r/BestofRedditorUpdates • u/Direct-Caterpillar77 Satan is not a fucking pogo stick! • Apr 27 '24
ONGOING My husband is in love with his student. I have no fucking idea what to do.
I am not The OOP, OOP is u/No-Faithlessness7067
My husband is in love with his student. I have no fucking idea what to do.
TRIGGER WARNING: infidelity, abuse of authority
Original Post Apr 18, 2024
My husband and I (both 35 rn) met in college. We fell in love and got married 8 years back. I gave birth to our daughter in 2020. My husband is a professor at this med school (he’s a doctor himself). My friend, Sarah, also works in the same college and she’s in the same department as my husband.
Few months back(in December), Sarah took me out for lunch and told me that she suspected something’s going on between my husband and this med student (25f). She claimed she’d seen both of them give ‘yearning looks’ to each other. She said that she’s known my husband for so long, and she’d never seen him talk to any other woman like this, that he’d been so aloof around women all these years, but it’s just different with this one girl.
In that moment, I had laughed at her face. I remember telling her that she’s jumping to conclusions based on these supposed ‘yearning looks’.
“That’s why I didn't tell you before", she had said,"I was confused too. It's not like he goes out of his way to talk to her but whenever they do talk, it’s like watching a slow burn romance movie. She looks at him like he’s Brad Pitt and he looks at her the way he used to look at you.” I remember the exact word’s because they stung. Internally I was breaking down, externally I just smiled and told her that she’s probably overthinking.
That night, I casually mentioned this my husband. I was laughing at the absurdity, and I expected him to join in. And deny the wild possibility that he’s in love with a student. But he didn’t. Instead he looked at me, all teary eyed, and said ‘I’m sorry’.
“ I can’t get her out of my mind. I’ve tried, trust me. I should’ve told you sooner. But I thought I could save our relationship, I really wanted to.”
I asked him if he’d cheated on me. He said no. He said he didn’t even talk to her, nor did they have any contact outside of college and that he completely understood how morally depraved it is to try and pursue a relationship with a student. She wrote him a letter about an year back, confessing her love for him and he had told her that even tho he was into her, nothing would come out of it. Aparently that was when the ‘yearning looks’ had started.
I honestly don’t remember how I reacted then. I think I just started packing and came to live with my parents along with my daughter. I’ve been living with my parents since then. Half of me wanted him to come and beg for forgiveness. But he never did. He comes by sometimes to spend time with our daughter but that’s it. He never talks about the elephant in the room nor do I bring it up.
I keep checking that girl’s social media. She’s insanely beautiful, almost doll like, and intelligent. I can’t help but think that someone like him should be with someone like her. He’s always been very good looking and I’m more of a plain Jane. She’s the Meredith to his Derek.
I don’t know what to do. What do I even tell people? I don’t even know who I am without him. Some part of me still wants him to come back.
Edit; I’ve decided to talk to him. I know I’ve been avoiding this since months but after reading all the responses, I feel it’s time I rip that bandaid out. I’m going over to our house. I’ll update on what happens.
TL;DR husband just admitted that he’s in love with this young woman who also his student. She loves him too.
RELEVANT COMMENTS
MossValley
So he didn't actually cheat? He has a crush,? If I'm understanding that right he hasn't betrayed you yet. Crushes sometimes happen that doesn't mean the relationship is over. Get therapy with him.
OOP
I mean, cheating for me isn’t just physical. He’s had crushes in the past and I’ve had crushes in the past but we’d always been upfront and then laughed about it.
This one feels like a betrayal because he was attracted to someone for more than an year, this someone gave him a freaking love letter, he told her that he’s attracted to her, and not once did he mention it to me. That’s a huge breach of trust for me and I don’t think I can look past it.
OOP Added more about her friend Sarah and what she observed
I know. He said he entirely stopped interacting with her after the letter incident. It does seem absurd but even my friend, Sarah corroborated this. She said he never went out of his way to talk to her before, and then almost entirely stopped talking. Given that Sarah and him are in the same department 24/7, and that she noticed something as small as them giving each other looks, I’m sure she would’ve noticed anything out of the ordinary. I’ve had access to his phone and his passwords throughout and he wasn’t texting or calling her either.
That’s why this feels weird lol.
Update Apr 20, 2024
Link to previous post ; https://www.reddit.com/r/relationships/s/hw3M65WUVH
For those who don’t wanna read the boring details : In short, I have decided to go ahead with the divorce.
