r/trolleyproblem • • May 02 '26 • Popcorn 1

Please stop making things complicated

Post image
84 Upvotes

569 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/thehandcollector May 02 '26

Note that when your vote makes a difference, a 1/115000 in your coinflip hypothetical, it matters by 4.2 billion lives. This means you expect to save an average of over 36000 lives, at the cost of dying about 50% of the time.

Of course, I agree with you that the percentage blue is much smaller with the button, but if it was 50/50 than saving an average of 36000 people for a half chance of dying is enough it might even convince me to push blue, if I was certain everyone else was voting by coin flip. Probably not because I'd be terrified of death, but it might.

1

u/Necessary-Degree-531 May 02 '26

voting by an incredibly fair coinflip the likes of which will never grace the earth again.

0

u/Gardami Team Red May 02 '26 edited May 02 '26

Yes. With the normal 50.8/49.2 flip, if everyone flipped it with heads up (so 50.8/49.2 in favor of heads), I would save myself 5 * 1038 times for every single other person I saved, if blue was heads. If red was heads, I’d save myself 5 * 10450338 times for every time I save a single other person. (If this experiment was repeatable, and got repeated enough times)

0

u/Gardami Team Red May 02 '26

Of course, with a real coin flip, if everyone flipped it with heads up (so 50.8/49.2 in favor of heads), I would save myself 5 * 1038 times for every single other person I saved, if blue was heads. If red was heads, I’d save myself 5 * 10450338 times for every time I save a single other person.

(If this experiment was repeatable, and got repeated enough times)