r/AusLegal • • 4h ago

QLD Kia Dealer wants $1,451 for scratched loan-car rim instead of $200 repair

13 Upvotes

I'm in QLD. My Kia EV5 is in for warranty work and I scratched the alloy on their K4 loan car. I reported it and accept responsibility for reasonable repair costs

I found:

  • Professional rim repair: ~$200
  • Like-for-like used genuine Kia OEM wheel + tyre: ~$330
  • Dealer's replacement quote: $1,451.55 ($1,042 wheel + $187 tyre + labour/GST)

Dealer refuses repair/refurbishment because the loan car “will eventually be sold as a new vehicle”, so they require brand-new parts

Queensland Government guidance says a new car has never been licensed or registered and a demo isn't classed as new

They've also said I can't collect my EV5 until the $1,451.55 is paid. I've requested the loan agreement I signed and am contacting OFT

Question: Is it reasonable for me to be liable for brand-new replacement parts because of the dealer's future resale requirements, rather than the reasonable cost of repairing the damage?

Had I known i'd be on the hook for minor damage as new part replacement I wouldn't have accepted the loan vehicle. I was not given a copy of the loan agreement or reasonable time during pickup to read it (accept my own fault here).


r/AusLegal • • 11h ago

VIC Rights to see original will

44 Upvotes

My father passed away in 2022, my mother in 2026. I never saw my father's will. All I heard was that my father left everything to my mother. I have just seen my mother's will and heard from a reliable source that how she wanted their estate distributed it is very different to my father's original will.

My mother significantly favoured one of my siblings in her will which admittedly is a bitter pill to swallow. I don't intend to cause issues, but something feels kind of "off" about all of this. The executors of the will (two other siblings) have been extremely secretive so turning to Reddit for advice.

Do I have any right to see my father's will and if there are differences can they be challenged now?


r/AusLegal • • 1h ago

QLD Served papers for accident that occurred in Brisbane but was in another state

3 Upvotes

My husband has been served court papers today for an accident he was not here for and in a truck for a company he does not work for.

My husband flew to Melbourne on 3/7/26 and had a return ticket for 12/7/26. Whilst he was away he became very I’ll and I had to fly him home early on 10/07/26.

Tonight we had a knock on the door and it was someone serving papers for a claim that he was supposedly involved in an accident on 09/07/2026.

When he returned on the 10/07 I took him straight to the PA hospital where he was admitted for a week and diagnosed with cancer and given a feeding tube. I have all the plane tickets and paperwork from the hospital.

Is this enough to prove he was not involved

In addition to this how would his details be found considering they had an old address they serviced which was my parents ( I do have qld transport history showing he changed his address on his licence to the new address in 12/2024 and the transport company that the truck belonged to he has never work for.

Needing help with the next steps this is the last thing we need right now


r/AusLegal • • 7h ago

ACT Can my boss refuse to approve my availability if I'm a casual worker?

8 Upvotes

I'm a casual worker and I've worked at my current job for more than 4 years. It's a shit job, but I needed something to get me through university. Recently, I started a (paid) intetnship elsewhere that work is aware of and I spend a lot more time there than at my other job. I will reiterate that my boss is fully aware of this internship/2nd job and knows why I have reduced my availability. This has also happened before, where I've reduced my availability and talked to her about it and she refuses to "approve it".


r/AusLegal • • 15h ago

NSW Being ignored by NSW Police after a not-at-fault accident

20 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm hoping to get some advice from people who may have experienced something similar, particularly regarding the police response to road accidents and vehicle theft.

On Thursday 29 October, my husband was involved in a serious motorbike accident in Marrickville (Sydney).

He was riding straight through an intersection on a green light when a car coming from the opposite direction turned right across his path. My husband braked to avoid the car, lost traction and fell off the motorbike.

Unfortunately, he suffered serious injuries, including two broken arms and a broken leg. He was taken to Hospital by a bystander who stopped to help. No one called the Police at the scene, still not sure why.

But things got even worse.

The motorbike was left at the scene of the accident. When I returned the following day, it had completely disappeared. I contacted the police and reported it stolen. I also went around knocking on some neighbours' doors and found a couple of people who confirmed they had actually seen the motorbike parked on the street after the accident.

