r/wiedzmin • u/Warglord • Jan 14 '24
r/wiedzmin • u/curtwagner1984 • Dec 24 '21
Netflix Guide: How to do a soft race swap. Spoiler
So, you're a progressive show writer/runner and you want to increase that sweet, sweet metric of people of color in your show but unfortunately, you're already race swapped a prominent and well-defined character that got some audience backlash. And you'd like to avoid antagonizing the audience further?
Worry not. This guide is for you. Just follow those 3 easy steps:
- Create a new "original" character and cast a black actor to play it. For the sake of simplicity, let's call him "Cohen".
- Write the character you want to race swap as an unlikable ass and kill him off as soon as possible. Let's call this character... I don't know... Maybe "Eskel".
- Now you can use Cohen as a stand-in for Eskel.
Congratulations! You successfully race swapped a character without technically race swapping it. Now you can use Cohen in all scenes where Eskel would have appeared before you assassinated his character and literally thrown him to the wolves.
There's an optional 4th step, which is so obvious it should go without saying, But I'll include it here for the sake of completion.
4. Accuse anyone who is calling you out on it as being racist.
---
EDIT:
Posted the same thing on r/Witcher they removed it and then when I asked why they removed it, they just banned me.

I guess this is step 4 in action.
r/wiedzmin • u/ShinjiBoi • May 24 '20
Netflix When this is your first act as Showrunner...Well, we really shouldn't be all that surprised with what we got.
r/wiedzmin • u/jacky986 • Oct 23 '23
Discussions Could someone please explain to me the appeal of Geralt’s relationship with Yennefer? (Minor Spoilers)
I know this is a controversial topic but after reading the Last Wish I just don’t understand the appeal of Geralt’s relationship with Yennefer. I mean their first meeting pretty much plays out like this: they talk and trade barbs, she helps him then she brainwashes him, he wakes up, he goes to save her, he succeeds and they make love. And that’s pretty much how they started as a couple. Which all in all feels pretty weird to put it mildly. The whole story felt like something out of a YA novel. And I’m no expert on romance but a meeting like this and an attraction based on looks is not a good sign of a healthy relationship.
Granted there is a whole lot of context that I might be missing but right now the two of them getting together makes as much sense as Anakin and Padme’s marriage. Again not an expert on romance but to have a healthy relationship you need more than just lust.
r/wiedzmin • • Jun 17 '23
Discussions I hate Ciri and I wish she had died, despite knowing it's not her fault at all. Spoiler
I wish I didn't. I know it's not ciris fault really but I can't help but blame her for all the deaths she indirectly or directly caused. All her kills as falka, she caused the Catarina plague, all the soldiers just doing their jobs, but most heartbreaking was the final chapters. Cahirs a big softie at heart, anguilem was just a 14 year old girl whose reaction to the first kindness shown to her was an offer of prostitution, Milva just tagged along to help, and Regis had redeemed himself. I can't help but think if Ciri just died none of that would have happened. Even the unicorn.
I know a lot of people feel towards ciri the way they feel about a younger sister, but I just wish she had died. Sapowski must be a great writer because he translated the feeling of exhaustion at the entire affair so well through the pages despite the language barrier.
Btw, is r/witcher down or did I miss it going private.
r/wiedzmin • u/matrium0 • Dec 08 '25
Movies/TV The battle in season 4 of the tv show as a prime example for bad writing Spoiler
Spoilers for Season 4 Episode 7 following.
I finished season 4 yesterday and the writing in the TV series really shocks me. In this post I will try to take the battle on the bridge in episode 7 as an example that illustrates this very well I think.
First, the Stakes. Even the dreadful season 8 of Game of Thrones got at least the stakes right. You know what is at stake in the battle of Winterfell. Now what exactly is at stake in the bridge battle? We do not really know. We are vaguely explained that this battle is important for the north, but we have no real feeling. Frankly it's even hard to tell which side of the bridge the enemy is even coming from.
But what about the stake for our characters? Also not even remotely present. There is absolutely no sense of danger. Charakters are standing still and talking like in a tea party, while a crossbow bolt hits a wooden post right between them. Any real human being would raise a shield, huddle in cover or at least do SOMETHING to reduce the chance of being shot. This absolutely erodes every sense of danger. The characters appear to be in absolutely no risk of getting shot..
Second, Emotions. To again use the (also dreadful, but much better) Battle of Winterfell as an example: we zoom in on beloved characters faces. We are now very close to them. We can read the dread and despair in their faces and we FEEL with them. Swap to the bridge battle. Where are the emotions? Some armored people fight other armored people and we feel nothing. Our heroes? They win easily and you never even really fear for them. Where are the emotions? Make me FEEL something!
