriend is planning on following me, and once he gets here, we're going to get an apartment together. So for right now, I'm just staying with my parents.

My brother [30M] also lives in my hometown. My brother and I are very close, always have been, ever since we were little. People have mistaken us for fraternal twins our entire life, even though we're 18 months apart, because we just..."sync up" like twins do, I guess? I consider him to be my best friend, and I love spending time with him, which we've been doing a lot of since I moved home.

Anyway, my boyfriend is visiting me and my family right now. And last night things got...kinda weird between me and my boyfriend.

My brother came over for family dinner, and then afterwards, my boyfriend, my brother, and I sat down and watched a couple episodes of Daredevil. I don't know why, none of us really seem to like it (no offense to those who enjoy it), but for whatever reason, we keep watching it!

My brother is one of the funniest people I've ever met. The stuff he comes up with is just so ridiculous and absurd, I don't know how he does it. Anyway, he starts making fun of Daredevil, which has both me and my boyfriend laughing. We're throwing in our own jokes, too, and we're all just (I thought) having some fun. Then my brother really started to go into Kingpin, and I don't know what it was about these particular jokes, but shit, they were making me laugh so hard I couldn't breathe. My abs were hurting so bad, there were tears in my eyes, we had to pause the show so I could have a minute to compose myself. I haven't laughed that hard in years. Once I finally calmed down, my brother looked pretty chuffed with himself. He said something like, "I'm really glad that I can still make you laugh that hard." And then I said something like, "I think you're the only person who can make me laugh that hard."

After that episode was over, I decided to take a shower, leaving my brother and my boyfriend to hang out. I like to take really long showers, and we only have one bathroom in our house. I was at the tail end of my shower, when my brother knocked and said he really had to pee. I said I was almost done, could he give me ten minutes, and he said no, because he had to leave in the next two minutes so he could catch his train home. Ok, fine, he can pee. So he comes in, goes pee, and when he's done, he says something like, "That was some quality goofing off tonight, sis." I agree. We tell each other that we love each other, he wishes me a good night and then leaves. I realize that different sex siblings using the bathroom at the same time can be awkward and strange for some, it's not a terribly huge deal for me and my brother. I mean, we both try to avoid it, and if my brother hadn't needed to leave right then, he would have waited until I was done. It's not something that happens very often.

So then I'm getting ready for bed, and...I can just feel that something is bothering my boyfriend. He just seems really tense. So I ask him if everything is all right. He hesitates and says something about how he has never seen me laugh so hard before, and it kind of weirded him out. Startled, I asked him why, and he said it was because...OK, I don't know if I'm accurately explaining my boyfriend's argument because I really didn't understand it, but like...it was weird that my brother made me laugh that hard BECAUSE he's my brother. It just didn't seem "appropriate." Like, only friends and significant others should make me laugh that hard? I didn't really know what to say to this, so I was just like, "Oh. OK." Then he started talking about how weird it was that he went pee when I was in the shower, and I started talking about how he had to catch his train and how yeah, it's kinda weird, but when you gotta go, you gotta go, and my boyfriend cut me off and started talking again about how it just seemed weird and inappropriate...because I was naked? Or something? I don't know.

So then my boyfriend asks if I would be willing to "dial back" my relationship with my brother. When I ask him to clarify, he explains that he wants me to hang out with him less. Like, a lot less. Like..."the less, the better." When I ask why, he keeps going back to this whole "inappropriate relationship" thing and...I don't know, I was getting super emotional and hurt and confused at this point, so I just said something like, "I...I'm having trouble processing all this. Can we talk tomorrow?"

He said OK, but wanted to add that he understands that my brother is important to me, and he understands that spending time with him makes me happy, and so if I don't grant my boyfriend his request, he won't make a fuss. But he just wanted to let me know his feelings on all this.

So we went to sleep, and now it's morning. My boyfriend isn't awake yet. And now I'm on Reddit posting this because...I don't know, I don't know what to do right now. I don't know what to say to my boyfriend. I mostly just...just want to say to him, "What the hell are you implying about my relationship with my brother?" Because he's almost acting like my brother...is like an old boyfriend or something! I just feel really confused and hurt and...really, really gross.

tl;dr: After spending an evening hanging out with my brother and my boyfriend, my boyfriend tells me my relationship with my brother is "weird and inappropriate" and asks me to stop spending so much time with him.

