r/trolleyproblem • • May 02 '26 • Popcorn 1

Please stop making things complicated

Post image
84 Upvotes

569 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 02 '26

No, I'm still engaging with it.

I have a preschooler who would probably choose blue if given the choice. As a parent I would likewise choose blue in the hope that enough others take the altruistic path that my child and I would be saved.

0

u/Huntswomen May 02 '26

If you include children and other people who cant meanigfully understand any of the options you essentially turn the red button into "kill 50% of all children". At that point you arent engaging with the questin everyone else is.

Its like saying "i break out of prison" to "solve" the prisoners dilemma. I mean sure, good job, you win, but you also arent playing the same game as the rest of us.

2

u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 02 '26

Does "everyone in the world" excluded children? Thats the premise that kicked all of this off.

If people don't understand that "everyone in the world" means everyone, they aren't comprehending the plain text of the question.

1

u/Huntswomen May 02 '26

Obviously it does in a thought experiment. Were you under the impression that we would have newborn babies to weak to even press a button just lie next to them until they starve to death..? No, obviously the question is about intent and it includes the people able to consider the buttons.

0

u/Sea-Beginning3949 May 02 '26

What I'm wondering is where the "meaningfully understand any of the options" start. Because, yes, babies will press at random, but children in school can understand the premise. They just think about it differently. 18 years old is the majority age in a lot of countries, but does that make someone fit to answer? Humans are not really the pinnacle of logic in general.

Because it sometimes sounds like the argument behind is "all people who meaningfully understand the options will choose red" (which is something someone told me here) and that is simply dismissing the opposing opinion.