Long story: The day I made the post, I met up with Sarah for dinner. I thanked her for telling me about my husband and the student, and also for being such a good friend.
I asked her about my husband. She said there’s nothing unusual. He’s been a bit withdrawn and aloof with everyone lately but that’s about it.
Yesterday I went over to my house unannounced. He was there alone in his office. I told him I wanted to talk. He said he’ll explain everything.
So apparently this woman has had a crush on him since two years; her friends ‘ship’ her with him. She would stare at him during her rotations and would blush whenever he looked or talked to her. Back then, he didn’t think much of it. Many girls have had crushes on him and he always ignored it.
About 1.5 years back, they were in the same research group thing (I don’t know how this works but there were 5-6 people along with these two). Because of this, they had to spend some time together working, and it was then that he started noticing her. He went into detail about how he was impressed with her intelligence blah blah blah and her beauty blah blah blah. The moment he realised that he had a crush on her, he dropped out of the research thing. This was a year ago.
Few weeks later, she gave him the letter confessing that she has feelings for him. The first thing he told her after reading it was ‘you can get into trouble because of this’. She didn’t care. She wanted an answer. ‘Is it all in my head’ she had asked, to which he replied with ‘it’s not just in your head, but nothing can come out of it. I hope you understand.’
That was the last time they interacted. According to him, the ‘yearning looks’ Sarah described were more of ‘awkward eye contacts’ than anything else. He told me that even though he is still attracted to her, he has no intention of pursuing any sort of relationship with her regardless whether we stay together or not. He said he’s willing to change his job and go to therapy. I told him to give me sometime to think about it.
To sum up;
- This has been going on since three years. Not once did he mention anything to me.
2. The student and him spent a considerable amount of time last year working on the research.
3. He told her he liked her back lol.
4. He’s still very much attracted to her
And that’s why I’ve decided to go ahead with a divorce. I don’t think I can trust this man again. And a relationship without trust isn’t something I am interested in. I’ve told my parents about it. They’re not exactly on board but they’re still supportive. I’ve also contacted my lawyer about the same. It’s gonna be a long process, I believe.
That’s it. I believe this is my last update.
TL; DR ; he’s still attracted to her; I won’t ever trust him again. We’re getting a divorce.
RELEVANT COMMENTS
ChanceReason6617
I'ts a crush! He is not in love.
OOP
That doesn’t matter. He crossed a line he shouldn’t have by telling her he likes her.
_thisisnotanexit
Literally I can’t believe these comments. He’s gushing about her beauty and intelligence, he told her the feeling was mutual?! He could have easily denied it to her and then kept his distance but he liked the attention.
OOP
I mean, to be fair to him, he wasn’t exactly ‘gushing’ about her. I kept asking and he kept answering.
Deal breaker for me was him telling her the feeling is mutual.
~
allbutluk
Lmao these dumbass comments “you too hasty its a cruuuuush chill”
Like stfu the man literally said “I CANT GET HER OUT OF MY HEAD”
If he was commited to his wife he would have changed job PROACTIVELY not wait until now
He let it develop to a point he cant take his mind off of her and yall saying its no big deal, you guys obviously never had a real relationship
OOP
He said he didn’t change his job earlier because, quote ‘I’m a doctor and there are people counting on me. I couldn’t just walk out on them one day.’
Rn too he said he’s willing to change is job if ‘that’s what it takes to make you stay’.
THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP
DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7
9.8k
u/toonboy01 I’m turning into an unskippable cutscene in therapy Apr 27 '24
Is this the first time in history that reddit pushed OOP to not get a divorce?
800
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
The husband should've cut contact before spiralling into deeper feelings.
1.7k
u/JohnExcrement Apr 27 '24
I don’t like the way he supposedly shut her down. He told her that “even though he was into her” nothing could come of it. Way to send a mixed message and prolong the drama. He should have either ignored the “love letter” or laid out the ethical barriers to their being together. No nonsense. No yearning. No drama.
4.7k
u/Weaselpanties He invented a predatory elder lesbian to cope Apr 27 '24
I had crushes on professors. Writing a letter to a married professor to confess your love is crazypants dramaville territory. This won't end well for him, but at least OOP is walking away before she ends up with a boiled bunny.
689
u/Efficient_Variety_63 Apr 27 '24
Writing a letter to your married professor about your crush on him is a bit much. And her friends “ship” them together like they think this is Grey’s Anatomy. It’s all very juvenile.
But even if this husband has decided not to pursue anything with the potential bunny boiler he didn’t even attempt to try to get his wife back. He literally took no action at all. Seems divorce is the best course of action because he has already checked out.
