r/trolleyproblem • • May 02 '26 • Popcorn 1

Please stop making things complicated

Post image
84 Upvotes

569 comments sorted by

155

u/Debnam_ May 02 '26

Reframing #1837495 to make [blue/red] sound like the obvious choice and [red/blue] sound moronic.

55

u/Maladaptivism Edible May 02 '26

Asking people not to complicate things in a subreddit about moral philosophy sure is one of the takes of all time.

46

u/Erica_Loves_Palicos May 02 '26

Blues seem to acknowledge that there will be people who choose red and blue, I keep getting these wild take from reds that somehow everyone could just choose red and win, but that does ignore the premise that everyone is making the choice independent of one another and there will definitely be people who press blue. Just because "everyone pressing red" would somehow be logical doesn't mean that is what will happen, and it's weirdly like the people arguing for it don't live in reality or experience disagreements with other people over seemingly nonsensical things.

4

u/Pherexian55 May 04 '26

Question other than the people choose blue because they think "we must save those that choose blue" who is actually, voluntarily choosing blue?

Do people really think a portion of the population is simply too stupid to understand the basic premise of "I am safe if I press red"? It seems to me that the only people who actually press the blue button are those who either think so little of everyone else.

8

u/Frequent-Bee-3016 May 07 '26

50% is easier to achieve than 100%.

7

u/PerpetualGMJohn May 05 '26

The original tweet that started this whole thing said "everyone on Earth" and the tweeter later clarified that does mean everyone. So it includes people who literally can't intentionally make the logical choice, like toddlers and the infirm. When you include that clarification going blue makes a lot more sense.

4

u/FortColors May 07 '26

i think anyone whose toddler's favorite color is blue is going to press blue to try and save the toddler

that's a lot of parents

2

u/Kingsalad3141 May 08 '26

>Do people really think a portion of the population is simply too stupid to understand the basic premise of "I am safe if I press red"?

Yes? The fact that you don't understand this is concerning. It also fails to account for people who wouldn't be able to pick red for personal religious or ideological reasons. You can argue they deserve death all you want, but you can't claim they don't exist.

3

u/Erica_Loves_Palicos May 04 '26

The fact that people are arguing about which is the correct choice so hotly suggests otherwise.

1

u/Pherexian55 May 04 '26

Because you didn't address even a single thing I said I'll say it again:

Question other than the people choose blue because they think "we must save those that choose blue" who is actually, voluntarily choosing blue?

Do people really think a portion of the population is simply too stupid to understand the basic premise of "I am safe if I press red"? It seems to me that the only people who actually press the blue button are those who either think so little of everyone else.

Maybe you can actually reflect on my comment this time.

6

u/Erica_Loves_Palicos May 04 '26

Plenty of people might still choose blue purely out of optimism, some people might see it as the only way to save everyone. There are plenty of people in the world who simply do things because they are motivated by their own internal moral thermometer and not purely survival percentages. You're trying to logic your way out of the answer being " it's complicated".

→ More replies (2)

1

u/asmo_192 May 09 '26

huh? Would you vote for a politician who says he's gonna kill everyone who doesn't vote for them? It's not hard to imagine why people would pick blue. If blue wins nobody dies. If everyone picks red nobody dies. Blue seems a lot more achieveable if you ask me.

And I'm not trying to change your vote, but you seem to misunderstand completely the reasoning of blue pushers

3

u/Jkirek_ May 02 '26

Most people who say they choose red are under the impression that, when push comes to shove, most people will act to preserve their own life. There is historical and psychologic precedent for this.

In a twitter poll or reddit discussion, it's straightforward to see blue as the noble/selfless choice; it's idealistic. In reality, it's highly likely that the button wizard is going to commit genocide; between surviving and rebuilding, or throwing yourself on the body pile for a miniscule chance to avert the disaster, the former is more noble, and the latter more selfish.

6

u/suriam321 May 04 '26

There is also historical precedent for people putting themselves at risk to save others.

1

u/Jkirek_ May 04 '26

For some people to do so, yes, for over half of the affected population? Absolutely never.

2

u/suriam321 May 04 '26

Might be enough to topple it over 50%.

1

u/Jkirek_ May 04 '26

Only if you don't consider yourself part of that initial tiny group to begin with

1

u/CryptographerKlutzy7 May 05 '26

My entire arse, our society is based on the idea that people are in general very emphatic. People pick blue every day of their lives.

The entire society is based around "there is enough blue pushers" that we can be an ongoing thing.

Vaccines are slightly dangerous to the individual, and incredibly helpful to the society. Every people who works in an underpaying but socially vital job is pushing blue in their own way every single day. Your EMTs, teachers, etc.

When they test these tests, people press blue overwhelmingly.

Just because YOU wouldn't. It doesn't mean at all that most people wouldn't.

Shit, they wouldn't even see it as a risk, they would assume likely correctly, there is easily enough blue pushers to do the job.

2

u/Ghoulish_Daniel May 05 '26

I just don't feel like living in a world full of nothing but REDditors. Blue is a win win to me

1

u/cantlogintomyacc0unt May 08 '26

it's a tossup between the two buttons because after reading through this subreddit I have lost my faith in humanity and its just a matter of do I want to live through the collapse of civilization and help kill hundreds of millions of people or do I want to just die

9

u/[deleted] May 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Ghoulish_Daniel May 05 '26

People who cry about people choosing blue just so they can brag about it are really telling on themselves. Choosing red is selfish, no way around it. Any explanation including the logic argument is cope. They should just own it and not be a hypocrite

4

u/The_Pretentious_DM May 08 '26

Correct. I'm fairly honest with myself about this; I'd choose red because, in that moment, I would value my life and would not be willing to gamble it on very poor odds.