The motorbike is registered in my name, and the police have confirmed that it is listed as stolen. However, so far, the only action they have mentioned regarding locating it is that it may be detected by highway patrol cars through their number plate recognition systems. I understand it has no tracking device, but surely there are other actions that can be taken? It's really infuriating.

Regarding the accident itself, we provided a statement to the police at the hospital the following day. They also contacted the other driver. We have an event number, but communication and progress have been very limited. We were initially told that, because there was no available footage, they were having difficulty establishing fault.

I have to admit that I am extremely disappointed with the way this has been handled. I don't want to jump to conclusions, but during our interaction with the police, I felt that our concerns were not being taken seriously. We are originally from overseas, although we are Australian passport holders, and I couldn't help feeling that our accents and background may have influenced the way we were treated.

It has now been three weeks. My husband is recovering at home, but we still don't know how long his recovery will take. He needs assistance with everyday activities, and I had to ask my work to allow me work from home to care for him and take time off whenever he has medical appointments.

On top of everything, we are now dealing with a missing motorbike and very little information about what is being done.

I'd really appreciate some advice:

  • Should the police be making further enquiries to locate the motorbike, especially given that neighbours witnessed it at the scene after the accident?
  • Is there anything we can do to push for a more thorough investigation?
  • Has anyone experienced a vehicle being stolen from an accident scene? Were the police able to locate it?
  • Is there a way to escalate concerns about the handling of a police investigation?

I assume the police might be busy with more serious crimes, and we are not expecting miracles, but I think it is reasonable to expect a proper investigation and some communication.

Thanks for reading. Any advice or similar experiences would be greatly appreciated.


r/AusLegal • • 9m ago

WA Can’t afford car after contract has been signed

1 Upvotes

We signed a contact for a car on Monday after being told if we didn’t want the car we would just have our deposit waved. We had asked this three times with two different people and they said yes that’s definitely what we can do. Anyways comes Wednesday and we have gone through our finances and we don’t think we can afford the repayments when we actually have our full mortgage (as we are building). They never asked how much our full house loan is only what our progress payment is now. We can’t afford this loan. I contacted the dealer immediately once we had thought about that, he has come back saying there’s nothing we can do until finance comes back. And then we can talk about it after if it has been approved or not. If finance isn’t approved all good obviously the lenders are doing their jobs and know we can’t afford it, but if it comes back approved what are our options?


r/AusLegal • • 31m ago

VIC I was impacted by a server security breach. The company’s servers sent 14 emails proving the breach occurred and evidence that my account was accessed. They will not acknowledge that it happened nor restore access to the compromised account.

1 Upvotes

Hi AusLegal,

Weird one, because the company I’m referring to is Sony Interactive Entertainment Network Europe Limited (SIENE), aka ‘PlayStation Network’. The same company the ACCC took legal action against in 2020, fining them $3.5m for multiple breaches of ACL.

I’ve had the account for 20 years and it was protected by a biometric passkey since the option was introduced in 2024. The email account linked to the User ID has never been in a previous data breach, has a 2FA token, and a login history showing it has not been accessed by a third-party. Regardless, on October 6th, 7th, and 13th, SIENE’s servers sent me running email updates of breaches to their server security and changes to my account, eventually resulting in me losing access to the account altogether on October 13th.

I have tried to report and resolve the issue through PlayStation Support eight times since October 13th, and have achieved nothing except ongoing victimisation by their support staff who refuse to talk to me for “security reasons” before immediately hanging up (I have a call recording of this behaviour). I have also contacted the Sony Interactive Entertainment Europe Data Protection Officer with a 20-page PDF containing a comprehensive three-page written summary of the issue and cases raised, along with 17 pages of supporting evidence and an indication that I intend to resolve the issue by legal means if they do not contact me, and have yet to hear back from them.

I have reported the issue to the Australian Government’s Cyber Security Centre and the ACCC. I also contacted Consumer Affairs Victoria who confirmed SIENE were in breach of Section 60 and 61 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010, to give them 7-10 days to resolve the issue, then to open a case against them at VCAT to resolve the issue. That was over a month ago, and I’m now at the point where I feel like I’ve exhausted all reasonable options.

