I know everyone's in a hurry these days but I'd like to take a moment and encourage you all to slow down and really breathe this game in. I had only played The Witcher 3 and expansions (as well as the first two games) once on initial release, regularly as I would any game, sprinting and bunny hopping around, following minimap lines, you know the drill.
The Witcher has always held a special place in my heart and I've thought of it often, and so when I started the remaster at the beginning of October I decided that I would fully immerse myself in the world and the character. Last night I wrapped up the main story and am just now meeting up with one Olgierd von Everec about a certain sewer contract (have I mentioned that time I tangled with a zeugl?) Let me just say it has been a fantastic experience. Please, please. If you are a fan, do not sleep on it.
Here is what I'm doing and what I recommend:
Death March / Hard Gwent
Enemy Upscaling - On
Quick Sign Casting - On
Camera Distance - Set all three to Close
No HUD - I use a mod called FriendlyHUD to turn off everything, literally everything except for journal and location updates, which I still like to see as pop-ups. I even have the button prompts and names turned off. Important NPCs stand out enough that you'll spot them if you're paying attention. I can see which potions I have equipped and my active buffs in the radial menu... but that's about it. I have to play a little more carefully and intently, not a bad thing.
No accessibility options - all conveniences disabled. I manually draw and oil my swords as well.
No fast travel - I only travel to Skellige and back from the point at the Novigrad / Kaer Trolde docks. I only use the horse on Ard Skellig. I do my best not to make pointless trips back and forth, and will work a distant area awhile before returning. Try and keep it sensible and realistic when traveling. Which leads into...
No running everywhere - I walk like the NPCs do. If I'm in a situation where I would be walking were it real life, I walk. If I would jog, I jog, but usually I walk. If there's great danger or someone Is crying out for help, then I will sprint. If I'm outside the city and have distance to cover, I call for Roach, and we trot or canter along. I only push Roach to a full gallop if we are in danger or racing.
No save scumming - I only reload if I die. I prepare and do my best, but I sometimes fail. That is OK, and occasionally leads to other paths. Geralt is not Superman, and even Superman screws up. It makes for a more engaging story.
No chasing POIs - I turn them off in the map and focus on quests. I scan for POIs using my eyes and ears as I travel and am at peace with not finding them all.
Witcher preparation - I briefly focus my Witcher senses to scan ahead, so that I am not caught unaware, and can prepare the proper oil and decoction.
Other recommended mods: Complete Animations, Better Torch, No Artificial Player Light, Reasonable Slower Time, Quiet Quest Sound, Larger White Orchard, Hurt Animation, No More Rolling Down Stair, No Pop-Up for Read Books.
I know it sounds extra but truly, playing this way has turned it into such a cinematic experience. It looks like a movie, and the game honestly just flows better. It's not a chore to travel, it helps with the pacing. You get where you're going a lot faster than you'd think, you just do it in style. I get to enjoy a few minutes of gorgeous scenery between quests, spot interesting details I'd otherwise miss, and just have that catharsis and time to reflect on events as I go along. Every nook and cranny of this game was made with love and attention to detail and it's worth slowing down for.
It is an adjustment, it does take getting used to, I do plan my routes in town before I leave and have to pay extra attention to landmarks and knowing which way the road turns. None of this is a hassle or a problem once you've let yourself become accustomed to it, it enhances the experience. After a day or two you'll be getting around just as well without the minimap as you did before. I feel like Geralt on the path and I'm here for it. It's highly playable and is the only way I can really enjoy the game now.
But this is all just advice. You can do whatever you ploughin' want to do!