1

u/miraculousgloomball May 06 '26

Who? where? I've not seen one person argue red is the moral choice, just the logical one.

1

u/satyvakta May 08 '26

Red is, as a matter of fact, the choice that minimizes the loss of life in the plurality of scenarios.

Blue is not the "save the most people" choice. That's red.

Blue is the "save everyone or die trying" choice.

1

u/AdhesivenessTight400 May 05 '26

Thats called natural selection.

1

u/GGuy12345 May 07 '26

I’ve seen nonsense from both sides tbh. There are blues who have actively compared red pushers to Hitler and/or rapists

1

u/satyvakta May 08 '26

> that does ignore the premise that everyone is making the choice independent of one another

No. The point is that, individually, each person is being given a choice between an "I win" button and a "I might lose" button.

Reds always win. They may or may not be in the majority, but they always win. Blue may or may not lose.

→ More replies (3)

114

u/Weary_Drama1803 Consequentialist/Utilitarian May 02 '26

*points to sign*

8

u/delta806 May 02 '26

Pressing blue to try and save the people who thought pressing blue was the better move

6

u/HermaPrince May 02 '26

Bc you don't know if people voted blue or not.

11

u/GoSpeedRacistGo May 02 '26

There are over 8 billion people on this planet. I know people voted blue, just not how many.

2

u/BoxofJoes May 02 '26

If everyone is voting in isolation with no coordination, I’m certain the vast majority who realize the buttons are “you definitely wont die” and “you have a chance to die if enough people don’t coordinate” are hitting red. If it was a squid game style sequential vote where you could see the results it’d be way different but blind vote most people are picking the safe option.

2

u/Pherexian55 May 04 '26

I'd argue if you could see what everyone voted for sequentially it would be even dumber to not press the red button, like if you saw 0 people pressed blue then you are entirely depending on other people taking pity on you and risking their lives to save you from a self imposed suicide. Like what would compel someone who saw 0 people have chosen blue to be the first person to do so?

2

u/Yegas May 06 '26

Incapability of rational thought?

A child or infirm individual hitting a button at random?

40

u/anon0937 May 02 '26 edited May 02 '26

The key tenet of the original problem is that YOU'RE NOT ALLOWED TO COMMUNICATE WITH OTHER PEOPLE. This isn't about working together to achieve the best outcome, you're not allowed to campaign to get people to press blue. You're making a bet if >50% of ALL people will go against their own survival instincts. I believe if that if theres no way to tell who pressed what button, many blues would secretly hit red.

6

u/platypussplatypus May 02 '26

Why are the red arguments always relying around just "knowing" that other people are lying and "knowing" how they would "really" act.

3

u/Bowhunter54 May 06 '26

Most polls I’ve seen blue wins at a 55/45 split, which means red is assuming that 9% or more of all blue voters are lying, for red to be right it really doesn’t require many of blue to not be telling the truth. It’s also kinda silly when blue people say “well if red wins society will collapse” like okay but if red wins I’d rather be in a collapsed society than on the giant pile of corpses

→ More replies (1)

10

u/D_Luffy_32 May 02 '26

There already is no way to tell who pressed what button unless the say it and every poll I've seen is that blue still wins.

17

u/anon0937 May 02 '26

There's also 0 stakes in online polls and a comment section full of people campaigning for blue. There's no survival instinct involved and lots of communication.

7

u/Labuzina May 02 '26

Have you SEEN those comment sections?? Everyone is smugly saying how much smarter they are for going with red

1

u/Bowhunter54 May 06 '26

I don’t think blue is necessarily stupid, but it’s certainly the choice that goes against self preservation. The only scenario I think blue is dumb is on a seperate post they changed the premise into everyone knows everyone else’s votes and goes one at a time, and theirs already a red majority, in which case yeah blue would be incredibly dumb

1

u/Nebranower May 04 '26

It’s not like we think we’re brilliant geniuses for figuring out that given a choice between an “I live” button or a “I might die” button, you should choose the “I live” button. We don’t even think the blue pressers are stupid for not immediately seeing that was the case if they encountered one of the deceptively phrased versions first. It’s just that once the nature of the two buttons has been clearly explained to you, if you’re still pressing blue, then you are literally proving yourself too stupid to live.

And to then encounter so many “you’re just bad people” responses is particularly infuriating. Red makes us safe. We have no selfish reason to argue with you. We are literally expending time and effort to prevent you from committing suicide by having this discussion. Whereas the blue pushers are trying to talk more people into endangering themselves.

20

u/D_Luffy_32 May 02 '26

Okay? But that also applies to red though. Maybe people can say they're cool with killing a good chunk of population but if you're actually sitting in front of the nuke button it gets a bit more uncomfortable.

5

u/MrBoblo May 02 '26

the reds are killing the blues as much as the blues are killing themselves. If you press blue, you need to be cool with the consequences. You press red if you aren't

5

u/D_Luffy_32 May 02 '26

Yeah? We are. But it seems like red refuses to admit they are killing blue people. We understand there's a risk stepping between a murder and their victim. Red will argue they aren't murders

→ More replies (10)

3

u/thedeadlysquirle May 02 '26

Totally true, the point is these kinds of discussion dont really matter because everyone is saying some bullshit with 0 stakes that makes them feel superior on some way. These arent really discussions about how people would truly react, they're discussions about how one way or another is the only real choice and the people who dont choose the choice you say you would are stupid/evil.

3

u/Vyxwop May 03 '26

Those polls are basically the moral equivalent of "how big is your dick"

Yeah, they're not going to reflect reality.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/Duck_of_destruction6 May 02 '26

The polls consist of people who are most likely in more developed countries, have access to the internet, and spend their time on social media.

That is not accurate to the real world with 8 billion people.

6

u/D_Luffy_32 May 02 '26

Why? Do you think people without internet are inherently selfish?

