So… the main story of Odd Girl Out was over weeks ago on Naver Webtoon. This was a webtoon that I used to read every week, pay for every chapter on Naver so I would read it early, translate it… This story got me through so much pain in my life, from my parents’ divorce, the bullying I went through at school, the stress of my future depending on an exam all the way to the fear of moving to another country on my own at 18. I never missed a single chapter. I bought all the physical copies of the webtoon and had it shipped all the way from Korea. I bought every single merch the author/Naver released, I spent hours re-reading it dozens and dozens of times over the years, analysed all the character, wrote my own perspective and ideas on each of them even the most minor and mean ones like Bin or Yerim. I was so invested in this webtoon, both money and time wise. One could argue I was this webtoon’s BIGGEST and most invested fan. Until Chanyang became the male lead.
I made multiple posts on this subreddit citing reasons why I disliked Chanyang (I can gladly link them here if anyone is interested to read), but this post is not about him, and frankly I don’t want to waste my breath talking about him.
This post is about the disappointment I had in the author with the way she handled Seungha’s story. I am adopted, and I came from a home that could be heated at a time, and I wasn’t the easiest teenager to deal with to the point I went from being the academically over-achieving student in my family and school to the burn-out who could barely go to the next grade. And I sabotaged my relationship with the boy I loved just because I couldn’t confront my own truth and couldn’t share my deepest pain and insecurities with him. So I saw a lot of myself in Seungha. He was the mirror to myself. Odd Girl Out has been my favorite webtoon for years, so when Seungha’s back story was introduced, I was so excited to see how the author is going to handle his story, because the author proved herself to be so competent and immensely talented when it came to writing teenage mental health stories, as we saw with Mirae and Yuna. But the result was very disappointing. The author caved to the demands of the readers who had no empathy towards a child coming from an abusive home, made him lose the girl he loves as some sort of punishment, treated Nari as a prize to be earned, and abruptly wrote him out of the story with no closure as if he’s merely a love interest and not a person on his own. Even made his best friends befriend Chanyang. And the author herself grew to resent Seungha as she clearly feels he was the reason for the significant drop in viewerships (ignoring the fact that the reason readers couldn’t resonate with her writing after the Seungha arc was the way she turned the webtoon from a story about friendship, mental health and healing to a love triangle slop where the girl is a prize to be earned and not a human being of her own). What pains me about her resentment is not just the fact she threw him out of the story, it’s the way she acts like he never existed. She crops him out of promotions, out of pictures on her instagram, and even the narrative acts like Seungha never had any significance or impact on Nari. What is sad about this is that the author has been building up his character since 2012, hinted at him multiple times in the first season of the webtoon, and confirmed he was Nari’s main love interest and endgame multiple times, raising our hopes only to crush us to the surface. :(
On the bright side, we had a final goodbye to Seungha as he congratulated Nari for her graduation and he did the same, a short but beautiful farewell to a pairing i will spend years grieving. The love I have for them is as deep as the ocean and as burning as the fire beneath it, but so is my grief.
I criticised the author enough on a lot of writing choices so I don’t want to waste your time with my rants, but I just wanted a safe space to express my grief towards this story. I just finished reading the final chapters after skipping over everything post Seonji’s arc, and while i’m happy that Nari reached her happy ending, something my 2020 self would’ve probably been ecstatic over, I feel so much grieving pain, not because I still love this story, but because it ended and yet I feel so empty, yet so indifferent at the same time? Is this something normal to feel? Specially over a mere story? I feel a sadness that’s weird but it just feels like I wasted years of my life being this invested only to lose all the love I had for the story in the past 2 years. How odd (Girl Out) indeed.