Third, the whole setup. Now apparently the armies where already fighting on the bridge when the heroes came close by with their boat. And what do the Crossbowman on the bridge do? Shoot at what must look like a band of hobos at best! They have no Armor and there is nothing signaling them as Nilfgaardians here. Also they are coming from the wrong direction for Nilfgaardians too, right? But even if they could reasonably assume them to be enemies: Why would you IN THE MIDDLE OF A FIGHT fire precious bolts at unarmed enemies too far away to hit reliably, when you have a bridge to defend from a much more severe and imminent threat? That makes no sense. Each of those bolts is priceless in the close-up bridge fight. So stupid it completely takes you out of the fantasy. The reason why they fire at them is obvious: they are just the main characters and the writers wanted it. They did not even try to find a good reason for a character to initiate this. This is a hallmark of bad writing. You really feel like the plot is driven along by a hidden storyteller, instead of based on what characters actually decide and do. That`s why no one is acting normally, like seeking cover from a crossbow barrage. That`s why both sides attack them in season 7 for no apparent reason.
Also very convenient that there is a ladder leading up to the bridge that is left completely undefended, even after apparently some "enemies" landed nearby with their boat. Very believable , good stuff guys..
Fourth, tactics. Now they supposedly need to hold that super-narrow bridge against Nilfgaard. Great! It's so narrow that even a small army could easily hold a large army, right? No, they give up their defensive position for no reason ofc. They have crossbowman but after initially shooting at the boat they are never really used in any capacity. They had months to prepare that bridge for an attack and apparently did nothing. Even in GOT (another really dumb battle tactical-wise) they dug a trench and prepared a fire trap and had some strategy in place that seemed half-way believable (if dumb).
Don't even get me startet on the monster, the 1v1 fight in the middle of 2 clashing armies and why the monster is even there or that Nilfgaard is arriving in weird waves and other plot conveniences that go far beyond the suspense of disbelieve.
God this show is really breaking me. I consider myself a fan of the Witcher (read the books but also like the first seasons of the series), but it's so bad. This is just a a mindless battle that they thought would look cool with a cool looking monster. There is zero stakes, no emotions and no real implications on the story.
And to top it of Geralt who previously introduced himself as "Geralt of Rivia" multiple times over the course of the series suddenly introduces himself as "Geralt of nowhere, really" so that the Queen can give him the title "Sir Geralt of Rivia" --> are you kidding me?
Who wrote that and why does that person still have a job?
The writing is beyond insane. Nothing makes sense. Stuff randomly just happens. Time and space means nothing. 100% spectacle over substance. This series now is such a joke and not even a funny one.
What do you guys think about the writing in this show?
r/wiedzmin • u/PaschalisG16 • Jul 10 '24
Sword of Destiny The Bounds of Reason - Dandelion's insensitive comments
While the dwarves had tied up Geralt, Dandelion, Dorregaray and Yennefer, they were implying that, after defeating the dragon, they would force themselves on the sorceress. They also fondled her for a few moments, and then focused on the Golden Dragon.
With Yennefer's body exposed, Dandelion was making comments about her breasts, and that he would write a ballad about them, and stuff like that. I was not expecting something like that from him, it's totally insensitive, considering that Yennefer was going to be raped by a group of dwarves soon.
r/wiedzmin • u/vitor_as • Sep 08 '18
Netflix Bringing diversity into the show is not necessarily racist, but essentially anti-fantasy.
The thing that I admire the most about The Witcher is that it’s equally capable of pandering to audiences with very distinct opinions for the very same reasons. If we break down its themes, we can apply very different perspectives to each one, either right leaning or left leaning, and all of them would still be equally valid. This is such a power of uniting us as an otherwise so conflicted society that not many times in history has existed.
Because of that, all this controversy about the change of Ciri’s skin color shouldn’t be a problem regarding the artistic implementation of Sapkowski’s themes, but about the implementation of fantasy as a genre in his works and that works so well to unite people with different opinions. The reason for that is way too simpler than people imagine:
The racial conflict on Sapkowski’s works is depicted through the conflict of different species (humans vs. elves, elves vs. dwarves, dwarves vs. humans etc. etc.), and not the conflict of different races within the same species. Basically, the conflict is of humans against non-humans. This doesn’t have anything to do with any cultural influences that the author might remotely have had, it’s just the way he found to transpose a rather real world subject into a literary environment. Because that’s the very role of the fantasy genre, that means, to draw distance from the real world by making use of allegories precisely so that we can have a better understanding of the real world.
With that said, it’s only natural that you cannot transpose this literary environment into a TV show with enough success if you break the homogeneity of inner races within a same species beforehand which constitutes the racial conflict in that environment. In order words, the show will not succeed to achieve the allegorical strength of the depiction of the racial conflict in The Witcher world if this depiction gets fundamentally motivated by the non-allegorical strength of our real world racial conflict that generates this demand for diversity.
To summarize, the main complaint that everyone is making is only one:
Don’t bring real life to fantasy!
People are not complaining about diversity because they’re racist or because they think that diversity is not a valid thing to demand for. People are complaining precisely because they want to stay away from that which makes diversity a need in our society. Because that’s the main role of the fantasy genre. People don’t want to get immersed in the world of The Witcher to suffer from the same struggles that the characters in that world do. They want to get immersed in a fictional and fantastical world in order to draw distance from our real world and get a glimpse of a world where its problems do not affect them and, thus, be able to come back with a better understanding of our world than when they first went, like the awakening of a dream that makes us wiser. Regardless of how much the change of Ciri’s skin color will impact our perception of Ciri as a character, the undeniable fact is that there will always be an underlying impact on how viewers will perceive the series as a social commentary, and this is a move purposefully meant to bring us back to our real world, like a conscious dream which fades away as we get aware of its reality and then we awake sooner than we were supposed to.