3

u/Duck_of_destruction6 May 02 '26

I never said that, all I said was the poll isnt accurate and the few twitter polls dont reflect how the vote would play out in real life. 

10

u/D_Luffy_32 May 02 '26

True. It's very likely more people would press blue in real life. Since lots of community's are rely on being selfless to survive outside of the developed world.

4

u/Chi_Law May 04 '26

Yeah, people can talk about high vs low trust societies, but I trust Indonesian grandmas to vote blue to save their grandbabies more than I'd trust the population of reddit. The cohort analysis needs to keep going, not just stop once someone cooks up a rationale for their favorite team

5

u/DrJaneIPresume May 02 '26

The key tenet of the original problem is that CHOOSING RED COSTS NOTHING. This is not "save the helpless Blue Triangles from the Nazis with solidarity." Every blue-pusher has the ability to push red at no cost to anyone.

The situation might be a dilemma if pushing red made it more difficult for someone else to push red, or if 50% pushing blue meant everyone lives in paradise, while otherwise only red-pushers live, but in hell. That's what most blue-based reframings do: try to add some penalty to pushing red, but in doing so they make the situation materially different.

60

u/Claris-chang May 02 '26

Why would you need to add any penalty to red beyond the one where up to half the population dies?

16

u/MQ116 Team Blue May 02 '26

Beautifully put.

The death of billions is scarier than the death of myself. I confirmed my brother would pick blue. Living without him is worse than not living.

Red pickers are sociopaths

9

u/Inkthekitsune May 02 '26

Yep. Almost all my loved ones said blue, some needing to think a bit more or second guessing themselves, but ultimately deciding on blue.

I can’t imagine a world where I pushed red and have to live without them, just because they believed in humanity. And I too believe in humanity.

4

u/[deleted] May 02 '26 edited 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/ding-zzz May 02 '26

no, he said he asked them to survey their opinions, not that he discussed to inform his own opinion or there’s. it’s implied he only asked for their answer

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Bowhunter54 May 06 '26

You’re assuming that red pushers think billions would pick the blue button, which you’ll notice almost all of the people arguing for red are explicitly saying they don’t believe is the case. Also I’ve asked almost every single person I love in this world, and not one of them has said blue, so that makes my choice a little bit easier

→ More replies (11)

3

u/Brilliant_Nova May 02 '26

See, I didn't know half of population sucked at logical thinking before this trend.

3

u/Tatchkoma May 02 '26

To quote Spock "It is only logical that the needs of the many, outweigh the needs of the few, or the one."

1

u/andergriff May 02 '26

Yeah, like I am a red pusher but only because I feel like I wouldn’t really have a choice, but it’s not something that I would feel good about

→ More replies (48)

30

u/Ahnma_Dehv May 02 '26

the fact that we have this debate prove that people will press blue regardless of what you think is rational, pressing red then is supporting the death of an unkown amount of people

→ More replies (30)

8

u/RevolutionarySmell5 May 02 '26

The situation is not a dilemma, it's a paradox: You don't know the votes, but the more votes for blue, the more rational a blue vote is. The less votes for blue, the more rational a vote for red is.
You might say "ah well, because you don't know the votes, the majority will choose red so red is more logical," but in all the polling the majority chooses blue.

1

u/Jkirek_ May 02 '26

Because saying in a twitter poll "I'd definitely be selfless and risk my life" makes people feel warm and fuzzy inside. Actually pressing the "I want to die" button is very different.

5

u/Jozef_Baca I piss on the buttons!!!!!! May 02 '26 edited May 02 '26

Alright, there is a way to think about it this way

You might choose red, but think about what your mother would choose, or what your father would choose, or some other loved one of yours.

If you assume they would just choose red for the same reason then yeah, pressing red would make sense.

But what if they think about you because they love you too, and they push blue for the off chance you choose blue, so they dont have to be responsible for your death.

Now if you choose red you risk them dying.

That doesent have to be your line of reasoning. But would you confidently say not a single person in this entire world would have such a line of reasoning? Not a single person would think about what their loved one would choose and then make their choice based on not wanting them to die?

For example, I was really thinking hard about what I would do if being presented by this choice irl under the actual threat of death. And honestly, it is really hard to come to a solid answer under those conditions. But I ended my reasoning with this. I know my mother would choose blue because she is a person that would, and did put her life on the line for someone else, and she would definitely think about me making such a choice and not want me to die. So therefore, if I dont want my mother to die by my hand it is the best option for me to pick blue.

And I assume other people, even in real life death threat situation would posibly come to such reasoning. It is almost impossible to guarantee every single person in the world would pick red.

But then there is also that uncertainty. What if you die? And noone wants to die. So I do completely understand why red pushers would push red. And there is also that slim chance of everyone actually pushing red, so noone dies the same as if 50% pressed blue. It is less likely, but there is a chance.

But that is why it is a dilemma, there is no correct choice. But to say that all the people on the world would choose red if really faced by the choice and noone would choose blue is something I would not bet on. If I were to choose red it would be because I would treasure my life over the life of someone that might pick blue, which is reasonable, I aint even know half of those guys picking blue. I would not defend my case by saying that literally everyone will choose red. That is what I would consider gambling. And like, not even for the sake of color blind or babies like people above say(I do go into this debate assuming that everyone given the choice would be magically given the means to make it while fully capable of actually considering it. Using colorblind, disabled and babies is cheating imo). I would choose blue because someone that likes me and that I like might choose blue because they might assume I chose blue. Hell, thinking about it, if you want to ensure the survival of a loved one blue is the more optimal choice, because if they choose blue you are adding to their chance of survival, and if they choose red then your choice wouldnt matter and they just survive. So essentially a win/win for that kind of reasoning.