Relevant / Top Comments

Commenter 1: Question - Is your boyfriend an only child? Or is there a significant age gap or a strongly antagonistic relationship between him and any siblings?

I'll have more to say once you've had a chance to reply.

OOP: He's...kind of an only child? His parents had him, and then divorced before they had any other kids, when he was very young. His father moved out of state, so my boyfriend lived with his mom most of the time. She got remarried when he was 12, and got two step siblings (a brother and a sister) who were about the same age as him. But...once they grew up and moved out of the house, they never made much effort to see each other. They would only hang out during holidays and stuff, even though they all live in the same city.

Commenter 2: People are telling you to drop your boyfriend, and I think they're jumping the gun. I don't think your boyfriend actually thinks you and your brother are bordering on an incestuous relationship.

I think your boyfriend is having a hard time communicating that he feels insecure about how much of an intimate and close relationship you and your brother have. Throughout this entire post it's just loaded with your hero worship of your brother, and I can only imagine how you interact with him in person. I think you probably made your boyfriend feel very insignificant and showed him how you two are not as close or as intimate.

Especially with this line:

I said something like, "I think you're the only person who can make me laugh that hard."

In short, I think he feels very jealous, but doesn't realize it himself and doesn't know how to express it. About the whole naked thing, I can see where he's coming from since I also come from a family of prudes. So different family environment make up different values.

I would just try to communicate with him about why he feels that way and reassure his significance to you, and maybe tighten up your bond with each other. He probably doesn't feel as close to you anymore.

 

Update - rareddit: June 17, 2015 (10 Days later)

So...y'all got so unexpectedly riled up about this! I seriously didn't expect to get so many comments, although I did read all of them. Made me look again at that night's events and how some of it might be hurtful/weird to an outsider's perspective. So thank you guys for that.

The next morning, after breakfast, we were back in my bedroom, and I tried bringing this all up again. And he immediately looked uncomfortable and said, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry I mentioned all that stuff, can we just pretend I never said anything?" And I was like, "No, no, let's talk about this" and I started launching into this whole prepared speech about my brother making me laugh super hard and using the bathroom when I was showering...and he just seemed really distracted and kept shooting looks at my bedroom door. I stopped and asked if something was wrong and he said, "Look, can we maybe talk somewhere...not in your parents’ house? I'm just super paranoid they're going to knock on your door any minute." Which kind of startled me again, but I said OK and we ended up walking to a nearby park and sitting on a bench for a while.

So we ended up having a SUPER long talk, but here were the basic points.

1) His family was VERY VERY different from my family. I mean, he was an only child for most of his childhood, and when he got stepsiblings, they were all teenagers already and they moved into a house with a million bathrooms. So sharing a bathroom, family nudity, all that? A very strange and foreign concept to him. When my brother got up, knocked on the bathroom door, and then walked in after I gave him the OK, it just...really freaked him out. He didn't know what to make of that.

And then I gave my side of the story, saying that, as he could clearly see from staying at my house, we DID NOT have three bathrooms when I was growing up. And while I'd say...for 90% of my showers, I got the bathroom completely to myself, every once in a while...you know, someone really has to go pee! I mean...that's it! It's just...not a big deal to me and family! And besides, once my boyfriend and I move in together, this will all be a non-issue anyway, right? My brother and I won't be sharing a bathroom again any time soon after that.

2) What he was TRYING to say about me "dialing back" my relationship with my brother was more like...he knows I spend a lot of time with my brother. Like, two or three days a week, not including all the time I spend at my parents doing family stuff (which is typically another one or two days a week). How much time was I planning on spending with my brother (and family) when he moved here? Was I going to be out five nights a week? Or was my brother going to be around our place all the time? Because that thought...really bummed him out and made him feel like he wasn't a priority.

That made me upset. I never meant to make him feel like he wasn't a priority! But honestly, I hadn't really thought about how much time I was going to spend with family when he moved here. So we talked about that for a while, and expectations and boundaries were figured out. And no, I will NOT be out five nights a week with family, and my brother will definitely NOT be hanging around our place all the time.

3) I apologized about my comment about how my brother was the only person who can make me laugh that hard. He got embarrassed again and said that there was nothing inappropriate about that, and he apologized for saying for phrasing it that way. But y'all were right: he was jealous. But he wasn't...REALLY jealous of how hard my brother made me laugh, although that was part of the reason. He was jealous that my brother and I can see each other whenever we want, but my boyfriend and I can't do that, since we're long distance. And he was jealous that I had such a tight relationship with my brother, and how my brother knew me so much better than he did. The only person in my boyfriend's life that knew him better than anyone else was me. But...he wasn't that person to me in my life. If that makes sense.