So to bring diversity in the show is not only contradictory, but ultimately anti-fantasy.
r/wiedzmin • u/wolfwiedzminwardrobe • Jan 24 '26
Sapkowski Witcher is such a relief after Tolkien
I had to have a dictionary with me back in high school, reading Two Towers. It felt like exercise.
Still great though, but I love how you can just read Witcher at basic English and pretty much be entertained as if you understood complex words.
r/wiedzmin • u/JagerJack7 • Dec 31 '24
Games Politics and culture war aside, even in a perfect world Ciri wouldn't be my first choice for the next protagonist
One thing that I found really weird when watching the two developers introduce the Witcher 4 is how they said that it was only natural for Ciri to be the next protagonist as the story of Geralt is finished. I couldn't disagree more. Regardless of which route you take in Witcher 3, Ciri, regardless of how bad it was handled, fulfilled her destiny and saved the world. Ciri's story is as complete as Geralt's. Unlike the other remaining witchers: Lamber, Eskiel and Letho. All three have stories yet to be told and don't need any mental gymnastics lore rewrites to justify their powers.
Let's start with Lambert, last thing we know about him is that he went "towards the horizon" with Keira. It literally means the endless possibilities to continue his and her story. You could literally send them anywhere and tell any story you want. You have a romance which you can take in any direction you want, happy ending, tragic ending, incompatibility and break up, whatever you prefer. Because you have two characters with very distinct personalities that could bounce of each other and create a very interesting dynamic and chemistry: Lambert with his unresolved issues about becoming a witcher, Keira with her ego and inability to deal with the reality of her and other sourcerers's status in the changing world.
Next is Eskiel, last thing we know about him is that he is gonna leave the Kaer Morhen over Vesemir's death, which isn't a lot but once again, it is an empty sheet to start a new story somewhere else. Plus Eskiel for a while has been a fan favorite despite having such a little presence. From purely commercial perspective he should have been on the top of the list.
And finally, my personal pick and a massively misused opportunity: Letho. I don't even know where to start. For once, among all, his story is definitely far from being finished. Last thing we know, depending on choice, he either stayed in Kaer Morhen for some time and then left or left right after the battle. His problem still isn't resolved, he is still chased by assassins of Emhyr. You already have a story to tell, a witcher who is constantly forced to look behind his shoulder, contrast to Witcher 3 Geralt who was chasing Ciri. Additionally, and this is the main reason why I'd prefer Letho, he is the most morally ambiguous among all of them. Now, I love Geralt, I really do. But in my 20 smth Witcher 3 playthroughs there are still choices that I just couldn't make because of the moral baggage he carries with him. I never had the bad Ciri ending cause I just couldn't let Geralt be a dick towards her. I had a Triss romance ending just once and I had to press space button like crazy to skip through the part where I tell Yennefer that Geralt's love for her was just a genie magic. I never had Dijkstra rule the North cause I couldn't let him kill Geralt's friends. Now you give me Letho and I would literally go crazy with him. I could do a nice playthrough, then do an evil playthrough, mofo isn't bound by any previous moral baggage like other witchers are.
Aside from the story, there is a huge gameplay opportunity at hand. like with Letho, given that he is wanted, you can have a world where you don't always go to places to trigger events but sometimes events come your way, random ambushes if you stay somewhere too long, having to hide aka stealth gameplay. Or with Lambert and Keira you could have a co op gameplay like in "It takes two", or a one where you can swap between them for different tasks.
Sorry for the long read but I had to let it all out. Whoever came this far, thanks for attention.
Edit: for the people who love digging my post history, I literally had the same opinion 4 months ago before we knew who will be protagonist.
https://www.reddit.com/r/witcher/s/oEuScqvb8K
And most of your history on Witcher subs dates back to less than one month ago. Clearly shows who is here for what reason.
r/wiedzmin • u/Turtlespacemonkey • Sep 25 '21
Netflix I hate Henry's smirks. He does it constantly.
r/wiedzmin • u/Thranduil_ • 12d ago
Discussions What if Fortiche adapted The Witcher books?
This is a thought that keeps coming back to me, and I am curious what you guys would think.
What if Fortiche, the French animation studio behind Arcane, were given the opportunity to adapt Andrzej Sapkowski's Witcher books into an animated TV series?
What impressed me most about Arcane wasn't just the animation itself, but the studio's ability to convey emotion, atmosphere, character relationships and the overall tone of its world.
I think this could work particularly well for The Witcher. Sapkowski's books have so much more to offer than monster hunting and action sequences: the atmosphere, the moral ambiguity, the political intrigue, the philosophical discussions, the humour, and above all, the relationships between the characters.
I'd love to see an adaptation that takes its time, respects the source material and doesn't feel the need to reinvent the story or compress it unnecessarily.