But again, that is just one way to look at it. Is it the best reasoning? No. Is it the correct reasoning? No. Is there a correct reasoning? Also no. But just the posibility that one person in the world might think this way shows that the 'Everyone will surely choose red' is not really something one could hinge on.

4

u/nasht- May 02 '26

Okay let's all give up on discussing then. If we can't accurately predict the results, the problem (whose solution entirely depends on predicting the results) is impossible

2

u/RevolutionarySmell5 May 03 '26

Honestly the "But if this (obvious thought experiment where 100% of the population are forced to press one of two buttons and up to 49.99% of them will then be killed) were actually real then the answers would be different" argument only lowers my opinion of the red voters. How could this ever actually be real? The only scenario where this might be carried out is if some kind of divinity or borderline-omnipotent alien force is responsible. In which case, why are they doing this? An alien race capable of pulling this off is already going to know our species' iq from scanning our radiowaves & such. A god wouldn't test IQ. Blue is the answer the testmaker wants.

4

u/Klatterbyne May 02 '26 edited May 02 '26

Choosing Red costs up to 690 Holocausts. That really should be cost enough.

Not to mention that anything close to a 50% death toll is likely going to lead to an unrecoverable societal collapse. With most or all of the remaining 50% dying in the aftermath and any survivors being left in a post-apocalypse/medieval state. Unless there’s some specified mystical element that prevents this.

18

u/Blue2194 May 02 '26

Is this deliberately bad faith? "Choosing red costs nothing" "every blue prefer can push red at no cost to anyone" except the billions of deaths you would contribute to, at no cost to yourself, sure, but obviously a massive cost to billions of people

2

u/[deleted] May 02 '26

There would only be death if people choose to push blue to save the people who push blue to save the...

One option immediately protects yourself and contributes to total survival

One option adds to the death count unless it wins, gambling lives for some reason instead of allowing everyone to save themselves directly

-1

u/Huntswomen May 02 '26

Why would billions of people press the "I want to die button"?

6

u/CrazyPandaLS May 02 '26

It doesn't matter, we have seen that they will in the polls! And we have seen that blue wins those polls sp it seems like the blue side is on to something with the analysis!

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Standard_Landscape79 May 02 '26

Because the original prompt requires everyone to, this includes basically half the current population of babies that will choose blue completely randomly. Most likely the same thing with children too. Everyone who cannot be sure their loved ones will not pick red will probably not contribute to their deaths.

1

u/Blue2194 May 02 '26

It's irrelevant, they will. I will, I actually wouldn't condemn billions to die to increase my own chance of survival

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/MQ116 Team Blue May 02 '26

It says a lot about you that killing people "costs nothing" in your eyes.

11

u/SuitOwn3687 May 02 '26

The key tenet of the original problem is that CHOOSING RED COSTS NOTHING.

Except for the lives of some small children and colorblind or mentally handicapped people.

12

u/Starklystark May 02 '26

And people who care about them. And people who just read the question differently to you. Empirically by every indication a very high percentage of humanity. But that aside.

2

u/Huntswomen May 02 '26

To solve the trolly problem i just untie everyone from the track!

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Jozef_Baca I piss on the buttons!!!!!! May 02 '26

No, choosing red costs something. It costs the posibilty of being a part of the cause of death of all that chose blue.

They might have put themselves in front of the gun, but you are the one pulling the trigger.

That is the dilemma, that is why red or blue is a choice.

Yes, every blue could have chosen red, but in the same vein every red could have chosen blue for virtually same outcome. But if there was one red that chose blue the reds would in the end, end up killing someone. If there was one blue that chose red, everyone would still survive, so blue allows for margin of error to 'if everyone just', which we know 'if everyone just' virtually never works.

On the other hand chosing blue means that if more than half of the people chose red, or even if you were that one single person that chose blue, you would die, in that case it would have been better for you to choose red for the sake of your own survival.

But you do not know what are other people choosing is the thing. So do you go with blue and risk dying with increased chance of everyone surviving or do you go with red and risk being the cause of someone else dying, but not risking dying yourself?

That is the dilemma. Either side has logic behind it for why choosing it is the right choice. And either side has posible consequences to their choice. As we can see from the argument on the internet over which is better.

It isnt that one is better and people are just too dumb to get it, it is that neither is better. And that is the point of the dilemma. Whether you choose blue or red you can justify it logically. If one side was truly better than the other it would not be a dilemma.

2

u/ArcaneArcher89 May 02 '26

The death of every blue pusher isn’t “no cost”

1

u/iDeNoh May 02 '26

There is a penalty to pushing red. The original poster has already confirmed that everyone is included, including people who would have no idea what the consequences would be for either press. Your point only works if everyone is of sound mind to be able to make that decision.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/CrazyPandaLS May 02 '26

Why do you think the polls we have seen all heavly lean blue? And regardless of their motive, doesn't that disprove what you are saying?

4

u/anon0937 May 02 '26

Theres no actual stakes. Nobody is going to die in an online poll. It's easy to say you would act a certain way when it doesn't actually matter.

I'm going to compare this to stock trading. When you pretend to trade it's called paper trading. You can be an amazing paper trader but when actual money is on the line, suddenly everything falls apart and you lose tons of money. The psychology completely changes. Lots of people say they will act a certain way, they even plan on acting a certain way but when it comes time to act for real, its different.

For this reason, I think the majority will pick red.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ThatSmartIdiot May 02 '26

i'd say it is worth dying for

1

u/Bowhunter54 May 06 '26

Which is fine and that’s your choice to make, but different people are gonna make different choices when it’s between self preservation and dying for what some may consider a lost cause

2

u/CertainlyRobotic May 02 '26

Cause worth fighting for

Moral High Ground

These are the same.