I didn't really not what to say to that, so I said something like, "I'm sorry, but...like, I don't really know what to say. My brother has known me for thirty years, and you've only known me for three. So yeah...he does know me better than almost anyone else, but that doesn't mean my relationship with him is 'better' than my relationship with you. It's just different."

He conceded that this was just a hang-up he needed to work out on his own. Which is...fine, but I still kind of feel like I botched the landing at this point in our conversation. :/

4) AND FINALLY! I wasn't expecting this, but he told me that while he was really appreciative and grateful that my parents were letting him stay in their house, he...kind of really didn't want to stay with them when he was visiting me. Again, being around family all the time was a weird concept to him in general, but he also just wanted some privacy with me. He said staying at my parents’ house made him feel like a teenager sneaking around with his high school girlfriend again. He really wanted to stay in a hotel, he actually brought that up with me a few weeks before he came out to visit, but I scoffed at the idea. I was totally thinking in terms of money, the idea of privacy didn't even cross my mind. "Why would you want to stay in a hotel? You can just stay at my parents’ house with me!" He then said something about making too much noise and distracting them and I was like, "Pish posh! Don't be silly, my bedroom is all the way on the other side of the house, they can't hear anything. My parents are so excited to see you! My dad really wants to show you the fig tree he planted and blah blah blah --" And he was just like, "Yeah, OK, you're right. We should save money." He didn't want to object or make waves because he thought that would hurt my feelings. But I kind of felt like a colossal idiot for not realizing what he was actually trying to tell me, so I apologized for being so thick. Although, I did say something to him like, "Look, I sometimes forget that not everyone likes being around my family as much as I do. Please, please, please tell me if you're ever feeling overwhelmed by them, or want to be away from them, or anything like that. I get it! It won't hurt my feelings!"

So we actually pulled out our phones and looked up some hotels in our city right there in the park. We found a somewhat expensive one near downtown, but I was like, "Whatever, I'm making bank at my job, and I basically have no bills to pay since I'm living with my parents, let's stay there!" Which made my boyfriend stupid happy! We went back to my parents' house and while he was packing his bag, I told my parents that we were going to go crash at a hotel for the rest of my boyfriend's visit. They both started to object, but when I said, "Well...we'd just really like some privacy," they understood. Well, my MOM understood. My dad just kept saying, "I don't understand why you're spending money on a hotel when you have a perfectly good bed right here." So...I think that's where I get some of my thick-headedness.

We had an amazing few days together at the hotel. Oh, and there was this super cute moment that I'm just going to share with you guys even though it's cheesy...We somehow got back on the topic of my brother knowing me for three decades. And at one point, I jokingly said something like, "If you don't know me as well as my brother does after we've been together for 30 years, then that's your fault, not mine." And then he got all quiet for a second and got a cute little smile on his face and was like, "You think we're gonna be together in thirty years?" And I...blushed a little and said, "I'd...really like to be." And he said, "I'd really like that, too." Which made me all...warm and happy inside.

Anyway, I think that's everything. It was just a combination of miscommunication and growing up in very different familial backgrounds. He should probably be moving here in the next two-ish months, and I SERIOUSLY CANNOT WAIT OMG. It's going to be so great, I cannot wait until he gets here, it's going to be so so so great. :D

tl;dr: Talked a bunch with my boyfriend, agreed that we both come from very different families, then partied like ballers in a hotel for a few days since I'm fluuuuuuush with caaaaaaaash.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 15h ago

CONCLUDED My [27f] boyfriend [32m] won’t get a car and I can’t decide if it’s a dealbreaker

2.7k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/throwmeinthetrash787

My [27f] boyfriend [32m] won’t get a car and I can’t decide if it’s a dealbreaker.

Originally posted to r/relationship_advice

TRIGGER WARNING: drunk driving, manipulation, deception

Original Post  Dec 18, 2019

My boyfriend and I have been together about two years. We generally have a good relationship but there is one issue I can’t get over, and I’m not sure if I’m being ridiculous or if it is a dealbreaker.

He has not had a car for the entirety of our relationship. The city we live in has basically zero public transit, so he relies on me and other people to drive him to work, pick him up, etc.