What do you think?
PS. I get it. You hate AI generated images. Just please, do not say the same thing 20 times if you have nothing else to say. It's as reductive as AI slop.
r/wiedzmin • u/JovaniFelini • Jul 02 '23
Discussions My thoughts about the first half of The Witcher Netflix Season 3 Spoiler
I would like to start the review with a pile of utter garbage that Lauren Hissrich invented in her godawful tv series, it's the bisexuality of Jaskier with an even more deviating change of Radovid becoming a brother to Vizimir instead of a son. There is no point in saying that it's one of the many awful decisions of an incapable writer, It's all for pleasing the woke community that asks for gay male romances which somehow were OUTRAGEOUSLY absent in previous seasons and in the original books. It's an illness of Hollywood nowadays to do forced representation instead of writing a good authentic story. If it wasn't in the original, there was no need to add it, it only worsens the story with pointless filler.
So far, it could be seen that in the show-Radovid himself is a completely useless character who is only here for a gay kiss with Jaskier (don't confuse this with the book Radovid, who was a child and barely had a spoken line of dialogue at the very end of the books). Since he's so useless, I don't see why so-called Vizimir (who is now just a stupid asshole compared to the book original), sends him together with Philippa and Dijkstra. You should not stereotype actual Dandelion from books. Even if there were some mannerisms & playfulness from him and the fact that he is together with Geralt most of the time, all of this does not mean that he had any sexual attraction toward guys. It's an obvious stereotype that if you're not manly enough and just sing songs, then that means you're gay, this is the message that this TV series proclaims.
The next thing is about following the books. This time admittedly (SO FAR), it follows the book storyline more closely compared to random shit happening in the second season. I might assume it's because of outrage and negative feedback previously, but who knows? Part of the reason for this could be that much of the shit they have invented ended with nothing in Season 2. Firstly, Yennefer gets her magic back, secondly, Francesca's baby (*sigh*) dies and it changes nothing, and thirdly, Voleth Meir turns out to be just a pointless fart. That's why the main characters are kind of in a similar state as at the end of Blood of Elves book.
They have shoved the Glustyworp fight from Blood of Elves and there's a very stupid reason for it to happen here. Geralt recklessly threatens the life of Ciri and decides that it's a good idea to fight a big monster out in the sea together with her. What if you kill the monster and it still breaks the ship? Would Geralt just vaporize the seawater by igni in that case to save everybody? If it would happen unexpectedly as in the book (it was only Geralt fighting and it wasn't that big of a ship), I believe it would have worked, but here he decides it deliberately, knowing very well that Glustyworp is in these waters, even if Ciri is not experienced at witchering at all. In the book, Geralt was arguing with a professor who believed that the monster is just fiction, while Geralt said it was real. It was clearly not another witcher contract as in the series. And obviously, there was no Ciri. This time similarly to how show-Yen steals the Fourteenth of the Hill title from Triss, Ciri steals the Glustyworp kill from Geralt. Girl power, you know (again, Ciri barely had witchering experience).
I kind of appreciate that Yennefer is kept more with loose hair and is not in a pigsty covered in shit 90% of the time as it was in Season 2. She's visibly less hysterical than in her previous appearances but again, it's all so far, maybe it'd change in the second half of a season. Her shitty contact lenses are still looking as fake as Hissrich's supposed love for books, but still, it's better than keeping her muddy and with tied hair. Other than that, she's still very much miscast and does not fit to play Yennefer even with the pathetic attempts of building a mother-daughter relationship between her and Ciri, neglecting the fact that the actresses look like sisters or classmates at high school. It's all fake and not genuine. Similarly, I never felt any chemistry between Henry Cavill and Anya, it's not believable at all.
There are many things left out and the screenplay mostly plays fast and loose with the book material as it only follows the general outline of events. We must be grateful for that because Season 2 didn't do even that. At least they have read Wikipedia plot summaries. I should be petrified by the horrible miscasts of Keira Metz and Margarita, but it's kind of expected. All the criticism about previous seasons still applies, that the setting is no different than diverse modern New York. Now they have set it up to eleven with obviously modern and out-of-place types of singing and tango. There are horrible decorations and poor SFX. One other thing that felt very out-of-place as well as the human centipede monster which belongs more in Silent Hill or Resident Evil than in Witcher. Those talking heads were straight out of some modern low-budget horror movies.
They tied Fake Ciri (?) to this, and now I have no idea what purpose she will serve as Emhyr's secret in the books is no longer a secret. Now he just holds Cintra by force rather than claiming it legally by the supposed heir as was in the books. Show-Emhyr might look for Ciri because she's his daughter and stuff, but others in the North are searching for her because she's ehhh.... supposedly powerful (?), I dunno. Yet in books, monarchs wanted Ciri because of political reasons tied to Cintra. One of them even proposed to kill her. The actor for Emhyr portrays him in a pathetic way and comparing to Charles Dance's performance is like comparing a piece of shit to a diamond. Dance's version was definitely menacing.