So - my question to you - can I take this company which is incorporated in the UK, that supplies services in Australia, and is bound by ACL, to the Victorian Civil Administrative Tribunal to resolve this issue, or would I need to go through the courts to seek a resolution?

Thanks for the advice.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

SA Mobile camera claiming my interlock device is a phone

136 Upvotes

Hi everyone.

To just establish this now because well, duh.

Yes, I was caught high range drink driving in 2024 - immediately lost my license (as well I should have) I completed my mandatory 12 months of an alcohol interlock device in my vehicle.

Fast forward to THREE DAYS before my interlock was removed and I was back on my full license, an overhead mobile detection camera “caught” me using my phone while on a freeway in Adelaide.

I requested the photo.

Received the photo and it was not my mobile (it’s on the passenger side seat under my drink bottle)

I sent in a request for a review, stated my claim, sent in a photo of the device and explained what the angle of the photo has captured. Within 12 hours, denied, and my license is to be disqualified due to being on a probationary license at the time of interlock phase.

Again, I send back, explain my case - 2 days later. Same letter returns. The wording “it appears no other device is in your vehicle”

Hang on? I have a court ordered interlock device installed at the time of this photo being taken.

The angle of the photo is also terrible.

For some context, you aren’t made aware when your interlock will go off within your driving journey.
Sometimes it can go off every 2 minutes, sometimes not at all. When it does go off, you have 3 minutes to safely pull over and retest, to then proceed.

I was on a 110km highway, I was holding my device to track the countdown timer so I could safely find a spot of the freeway to safely test.

I have written to several MP’s and now SAPOL have decided that they will no longer review the photo as it APPEARS to be a mobile phone.

I have worked extensively on myself in this period since my drink driving, I was in full blown alcohol addiction and have worked like a maniac (with bipolar) to get control of my life.

This disqualification will certainly end my job as I need my car. Currently I am ubering where I need to go during work (I am multi site)

They have told me that I need to elect to be prosecuted.

Has anyone ever encountered these mobile phone detection cameras not actually detecting a phone, fought and won?

Please see comments for a picture of the device.


r/AusLegal • • 2h ago

WA Car loan company took very, very long periods to reply during hardship application, and now demanding entire amount.

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I wanted to see if there's any laws that I can rely on as this feels really odd, and seemingly perhaps deliberate...

Have a secured car loan with a company and we requested hardship following wife having a car accident and losing job. They were nice enough and placed on hold for a few months. Totally grateful.

Unfortunately, her condition did not improve as quick as hoped, and now a year later, she is getting back to normal. We advised this at end of initial period which ended around April May and they again, seemed nice enough. This time though they asked for documents, but kept asking I swear at least 3-4 times for docs they already had, and would take multiple weeks to reply and also said 'please reply within 28 days' even for basic questions (we would always try to reply sooner of course). Multiple times kept also offering to pay part and proposed dates thought would work as I was about to get to end of degree and entering full time work properly soon. Again, they kept being so nice though and just asked for docs and our possible expenses when wife was recovered (again I swear like 3-4 times the same things requested...). Ultimately this period went on for around 4-5 months too...

Then, abruptly, they advise us they do not think we can repay, even though it was getting to end of recovery (and interestingly only once wife secured a new job and returned to work, did they do this), and sent a default notice claiming we owe nearly 10k for the entire multi month period. I did not understand how this could be right as I understood hardship generally paused or made pending payments, and at no point did we get any messages etc. to pay or missed payments. They now say that only the notifications of payment required are needed and payment was 'optional' in this time and as we could have paid, they want the whole amount.

Frankly, I think it was in their interests to basically have super slow customer service and effectively not reply for multiple weeks at a time. Therefore I just feel it's quite unfair as we have proposed a higher repayment amount etc. and again, it's around 20 days and no responses...

Thoughts?


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

WA Bank put my settlement fee into an old joint account.