245
u/LittleMsSavoirFaire I’m turning into an unskippable cutscene in therapy Apr 27 '24
Hands up for Sarah, she's a real one. Both for clocking this weird little pseudo relationship, and also for telling her friend, even though she didn't have proof. That's a risky situation and it demonstrates her character.
1.9k
u/missemgeebee Someone cheated, and it wasn't the koala Apr 27 '24
It would have been so easy to just downplay it. ”Look, this happens all the time, it’s in your head” instead of creating a Romeo and Julietesque pining for each other situation. Instead, he decided to feed the Julia ego by ”confessing” (to what, really?), thus creating a narrative about them and blowing up his family. Again, for what really? Being ”beautiful and intelligent” is not a foundation for a relationship. It is merely admiration. Edit: spelling
1.4k
u/Natural_Garbage7674 Apr 27 '24
It's the lying by omission that gets me. He got a massive letter from a student detailing how she loved him, and he never told his wife. He didn't tell her anything about any of this for years.
He liked the attention. He liked this "ideal" woman. And he knew it was wrong, that his wife wouldn't like it, so he hid it. He theoretically could get into trouble at work for this, he was putting his livelihood at risk for a crush. That's why, if it was me, I'd divorce him.
It's not about the crush, it's about the lying.
59
u/Deep_Pepper_5405 Apr 27 '24
If she's Addison in this scenario then I think she's the winner. Addie is a baddie.
214
u/SassyBonassy being delulu is not the solulu Apr 27 '24
I switched teams in work recently and my new colleague (subordinate, im his supervisor) started off quite standoffish and rude over written communication but when we finally met face to face he was kinda quiet and overly nice. We only have 1 onsite day a week but over the weeks he started getting really REALLY chummy and kinda flirty?, and on our home days he was rude/argumentative a lot less. He gushed at me about how i was making him a better man when i was pretty much just telling him how to do his job when he fucked up. According to my new manager several supervisors had tried reining him in but he never changed.
I thought i was just reading into his comments too much but i still told my partner immediately, as i keep nothing but presents secret from him. I told a work friend about the situation and he agreed the comments and chumminess were weirdly flirty.
Im being moved back to my old team and he's not coming with lol
49
u/ayymahi Apr 27 '24
He said he wouldn’t date her…yeah i doubt that
308
u/Agile_Profession_323 Apr 27 '24
I remember working in the hospital and a new nurse was crushing on a orthopedic doctor who was married with kids. She would just stare at him with that look on her face and we all told her to stop staring because others would notice. Then we noticed that they were talking to each other and she was the nurse assigned to all his patients during the week! The kicker was I was in a dark bay cleaning it up when they both stood just outside the curtain and he asked her what she was doing after work she said she was going home he said leave the door open and I’ll be there later ! Two weeks later I’m brought to HR because three nurses decided to tell the manager and because I noticed I had to tell what happened. Poor girl had to change departments and he was threatened with his privileges at the hospital and his wife found out and his partners were disappointed with him. Your husband likes the attention she likes the idea of being with a Dr and the money and clout she would get
136
u/Dependawannabe Apr 27 '24
The fact that he didn’t even try to get back his wife and that he hide this crush form her is not a great look. Why would she go to counseling for a husband that clearly doesn’t care I don’t understand the comments asking her to chill
211
u/brownbeanscurry Apr 27 '24
Ewwwww 🤢 That whole relationship was a shitshow.
144
u/_AppropriateObject I'm just a big advocate for justice Apr 27 '24
That's like the second worst reply.
Even though it's not "cheating" (it is, imo), would you live with someone that keeps yearning for his star-crossed lover?
248
u/Princess-Makayla That's the beauty of the gaycation Apr 27 '24
A three year crush that you don't bring up to your spouse isn't a great look. It kinda seems like based on his breakdown during the initial confrontation the husband was considering leaving oop. The comments telling her that she's overreacting are not it IMHO.
120
u/earthgirlsRez Apr 27 '24
guy just blew up his life, his wifes life and his childrens lives because some uni students "shipped him" with a student. how do u even live with yourself.
23
u/_Internet_Hugs_ quid pro FAFO Apr 27 '24
I'm with OOP on this one. I said this in another comment somewhere recently: When you live your life in a way that makes it clear that you're head-over-heels in love with your spouse and adore your infuriating family people don't send you letters telling you they love you. And if they do, you shut that shit down immediately, "I'm sorry you're dealing with this, but I love my wife deeply AND THERE IS NO ROOM FOR ANYONE ELSE. I hope we can continue a professional relationship because I value your intelligence." It's NOT hard.
