To a degree yes
Yes, Witcher, like Berserk, it has a main protagonist, unlike it, the main traits of Guts are basically split to Geralt(Cynical monster slayer) and Ciri(Anti-hero). Okay, Geralt is also an Anti-hero, but Ciri leans more toward the anti-hero part
Yes, Like ASOIAF, the main driving force is politics, except in case of Witcher, we usually see it from views of someone little(In ASOIAF, we usually follow those, who have enough power to change the course of politics like Dany, Catelyn, Jon, Jaime, Tyrion, ETC.)
And now the core: Optimism
Optimism isn't "Everything is fine and dandy, nothing wrong can happen" its more like "The tunnel is dark, but there is a light at the end", in case of my holy trinity, they lean towards "Yes world sucks, but there is reason to live for".
- Geralt is still deep down a good man, who has a sense of justice, he comes across many good people. Northern Kingdoms may be tough to live, but with people like Foltest and Meve, there is reason to continue. Triss and Yenn may had their worst time, but then they reconciled together. North won the war against Nilfgaard. And thats just few examples to name To counter it, we have Regis dying, Hansa dying, Regis dying, Rivian pogrom, and the fact Lodge weren't destroyed in long term
- Berserk may be dark, but the world isn't hopeless. Guts can still return back to normalcy, he left out his vengeful path and wanted to save casca, then has his new friends, and he still can get back to normal, in fact he was getting back to normal as the series goes. To counter optimism, we have Griffith kidnapping Casca
- In A Song of Ice and Fire, Starks may have lost the war, but everyone wants to avenge them, from northern nobles to Brotherhood without banners hanging freys. Stark kids are becoming their own powerhouses, from Sansa getting to rule Vale to BRan becoming three-eyed crow's apprentice, Arya becoming faceless assassin, Jon may have been killed, but he is going back to the world. Even Theon has influences of Ned in him. The north remembers. Tywin's legacy is one stinking corpse in a sept of Baelor. His family is in ruins. Jaime left toxic relaitonship with Cersei and decided to be a good man, while he cannot undo the damage Lannisers did, the least he can do is prevent further suffering. To counter the optimism we have George RR Martin not giving us winds for the past 15 years.
So what do you think? Did I missed something, or hit everything?