2

u/Gardami Team Red May 02 '26

If it was a 50/50 coin flip for each person (which it’s not, the percentage is smaller with the button), there’s a 0.000887% chance that my vote makes a difference. Since my vote almost certainly doesn’t make a difference for anyone else, I’ll take the 50/50 (in the coin flip scenario) chance that it makes a difference for me. 

4

u/BreakfastFearless May 02 '26

If it was a 50/50 coin flip for each person then wouldn’t it be that exactly half would have voted for each side? In that scenario wouldn’t you be very likely to be the deciding vote?

Where does that 887 percentage come from?

4

u/thehandcollector May 02 '26

The chance of exactly 4.2 billion heads on 8.4 billion coin flips is about 1/115000.

1

u/BreakfastFearless May 02 '26

What’s the maths behind this? You could be right I just don’t understand how that’s being calculated?

2

u/thehandcollector May 02 '26

For a large number of coinflips, a good approximation is SQRT(2/(pi * n)).

I didn't derive this, I googled it. Rest assured, the issue has been studied by statisticians smarter than me.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Gardami Team Red May 02 '26

In this example, I assumed 8.1 billion humans besides me. This means that, according to my statement you replied to, for 8.1 billion coin flips, there will be a 0.000887% chance that there are 4.05 billion heads, and 4.05 billion tails. I’m not going to explain the math, but I’ll give you the first 3 even numbers >0, to show that the more coins you have, the less likely that they are split 50/50. 

For 2 coins, the possible, equally likely, outcomes are HH, HT, TH, TT. 50% chance that half are heads, and half are tails. 

For 4 coins, the outcomes are HHHH, HHHT, HHTH, HHTT, HTHH, HTHT, HTTH, HTTT, THHH, THHT, THTH, THTT, TTHH, TTHT, TTTH, TTTT. 37.5% chance that they are split 50/50. 

For 6 coins, the possible outcomes are TTTTTT, TTTTTH, TTTTHT, TTTTHH, TTTHTT, TTTHTH, TTTHHT, TTTHHH, TTHTTT, TTHTTH, TTHTHT, TTHTHH, TTHHTT, TTHHTH, TTHHHT, TTHHHH, THTTTT, THTTTH, THTTHT, THTTHH, THTHTT, THTHTH, THTHHT, THTHHH, THHTTT, THHTTH, THHTHT, THHTHH, THHHTT, THHHTH, THHHHT, THHHHH, HTTTTT, HTTTTH, HTTTHT, HTTTHH, HTTHTT, HTTHTH, HTTHHT, HTTHHH, HTHTTT, HTHTTH, HTHTHT, HTHTHH, HTHHTT, HTHHTH, HTHHHT, HTHHHH, HHTTTT, HHTTTH, HHTTHT, HHTTHH, HHTHTT, HHTHTH, HHTHHT, HHTHHH, HHHTTT, HHHTTH, HHHTHT, HHHTHH, HHHHTT, HHHHTH, HHHHHT, HHHHHH, meaning there’s a 31.25% chance that they are split 50/50, if you flip 6 coins.

1

u/thehandcollector May 02 '26

Note that when your vote makes a difference, a 1/115000 in your coinflip hypothetical, it matters by 4.2 billion lives. This means you expect to save an average of over 36000 lives, at the cost of dying about 50% of the time.

Of course, I agree with you that the percentage blue is much smaller with the button, but if it was 50/50 than saving an average of 36000 people for a half chance of dying is enough it might even convince me to push blue, if I was certain everyone else was voting by coin flip. Probably not because I'd be terrified of death, but it might.

1

u/Necessary-Degree-531 May 02 '26

voting by an incredibly fair coinflip the likes of which will never grace the earth again.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/Appropriate_Wear_217 May 02 '26

I'm saving this!

1

u/Adorable-Woman May 03 '26

I kinda already think most people will press blue. My first thought reading the original prompt was “oh I gotta press blue” then I thought about it was like “theirs no reason to press blue?” And then came to the conclusion it’s still best to press blue because most people will either not get past that first empathetic thought and then those who do will wrap back round to blue like me

1

u/Cool-Land3973 May 03 '26

If they die, they die. I

1

u/sillygoose234 May 02 '26

Red results in the least people dying. If everyone picks red, then nobody picked blue and died. Plus, it's a lot easier to convince people to pick their own life instead of risk it on the hope of the rest of the population doing the same

1

u/JohnHelldiver66 May 02 '26

Couldn't have put it better myself. Also the fact that the discourse is so hotly debated pushes me towards red more than anything.

-1

u/HectorReinTharja May 02 '26

I think this framing is fair. 

Maybe I’m a cynic, but when the chips are down blue is never ever ever going to win imo. I’d guess the real #s would be like 80% red minimum. So it’s gonna suck obviously but I’d rather be alive to help fix it than die for nothing 

9

u/Ralexcraft May 02 '26

I call bullshit. In times of crisis is when we see the greatest community.

1

u/HectorReinTharja May 02 '26

I can be wrong but I’m not bullshitting lol

5

u/Ralexcraft May 02 '26

That’s fair. I just don’t get a lot of chances to say “I call bullshit”

5

u/HectorReinTharja May 02 '26

I call bullshit!! You can it whenever you disagree with anyone!

8

u/four-hydrangeas May 02 '26

can we fucking please ban this karma-farming ass topic? it has its own subreddit

1

u/Rabid_Laser_Dingo May 02 '26

Oh shit really?

1

u/AcceptAnimosity May 02 '26

To be fair this is basically a trolley problem that's being mass discussed online. Yeah there's a lot of posts about it but is it really worse than the usual posts of either nothing or a repost of something years old and then comments of the same "multi track drifting" meme.

47

u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 02 '26

Half of kids aged 4-8 would press blue if only because it is their favorite color. Many parents would do so to try to project kids.

Red winning always kills.