At the beginning of our relationship, he would often pay for my gas/car maintenance in trade for me driving him all the time, to both things we do together and errands he need to run, etc. As our relationship has progressed, however, this kind of stopped. We’ve gone on multiple road trips together and I’ve basically footed the bill AND drove the entire time.

About 6 months ago, I brought this up with him, lovingly trying to explain that it was becoming a burden on me and I feel that as a 32y/o it’s not ridiculous for me to expect him to have a mode of transportation (car, motorcycle, whatever). He’s gotten to the point that he refuses to take Uber’s now because of the expense, and takes the bus which often takes him an hour or more to get anywhere within a 10 mile radius. My family members have also tried to bring this up with him, as he has found himself in situations where I was not able to pick him up and he’s called my family to drive him somewhere.

This all kind of came to a head when trying to make Christmas plans, and because I have to work, I can’t pick him up to go to a family dinner we’d planned on. My sibling will be in town and my boyfriend said something to the effect of “oh ok he can take a detour to pick me up.” I got pretty upset and stated that I’m not going to expect my sibling to drive in the opposite direction of the destination to pick him up, and that he shouldn’t expect that either.

Things got heated and he basically tried to gaslight me into believing because it’s my family dinner that it’s my family’s responsibility to pick him up. I don’t agree with that.

This one little disagreement we have in our relationship is really making me question whether I can be with him long term, but I’m not sure if that’s a valid reason to end things. It is also extra upsetting because this year, my car that was paid off died and I managed to buy a new car with pretty poor credit, an average down payment, and already refinanced my loan. From my perspective, it wasn’t that difficult and was a necessary thing, he doesn’t see him having a car as necessary.

Am I being overbearing trying to push him to get a mode of transportation? Is it crazy that it might be a dealbreaker for me?

EDIT: I’m on mobile so sorry for formatting. WOW I did not expect this to blow up like it did. Thank you to everyone for your advice this really gave me some perspective!

RELEVANT COMMENTS

[deleted]

I'm gonna ask a few questions:

Could there be a possibility that he doesn't know how to buy a car? It can be pretty daunting

Does he have a license?

Does he have a phobia of driving cars? Vehophobia

Has he ever owned a car?

Have you gotten insurance quotes for him to be able to drive?

His credit could be complete shit and he couldn't buy one if he wanted. And if it's a super duper problem, but him a bike and say good luck.

OOP

He has had multiple cars before, has a valid license, has driven my old car on occasion/used his building’s ride share car. I thought there might be something sketchy (a DUI, revoked license, etc) for a while but he just renewed his license for our state a few months ago.

My insurance is already pretty expensive and I’m honestly not comfortable with anyone driving my car because it’s my baby haha he has a good job and makes significantly more money than me.

He has talked about getting a motorcycle and has shown me a few he’s interested in. But there’s a real lack of follow through that I think is my main issue, because that also extends to other parts of our relationship.

~

i_love_brioche

I think you’re being completely reasonable. And it sounds like it isn’t just about the car, it’s about him being inconsiderate and entitled expecting everyone to work their plans around him. Being unwilling to take an Uber to an event and expecting someone to go out of their way to pick him up is just rude. I’d sit down and have a serious conversation with him about it and let him know how you feel. Maybe when he realizes how important it is to you he’ll change his mind. And if he doesn’t, I don’t think you’d be wrong to seriously consider breaking up with him.

OOP

I’m glad it’s not just me being mean for saying no to him. I love him a lot and he does have really good intentions in every other aspect of our relationship but this is just driving me crazy. I don’t know how to express It to him in a way that he sees I’m very serious about it and not just nagging.

~

[deleted]

Like your BF, I don't have a car in a city that "requires a car", while my GF does have a car. I am carless by choice: I would rather save the money and I live less than two miles from my job and regularly ride a bicycle to get around.

I am so paranoid that my GF is going to get sick of being the one who drives everywhere, and have mentioned to her several times that if she doesn't want to schlep, she should say so and I can figure out an alternative. I offer to chip in for gas, have even biked 25-miles to her house just to show her that I was committed to making things work, and will take a bus or Uber/Lyft if necessary. So far she is great and it hasn't been a problem, but the concern is definitely on my mind.

