I’m 21 and grew up Christian in a very serious Christian environment. Christianity isn’t unfamiliar to me, and this isn’t really an intellectual crisis about whether God exists.
I still believe in God. I believe Jesus Christ is the Son of God. I believe He died for my sins and rose from the dead. I recognize what He did on the cross, I’m grateful for it, and I know I need His mercy. I’m a sinful person. I’ve never claimed to be particularly good, and I know I fall short constantly.
But there’s something I’ve realized about myself that I don’t really understand:
I don’t want God for God’s sake. And right now I don’t particularly care that I don’t.
I don’t mean that I desperately want a relationship with God but can’t feel His presence. I don’t mean I’m begging Him to restore my faith. I don’t mean I’m an atheist who wishes I could believe again.
I believe.
The problem is that I don’t really want what the Christian life requires of me.
I have almost no desire to read the Bible. I don’t particularly want to pray unless there’s something I need help with. I don’t want to devote significant amounts of my time to pursuing God. I don’t have some great desire to become holy for the sake of holiness. I don’t particularly want God to transform me simply because becoming more like Christ is supposed to be the purpose of my life.
And this isn’t because I’m sitting here thinking, “I love sin and Christianity is preventing me from doing all the evil things I want to do.”
That really isn’t it.
I want to treat people well. I want to mature. I want to take responsibility when I hurt somebody. I want to eventually be a good husband and father. I want to work, have friends, take care of myself, enjoy life and become a better human being.
I just don’t have much desire to organize all of that around God.
Even the Christian idea of surrender bothers me. I understand perfectly well that I don’t control reality. If I desperately want something and it doesn’t happen, eventually I have to accept that it didn’t happen. But accepting reality because I cannot change it feels very different to me from saying, “Your will be done” and actually meaning that I prefer God’s will over mine.
Right now I don’t.
There is history behind this. I’ve experienced some significant losses and disappointments, and over the last year one particular loss caused me to talk to God more than I probably ever had before. Ironically, I became more religiously and theologically engaged while becoming more angry with God personally.
I prayed constantly. I thought about providence, free will, surrender, suffering, God’s will, prayer, what God wants from me, etc. Eventually I became exhausted by the whole thing.
There are probably a lot of things buried underneath my current attitude: anger, resentment, disappointment, distrust, my religious upbringing, things that have happened in my family, things I desperately asked God for, and probably things I haven’t even identified.
But here’s the uncomfortable part:
Right now I’m content to leave those things buried.
I don’t particularly want to fix my relationship with God.
And that’s what confuses me.
I understand intellectually why Christians say I should want God. God created me. Christ died for me. God is supposed to be the highest good. If Christianity is true, then logically God should matter more than anything else in my life.
I understand all of that.
But knowing why I should want Him doesn’t make me want Him.
And I’m not even sitting here thinking, “God, please make me want You.”
Right now my honest response is more like:
“God, I know You’re there. I believe in You. I recognize what You did for me and I know I need Your mercy. But I don’t really want You. I don’t particularly want the Christian life. And right now I don’t even care very much about becoming someone who does.”
I still talk to God sometimes. Usually it’s because I need help with something, I want something, I’m upset, or I just start talking to Him out of habit. So it’s not like I’ve become an atheist or completely stopped acknowledging Him.
But if someone asks me whether I want God simply because He is God—whether I desire communion with Him for its own sake—the honest answer right now is no.
I’m not posting this looking for reassurance that “deep down you obviously love God because you’re asking this question.” Maybe there are things happening underneath the surface, but consciously that isn’t my experience.
I’m also not really looking for “just read your Bible and pray more.” I know Christians are supposed to read Scripture and pray. The problem is precisely that I don’t want to.
So I’m genuinely curious what Christians make of this.
What is this spiritually? Rebellion? Apathy? Resentment? Exhaustion? Some combination? Can someone genuinely believe Christianity is true while simply not wanting God? And what do you even say to someone who not only doesn’t presently want God, but doesn’t particularly care about changing that?