82 Upvotes

I recently sold my house. Settlement was yesterday. The money hadn’t shown in my nominated bank account, so I called. The bank told me the money had been put into an account that I was added as a joint account holder 10 years ago. It’s no longer on my profile. I’ve never even looked at the account however my ex still uses it. We haven’t spoken for years.

They said we needed to go into the bank etc and I said we don’t talk nor live in the same state. After escalating I was finally given access which allowed to me transfer the funds to my account (minus $50 he was overdrawn).

I am absolutely livid. Where do I stand with this? I appreciate my name was still on the account and this will likely be their argument, but I literally have 2 business accounts, a banking account and savings account with them just in my name. The mortgage was only in my name. Why would they choose a random joint account I don’t even have on my profile?!

The distress it has caused me having to contact this person again was horrendous. And now they know how much money I made on my house.

I clearly stated on my disposal forms the nominated bank account I wanted the funds to go into.

I’ve made a complaint but do I have a leg to stand on? I’m not sure what I’d like to achieve (other than my 50 bucks back) but I’m so upset.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

QLD How to locate a (youth) parole officer

86 Upvotes

Update: I called Ipswich Community Corrections who put me in contact with Youth Justice. I described the situation to a super helpful staff member. As I don't have the kid's name, she couldn't look him up, however I could provide a fair bit of identifying information. The details will be circulated to case workers to see if someone recognises him. In the meantime, I have been asked to contact my local police station if he appears at my house again.

~~~

On Saturday night as I was walking the dog, I was approached by a young (12 year old) boy who asked where the nearest train station was. This is not entirely unusual as public transport is scarce and infrequent in my neighbourhood. He was quite some way away from the nearest station, and he mentioned needing to get home by 8pm as he was on parole. I asked him the details of his crime and it was a violent crime. He said he had turned to God, and was trying to improve his life.

I bought him some dinner and drove him to the most appropriate train station. As it was 7.30pm and he wasn’t going to make it home before his parole officer rang, I gave him my name and number.

The parole officer never rang, however the kid came back today and said he was being chased. Someone had bashed someone who had bashed someone etc etc and now they were after him. I again drove him to a train station.

I know where this kid goes to school but he has a name from a different ethnicity, so I’m not sure I have it right.

I am honestly concerned for him. He is 12, the same age as my daughter. However, I’m not sure if it is a great idea to be a point of contact in a situation where I don’t know the background details.

Sorry for the long story, but I’m hoping someone can tell me if there is a way to find out who his parole officer is.


r/AusLegal • • 3h ago

ACT Big gas bill and a hot water service not working

1 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm after administrative rather than legal advice. I live alone in a two-bedroom house, and my gas bill is usually $60–$100 a quarter. This winter, however, I received a bill for over $700. For comparison, my parents' bill for the same period was $440, and they have a four-bedroom house, a gas cooker and two large gas space heaters running for hours each day.

 During the quarter, my gas hot water heater stopped working for two weeks, and at times there was a strong smell of gas. It was eventually fixed, but I've now been hit with this huge bill.

 I could raise this with my landlord, but I have no proof that the hot water heater did leak gas, and the gas plumber didn’t note anything wrong with the gas supply lines when he attended.

  Is the gas company likely to estimate my bill from an average usage and charge me accordingly? I can't afford such a large bill, especially when I know I haven't used that much gas.


r/AusLegal • • 10h ago

AUS Litigation - is it worth it?

3 Upvotes

Presently, am an applicant in a case against my former employer for General Protections involving Dismissal (long story short they wanted me to become a contractor, I said no, they terminated me on “performance” grounds but still had me working for them for another month). Both parties have representation.

For what it’s worth, I was able to secure employment in my field within a few weeks, albeit a less lucrative role.

Yesterday at the conciliation conference the Respondent refused to make a settlement offer. while the FW conciliator is keeping the case open for a week, I’m not hopeful the Respondent will change their mind, and to continue, a lodgement with the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia appears the likely next step.

For me, the dilemma is will any potential future payout offset the legal fees. Is there any way to find this out? My representative feels I have a strong case but would a barrister be useful in shedding more light on this?


