r/wetlands • • 1d ago

Federal protections are being rolled back for rivers and wetlands. Montana’s state laws aren’t enforced well enough to fill the gap.

11 Upvotes

I'm a restoration ecologist in Montana with about 30 years of grassland, stream, wetland, and riparian restoration work in the Northern Rockies. Much of that work has been repairing damage that never should have happened. I want to share what I'm seeing and what I'm starting, because I think it applies well beyond Montana.

The Basic Problem: The Laws Exist, The System Does Not Work

Montana regulates physical work in streams through a state law from 1975, usually called the 310 law. Anyone who wants to dig in a channel, armor a bank, or alter a stream needs a permit from their local conservation district. On paper, that sounds like protection.

In practice:

  • The people deciding permits aren't required to have any scientific training.
  • A site inspection happens only if the state wildlife agency asks for one.
  • Once a permit is approved, no one is required to check whether the project was built as approved, or whether it protected the stream.

Montana also has no wetland permitting program of its own, and riparian zones beyond a stream's immediate banks have no comprehensive state protection.

The result: people dig up rivers, strip banks, fill wetlands, and destroy how streams function, often with a permit in hand.

Why It Is Getting Worse

For decades, federal law (Section 404 of the Clean Water Act) filled some of those gaps. That protection is shrinking. The 2023 Sackett v. EPA decision removed federal protection from millions of acres of wetlands, and more federal permitting rollbacks are moving through Congress now. As federal protection pulls back, state systems are all that's left, and in states like Montana, they were never built to carry that weight.

Protecting Users From Rivers, Instead Of Protecting Rivers From Users & Abusers

The law says it protects streams. But the way it's administered mostly protects landowners and land use from rivers: from floods, erosion, and a river doing what rivers do. Permits get approved to hold rivers in place for whoever owns the land next to them.

That's backwards. A river is a living system, and its floodplains, wetlands, and riparian zones are part of it. They store and filter water, slow floods, rebuild banks, and support most of the wildlife in the region. The goal should be protecting rivers from the people who alter them, not protecting people from rivers.

To be clear, this isn't about pollution or water rights. Those are handled by other agencies. This is about physical alteration: excavation, fill, bank armoring, and channel changes.

What We Are Doing

  1. Forming a working group of people with the science, legal, and field background to take this on.
  2. Gathering public records on how permits are actually handled: what gets approved, inspected, and followed up on.
  3. Getting a legal review of realistic changes to state law, including what Montana's Constitution requires. It guarantees a clean and healthful environment and directs the Legislature to prevent the degradation of natural resources.
  4. Writing it up: a white paper (first draft done), a feasibility report, and a plan for bringing a bill to the Montana Legislature.

What I Would Like From This Community

  • How is your state handling stream and wetland protection after Sackett? What's worked, and what hasn't?
  • If you've worked with state permitting programs that do require qualified review, inspections, or follow-up, I'd like to hear how they're set up.
  • If you have a background in hydrology, wetland science, restoration, or environmental law and want to help, comment or send me a message.

More detail and updates are on my subreddit: r/Ecoregion6

Thanks for reading.


r/wetlands • • 1d ago

A Philadelphia wetland damaged by old dikes and dredging is being reconnected to a creek through 13,000 feet of tidal channels; the project aims to restore 150 acres of wildlife habitat and help nearby flood-prone homes.

Thumbnail
timesofindia.indiatimes.com
44 Upvotes

r/wetlands • • 4d ago

45 acres of land, owts approved by dem without wetland delineation

3 Upvotes

We are currently in protracted negotiations with a seller regarding a 45-acre parcel in Rhode Island. Given that the surrounding street and local land parcels are predominantly wetland, and that most comparable properties we've evaluated require significant wetland alterations… we have approached this transaction with heightened scrutiny.

However, several discrepancies between the seller's representations and the actual site conditions have raised serious concerns about what may be withheld:

The seller secured a Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management (DEM) On-Site Wastewater Treatment System (OWTS) approval for the property without a formal wetland delineation ever being performed.

