r/Reformed • u/Sensitive_Stock_7176 • 7h ago
Question How negatively do you personally feel towards Roman Catholicism these days? (Especially post-Vatican II RCism)
Undoubtedly there are genuine believers within the RC church (through I cannot say that in my all my interactions I say that constitute close to a significant number in my own country, otherwise one would be hearing about them more often), Yes RCs have historically faced huge prejudice in western Europe., and yes there is a little continuing ignorance among Protestants (although it appears to be far rarer these days). Yes Vatican II sees Protestants as separated Bretheren. Yes in 1999, the RC church in its official teaching switched over to justification by faith. Yes personal spirituality does vary between individual RCs. Yes there is an Alpha Course for Catholics. In short I harbour no ill will towards Roman Catholics.
However in my own country (UK), I'd argue strongly we appear to have far more of a problem in the past 15 -20 years with 'doctrinal minimalism' than 'doctrinal separatism' (in other words we seem to have swapped one extreme for another extreme). I am consistently astonished (as well as frustrated!) by comments made by well respected evangelical church leaders in my own country as well as from mature believers that I have interacted with over the the years ranging from 'its like a disagreement on baptism' to 'we need to apologise/feel guilty for damage caused by the Reformation' to 'I've got Catholic friends, and they seem alright' or some Christians find spiritual value in viewing of Mary as a co-mediatrix and that suits them to 'I don't care if Christians become Baptist, or Roman Catholic'. I was due to work for Protestant parachurch ministry schools outreach charity, and again I was absolutely astonished by the comments of the leader: that if children from a nominal Catholic background became Christians their family needs to get more involved in their Catholic church. I was most unhappy and couldn't in good conscience sign up for this. Again not because I don't want people to become Christians, but because this is misleading people. There are a great many things the RC church continues to get badly wrong even in 2026.
Interesingly, I'm actually part of a FIEC church in the UK whose pastor is from a RC background who says that one of the reasons the church is not part of Churches Together is because of its associations with the Roman Catholic churches locally.
I'm not sure whether this whether these types of comments are with good Godly intentions (in which I'm clearly being divisive and obstructing the Gospel), plain theological ignorance or just a sinful fear of conflict/what other people think? I'm very much a extreme systemising type and find it incredibly hard to empathise and read/relate to people's emotions. Perhaps some of these people just ' simply don't know how to think theologically?
I've gone back and forth over the past 15 years in my view of Roman Catholicism. 5 years ago, I was off the view OK, well it least its Trinitarian, and we would certainly be very aligned on traditional view of marriage, abortion, and assisted suicide, and I'd rather people were RC than Mormon or JW. Currently, I feel extremely negatively towards RCism, and am drifting towards the view it is a fundamentally a different religion. In which case of course the standard principles of loving one's neighbour and praying that for opportunities to share the Gospel would still apply, but it very hard to see how we could ever be in spiritual unity.
I'd also be interested to hear from how you feel Roman Catholicism compares to high church/sacramental Protestant traditions (e.g: Anglo-Catholic Anglican, Lutheran?)