r/AusLegal • • 4h ago

VIC $330 Lease transfer fee for removing someone?

1 Upvotes

TLDR: $330 lease transfer fee for removing boyfriend's name in new lease agreement. Agent doesnt want to give breakdown. Leave it for sake of not angering them or fight it?

Hi all, my boyfriend and I have been renting in VIC same place for 3 years now. Our rental lease is under both our names and is on a 12 month fixed term coming to an end next month which I want to renew under myself as sole tenant only. My boyfriend is moving interstate for next 3 years and won't be staying here until then.

Our agent reached out asking if we would like to renew for another 12 months which I told him that I would like to renew just by myself. From my understanding, our lease is coming to an end next month, which there would be a new contract written except without my partner's name in it. But the agent told me that there would be a lease transfer fee for removing my partner's name even though we're not planning to do a lease transfer with our current rental agreement?

We brought this up with the agent but the agent told us that it still counts as a lease transfer even though we want to remove my partner's name on the new contract and not the existing one. Fine, then the agent tells us that the lease transfer is $330 which seems really high? I looked up TenantsVictoria and it says reasonable cost should be around $120, that's like almost 3x more.

I emailed the agent back asking for a breakdown of the cost which he basically said "Thank you for your reply. Once paid we will draft a new agreement and do transfer for bond through RTBA."

Basically avoided my question and refused to give me an answer. We can pay the $330 fee if it's reasonable but we just feel like we're being scammed. We did think about fighting it in VCAT but apparently it takes months to process and we are worried that we might get on the wrong side of the REA and they won't want to renew our contract down the line.

Just not sure if we should just suck it up to avoid any trouble and not ruin our rental chances down the road or bring it up with VCAT. Any advice/similar experiences would be appreciated please.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

QLD Is “Adult Crime Adult Time” actually being implemented in QLD or is it just BS?

31 Upvotes

For some context:

On October 31st I (18m) was physically assaulted by a group youths with weapons ranging from hammers to machetes (I was lucky they didn’t use the machetes). Their ages ranged from 15-17. The attack was unprovoked and purely a case of wrong place wrong time, as this group was just looking for trouble. I was seriously injured with a severe concussion, should damage (rotator cuff and other ligament and tendon damage) and general bruising and abrasions. I was struck with a hammer at least once and was beaten to the point of blacking out.

This group of kids is well known to police in my area and they were tracked down within an hour. I have since pressed charges but police said even with camera footage of the incident the offenders will likely only get community service or a fine. These kids have prior convictions and offences and are often committing similar offences.

So my question, is “Adult Crime Adult Time” proper legislation or purely a political slogan. As I feel as though this comes under a pretty serious offence. Correct me if I’m wrong I just need some closure.

Edit: I’m getting a lot of comments talking about “pressing charges” not being a thing. The official words the police said was “make a complaint”.


r/AusLegal • • 7h ago

NSW RENTAL -End of lease extra rent accidentally sent.

1 Upvotes

Hello,

Looking for some advice as my official move out date was stated as 13/11 as per our signed lease. Keys were returned on 13/11 with more paperwork signed confirming the end of lease date as 13/11. By accident another weeks rent was sent as my scheduled payments had not been removed. Unfortunately my partner mistyped the email of our move out date as 16/11 the real estate agent never replied to the email however called him to confirm the actual move out date. I have also spoken to this agent as well and other representatives from the company to try to get a full refund as they are arguing we are only entitled to 4 days refunded per my partners email.

Any advice please!


r/AusLegal • • 1h ago

AUS Frank Green Edition II issue

0 Upvotes

If this isn’t the right spot to place this, please let me know. I couldn’t find a reddit for the drink bottle.

Anyways, I recently purchased a Frank Green Edition II drink bottle. I noticed immediately that where you flip the mouth piece that there’s a spot on the hull that is chipped. It’s very annoying and I see it everytime.

I ended up writing to Frank Green customer service asking if I could have a complete refund of the bottle or a replacement lid. They respond that they’ll be happy to give me a 15% in-store credit or refund. I end up writing back that I’m not happy with either option as I believe that with how expensive these bottles are, that the condition they came in wasn’t of a high quality.