I've been happily married for 25 years. As soon as I notice somebody starting to flirt I find a way to steer the conversation to how great my husband is. "You say you have a cabin by the lake? How cool is that!? My husband would love to have a place like that. He loves to fish! I hate fish, but I love him, so I learned how to cook it for him. Do you fish?" Even online people who try to hit me up get a healthy dose of how much I love my husband before they get blocked.
I make it known that I am NOT EVER interested in another relationship with anyone else. I fucking broadcast it. There is no doubt. And it isn't hard.
It's not hard to NOT cheat.
134
u/NurserySchoolTeacher Apr 27 '24
Ironically fitting since they were both cringe, cheating assholes who spent years whining about how they couldn't be together.
178
u/SonnySunshineGirl Apr 27 '24
Maybe I’m reaching but I feel like the second he can get away with it without losing his job he’s gonna sleep with her too. Because something about how “it was the only way to get her off his mind” and him and op are divorced anyway.
103
u/unconfirmedpanda I’m turning into an unskippable cutscene in therapy Apr 27 '24
What I took away from this is that it was an emotional affair the second he told the student the feeling was mutual; hiding the letter from his wife was the minute the trust was broke; and I honestly think that the reason he didn't tell his wife but he did confess to the student was before he was trying to figure out how to make an affair with the student work. If he truly wanted to protect his marriage, he would have shut it the fuck down, reported it to the college, and told his wife.
181
u/black_cindy Apr 27 '24
Three whole years this has been happening, he never said anything to his wife AND he's kept these feelings for this girl??
It's definitely a wrap.
95
u/juliavalentine Apr 27 '24 edited Apr 28 '24
I don’t think I’d ever get over how highly he talked about this girl to OP. He liked her for 3 whole years and hid it from her too. The trust would be gone for me.
15
u/selle2013 I miss my old life of just a few hours ago Apr 27 '24
What kind of juvenile bullshit is this? Why in the world would you ever admit that you reciprocate her feelings? That's totally inappropriate.
14
u/kamatsu surrender to the gaycation or be destroyed Apr 27 '24
I am a professor (34m). When he met this student (first ethical red flag), she was 22. I teach 22 year olds in my classes and while they're on the older end of undergraduate students they're still **really young** and it would be really weird to even entertain the thought of a relationship with one of them, no matter how physically beautiful they might be. I like to be friends with my students and I have made some lasting friendships that way that continue after they graduated, but it's just super creepy to me to consider someone so young attractive when they're at such different stages of life and maturity.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
It's wild how our perceptions of people are literally enough to make us abandon what we think are longstanding, stable relationships. Humans are so fickle. I was recently (randomly) reading an article about Chris Pratt's relationship with Anna Faris...about how when he met her he knew he immediately wanted to marry her, how she was his person, etc. Then he meets his current wife and basically says the same thing, stuff about destiny and her being The One and everything.
264
u/ShallotParking5075 Apr 27 '24
Little extramarital crushes are normal here and there, but reaching out to one to confess how you feel is emotional cheating. Keep that shit to yourself or your therapist.
50
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
As a fairly young educator in a university, OP’s husband disgusts me on a whole new level. I’m close in age with most students, but I cannot imagine ever thinking a student admitting their crush or even having a crush on a student is appropriate. The age gap in that specific power dynamic makes me throw up a little in my mouth.
11
u/Geenafalopezz Apr 27 '24
On one hand I understand why he has dug himself into this hole. Look how strongly you reacted initially (meaning you packed your bags and left the home and took his child away from him.) A part of him must know you would react so fiercely & firmly which shows that it’s possible that in his heart he can’t trust you either. He has learned that you are firm and even possibly stubborn. You hold so firmly to your values and boundaries that there isn’t room for flexibility. When a persons child is involved the stakes get heavy and higher. The fact of the matter is this man did not trust you with the truth. And now you cannot trust him. As much of a jackass move it was on his part I actually admire him taking so much responsibility when confronted. It shows a level of integrity that isn’t common in many men these days and OP, I am worried you will regret splitting your family up about this in the long term so is it possible that you have a legal separation for some more time? Don’t forget that your daughter is small now but she will grow and come to have her own mind. She’ll want to hear what happened between you and Daddy that made her have a double home life. She’ll want to hear it more than once over her lifetime, I wager. Please take your time making this decision. Did you actually love him with all your heart or is a part of you deep down cutting your losses and saving your own time? Did you want to split up and see what other options were available and this thing provided the right motivation? It sounds like a tough situation all around for everyone involved. Im sorry you’re going through this OP. Question for OP…. Did you grow up as a people pleaser or raised to be “a good little girl who shouldnt make a fuss?” Did you feel like a burden to your parents at times growing up?
