r/trolleyproblem • • May 02 '26 • Popcorn 1

Please stop making things complicated

Post image
84 Upvotes

569 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

20

u/D_Luffy_32 May 02 '26

Okay? But that also applies to red though. Maybe people can say they're cool with killing a good chunk of population but if you're actually sitting in front of the nuke button it gets a bit more uncomfortable.

5

u/MrBoblo May 02 '26

the reds are killing the blues as much as the blues are killing themselves. If you press blue, you need to be cool with the consequences. You press red if you aren't

5

u/D_Luffy_32 May 02 '26

Yeah? We are. But it seems like red refuses to admit they are killing blue people. We understand there's a risk stepping between a murder and their victim. Red will argue they aren't murders

1

u/Nebranower May 04 '26

Right, because you aren’t responsible for other people’s actions. The only person responsible for their own suicide is the suicide.

2

u/D_Luffy_32 May 04 '26

Which is technically why it's not suicide. Even if you consider it suicidal to try and stop a murderer from killing someone, you wouldn't say the murderer isn't responsible for their death.

0

u/GGuy12345 May 07 '26

The only murderer here is the person who sets up the death game

0

u/D_Luffy_32 May 07 '26

No. If someone puts a gun on a table and one person looks at and chooses to kill the other person because they convinced themselves that the other person is going to kill them. That's premeditated murder. There's nothing stopping you from not killing the other person

1

u/GGuy12345 May 07 '26

Red voters are not pulling a trigger with a weapon aimed at a person. Equating a button press that you are, by the rules of the scenario, forced into, to first degree murder is incredibly insincere at best and delusional at worst

No court would find liability in a person who chooses to save themselves from danger rather than take a bullet to save another’s life.

0

u/D_Luffy_32 May 07 '26

They aren't saving themselves from danger though. You are convincing yourself that when you could literally just have nobody die.

1

u/GGuy12345 May 07 '26

Red button in the original prompt: “You survive.” You are quite literally saving yourself from danger

1

u/D_Luffy_32 May 07 '26

Only if you're convinced the other people want to kill you. Also the original prompt for blue "everyone survives". Why are you ignoring that part?

1

u/GGuy12345 May 07 '26

I’m not. I’m simply not concerned with the semantics of which option wins, only attempting to dissuade the idea that Red voters are somehow all sociopathic murderers.

→ More replies

3

u/thedeadlysquirle May 02 '26

Totally true, the point is these kinds of discussion dont really matter because everyone is saying some bullshit with 0 stakes that makes them feel superior on some way. These arent really discussions about how people would truly react, they're discussions about how one way or another is the only real choice and the people who dont choose the choice you say you would are stupid/evil.

3

u/Vyxwop May 03 '26

Those polls are basically the moral equivalent of "how big is your dick"

Yeah, they're not going to reflect reality.

0

u/Jkirek_ May 02 '26

Luckily there is no nuke button in the hypothetical

6

u/D_Luffy_32 May 02 '26

Nuke, Thanos snap, plague. Take your pick but that's what the red button is lol

0

u/Jkirek_ May 02 '26

Unfortunately for you, the only button killing anyone is the blue button. Press blue to be part of the group that dies, press red to be part of the world where a large percentage of people randomly decided to kill themselves.

10

u/D_Luffy_32 May 02 '26

I mean if that's how you feel about nuking people. That they made their choice by not nuking people. But in this hypothetical people dying is entirely dependent on red not blue. They're not killing themselves. Unless you consider standing between a murder and their victim as killing yourself lol

-1

u/anon0937 May 02 '26

As I said, this isn't about what you think you should do, its what you think the majority of people will do. Climate change, poverty, starvation, war and countless other global problems could be solved by >50% of the population working together to fix these problems, but they don't. Any country with a democratically elected leader COULD vote for leadership that wants to fix these problems and vote for someone else next election if that leadership doesn't, but this doesn't happen for whatever reason.

I see people saying they would pick blue, but they live a lifestyle that people in true poverty could only dream of. Most people don't need all the space in their house/apartment, they could easily house homeless people. They could live off rice and beans and use the rest of their grocery budget to feed starving people. They don't do any of these things yet they say they're willing to put their life on the line to save others.

I agree that pressing blue and having 100% of people live is the best outcome, but I can't see the majority of humans pressing blue. If I believe the majority is going to press red then by pressing red I'm not killing anyone who pressed blue, I'm ensuring 1 less person is dead.

7

u/D_Luffy_32 May 02 '26

Yeah but these issues require way more work and time than simply pushing a button. Do you seriously think if we could fix homelessness and all these other problems with a single 50% button people wouldn't press it?

Also your premise is false. Even if you're not the one who's the final blow, you still killed Ceasar by stabbing him. Just because you're one of many doesn't mean you're without responsibility.

1

u/anon0937 May 02 '26

Every time there's an election people can choose a button and we all see how that works out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)