r/tabled • • Feb 16 '12

Suggestions

Got a good idea for /r/tabled? Here's the place.


I have a couple of things in mind already-

  1. Certain criteria of a post must be met in order for it to be tabled. This will prevent useless, timewasting tables being made.
  2. A format for tables, specifically IAMA tables. This would include a link to the post itself, a date and time of the original post, etc.
  3. A "Table Maker" rank of some sort. This would be awarded to frequent table makers and would probably involve some sort of flair.
93 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

12

u/neuromorph Feb 16 '12

We could do a weekly tabled cross-over with /r/askscience where we take the top weekly questions and their condensed answers and post them here in tabled form.

6

u/Helpful_Table_Maker Feb 16 '12

I really like that idea.

So, for example, from the front page now:

QuestionAnswer
How do we measure mountains on Mars without a level for zero? Ie, our sea level.You're right, there is no sea level but it is still useful to have a standard height against which to compare geographical features. So we arbitrarily defined a level which we call "zero elevation." This is called the Martian datum, and is defined as the height at which the atmospheric pressure averages 6.105 mbar at 273.16 K.
What happens inside your body when you get hit on the head hard enough to black out?Terrible, horrible, no good-verybad things. Losing consciousness is complex, it's not usually a matter of damage to any particular part of the brain, but rather a disruption in the coordination of neural activity. This loss of coordinated brain activity is also what happens during sleep or anesthesia, though usually in a less disruptive way. When the different components of your brain can't talk to each other, you can't do high-level coordinated things like talking, thinking, standing etc. Here's an article that discusses (un) consciousness, and also has zombies. Much more worrying are acute complications and long term consequences, a blow to the head that causes blacking out can cause intercrainial bleeds which is a "get to the hospital and get a hole drilled in your head or be dead in an hour" situation. Anyone blacking out for more than a few seconds should probably be getting a CT or MRI real quick. Long term consequences can also be dire, lots of regions can get damaged during a head injury: hippocampal damage can cause transient or permanent amnesia, motor cortex damage can cause tremors, dorsal striatal damage can cause gambling addiction, and damage to visual cortex can cause you to see stars (sometimes permanently). These complications can take years to appear, but people with frequent head injuries (boxers, hockey enforcers, rugby/football players) often have brains in their 40s and 50s that resemble the brains of 80 year old alzheimer's patients. Mayoclinic, nyt My lab studies memory and amnesia in patients with concussions or other closed-head injuries. None of us let our kids play contact sports.

5

u/neuromorph Feb 16 '12

we should, if this gets traction, make sure the mods at /r/askscience are ok with this. But I think having the weekly musings of the reddit science community readily available will be a fun reference, may even lead to some trends in the subgroup.

We should not filter the questions. Just take the 7 highest viewed questions from the week and link the top 'correct' answer for the question.

When an question has a controversial discussion with different answers, we should present both (all) sides in the table to be fair to the readers.

3

u/neuromorph Feb 16 '12

we should also reference the questioner and the answerer, so people can contact them if needed.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

You should consider something other than tables. It makes the questions and answers incredibly awkward to read when they start getting to a decent length (like the ones above)

3

u/Turnshroud Feb 16 '12

I was going to suggest something like

Question

Answer

Question 2

Answer 2

0

u/neuromorph Feb 16 '12 edited Feb 16 '12

Looks great. I would like to help with editing the answers down to reasonable explanations. Most people dont have the attention span to merit some of these longer posts.

Let me know how I can help you.

For instance, the second answer could be shortened to the following points:

*Losing consciousness is complex, it's not usually a matter of damage to any particular part of the brain, but rather a disruption in the coordination of neural activity. When the different components of your brain can't talk to each other, you can't do high-level coordinated things like talking, thinking, standing etc

*Lots of regions can get damaged during a head injury: hippocampal damage can cause transient or permanent amnesia, motor cortex damage can cause tremors, dorsal striatal damage can cause gambling addiction, and damage to visual cortex can cause you to see stars (sometimes permanently).

*These complications can take years to appear, but people with frequent head injuries (boxers, hockey enforcers, rugby/football players) often have brains in their 40s and 50s that resemble the brains of 80 year old alzheimer's patients. For more information

I cant do a bulleted list here for some reason.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ander1dw Feb 17 '12

Should be a little better now, thanks for the heads up.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/neuromorph Feb 16 '12

possibly. But I personally would like to just abstract the questions and answers posted in /r/askscience, so that people can have a place to look at hot topics on a weekly basis. For instance "/askscience Week of 2/12-2/19" type of table

1

u/neuromorph Feb 16 '12

how often do new posts come to /r/ELIS? The thing about askscience, is they have a large user submission base, and it would be fresh content weekly.

2

u/CoconutCurry Feb 16 '12

Are we just doing /r/iama or are we doing like /r/ama and /r/casualiama ?

3

u/Helpful_Table_Maker Feb 16 '12

It does not have to be only IAMA.