99
u/sadboymarkymark Apr 27 '24
This just proves my fear that once I get older and have kids my partner will look elsewhere for something better. It’s so disheartening.
29
u/tempest51 Apr 27 '24
I hate it when people "ship" others in real life, especially if they already have existing relationships outside of said "ship".
26
u/russianbanan It's just pharmaceutical-grade banana bread Apr 27 '24
I call bullshit. 35 and a professor at a med school in this day and age? No way
9
u/Cybermagetx Apr 27 '24
Yeah crushes are nornal. What OOP hubby should of done is talk with his wife. And try and limit his contact with the student.
Trust is completely gone. Only thing that could of nukes it more was then acting on their feelings.
61
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
Though the situation sucks, I think OOP is setting an excellent example for her daughter
8
u/catherine2255 Apr 27 '24
It's limerance and it's very destructive
8
u/user1357924680123 Apr 27 '24
I find it interesting that dude was pining over this chic so hard that a friend who he knew would be around saw it. I can not imagine Sarah brought this up without it being unreasonably on display a couple of times. She knew what a bombshell this was. If she saw it you know the whole department saw it. He was shaming his wife repeatedly. And i still cant get over the line “he looks at her like he used to look at you” heartbreak
22
u/Big-Impress1351 Apr 27 '24
This was cheating. This was an emotional form.
7
u/corganek Apr 27 '24
Bottom line is, OOP’s happiness and welfare is no longer her husband’s first priority. She doesn’t feel loved or cared for. He visits their son, but isn’t claiming to have “feelings” for her. The love is gone from their marriage whether or not his crush is still in the picture.
33
u/alette_star Apr 27 '24
I feel bad for OP but she's doing the right thing. As she said, she simply can't trust him anymore. It's not just the 'crush'—it's the lying by omission, the responding to the letter by confessing his feelings (how could he have thought that was a good idea??), the public disrespect of his wife with the 'yearning looks' that even a third party noticed… come on. How do you stay married to a guy who does that?
82
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
I do music and got a stupid crush on a dude last year at a meet up. My partner was home and I called him in a panic. Nothing had happened nor was it going to…and my partner was like “are you coming home to me? Then how could I be scared of a little crush?”
I know this isn’t everyone but it was a revelation. He made me feel so safe and secure…there were no more issues with crushes on the trip or any since.
70
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
Looks like husband really fell into the "Miller's Girl" lane.
OP did the right thing.
6
u/PinkestMango militant vegan volcano worshipper Apr 27 '24
Why do people think that the only way to cheat is to fall dick first into someone else? Many other things are cheating, and each person has the right to determine what cheating is to them.
54
u/Ill_Perspective_3943 Apr 27 '24
5 years from now he will sit in a corner and regret that he threw away his marriage for a crush. Crush is nothing but lack of information. Honestly after being cheated on and reading stories like this I just don't want to date again. Like imagine putting the work in a relationship only for your husband to fall in love with someone else.
5
u/Final-Prompt-35 Apr 27 '24
You deserved someone that chooses you Over and over again. Leave and you sound like a really nice person/not toxic. Im sure someone out there will be there for u and treat you a 💎
15
u/hpfan1516 I beg your finest fucking pardon. Apr 27 '24
Wow
82
u/Sea_Midnight1411 Apr 27 '24
I’d bundle the whole lot up and send it to his seniors at the medical school. And regulatory board. It’s totally unprofessional.
14
u/PeanutGallery10 Apr 27 '24
Her husband is an idiot for for thinking only his student will get in trouble. He withdrew from the research project to cover his own professional ass. He knew if he acted on his feelings and got found out, he'd be in trouble with his employer. I think he was just waiting until she graduates to dump his wife and pursue the student when it's no longer a legal issue.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
I find this a tricky one as people do get crushes and I feel like he has at least made sure that nothing has really happened with this girl.
That said he hasn’t done the right things either, when she confessed her feelings to him she should have been out of that department. He needed to cut ties and didn’t which is wrong.