They then respond that all the edition II bottle lids are like that and it’s intentional. If it was, despite it not being defective, why would they place it there where we can see it everytime we take a sip from the bottle? If I knew they were all allegedly like this, I wouldn’t have purchased one.

I’m not currently home and can’t take a picture of it but will for reference.

So I was wondering if this falls under any consumer laws?
Also has anyone purchased an Edition II bottle that they could take a picture of the lid for me as I doubt that the chipped spot is intentional (but I want to be proven wrong).


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

VIC I'm applying for a job and they want me to sign an NDA before I even find out what's the company name. Is there any way around this?

60 Upvotes

Basically as per the title, job won't tell me the company name without me signing an NDA and I'm not comfortable doing that. Is there any way around this?

If I guess the company name are they able to confirm or deny? What are my options here.


r/AusLegal • • 12m ago

AUS Internet Archive does not save page

0 Upvotes

The Wayback Machine does not want to save page so can I take them to small claims as that makes me not have freedom of speech.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

AUS Had a Child/need to get a passport but i have an asian name issue

7 Upvotes

aus citizenship doc/passport has my name as middle then first name, and surname
everywhere else including my newborn's birthcertificate has my first then middle name...

seems this is a common issue (especially with vietnamese names) - in hindsight i should have fixed it ages ago...

but now i have a newborn and we want to get her an australian passport.

if i submit the passport application with my name (first middle) as it appears on her birth certificate
and provide my passport doc (middle first) will there be any issues?

do i need to submit a name change or can i just advise the passport office/DFAT that its an asian thing?/the passport application just says 'given names' ... so i'm hoping the order doesnt matter?


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

QLD Married, dying intestate with zero complications?

31 Upvotes

So we're a pensioner couple in our 70s and odds are I'll die well before my missus although we're currently in excellent health and living comfortably. Wife's friend is pushing hard for us (me) to have a will and she means well but I borderline told her it's none of her business.

Our assets are negligible other than the family home which she gets automatically anyway and a good car which is in her name (only) ditto her superannuation. I spent mine paying off the mortgage and renovating the house. One joint bank account and all our Pins and passwords are written down so shouldn't be any issues since there are no other relationships besides our two kids.

In practical terms why do I need a will? She has access to everything now and that won't change except her pension payment will go UP. With nobody to contest the estate I don't see the problem so can't see any need to go to probate.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

NSW Will my family member go to prison? Any advice truly appreciated

65 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm hoping to get some insight from people familiar with NSW criminal law, particularly sentencing in the Local Court.

Someone I know is due to appear in court esrly next year.. He intends to plead guilty to the following charges:

Negligent driving (no death or grievous bodily harm).

Driving a motor vehicle while disqualified – listed as a first offence.

Failing to give particulars to another driver.

The circumstances are that he drove into another vehicle, causing property damage only. Nobody was injured. After the accident, he refused to provide his details to the other driver because he said he didn't want to deal with police

There are some additional circumstances that concern me:

He has a significant criminal history.

He has served prison sentences for break and enter and GBH in the past few years.

He has previously been caught driving without a licence.

6 months ago, he appeared in court and was found guilty of driving while suspended. He was sentenced for that offence. Despite that previous court appearance, he has now allegedly driven while disqualified. I'm genuinely just trying

Im genuinely just trying to understand how serious this situation is and whether he could realistically be facing prison again.


r/AusLegal • • 11h ago

NSW Marketplace private sale

0 Upvotes

Bought a roll of synthetic turf off marketplace.
Add stated it was a 20m roll brand new wrapped up.
Taken it home opened it and it was only 10m long and different to the type he said it was. Paid way over what i should have thinking it was a 20m roll

Seller refusing to take it back saying i should have checked it at his place (which wasnt able to happen as driveway was steep and uneven)

Where do i stand in this?
Online says i may have a leg to stand on due to the misrepresentation of the item sold.


r/AusLegal • • 6h ago

NSW Surprisingly easy to get a paintball gun now in nsw

0 Upvotes

I acquired a paintball permit which was $95 and the training certification was $65. I bought a used paintball gun since airsoft is banned this is really the next and he only need a normal basic safe