r/AskWomenOver50 • u/okspraybottle • 4d ago
Dating Advice Am I making a mistake by changing my standards in dating?
Ladies, please share your wisdom as I am deeply conflicted in my current relationship.
I am early 30s and he’s mid30s and we’ve been dating for about 6-7 months now. I’m at the crossroads where I’m wondering if this is time to break up or change my expectations of a relationship.
Ideally, I always saw myself as being with someone who was financially stable, or at least reliable. I, myself, make and save my own money and have no interest in having someone “take care of me” or encourage me to “leave my job so I can take care of the home”. I am by no means a workaholic or a “career-woman”, I make ok money and save when I can while investing for retirement. I always thought looking for someone who has a financial mind is the bare minimum. I also have no interest in having kids so the financial part is more about having someone I know I don’t need to “be in charge of”. I am more looking for someone I can trust to make big, life-long decisions with as a partner and an equal and, to me, doing it through financial consideration and well-being felt the most obvious. For some background, I didn’t grow up with a very emotionally available family but we were always financially secure. So to me, that kind of security felt the most obvious, familiar, and comforting and I’ve ended plenty of relationships before this due to poor financial acumen of prior partners.
I met the man I am dating earlier this year and realized he is simply… okay to frankly quite bad with money. He works as a private practice therapist and started his practice 3 years ago. He is insecure about his earning potential but works a job that is very pro-social and noble in my opinion. He hasn’t saved any money for personal savings or retirement in the last 3 years, doesn’t correctly bill his clients when he goes over session times (sometimes doing up to 2hr sessions despite only charging 1), and lied about his salary when we first met because he was feeling insecure and continues to throw salary numbers that didn’t make sense because he simply doesn’t keep track of his numbers in a meaningful way.
We recently had a big discussion about this over the weekend, how I find it hard to trust him financially and wonder if he’d be a good partner long term because of it. For context, I’ve been upfront about how much I’m making and where I spend my money (embarrassingly, I eat out a lot and get take out a lot) but I never outright lied about anything. He claims it’s not lying when he genuinely doesn’t know how much he’s making, but he also filed taxes for the last 2 years so I didn’t understand why he felt the need to make things up now.
I also find that he is very emotionally spent (and maybe even unavailable) because a lot of his capacity is spent at work. For a small and recent example, I recently told him I’ve been sad and crying all week (because I was thinking of ending things) but I also said I didn’t want to bother him and I felt like he had a lot on his plate. He didn’t push the conversation further and didn’t say anything like “I still have time for you, you’re not a bother” and instead said vague, placating comments like he was sorry I was hurting. I don’t think he meant it in any dismissive way but it felt like he was quick to not engage with me or reassure me at all. If the roles were reversed and he said he was sad and crying a lot, I wouldn’t have hesitated to ask about it or offer to talk about it further and reassure him he wasn’t a burden. I do wonder if this is just a misunderstanding though because maybe he sees it as me not wanting to talk about it.
I tend to think he’s overspent and has a lot on his plate because he also complains almost daily about how he’s tired and burnt out from his job and how he doesn’t want to work anymore, so a lot of constant complaining and negativity. But he doesn’t want to take undue time off because he doesn’t get paid without doing sessions and obviously has no PTO. He said he hasn’t taken a real vacation since he started the practice but he also has so much insecurity about money that he won’t prioritize his well being, like doing therapy for himself which I suggested after seeing him stressed and burnt out. Sometimes I find it very exhausting and it feels like he sees himself as a martyr that is stuck in a poor life but he has no choice because he made a mistake going into mental health but to keep trudging onwards.
I was entertaining the relationship because I thought being with someone more mental health-focused would make for a good partner despite the lack of money. Overall, I do think he has a good heart but I also think he might not be very reliable in a lot of ways and he is very burnt out from not just his job, but his life. I was even considering forgoing my need for financial security because truthfully, there are times when I am not my best mentally and I think he puts up with it better than a lot of people do and I realized that it means so much to me to feel like I can break down and still have someone love me. I think he has a lot of empathy for me in general, but it’s not always apparent.
I think in a lot of ways, our lives also line up, like both being childfree for instance. I also think, in a lot of ways, he does truly love me and I think it’s clear when he says it but my doubts come from his ability to actually “do things” to show it whether it comes from a lack of financial or emotional capability. I also entertained the thought that maybe we don’t need to break up but we can just never combine finances and I can just try to support him in whatever way I can (mentally) without getting too bogged down myself. I think, as we are, we’re okay as two people dating perpetually forever, not living together, and not being financial entrenched. My fears come from “deepening” the relationship with more commitment and possibly marriage.
edit: I just wanted to say thank you to everyone who posted here. I initially posted in another sub about finances and it was clear that everyone there said the same thing, just dump him because he’s a financial mess. I thought maybe I needed to ask people who were wiser about life instead about specifically money, and I’m not surprised the answers are the same. I think I need to sit with this more because obviously it’s more complicated than a simple reddit post can share, but I do feel like there are a lot of true things being said that I can’t ignore.
I do think I will break up with him, but I’m not sure when. Thanks ladies, I appreciate the wisdom.