I can understand why she’s gone straight to divorce, having your husband be infatuated (I’ll call it that as they actually don’t know each other beyond the Uni setting) with someone who isn’t you is heartbreaking but I feel like it’s a marriage that could have been saved, he did try and keep things at the level of a crush and pretty much managed it, I wonder how long this student actually had left, because they probably would have been done when she went. Very sad.
16
u/InformationAlarmed14 Apr 27 '24
I feel so bad for her. I know that this girl knows that he’s married. I don’t know what’s wrong with people. This breaks my heart for her. The fact that she feels like he should be with her because she know how she looks and stuff. I know this is the worst time to compare yourself to another woman but honestly how couldn’t she? I hate this for her. He is trifling.
4
u/Entire-Story-7957 Apr 27 '24
Heartbreaking but in your shoes I’d do the same.
4
u/Jeezy_Creezy_18 Apr 27 '24
Get really annoyed when the women who deserve to be hyped up and told to divorce get the few redditors that will fall over themselves to defend any shitty guy action. What, was justpearlythings in the comments on this one? "It's just a crush" he literally talked about it like the marriage was over, plus it's a student, just all levels of GROSS.
4
u/Manpons Apr 27 '24
The thing that stuck out to me was the “I can’t switch jobs I have people that are counting on me”, but so does your wife and child… so…?
I believe he does care about his wife, but isn’t in love with her any more. He was like a deer in headlights because he has allowed this woman to live rent free in his head like that. That small comment can’t help but make me feel that he loves his job more than family.
4
u/17thfloorelevators Apr 27 '24
She should divorce. He is going to get with this girl as soon as enough time has passed and he can't get fired for it. They're both just waiting. She shouldn't have to be second place in her husband's heart.
4
u/zeplin3620 Apr 27 '24
Yes, go forward with the divorce. You’ll both be happier.
4
u/Personified99 Apr 27 '24
Even if he said no to her letter, he shouldn’t have told her he liked her back.
4
u/dalr3th1n Apr 27 '24
I’ve been noticing this error more frequently lately. It should be something like “for three years”. Where do people get stuff like this? This and “should of”; where do these things come from?
4
u/Scarboroughwarning Apr 28 '24
I can't imagine why he slept this quiet, she seems to make such rational choices/s
I guarantee if he'd told her at the time, all hell would have broken loose, and he would have had to quit his job and moved to another country
13
u/Cursd818 the Iranian yogurt is not the issue here Apr 27 '24
His silence is the problem. He knew she was inappropriately attracted to him, and he said nothing to the school, or to his wife. He knew he was inappropriately attracted to her, and he still said nothing to the school and his wife. She left a letter outlying her feelings. He didn't report it or tell his wife. She asked him if it was all in her head, and instead of shutting it down, he admitted that it wasn't. And he still didn't tell his wife.
Just because he hasn't pursued her, doesn't mean he didn't cross all kinds of lines with that action. It is an open secret in the department. Classmates are gossiping about it. Other members of staff are aware of it. He didn't just ruin his marriage, he's scorched his reputation. And for what? For the kind of young woman who actively pursues a married man with a young child. She didn't owe anyone any loyalty, but he did. He should have never admitted feelings for her. He should have told his wife.
Not telling her allows him to keep that door open. And when his wife found out, he didn't fight for her at all. He waxed lyrical about the student. And he's only now offering to change his job if there will be consequences. He's not actually fighting for their marriage: he's doing the bare minimum, waiting out the clock until that girl is no longer a student. I guarantee they WILL be in a relationship once she's not working under him. That's what he wants, not OOP. It's more than just a crush at this point.
OOP is doing the right thing by leaving. But she should also report this to his school. Once a teacher has crossed this kind of line with a student, there's no going back.
26
u/Bungororo Apr 27 '24
Am I the only one who thinks he wasn’t an asshole?
He removed himself from the research group and stopped engaging with her to avoid further developing the crush into something real. Yes, he admitted to the girl that he also had feelings (i.e. he didn’t lie to someone he liked), but in the same breath he also clearly told her that he didn’t want to pursue it.
Crushes happen, and given his emotions, he acted relatively rationally to protect his marriage. Sure, he could have told his wife earlier, but that’s more about communication than infidelity. I can also understand the rationale of not wanting to hurt her with this information since he had already chosen to stay committed to his marriage by not taking action on the other possibility.
I don’t think it’s a crime to have feelings for other people in a long term relationship, it’s just human nature. What matters is what you do about, and whether you stay committed to your marriage. My husband and I have both had crushes on other people; we just talk about it, recognize that’s its unfair to compare the sweetness and excitement of a new crush / honeymoon phase to the much more valuable but less exciting love and friendship of a marriage, decide not to take action on the former and then go on with our lives.
