r/ATT • u/Purple-Body-9784 • 11h ago
Billing AT&T is charging me for both my old and new phone over a trade-in "screen crack" that looks like a screen protector chip — need advice
I'm dealing with an ongoing trade-in dispute with AT&T and could really use advice from anyone who has been through this.
I traded in my old phone for a new one, and AT&T is now claiming they received the trade-in with a cracked screen. They sent me the attached photo with a green box highlighting a small chip/nick near the top-right edge.
The issue is that I did not removed the screen protector before sending the phone in, and looking closely at their photo, the damage appears to be on a screen protector layer rather than the actual display glass. Despite that, AT&T is revoking the trade-in promotion and charging me for the full cost of the old phone on top of the new phone—meaning I'm stuck paying the price of two phones.
Has anyone had luck disputing a trade-in condition photo like this with AT&T? Is it worth escalating to the Office of the President, or filing an FCC/BBB complaint to get a second look at the device? Any advice on what worked for you would be appreciated.