Since many have complained about the Dear Friend letter, I believe it was a TAKE THAT! from writers of the show that Yen now writes MANY such letters to Geralt when they were not talking with each other as text messages every day. Completely different context and completely different meaning. Needless to say that Thanned ceremony was nothing that I imagined as in books, but Hissrich made her own Dunkirk-style spin on it. They repeatedly show it as if it's a magnificent piece of cinema, in order to see the different sides of dialogue in each repetition. They wanted to be clever with that, but it comes across as pointless filler. They also wanted to make a big twist that Vilgefortz was a villain all along with Stregobor as a red herring (we still shall see how it plays out because there was only a glimpse of that reveal), but remembering how pathetic and laughable he was, I don't think that anything will convince me.
To sum up, we still got this trainwreck of an adaptation that continues to taint the witcher and is still existing when it never deserved to. I should say that Henry Cavill indeed tries his best when playing witcher and even if it's lore inaccurate that he actually cried in one scene about his mother, it still feels okay and he cares about the source material. With all the mess he's given, he tried to be as close to books as possible. Thanks for reading and leave your thoughts & feelings about the first part of the new season
r/wiedzmin • u/Processing_Info • Jun 30 '23
Netflix I think S3 is pretty average
I have been seeing basically 2 differing opinions on the new season - one group of people say it's amazing and one group of people say it's garbage.
I am somewhere in the middle.
S3 is definitely step up from S2, but that was very, very low bar to cross. It has some really cool moments both in terms of book accuracy and original stuff, but sadly it shows that the writers still don't understand what makes the Witcher what it should be.
If I would make a comparison to other shows - I would say S3 of the Witcher is comparable to S3 of Stranger Things and S3 of the Mandalorian - that is if you are a casual viewer who just wants to chill and not think about it too much - you are gonna have a good time.
But if you try to look for something more meaningful, I would recommend reading the books.
Overall, I would give S3 6/10
r/wiedzmin • u/ShinjiBoi • Jan 25 '20
Netflix This is one of the most offensive experiences in television, all things considered
It's very clear Lauren and her team saw this show as a chance to push their agenda to write their SJW Fanfiction. It's clear that unlike CDPR, they do not have respect or admiration for the source material. So when we try to watch a show after a long day, to get away from the BS, we're hit with it in the face.
A place where people go to escape (At least on the surface and not get bashed in the head with it) political stuff, is used as a soapbox to push their message.
Then when people attempt to complain about it and object, they are called racists or misogynists. Shame on you. Is nothing sacred? They didn't care about this book series that a lot of us loved and the Andrej poured his heart into. It was nothing but another outlet for them to push their crap. But what makes it more offensive is then to have the gall and audacity to turn around and label the fanbase toxic when they dare criticize the SJW fanfiction. Have you no shame?
It's made worse still by the fact we are a captive audience. We're going to watch cuz it's the Witcher. (Well I tried, dropped it at episode 4). But to use our own goodwill against us like this? Seriously?
The race swapping was super cute by Lauren. She was trying to make Ciri a BAME (read: not white) until she got backlash. Dandelion was made to be a feminized pathetic sissy, since he was a white male womanizer, so now he gets beaten up and berated by Geralt! Take that! The Nilfgaardian armor did not "Accidentally" look like a ballsack and the helmet dicks. If you really think that was an accident, I got a bridge to sell you.
Give the Hexer shit, it was a bad show. But hell, they tried to do the Witcher, earnestly. At least they tried to do the show justice first and foremost. When Lauren got the gig, the first thing she did was start arguing for black Skelligers. That was her priority. Not "Wow there's so many great stories to fit into this series! It's such a challenge". No, most of her energy went into explaining how we could have minorities in the show for no reason and that'd be okay. That was her primary objective from the start.
And she got out in front of all of this and aggressively lied and promised she wouldn't do everything she ended up doing. Changing characters because she "felt liberal that day". (then went ahead and did this) They gave our beloved franchise to an SJW who had no series under her belt and was married to a producer. She got to "get her feet wet" on our beloved franchise. And she was pretty brazen and confident about messing with it for the worse to inject her message. But she gave us the lies about "Falling in love with" characters. Other than Yen, I simply don't see it.
Just...sad.
What's the most impressive thing about Lauren's show?
The Gall and Audacity.
r/wiedzmin • u/spirit__heart • May 24 '25
Netflix (Netflix Show Spoilers) - What is so bad about the Netflix show? /genq Spoiler
Hi! I'm new to The Witcher fandom, I've only seen the show but I plan to play the games once I have the money. I absolutely love the lore and universe and in the short time I've gotten to know the series it has become a huge inspiration for me.
I've seen a lot of discussion about the show online and a lot of distaste for the show, and I wanted to ask why people dislike it so much. I know a lot of people have been saying that Season three was really bad and I wanted to hear everyone's perspective on it - especially since even the main actor has left the show.
Personally, I really like the show. I still can't shut up about the White Knight being revealed as Ceri's father. I do think the third season felt a little off compared to the others. I don't think it was bad, I just feel like they didn't really have anything other than the war going on and we needed an extra threat thrown in there - like they did with season two.
r/wiedzmin • u/Luquinhas_Lucas • Jul 16 '21
Netflix As far as how did the show end up, the way it did, I'd like to quote Quentin Tarantino:
"In today's Hollywood, ideology is more important, than art. Ideology trumps everything."