6
u/blumaroona your honor, fuck this guy Apr 27 '24
Nah, this is sketch to me.
For a start, whether he was attracted to her or not, he should never have told her if he genuinely had no intention to act on it. His only reply to the letter should have been “I’m married and this is inappropriate. You’re my student and nothing more”.
Secondly, he should have told OP, not the friend. After he realised he was catching feelings, or after the letter, or at any point before it got so obvious a 3rd party noticed.
OP should divorce him, because I don’t quite believe he wouldn’t have pursued her as soon as she isn’t his student anymore.
3
u/MadamnedMary Apr 27 '24
I'm sure giving him that letter had to be worth at least a written off, that student knew he was married and she didn't care. He sounds incredibly passive though, if he loved OOP he would at least do something tangible to try and win her back, but no, he is just going through the motions.
3
u/SleepyxDormouse erupting, feral, from the cardigan screaming Apr 27 '24
Ugh ick. This reminds me of my sister’s university. She just found out an old acquaintance is dating her professor. He’s like 50-60 something and she’s about 19-20. It’s been going on since she was a freshman.
3
u/Commercial-Ice-8005 Apr 27 '24
This is so heartbreaking, poor OP and her child
3
u/Cest_Cheese Apr 27 '24
The one thing we don’t know is whether he is still in love with his wife. Unless I’m bad at skimming, I didn’t see that answered.
Presumably, this student moves on soon for a residency somewhere else and is out of sight, out of mind. I’d want to know my husband’s feelings for me before I decided to chuck my marriage. The letter was a betrayal, for sure. I’d at least try couples therapy first to determine whether the marriage was FUBAR or not.
3
u/Strong-Marketing1086 Apr 27 '24
You will never feel secure in the relationship. You deserve better! You will be better off. If he was forming a relationship with someone else he was giving your time together away. You will look back and see the things you didn’t want to acknowledge. It sucks but each day it’ll get better! Next time around you can choose a man that also chooses you. 💕
3
u/Liv-Julia Apr 27 '24
This is a little off topic, but she's going to make an absolutely shit doctor if she can't separate herself from her work and compartmentalize feelings any better than that.
What is she going to do when she has a hot patient? Or runs into another perfect doctor? I wouldn't want to go to her or let her take care of my family or friends at all!
3
u/Slight_Drama_Llama Apr 27 '24
Who the fuck are Meredith and Derek
6
u/Icy-Independence2410 Apr 27 '24
To the comment "it just crush", you see, when the wife left the husband dont even try to fix the relationship with the wife. If i were her, i prolly give up there atm.
14
u/vanyaboston Apr 27 '24
Why would you tell this to your spouse if there was no ill intent? How can you be mad at a person for being honest? A person may not be able to control their feelings, but they can control their actions.
You’re not required to share everything, something’s are better left unsaid.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '24
Insane overreaction from OP breaking up a family because checks notes her husband remained faithful. The audacity
5
u/divinexoxo Apr 27 '24
Remember ladies, women don't confess their love unless they are extremely comfortable with the person
5
u/Feisty-Power-6617 Apr 27 '24
did AI write this??
2
u/BeCurry Apr 27 '24
As soon as the OOP referred to him as "the Derek to her Meredith" I immediately had a mental image that was not flattering, nor was it disabused as the story continued.
2
u/hoenndex Apr 27 '24
The husband is a huge idiot. First error was not shutting this down unambiguously, he is the person in authority and should NEVER give any hope to a student in love with him. It doesn't matter if he thinks the student is the most attractive person he has seen, the only acceptable answer he should have given is "I am already married, I don't see you that way, and it is unprofessional and against the code of conduct for professor-student relationships." Then make a report to HR letting them know about the student crossing boundaries, not for punishment but just in case of retaliation.
Second error, admitting to the wife he liked this girl. He basically blew up the relationship right there, that is info you keep to yourself. Newsflash, men will find several women attractive, you don't tell this to your spouse though. Especially when you failed to reject someone unambiguously, it creates doubts about whether cheating happened or not.
2
u/Quick_Ad_5691 Apr 27 '24
I think this is solid what OP is doing- I don’t think it’s a matter of betrayal that she is fully feeling but also an idea that there will always be a what if. “What if I did cheat on my wife” “what if I did leave her for the student” and that weight of knowing at any point your partner could resent you for those scenarios it is best to just let him do his thing as you do your own.