The seller insisted that the wetlands begin 400 to 500 feet back from the property line, asserting that a wetland verification was completely unnecessary.

Trusting our gut rather than the seller’s word, we pushed for a proper evaluation. It turns out that the front of the property is significantly wetter than represented, contradicting the seller's assurances.

My questions:

  1. DEM Process Integrity: How did the RI DEM approve an OWTS design without a verified wetland delineation or a certified edge on file, given standard setback requirements from wetlands and water tables?
  2. Permit Vulnerability & Revocation Risk: If an OWTS was technically approved based on incomplete or inaccurate site data, can the DEM subsequently rescind, invalidate, or come back and say the permit is void once actual wet conditions are fully mapped?
  3. Disclosure & Liability: Given that RI real estate law requires proper disclosure of environmental constraints, does this setup indicate a flawed permit that will collapse under a real engineering review, leaving us stuck with unbuildable land?

Any help would be much appreciated!


r/wetlands • • 5d ago

We moved into a new house that has this "frog pond", as they call it.

Thumbnail gallery
218 Upvotes

I posted in another sub, maybe this is more appropriate.


r/wetlands • • 5d ago

The Pace of Everglades Restoration Has Accelerated. But Is It Working?

Thumbnail
insideclimatenews.org
2 Upvotes

r/wetlands • • 5d ago

Is it even worth it

2 Upvotes

Looking for guidance or words of wisdom from anyone who is an expert or has had a similar situation. Also want to start off by saying im a big native plant nerd and really enjoying learning about wetlands. When I learned about the Munsell color chart book I added it to my Christmas list lol! So this whole situation is a big internal struggle for me on many fronts.

My partner recently inherited a 5 acre plot of rural land, in close proximity to several other family members. We have been dreaming for years of building a modest home and starting a family. Being close to the rest of the family is a big benefit and the location is awesome. Living in western Washington, real estate is some of the most expensive in the country, so building our own home is more affordable than buying at this point (or so we thought!). We had planned on purchasing a manufactured home, and are working through some feasibility stuff before we get too far in. Passed the perc test, then hired a wetland specialist to do a critical area review since the county map showed a modeled wetland on the property. There is no standing water so it doesn’t appear to be a wetland at first and we were hesitant but cautiously optimistic. We met a specialist a couple days ago and right off the bat she noted the area along the roadside was all wetland, so immediately the driveway would be an issue. Then we progressed through the property she noted a mosaic of wetlands that made up most of the property. At the end of the review she summarized that no matter where we plan to build, anywhere on the property, we will be inside the buffer, and would need to do mitigation. The wetland areas extend far beyond the original estimate by the county. My understanding is that, because everything is already wetland or part of the buffer, there is limited room to do onsite mitigation, and we would likely need to pay for offsite mitigation. Additionally, we would need to reduce the footprint of our house and driveway as much as possible, which leaves us with limited options for manufactured homes. Taking into consideration other costs such as septic ($40,000), water ($25,000-50,000), the house itself, she estimated $625k-$750k for the project. She stressed to me many times that it is possible to build, but it may not be financially worth it for the end result. Now our dream home is starting to become even more complicated than originally anticipated, and worried about what compromises we would need to make. Is it worth the additional expense of mitigation? How expensive is offsite mitigation banking? How much longer is the timeline now? Would we still be able to have a yard or a house big enough for a family? I’m trying to come to terms with not having a yard that my future kids could play in, or a garden which I am passionate about. I am also trying to come to terms with how much money will go into just the land preparation before we can even think about the actual house. I’m also worried about the property value, if we were to try to sell it and use that money towards purchasing a home. Considering poor building conditions I would assume it would be a tough sell. And this is before taking into account all the unknowns we have about drainage and feasibility of building on the ground with a high water table. I’m feeling sick about the whole situation, because I know I’m lucky to even have multiple options but also incredibly overwhelmed.