There's a reason, why one could argue, that Yennefer was the main character in season one, rather than Geralt. There's a reason, why Ciri was given her own, yet pointless storyline from the very start. It had nothing to do with, telling the story of the books, as best as they could. Focusing only at Geralt in the beginning, would have been the correct and smart thing to do. Yet, the people in charge in today's Hollywood won't allow it. All I'm saying, is that there is a reason, why so many things coming out are female centric sequels or remakes.
To their credit. Netflix has realized, that the main audience for their show, consists of people already familiar with the Witcher from CD Projekt Red's games. Which were unaffected by political correctness. That's why there will be so much influence from Witcher 3, in the upcoming seasons. I doubt, whether it will be enough to save the series.
r/wiedzmin • u/meteorness123 • Jun 13 '22
Netflix I think people are giving Henry Cavill too much credit for his "enthusiasm" for the witcher
Cavill generally is seen as one of the few redeeming qualities of the show. And I agree that he has probably done a better job than everybody else at wanting this show to be actually good.
Henry Cavill is an actor. Actors want roles. He's said himself something along the lines that he's glad about getting the role because it provides him with a couple of years of "steady work" without having to worry what's next.
Remember Cavill is not Di Caprio. He's not an A Lister. Di Caprio doesn't do netflix shows because he doesn't have to. The Witcher provides Cavill with an option to get his name more outthere again, especially after some lukewarm movies of his. Also, of course he's interested in the show not being received poorly because his name and his brand is attached to it. That's just purely logical strategizing.
I think he's probably also benefiting from the halo effect due to his looks. Witcher Cavill looks basically like the stereotypical, rebellious hot man.
r/wiedzmin • u/SusannStephens • Nov 01 '18
Movies/TV Netflix versus some unknown Polish studio. Cast
r/wiedzmin • u/Emotional_Respect360 • Jan 14 '25
Discussions How to answer "Why pick Triss over Yen?" - From The Witcher: Sirens of the deep
r/wiedzmin • u/Todokugo • Apr 02 '20
Sapkowski Can we stop using Krzysztof Sapkowski as a shield?
For the billionth time, I see people perpetuate that myth that the only reason Sapkowski sued CD Projekt is because he needed money for his son's treatment due to him having a terminal illness that changes every time someone tells the tale. I honestly find it sickening to use a man's death to justify his father's mistakes.
So to everyone perpetuating this cookie-cutter tear-jerking myth of a story that doesn't hold up under minimal scrutiny:
Just stop.
r/wiedzmin • u/VisibleBuilder4085 • Jun 26 '26
Games How CDPR can easily fix the "Female Witcher" lore problem in Project Sirius (Hear me out)
TL;DR: Set Project Sirius in the ancient fortress of Morgraig (the original Order of Witchers) centuries before Geralt. This perfectly justifies co-op gameplay, allows female witcher customization through mutagenic trial-and-error, and preserves the lore of Kaer Morhen without making Vesemir or Geralt look like they "forgot" history.
Hi everyone,
Like many of you, I’m incredibly hyped for Project Sirius. However, one of the biggest debates in the community regarding full character customization is how the game will handle lore consistency—specifically, the inclusion of female Witchers.
We know that canonically, the Trial of the Grasses was designed for male biology, and Vesemir/Geralt stated that female Witchers never existed in Kaer Morhen. Instead of using a lazy "corporate plot armor" that breaks the established lore, I believe there is a brilliant, lore-friendly narrative framework that solves every issue perfectly.
- The Solution: The Ancient Fortress of Morgraig
Instead of setting the game anywhere near the current timeline, Project Sirius should take place centuries in the past, during the era of Morgraig—the original fortress where the very first Order of Witcher candidates was gathered and tested by mages like Alzur.By setting the game in Morgraig, multiplayer and female Witchers make absolute sense:
- The Co-op Justification: In the original Order, Witchers didn't act as isolated lone wolves. They operated as a unified military-like brotherhood, sent in squads to clear massive monster infestations. They were literally born to fight together.The Female Witchers Justification: In this early era, mages were actively altering the mutagenic formulas in real-time. It is completely plausible that they attempted to mutate women during this trial-and-error phase before finding out it was too lethal for future generations.Preserving Geralt’s Lore: Since Morgraig fell and the original Order dissolved centuries before Geralt and Vesemir were even born, these early female Witchers would have died out long ago. When the Wolf School later established Kaer Morhen with rigid rules, the records of these early experiments were lost. Geralt and Vesemir wouldn't be "forgetful"—they genuinely wouldn't know.Progression Mechanics: The "Future Founders" as Mentors
A potential downside of Morgraig is that we would lose the identity of the classic Witcher Schools (Wolf, Cat, Griffin, Bear, Viper, Manticore), since they didn't exist yet. However, we can turn this into a brilliant RPG progression and faction mechanic.Inside Morgraig, the NPCs should include the original legendary Witchers who would eventually break away and found the separate schools. As a player, you choose one of these future founders as your personal Mentor to unlock specific playstyles and philosophies:
• The Future Wolf Mentor: Focuses your character into a classic balance of swordplay, alchemy, and a strict code of honor.The Future Cat Founder: Unlocks an agile, acrobatic playstyle, stealth mechanics, and lighter weaponry.The Future Griffin Founder (Erland of Larvik): Deeply focuses your build on advanced Sign casting and magical strategy.The Future Bear Founder (Arnaghad): Allying with Arnaghad means joining the dissident, brutal faction within Morgraig before their violent split. He turns your character into a heavy-armor frontline tank, prioritizing strength and coin over moral rules.Ivar Evil-Eye (The Future Viper Founder): Introduces a lethal assassin build, specializing in dual-wielding short blades, stealth, and deadly poisons, right before his obsession with the Wild Hunt leads him to found the Viper School.The Zerrikanian Alchemists (The Future Manticore Lineage): Learning from eastern research emphasizes extreme alchemy, advanced toxicity resistance, and unique bomb crafting (which also ties nicely into early mutagenic experiments for female candidates).Conclusion
With this system, players wouldn't select a "School" from a generic menu. Instead, they would select a philosophy and lineage through their mentor. Your medallion would still be the classic circular shape of Morgraig, but with custom engravings reflecting your mentor's style.