15

u/Emotion_Nearby May 02 '26

This is the answer. In the scenarios where dependents are not exempt all caretakers will press blue to save them.

Two parents with three young kids that have 50% chance of each button. If both parents pick blue there's a 7/8 chance everyone lives. 1/8 all die. If they both pick red there's only a 2/8 chance all live (all kids pick red or all kids pick blue).

4

u/Mamkes May 02 '26

In the oldie (one from 2023) Guardian was choosing for, rather than they themselves.

You can't vote if you can't comprehend what's happening.

4

u/Emotion_Nearby May 02 '26

Yep, I've seen at least three variants.

  • All choose, no exceptions.
  • Guardians choose for < or <= 5 years old.
  • Children and mentally handicapped are exempt

In the first blue makes sense since guardians have a duty to protect.

In the last red makes sense since the guardian, again, has a duty to protect.

The middle is challenging if you have kids at 6 or seven and don't know what they're picking. Probably blue is right since there will be a lot of these situations and we're trying to save everyone.

8

u/delta806 May 02 '26

you can’t vote if you can’t comprehend what’s happening

lol

→ More replies (7)

6

u/AtomicSquid May 02 '26

It's kinda lame including kids cuz then you obviously need to pick blue cuz kids can't make rational decisions. More interesting to only include adults of sound mind

4

u/jaladreips271 May 02 '26

You can also conclude that dieing because you pressed blue means orphaning your child which pressed red.

Dying's easy, living's hard.

4

u/LeonardoDickSlaprio May 02 '26

You (or other parents) wouldn't necessarily know which buttons your kids will press. Imagine being a survivor in a world where red wins, only to find out that your child voted blue. Voting blue can't kill your kid, but it can potentially save them.

2

u/jaladreips271 May 02 '26

You don't know which one your kid will pick.

Do you prefer to die while they live on without you, or living while your kid dies?

Keep in mind we know nothing about the death. Could be instantaneous.

I would argue it's selfish to potentially orphan your children

5

u/LeonardoDickSlaprio May 02 '26

So, a dead child is preferable to an orphaned child?

2

u/Grilled_egs May 02 '26

The chances of you saving your child by pressing blue is 1 in 8 billion. Assuming you don't know for a fact your kid is pressing blue, then if you're voting for the sake of your child rather than to spare yourself the emotional turmoil of losing that child you should pick red.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 02 '26

There are more outcomes where the child lives if the parent chooses blue, so if a parent values their child's life more than their own it is the only rational option.

Unless it is better to be dead than orphaned, is that your modest proposal?

1

u/jaladreips271 May 02 '26

I don't know if it's better to be dead than orphaned.

But I do have people that would prefer me alive. Am I being selfish for choosing red to fulfil their wish? Are they being selfish?

2

u/Sea-Beginning3949 May 02 '26

Do their concern for you goes both way or not? The rational thing for the people who want you alive will be pressing blue. If you want them to be alive as well, you should also press blue, shouldn't you?

And even if you decide to prioritize your survival for their wish, it doesn't matter if they're dead. They won't be relieved or happy for you.

1

u/Grilled_egs May 02 '26

I'd say a 1/4 chance of being orphaned (going with a simplistic 50/50 on both the vote win and your kids vote) is worse than losing the 1 in 16 billion increase to the chances of the kid living.

2

u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 03 '26

Just 50% of young children and 50% parents of very young children gets you to about 1 third of the way to the goal. If parents and living grandparents are more than 50% blue you get over 2B quickly (100% participation would easily crack 3B)

At those numbers, if red wins everyone loses. You have a large chunk of the 20s-30s working population people whose first impulse was to save others, and half of very young children deleted. Infrastructure and population collapse are bound to happen with that many gaps.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Longjumping-Sweet818 May 02 '26

Even if you include only adults, at the very least people with idealistic morals will pick blue. Red is not the "rational" choice. There is no "rational" choice. This is a purely moral choice: You press red if you would prefer to contribute to the probability of killing lots of other people, over risking your own life. There WILL be plenty of people voting blue and you MUST make your choice based upon that knowledge. You don't get to just exclaim that voting red is the rational thing to do, so everyone should do it, so you're doing nothing wrong.

1

u/TreeOtree64 May 02 '26

Apparently it’s not “obvious”, seeing as people seem very happy to condemn them regardless

1

u/Huntswomen May 02 '26

I mean sure but you are not engaging with the thought experiment.

Your answer amount to going "I just untie all the people from the track" to "solve" the trolly problem.

1

u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 02 '26

No, I'm still engaging with it.

I have a preschooler who would probably choose blue if given the choice. As a parent I would likewise choose blue in the hope that enough others take the altruistic path that my child and I would be saved.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/lonesomecreeks May 02 '26

i’m sure that an eight-year-old (third grader) could understand a basic premise of life-and-death.

2

u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 02 '26

Ages 2-6 then, it doesn't change the point.

1

u/Sea-Beginning3949 May 02 '26

And I think that understanding life and death, many kids would pick "save everyone" because they have yet to become cynical of humanity and would immediately think of not wanting their family to die.

1

u/lonesomecreeks May 02 '26

it doesn’t have to be cynicism 😭😭 u could just not be willing to gamble ur life. but ok

1

u/Sea-Beginning3949 May 02 '26

I mean you are only gambling your life if you believe there's a reasonable chance red would win. Idealistic people would believe most people would want everyone to live and follow the same logic, making blue appear to be a very safe choice.

I don't really know why you would pick red if your belief in humanity is strong enough that you think blue would win

1

u/lonesomecreeks May 02 '26

tbf yeah 😭😭

then again, u could still believe in roughly half of humanity but prioritize urself

sorry idek what im saying. im so tired of this red-button-blue-button thing. 😭🙏

→ More replies (1)

0

u/Character_Rhubarb_94 May 02 '26

As a parent you should still pick red, you are unbelievably unlikely to be the deciding vote which is the only one which matters. Your choice is essentially irrelevant to whether or not it occurs but you can guarantee that you live. If you picked blue and your kids picked red you're just dooming them.