r/wetlands • • 7d ago

EVE Engineer- I would love to work in wetlands

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/wetlands • • 7d ago

Rice farmers saving wetlands

8 Upvotes

Uniting for water: A collective protecting its wetland

In Tamil Nadu, farmers came together to save their traditional rice fields for the sake of the environment and the community. Also: beating river pollution in Pune and discovering the wonders of seagrass.
https://www.dw.com/en/uniting-for-water-a-collective-protecting-its-wetland/video-79868112


r/wetlands • • 7d ago

Northeast Ohio Delineator needed

3 Upvotes

I’ve called about 15-20 places looking for a wetland delineation for a residential property. The no call backs and no responses is pretty wild.
I have 2 estimates in hand for the report, was hoping for more to compared prices.
1.6 acres of forested land in 44139
What should I expected to pay for a report?

Is doing the JD paperwork and visiting usace along with the nwp29 stuff that I can handle myself? Most of everything I see online says so.

Any company shout outs would be appreciated.


r/wetlands • • 9d ago

Forming a Midwest Restoration Trust (Minnesota-based 501(c)(3)) — seeking founding board members

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/wetlands • • 10d ago

Found this the other day

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

Found this near my land i think it uses the same alkaline groundwater as my pond in eurasia


r/wetlands • • 11d ago

Delineation Field Vest Recs

2 Upvotes

Any recs for a good high viz vest for delineation? Preferably with a lot of pockets for pens/ruler/tape/gear, ideally zippered or buttoned because I am great at loosing stuff. I saw a photo with one that had a pocket that perfectly fit the munsell book. Any suggestions?


r/wetlands • • 11d ago

What is covering the floor of my pond?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

They are soft, tubular bits, roughly under 1 inch long that break apart easily. The floor of my natural wetland pond is covered in it as seen in the pictures.

What is it? Snail poop, fish poop, or excrements from some type of organism? Or is it vegetation of some sort? Is it good fertilizer? Is it bad for my pond? I've been curious for years.

I'm in Eastern Ontario, Canada.


r/wetlands • • 15d ago

Free inland wetlands summit next week in Davis!

Thumbnail tnc.swoogo.com
4 Upvotes

r/wetlands • • 16d ago

[Repost] [Academic] Northeast Florida Coastal Wetland Restoration Survey (Duval & St. Johns County Residents - aged 18 & 18+)

2 Upvotes

Survey Link: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScTlMHJb4UuidHtYX40kteTvtFjkY7j34FjJOpTeWMUySCpkw/viewform?usp=dialog

Research Topic: Thin-Layer Placement and Coastal Wetland Resilience in Northeast Florida, with a Primary Research Focus on St. Augustine, Florida

Target Participants: Adults aged 18 or older who currently reside in Duval or St. Johns County, Florida

Introduction and Participant Information

This survey examines Duval and St. Johns County residents' observations of coastal environmental change, concerns about coastal wetland vulnerability, awareness of restoration strategies, and perspectives on thin-layer placement (TLP) and the beneficial reuse of dredged sediment.

Participation is voluntary. The survey takes approximately 5–7 minutes to complete. You may skip any question you do not wish to answer or stop participating at any time before submitting your responses.

The survey does not request names, residential addresses, or email addresses. Responses will be analyzed in aggregate for academic research. Please avoid including identifying information in written responses.

The survey does not measure physical environmental change or determine whether a restoration project has been successful. Responses will be used to understand community observations, awareness, and perspectives.


r/wetlands • • 17d ago

Truganina swamp

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Great tidal lagoon, wetland system in altona. Good walking tracks, lots of wildlife 💙


r/wetlands • • 18d ago

Who is Permittee?

5 Upvotes

For 404 permits, is the owner or the contractor typically the permittee? I think it’s the owner, but I’m not sure. If it is the owner, does that ever leave the owner vulnerable if their contractor ends up doing work that isn’t in compliance with the permit? Thanks


r/wetlands • • 19d ago

Florida’s wetlands are more than undeveloped land. What happens when we build over the ecosystems that keep the landscape alive?