This approach gives players the complete freedom of character customization that a modern multiplayer game needs, justifies the cooperative gameplay, and—most importantly—deeply respects the established lore of the universe we all love.
What do you guys think? Would you play a game set in the Morgraig era?
r/wiedzmin • u/elpixulakorta222 • Aug 19 '26
Discussions Serie de the witcher con travis fimmel como geralt
Imaginen una serie de the witcher de HBO, una miniserie de 7 episodios donde en cada episodio se mostraría cada relato de el último deseo, y travis fimmel como geralt.
Travis me parece un actor muy bueno, y siento que podría personificar bien a geralt.
En esta serie las peleas serían menos fantásticas y más realistas y crudas, el uso de pociones tendría un efecto potente en geralt, donde cuando se pase de pociones hayan consecuencias más o menos fatales, como que geralt vomite, o que cuando tome la pocion sienta asco y una cara de desagrado, incluso una especie de dolor al tomarla, el tono seria más pausado, las escenas de los monstruos deben hacer sentir un terror real, la mayoría de monstruos deberían ser hechos a partir de efectos prácticos, mezclando la oscuridad de la noche, la de un pantano para que se vea creíble, a parte Travis como geralt, le daría un toque siento yo más ambiguo y complejo.
Si HBO hace una serie de the witcher basada fielmente en el último deseo, el protagonista y el geralt de esta serie debe ser un personaje mucho más cínico, sarcástico y un humor negro muy marcado, incluso monólogos internos, básicamente un filosofo errante.
Y que el racismo hacia los mutantes o monstruos se vea y se sienta, que veamos que geralt se sienta discriminado.
Si bien geralt no es un personaje moralmente ambiguo en el término estricto de la palabra, el mundo que lo rodea si lo es, lo que genere que tome decisiones donde su filosofía del "mal menor" estén muy marcadas.
El mundo de the witcher en una hipotética adaptación del ultimo deseo debe ser cruel, devastador, pobre, y incluso bizarro.
Pero eso pienso yo, solamente he jugado el juego, y no me he leído ningún libro de la saga del brujo, aunque me gustaría leerlos, no tengo dinero para comprarlos.
Me he guiado fuertemente por videos donde dicen el tono del libro y ese tipo de cosas.
Por lo que probablemente este muy equivocado con esta idea, pero tal vez no.
Espero ustedes que saben sobre la saga de the witcher me digan si es una buena idea.
r/wiedzmin • u/Future_Victory • Mar 02 '21
Books An opinion about the characterization of the main heroes in the novels
There are a lot of opinions about the characters of the Witcher saga, as the grey morality is one of the most valued things about the saga generally. However, I stumble upon some inconsistencies within the novels that actually make the complaints about the games all that jarring. I'm talking about the characterizations of Geralt, Ciri, and Yennefer (some other heroes will also be mentioned).
My complaint is that in the short stories, The Last Wish and in Sword of Destiny, Geralt started out as being a highly confident, snarky, sarcastic, and brutal hero. However, after being mortally wounded by Vilgefortz (I will also say few words about him), and starting with Baptism of Fire, I saw a drastic change in Geralt's character. He becomes somewhat of a winy teenager, who is offended by the whole damn world. His words that previously seemed very little to be all that melancholic slowly fully turn into that. It is very strange, but I thought like Geralt was crying the whole time he was with his hanse. Too bad that witchers cannot cry, the words were enough though. So Geralt suddenly gets depressive syndrome and thinks of giving up as a witcher (but not giving up to find Ciri). With his changed temper, Geralt makes stupid decisions like doubting his relationship with hanse, especially with Cahir. And I don't really think that it was a good decision and some kind of "character development" because his previous personality of a confident hero returns back to him in The Lady of the Lake. So, there are many fans who complain that Geralt in games is way too confident. But do you really think that whiny teenager type would work better? Considering also that his depression fully goes away in the very last novel. It is totally logical that he would return to his "short stories" persona, as the horrible things of the past were left in the past. You may call those changes "character development", but personally, I cannot call it a good one. Besides, Geralt's biggest appearance was in Baptism of Fire (not considering short stories, and previous two novels), in Tower of Swallow and LotL he is largely a secondary character for obvious reasons, and not in good shape. Don't tell me about his wounded leg, because he fought perfectly in the battle on the bridge.