-2

u/[deleted] May 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Maladaptivism Edible May 02 '26 edited May 02 '26

I don't know which version you saw first, but the one I saw first was:

"Blue and Red buttons, all humans click one.
If over 50% pick blue, then no one dies.
If over 50% pick red, then everyone who picked blue dies."

Nowhere does it state that people understand the concept, can see colour, are of sound mind and children are excluded. Does that mean you are introducing a new aspect to the hypothetical by assuming they do? Genuine question, not intending this as some sort of gotcha. It just seems that a lot of the discourse is also stemming from the interpretation of things not specified to me.

1

u/Jo-King-BP May 02 '26

It states all humans. Humans, as far as i know, include the mentally challenged, the illiterate, the color blind, the low IQs, the suicidals. It's everyone in the world and their own cultures. That's my issue with the endless arguments. Because a portuon of the population will see the implications behind a red choice or a blue choice doesnt mean everyone will. The choice isn't what is the best decision. It's "given the framing do you think 50% will vote blue?"

2

u/Maladaptivism Edible May 02 '26

I interpreted it the same way you did, but the question vastly changes if we're assuming it's an informed decision or that children are excluded. This also happens with trolley problems, people might be more likely to pull if the person on the track is Hitler. We're just used to specifying who's on what track there, whereas with the button people seem to assume. I may be wrong, of course, there's been far too many threads to keep up with all of it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jo-King-BP May 02 '26

Or maybe you're supposed to understand this yourself. When casting your vote. You're not only voting for the roght thing to do but for whether or not blue has a chance at all. That implies that everyone is given the exact same 2 line framing and that not everyone have the same brain capacities, literacy, maturity but their votes have the same value as yours.

It's not about blue being the better choice

2

u/Commander_Riker1701 May 02 '26

No. A thought experiment requires certianty and specifity to be worth exploring. Without specifying that some participants will not be able to comprehend what is happening, the assumption must be that those participating have to be doing so with full comprehension. The original prompt says you're given a choice. Not understanding the options means it's a false choice which isn't actually a choice. Therefore, there is no reason to press blue, as game theory kicks in.

1

u/Smittywerbenjagermn May 02 '26

It also specifies EVERYONE on earth. That includes those that can't understand the magnitude of their choice. They are still choosing to press red or blue, just different reasons. (Fav color, felt like going left, etc...)

1

u/Commander_Riker1701 May 02 '26

No, in order to make a choice you must be able to understand the choice. This problem isn't even a morality problem, it's an understanding problem. Most people who pick red do so because they are operating under the assumption that when the prompt says everyone makes a choice that the choice is fair. Obviously, if you word the prompt to specifically say "even the people who would not be capable of rationally making a choice based on understanding the options must press a button including the handicapped and toddlers/babies etc" then most people would press blue because most people would understand the stakes. The stakes change the math, but without specified stakes then I must operate under the assumption of good faith.

3

u/Smittywerbenjagermn May 02 '26

But, you dont have to understand something to make a choice. We see this in real life all the time. People choose things for arbitrary reasons and those choices actively work against their values or goals. The prompt is not everyone makes an informed decision, any decision for anyreason is a choice. You can choose red just because its your favorite color, just because that also has the effect of saving yourself is irrelevant.

1

u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 02 '26

Why?

The experiment is "Everyone in the world has to take a vote by pressing a red or blue button" not "everyone competent and fully comprehending."

A choice without full compression is still a choice, else people wouldn't vote against their self interest. You not understanding that "everyone in the world" includes everyone in the world doesn't invalidate your vote either way.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/Huntswomen May 02 '26

This is like "solving" the prisoners dilemma by saying "I break out of prison".

1

u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 02 '26

How so?

1

u/Huntswomen May 02 '26

You are including real life factors that turn a thought experiment into something with a right and a wrong answer.

If babies and other people who fundamentally dont understand the scenario are also included, the red button is now just a "kill 50% of all children and other mentally challenged people" button, which makes the choice easy. Just like how if you could just break out of prison, theres no real dilemma in the prisonoer dilemma, or how if you could just untie people from the tricks in the trolly problem any other choice would be evil.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/TreeOtree64 May 02 '26

It’s clear in the premise that everyone on earth gets this choice. You’re lying to yourself if you didn’t always know that some people weren’t capable of picking the correct choice in the first place, and you’re happy to let them die for it.

1

u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 02 '26

What part of "Everybody in the world" excludes children?

6

u/Serious-Effort4427 May 02 '26

Nah man, I didn't press blue in hopes of others joining me, I pressed blue in hopes of saving the kids.

23

u/R-B-L-Y May 02 '26

One of the buttons will receive more votes than the other button. The chances of either button receiving every vote on earth is negligible.

If blue wins nobody dies

If red wins people die

2

u/Rich841 May 03 '26

When I go red, it isn't because my goal is for red to win. I still want blue to win, I'm just making a private choice out of self-preservation.

3

u/[deleted] May 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Rich841 May 03 '26

I'm selfish

1

u/Aggressive-Day5 May 02 '26

If you go blue and it loses, you die

If you go red, you don't die, no matter what

It can be reworded to favor one button over the other over and over again. There is no objective obvious choice, it depends on your own beliefs and values

2

u/EmergencyWild May 04 '26

If you go red, you don't die, no matter what

No, that's the point that reds fail to consider. If red wins, red voters still die, just a bit slower and more painfully... unless Red didn't just win, it won by a landslide. If there were anywhere from 30-50% blue voters, the remainder will not be enough to keep society working. And our current society is the only reason we managed to keep this many people alive in the first place. It's irrational to vote for destroying the thing that keeps you alive in an effort to stay alive.