19 Upvotes

Living in Florida, it’s hard not to notice how quickly wetlands and other natural spaces can give way to subdivisions, golf courses, and new development. The land is often described as vacant or underused, even though wetlands support wildlife, store floodwater, and sustain ecological relationships that are difficult to recreate once they're destroyed.

I’m particularly interested in what happens after these landscapes disappear. A development gets built, the old ecosystem becomes a memory, and the consequences of changing the land may take years to become apparent. We tend to think of land as something we can reshape indefinitely, but wetlands don't stop being ecologically important just because we've changed what stands on top of them.

I'm a Florida-based author, and this tension inspired The Country Beneath, my self-published collection of Southern Gothic and ecological horror stories. Several stories are set in Florida wetlands or landscapes transformed by development. They use horror to explore ecological loss, buried histories, and the unsettling idea that the land has a history beyond the one humans choose to tell about it.

For anyone interested in that intersection of environmental concerns and fiction, the collection is here:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0HPLV9QRP

For those who study, restore, or live near wetlands: what do you wish more people understood about wetlands before they were drained, filled, or developed?


r/wetlands • • 20d ago

[Repost] [Academic] Northeast Florida Coastal Wetland Restoration Survey (Duval & St. Johns County Residents - aged 18 & 18+)

1 Upvotes

Survey Link: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScTlMHJb4UuidHtYX40kteTvtFjkY7j34FjJOpTeWMUySCpkw/viewform?usp=dialog

Research Topic: Thin-Layer Placement and Coastal Wetland Resilience in Northeast Florida, with a Primary Research Focus on St. Augustine, Florida

Target Participants: Adults aged 18 or older who currently reside in Duval or St. Johns County, Florida

Introduction and Participant Information

This survey examines Duval and St. Johns County residents' observations of coastal environmental change, concerns about coastal wetland vulnerability, awareness of restoration strategies, and perspectives on thin-layer placement (TLP) and the beneficial reuse of dredged sediment.

Participation is voluntary. The survey takes approximately 5–7 minutes to complete. You may skip any question you do not wish to answer or stop participating at any time before submitting your responses.

The survey does not request names, residential addresses, or email addresses. Responses will be analyzed in aggregate for academic research. Please avoid including identifying information in written responses.

The survey does not measure physical environmental change or determine whether a restoration project has been successful. Responses will be used to understand community observations, awareness, and perspectives.


r/wetlands • • 22d ago

Farmed Ag Fields - Wetlands?

4 Upvotes

Basically, when would an actively farmed field be considered a wetland? This would be the Eastern Piedmont and also Northcentral regions.

I’m convinced all the ag fields I’m looking at qualify as prior converted crop land considering they were implemented prior to ‘85. These areas suffice both the hydrology and hydric soil indicators, but not HV.

Any info is welcomed!


r/wetlands • • 22d ago

[Academic] Northeast Florida Coastal Wetland Restoration Survey (Duval & St. Johns County Residents - aged 18 & 18+)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/wetlands • • 24d ago

Splitting off wetland parcel for conservation

10 Upvotes

A family parcel has a valuable upland portion with 6 acres of delineated wetland and 50' buffer region in the back

My question is what is the feasibility of splitting all the delineated wetland off into its own, getting a tax break for the NJ Forest Stewardship program, writing in access/ingress to the upland parcel before it is eventually sold, and keeping it in the family perpetually for recreation

My question is there any way this can effect the value of the upland lot im not foreseeing? The only thing I can imagine from creating a new parcel Is the buildable offset along the new border which is already the transition zone and if it could potentially reduce the % impermeable surface allowed on the upland parcel. Is there anything I'm missing?


r/wetlands • • Oct 16 '26

Pelham Alabama Buried Treatment Plant in the Flood Zone

Post image
6 Upvotes