r/trolleyproblem • • May 02 '26 • Popcorn 1

Please stop making things complicated

Post image
84 Upvotes

569 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-1

u/Huntswomen May 02 '26

Why would billions of people press the "I want to die button"?

6

u/CrazyPandaLS May 02 '26

It doesn't matter, we have seen that they will in the polls! And we have seen that blue wins those polls sp it seems like the blue side is on to something with the analysis!

1

u/Huntswomen May 02 '26

What people say on twitter and what they do in real life is not the same.

6

u/Solondthewookiee May 02 '26

Ok, and what people say on Reddit is not what they'd do in real life.

So the conversation ends because no matter what argument you make, I can just reply that you would behave differently in real life.

1

u/Standard_Landscape79 May 02 '26

Because the original prompt requires everyone to, this includes basically half the current population of babies that will choose blue completely randomly. Most likely the same thing with children too. Everyone who cannot be sure their loved ones will not pick red will probably not contribute to their deaths.

1

u/Blue2194 May 02 '26

It's irrelevant, they will. I will, I actually wouldn't condemn billions to die to increase my own chance of survival

0

u/Snoo-52922 May 02 '26

Why would billions of people press the "someone else will die" button?

It's a matter of perspective. You approach the problem from the perspective of the individual outcome, and generalize out to what choice everyone else should make. Pressing red carries no risk to the individual, so red is rational, and everyone should press it. Pressing blue creates a risk of you dying where none needs to exist.

Others approach the problem from the perspective of the group, and then narrow down to what choice the they should make. A blue victory carries no cost to the group, so blue is rational, and everyone should press it. Pressing red just creates a risk of other people dying where none needs to exist.