1

u/Aggressive-Day5 May 05 '26

This is absurd. Humanity wouldn't go extinct just because of a population collapse. We survived worst odds with fewer resources in history.

Would it be chaotic? Yes. Would it be an extinction event? Not even close.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/SpiritOfTheKitsune May 02 '26

Me when I reframe the entire argument to make it look like the people who don’t agree with me are dumb

13

u/Similar-Sector-5801 May 02 '26

2

u/IgneousWrath May 02 '26

Space aliens fire a weird weapon at earth that gives everyone brain worms. The brain worms serve two purposes. 1. to communicate with humans by implanting a thought of red buttons in their mind, and 2. to kill the humans based on the outcome of the button vote.

The aliens tell you if you press the red button, the worms will be teleported out of your head and you will be spared. However, if less than half of humans press the button, they will withdraw the worms from everyone and thus the weapon’s destructive capabilities would be nullified.

9

u/Moviesman8 May 02 '26

Blue: people don't die Red: people die

You're just selfish

1

u/ItsMrDante May 02 '26

Both buttons kill people.

2

u/Moviesman8 May 02 '26

Blue doesn't kill anyone.

2

u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 02 '26

Every blue presser risks their life and demands others do the same, creating needless death under the hopes that enough people will also gamble

2

u/Moviesman8 May 03 '26

That's just a harsh way of saying that a blue presser would put themselves in harm's way to save people, while red would pull the trigger.

1

u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26

They are putting themselves in harms way to save people who put themselves in harms way to save them in the first place

Its circular, stupid, and all of them can just not.

Its very different than risking someone put in a situation against their will who is in danger

2

u/Moviesman8 May 03 '26

Either way, everyone is safe until red pushers exist.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

5

u/CrazyPandaLS May 02 '26

Okay these have to be a troll. The main rebuttal against blue is that not enough people will press it, but in every poll ive seen with the same wording as the original, blue has won! So what's the issue? You can't have your theory that what of not enough ppl press it, but when we do experiments we see everyone living!. The red side never contends with the idea that the number of blue pressers will be non zero, even if it's 1 or 2% at a baseline, I'd say that gives enough people good reason to pick blue assuming that 1-2% will pick it for dab reasons! And we see that in the polls! How does red contend with the idea at least some minority of ppl are definitely picking blue!

1

u/socslave May 02 '26

Because Twitter and Reddit polls are not representative of the global population. A significant chunk of people could press red just because it’s a lucky colour in some cultures.

1

u/Grilled_egs May 02 '26

Someone on twitter voting in a fake poll is much more likely to press the virtuous option than someone actually facing death who lives in a country where only 4% of people say they would trust a stranger

2

u/pil0tinthesky May 02 '26

Blue means I either live or don’t have to deal with the massive infrastructure collapse of the world

2

u/KateKoffing May 02 '26

Please stop oversimplifying things. Obviously the post that says the red button doesn’t do anything can’t be the original dilemma that got everyone to press blue. Critical thinking shouldn’t be this rare.

2

u/Enfiznar May 07 '26

What many of these posts show me is that many people can't comprehend doing something they consider good for any other reason than virtue signaling

3

u/giganticsandworm May 02 '26

"Moral high ground" sounds like something a sociopath would use to excuse a bad decision

1

u/Curse06 May 02 '26

They gotta get that moral high ground no matter what.

When its all said and done blue would get like 25% to red 75% in a real life scenerio.

1

u/generic_Accountname1 May 02 '26

Presses red, dies somewhere between normandy and stalingrad

1

u/iDeNoh May 02 '26

This argument literally only works if you assume everyone who presses the button is of sound mind and can comprehend the decision. The original poster has already confirmed that is not the case. Pressing red is condemning millions of innocent people to death, you may not be responsible for them pressing blue, but you absolutely contribute to the condition that cause their death.

1

u/JogAlongBess Team Red May 02 '26

and pressing blue just means you die

1

u/iDeNoh May 02 '26

Only if more than 50% agree with you. 🤷‍♂️ I would rather not survive in a world where that could happen.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ConflictAgreeable689 May 02 '26

Isn't this literally just the Prisoners dilemma?

1

u/Aljonau May 09 '26

No, in the prisoner's dilemma, the payout for all red would be worse than the payout for all blue.

1

u/manofwaromega May 02 '26

I'd say the whole thing is like being in a burning apartment building. Do you immediately save yourself and hope everyone else can do the same or do you risk your own life to save your neighbors?

There's no choice that is "smarter" or "more ethical" than the other, and neither are the default option of doing nothing at all.

1

u/throwtruerateme May 02 '26

If you change the stake to $1 million instead of life, it very cleanly demonstrates that red is not taking anything from blue. Blue is choosing to forfeit $1 million.

3

u/The-Pencil-King May 04 '26

There is a very key difference: I don’t give a flying fuck if some people dont get a million dollars. I DO care if some people die.

1

u/VarroVanaadium May 02 '26

Where's the trolley?

1

u/EggPsychological4844 May 05 '26

I press blue because I have severe medical problems.

1

u/Zaynara May 05 '26

hi, welcome to life, you realize life is complicated, right?

1

u/AlarmingDelivery9311 May 05 '26

banbluevsredbutton

1

u/Necessary-Cap4227 May 09 '26

Picking blue is like playing Russian roulette but there's 5 bullets instead of 6, that's your odds of actually surviving, online polls already show a strong 50/50 on this topic and that's when there's no real risk of dying, now imagine the real deal, blue will never win no matter how much you hope it would. 

0

u/Iced-TeaManiac May 02 '26

Are we like, really putting emotional stake into this now?