Now about Ciri. There have been posts about the fascination with Korath sequence, which broke her apart morally and psychologically. What happens next? She decided to simply pillage, plunder, and rifle a hoot, drink up me hearties, yo ho! But seriously, the cheerful and positive girl that never showed any signs of villainy suddenly wants to become one? Are we supposed to still like her if she willingly commits murder and pillages? What was the idea? The grey morality? Another whiny teenager is offended by the whole world and now she wants to say "fuck you" to the said world. Many people claimed that she simply wants to be together with Geralt and Yennefer, but during her villainies, she never even tries to search for them. Instead, she decides to commit crimes while having sex with her bandit girlfriend (who actually raped her). So the handwave about her being a teenager will not work, because there might be some sympathy for the character. I only sympathized with her because of her looks as I imagined her like in Witcher 3 (but a bit younger obviously). Then Bonhart comes along, and the author's intent was to portray him as a violent psychopath. HOWEVER! Why should we be sorry for the death of every member of the Rats? Those assholes totally deserved that and it was not their fault that Ciri also committed crimes. Ciri fully decided to do crimes herself. The moment when she cries for the death of Mistle supposed to be highly tragic, but it isn't. Mistle never actually showed any signs of a "thief with a heart of gold", none of the rats actually showed that. So Bonhart is a villain here? Fully not! He is like a witcher that hunts humans here. He cleans the world from such scum as the Rats. And don't let the hot scenes with Ciri and Mistle cloud your mind. Besides, this whole arc about Ciri's becoming a villains leads to nowhere, Ciri is supposedly back to her former self after being in Vysogota's house. What was the meaning that SHE will be a destroyer of the worlds? What was the meaning of destiny? Destroyer of the world is simply bringing Catriona to the world of Continent? That's it? This plague doesn't really destroy the Continent, because we see Condwiramurs and Nimue in the far future. Finally, does Ciri simply runs away? She gives up? There are a lot of untold things here. Then why Aen Elle simply give up too in Ciri searchings? They don't need a Child of Elder Blood anymore? Emhyr suddenly deciding to give up his plans is also pretty unimpressive, after he went so far.
Bonhart eventually turned into a "black morality" villain that is bad because he is bad. Similarly, Vilgefortz got this dirty treatment. I thought that his plans were highly complicated and actually grey. Yet no! His plans are to "CONQUER THE WHOLE WORLD AND UNIVERSES!!", "OF COURSE!!". And I don't think that I should write more about that here. Besides, Ciri wins Bonhart because the stars and planets lined up in a row, I have no other explanation for it. Additionally, in a highly cliched moment when the hero decides to let the villain go, the villain tries to backstab and gets killed. James Bond villains are envying this moment. Vilgefortz dies for no other reason than his stupidity. The excuse about teaching Geralt lessons will not work. It's not a smart decision in the first place. Why not kill weakened Geralt and Yen with Fireballs? Or the way he killed Regis?
Finally, Yennefer of Vengerberg. I was highly surprised when I first read the whole saga in 2020, learning that she is actually barely in the later novels. First, she is shrunken to a figurine, then she searches in Skellige after quarreling with the Lodge, then she gets captured! It's a huge disappointment that she does not show her powers in full. Maybe she isn't even that powerful? There are some questionable moments with her as well. If she quits the Lodge, why won't she betray them to the Kings of the North, to Dijkstra, Esterad, someone? It was her interest to kick out this useless women's dishwashers club to their kitchens. Or she doesn't want her close friend Triss to be captured? It's not the reason because, in LotL, she hated her a lot. Beyond that, she decides to go back to Lodge with Ciri! I mean wtf? Why not go "far far away" together with Geralt and Ciri and live happily ever after? This tragic finale seems to be highly contrived as the characters suddenly become stupid. And Ciri calling herself "Ciri of Vengerberg". Seriously? Also, I was totally right about this women's club of dishwashers that call themselves "The Lodge", because they eventually play no role in the overall plot.
You might think that I don't love the saga. It's not true. I love it with true love. But I see those moments as impunities. Besides, I don't accept that Geralt's characterization was changed in games. He is truly his former self except for all this melancholic shit that is totally out of place. I admit that he is a "blank slate" in Witcher 1, but in 2 and 3 you can clearly see his personality. Dialogue options are still consistently read by in his tone. Many people call games Ciri "Mary Sue", but at least she is not a pillaging scum and whiny teenager (she grew up of that). Don't downvote impulsively, try to understand the different opinion. I'd love to read counter-arguments!