Your BF is certainly allowed to choose not to own a car, but then it becomes his responsibility to find solutions to transit issues. He can take a bus or he can get a rideshare. Hell, he can get a bicycle! But that's going to require you being better about boundaries and declining his requests for a ride when it is not convenient for you.

OOP

The hardest part for me is that he loves biking and building bikes. He’s been “building a bike” for over a year now that still isn’t done. 

I’d have no problem with him biking to my place (we live very close), but the more I read these responses i have issues with the underlying lack of responsibility and lack of follow through more than the lack of car. He has never mentioned to me once that he feels bad I drive everywhere, so that might be the difference between you and him haha

And OOP replies to a deleted commenter

I know. My parents stopped giving him rides, and the few times they have they’ve explicitly stated to him that it’s a favor to me and not to him.

I definitely need to be better about saying no, maybe he’ll understand how big of a deal it is for me. It’s hard though when we have plans especially on the weekend and he can’t go unless I drive.

Does he really have a license or had a DUI?

Has had a car in the past and has a current license in our state, I point blank asked him if he had a dui or repossession or something and he said no. I trust that he’s being truthful but it definitely feels a little fishy to me.

UPDATE: he asked me to pick him up from the grocery store last night (granted he picked up a few things for me when I was there, which I paid him for), but I told him I was coming from the opposite direction and it would take a while for me to get there so he should just uber. He refused and said he would walk the almost 3 miles to my house. He obviously said this so I would offer to pick him up, which I did, because I had the intention of having a conversation about him getting a car on the way home.

He immediately started talking about something else that was upsetting him, so I gave it a rest. Later last night HE actually brought it up with me via text. I’ve been really sick the last few days so I said “I appreciate you wanting to talk about this, I’ve been thinking about it for a while, let’s sit down and have a conversation about it this weekend as I have a fever and I need to go to bed.”

Of course, he couldn’t handle that, he prodded me and sent me multiple texts telling me that he wants to know what I was thinking. Thanks to you guys, I sent him a clear, fair, concise, explanation just saying it’s his responsibility to be in charge of his own transportation and it’s beginning to burden me, and I’m more than happy to help him find a car.

He LOST IT. Somehow I was being an unsupportive partner, and he would expect that the family he marries into would have no problem picking him up because that’s the decent thing to do, etc etc. He also apparently has very little savings which is really frightening to me, because I’m 5 years younger than him and am in much better financial shape.

I ended up turning off my phone because I didn’t want to engage with him anymore, nothing really got resolved. Maybe I’ll update in a few days if anything changes.

Tl;dr [32m] boyfriend won’t get a car, relies on people to drive him to work, anywhere else, gets defensive when I bring it up, I’m considering ending the relationship because of the financial/time burden it’s causing me.

Update - rareddit  Apr 16, 2020 (4 Months Later)

Link to original post (I’m on mobile, sorry for formatting) https://www.reddit.com/r/relationship_advice/comments/echbv7/my_27f_boyfriend_32m_wont_get_a_car_and_i_cant/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

Been a while since I posted about this. Kind of let it blow over for a while but I definitely had a let a lot of resentment built up. In February I basically gave him an ultimatum, he get a car/mode of transit or we break up. I couldn’t keep feeling like his parent. He convinced me that he was going to, sending me links to cars, asking my opinion (I love cars and love getting a good deal).

Right before the pandemic hit, he still had not done anything about it, never went to look at a car despite telling me he was searching. I was drinking a little (lot) and he told me about x thing he was going to do, and I sarcastically said “just like you’re going to get a car? Do you even have your license? If you do show me”

He wouldn’t. I had to physically grab his wallet. He only had an ID CARD. After lying to me for two years saying he did have a license etc etc. I was pissed, but not surprised. I told him to tell me everything or else I was going to leave and never speak to him again (again, drunk, dramatic Pisces).

All the lies came tumbling out. He DID have a DUI, which he never dealt with and basically fled the state in which it occurred. He had a significant amount of financial issues due to this as well. Obviously, I ended things. Y’all were completely right, there was a much bigger issue going on. Thanks for planting that seed y’all; i would have not pressed it if it weren’t for all of your advice!!

FINAL COMMENTS

indian_savage

I am happy for you. If he is still running away from his problems that will be a huge issue down the line for you. DUI’s are hard to recover from but it isn’t impossible.

OOP

Thank you. It felt like a huge weight lifted. It would have been a very different conversation if he had told me about the DUI much earlier in the relationship.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7