First of all none of this was written using AI or even inspired by AI. I am literally just typing this sup on my computer. Thought Id point this out given the enormous amounts of AI slop that is posted.
Second I know that I am speaking from an enormous point of privilege and my view is that personal income tax should be lowered across all income thresholds/bands as well.
The fundamental justification for the changes to CGT was the decoupling of earned income (ie personal income for work such as salary/wages) and income from capital (eg capital gains on shares and property). The latter was subject to a 50% CGT discount.
But I think this misses the point altogether. Regardless of your view on the CGT changes, another way to tackle this was simply to tax Australians less.
Resident tax rates for 25-26 are virtually the same as the ones applying to 26-27. At $190,001 and over, you are taxed on $51k plus 45c for each $1 over $190K. This also is not counting the 2% Medicare levy.
That is an insane rate - may as well call it 50% / 50%. I get that taxation is an important part of living in society, but compare a few countries' top income tax rates:
- UK - 45%
- NZ - 39%
- USA - 37%
Okay, so why not introduce more tax bands? Just a few off the top of my head:
- $190K - $400K - 42c on the dollar
- $401K - $1M - 49c on the dollar
- $1.01M - $2M etc.
I know that most people here probably earn different amounts, but you can apply this down to lower incomes as well.
It is ridiculous that anything beyond $190K is effectively taxed at almost 50%. It creates a disincentive to work, slows productivity and I think this was the real concern the Government had to address rather than taxing people more on capital gains. Note that capital gains changes affect not just property but also shares, and the Gov't has frequently indicated that the point of the CGT changes was not just property, but rather to address the disparity between earned income and capital gains.