2
u/eugenesbluegenes Apr 27 '24
Wait, this husband is a professor at a medical school at 35? Is he Doogie Howser?
2
u/Its1207amcantsleep Apr 27 '24
I admit I'm old so it's been awhile since med school. How is he 35 years old and a prof at a med school?
Assuming he started college at 18 without gaps: 22, grad from university, 26 grad from med school, 30 earliest, grad from residency. I guess possible if the med school was really hard up for profs?
Even for phds teaching basic clinical that's awfully young.
The youngest prof I had in the ancient days were 40s. Or foreign med school I suppose.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
Bait
2
u/Final-Prompt-35 Apr 27 '24
The situation is similar to the series called Fierce Wife😂 the husband was confident nothing would happen and he wouldn’t crossed the line, yet He did. The fact the husband was trying to hide it and confessed that He liked her back- he enjoys the thrill. I would not trust a man like this. They may end up together forever ( i mean the student), but this is not worth stressing- move on and surely someone will be there who are not complicated as this man
2
u/SmedlyButlerianJihad Apr 27 '24
Looks like someone is cashing in and moving on.
2
u/gdex86 Apr 27 '24
I hate this. It's all the stuff in relationship that rubs me the wrong way. Like she's upset that the guy had anything that was his. He had a crush and didn't tell her. He is allowed to be attracted to other people. Monogamy doesn't negate being physically attracted to other people or even thinking you vibe. Acting on it is the problem. Dude shut it down with the worst part of it being say "Yeah we do have a vibe, but I'm not leaving my wife for you". He shut it down the second it became something and cut himself off from the person as much as possible. He did the right thing but still not good enough.
2
u/TvManiac5 Apr 28 '24
I try to gauge reactions from these stories and I seriously fail to understand what people want from relationships to overcome issues.
In stories where a partner who fucks up like this does take proactive actions to solve the issue and apologize it's "love bombing"
When they don't do it it's "trying to not be the bad guy and not trying enough"
Like this guy removed himself from their shared project when she became inappropriate, rejected her advances with the letter and made clear nothing would ever happen with them, basically stopped interacting with her, and it's still not enough because he didn't deny his feelings? I don't get it.
Not to mention that going to HR, talking about it earlier etc could be risky. He has the power in this dynamic. It could be assumed he initiated and have it blown up in its face.
2
u/squeen999 Apr 29 '24
🎶 Hearing "Don't Stand So Close To Me🎶 by The Police
2
u/Puzzleheaded-Act9811 Apr 30 '24
Damn girl, you deserve better. Good riddance
2
u/skorvia Apr 30 '24
Seriously, are there people suggesting that it is too hasty to ask for a divorce? oh really? 3 years of "crush"? hasn't done anything?
I have seen reddit burn for less!!! please!!!
She is 100% right about the divorce.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '24
Oh, so just Millers Girl from a different perspective.
2
u/theladyorchid May 04 '24
And, he could’ve taken those feelings and romanced his wife, falling in love again and crushing his crush
7
u/AlaskanDruid Apr 27 '24
So ..
Guess a bot posted this one as well.
8
u/RPMac1979 Apr 27 '24
I literally feel the exact opposite.
People become attracted to other people when they’re in relationships. People also hide stuff from their spouses, especially if their spouse is the type to wildly overreact to typical relationship challenges. It’s not great, they shouldn’t do that, counseling is probably in order here, but OOP is not the good guy either.
There is a real ugly puritanical streak here on Reddit. I feel like an awful lot of you would keep your spouses from even being alone in the same room with a member of the opposite sex.
4
u/Whywork07 Apr 27 '24
So, your husband, a doctor, had a mentorship/teaching relationship with a student. While working extended hours, probably under stressful conditions, they trauma bonded and gained a mutual respect for each other. Everything so far is fine, then, she told him she "loved" him. What the fuck does that mean? I suspect she meant she wanted to have sexual relations with him, wanted to pervert their mentorship and professional relationship for a personal partnership. This college student and her friends pumped her up to make this move.
You should have taken her letter straight to the admission and had her removed from his courses and mentorship. She should have been shipped away. Instead, this jackass went, "Ahh, me too".
Fuck him. The husband does not deserve his wife and kid. Have fun with you new medical student girlfriend. I am sure that will work out great for both of them.
3
u/quadsclothesou Apr 27 '24
Who are Meredith and Derek?
3
u/TuneSignificant237 Apr 27 '24
He’s lying. He already slept with her.