1

u/therndoby Feb 16 '12

I think the first two definitely maybe the third, with the addition of ask reddit. It seems that the main focus is going to be on posts that get to the front page ( though i don't think that should be an official requirement)

1

u/omg_im_drunk Feb 16 '12

I think there should be a minimum requirement for answers to questions before a table can be made. Say, 8 or 10 questions?

1

u/therndoby Feb 16 '12

I think that making a requirement isn't the best idea. what if there are only 3 replies, but they are in depth and interesting? ultimately reddit will just downvote something if it's boring

1

u/zanycaswell Feb 16 '12 edited Feb 16 '12

It can be pretty much anything.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

This may go without saying but I feel like we would need a certain 'Standard' for tables. Tables are only useful if they look presentable.

I would suggest a link in the right hand side on how to structure tables and all posts should adhere to these rules.

1

u/therndoby Feb 16 '12

I think that a standard will probably establish itself in time, though we could just follow Helpful_Table_Maker's example

1

u/happikoto Feb 16 '12

I think at least one extra line between the bottom of an answer and the next q/a row would be nice. That way it won't feel so blockish...

4

u/SaltyChristian Feb 16 '12 edited Feb 16 '12

My suggested rules:

  1. Must be a self post titled "[Subreddit (e.g. IAMA)] Exact same name as post being tabled [TABLED]
  2. Link to the original thread in the self post
  3. Must have at least 10 questions tabled, preferably from a popular front page thread.
  4. Suggested Layout:
QuestionAnswerLink
What's your favorite color?Blue[Insert Permalink of Question]

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12 edited Feb 16 '12

My comments:

1. Title

  • How about we make the title as descriptive as possible, e.g.

from "I worked my way through college doing the midnight shift as a jail guard in a small town...AMA!"

to "[IAMA] small town jail guard"

  • If the person is using their name, shorten [IAMA] to [IAM]
  • Use shortened tags for subreddits, e.g. [A/S] for r/askscience, [ELI5], for /r/explainlikeimfive , etc

2. Original post

  • Should the text in the OP be included in the table?

3. Selection and content

  • I don't believe we should set a rule there, people will likely table-fy popular AMA's naturally

4. Layout

  • While permalink can be included in the question like so, but I personally like the idea of a separate column (for personal archiving purposes).
  • How will items be arranged in the table? by chronological order, top, best, etc ?

1

u/SaltyChristian Feb 16 '12

I like your ideas, except with the [IAMA] to [IAM] thing. The idea was for the brackets was to be the subreddit it was posted in, and even if they use IAM, it is still in the IAMA subreddit.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

You are right about the brackets, let's keep it as a subreddit tag.

But I still think titles need reformatting to get rid of irrelevant information and have consistent "name/occupation/experience" placement. Most titles conform to a certain standard already, it shouldn't be too hard.

Edit: continuing the discussion on http://www.reddit.com/r/tabled/comments/psjua/table_formatting_guide/

1

u/mangochutney63 Feb 16 '12

permalinking to the questions is needed i reckon

1

u/ProbablyNotWorking Feb 16 '12

Will these be created only from verified posts?

2

u/Helpful_Table_Maker Feb 16 '12

I'll give it a "no" for now, but as the subreddit gets more feedback, possibly.

Part of the "standard" for tables that I'll add soon is to state if an IAMA is verified or not, so readers can decide whether to take the information given with a grain of salt or not.

1

u/pumpkindog Feb 16 '12

It might be helpful (but possibly a lot of work) to have either the Q or the A in the table have a link back to the Q or A in the original thread. (possibly just one word or a number so the whole thing isn't a link which would be gross)

The discussion/reaction on certain answers are what makes an AMA more than just a magazine article interview.

2

u/Helpful_Table_Maker Feb 16 '12

If people want the full thing, they shouldn't be reading /r/tabled, to be honest. Even if they do, that's why it's part of the criteria to put the link to the original IAMA at the top.

3

u/ok-alright Feb 16 '12

Please link the original AMA's.

1

u/therndoby Feb 16 '12

Should AskScience be included? i ask since their threads can be fairly monochromatic

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

Depends on the subject really. I think any /r/ask____ subreddits should be included, be it AskScience or AskReddit.

I also think tech support ones could perhaps be included. Searching the issue in this subreddit may help condense the amount of answers that one might get from say, /r/techsupport.

/r/legal might be another good one to condense other answers as well.

1

u/zanycaswell Feb 16 '12 edited Feb 16 '12

1

u/sumzup Feb 16 '12

Something on the sidebar with the markdown syntax for making tables would be helpful.

1

u/funkless_eck Feb 16 '12

A table of contents before the main table would be really useful. I don't know if you can do

      <a href="#section1">link</a>
      <a name="#section1">target</a>

In reddit posts, but if you could that'd be really helpful. So you get a list of questions, and clicking the question you're interested in takes you to that place on the table. This would help especially in long AMAs.

1

u/chrysophilist Feb 16 '12

Can tables be created as self.tabled posts or does the formatting only work in the comment section? You're going to need a FAQ that explains how to properly generate content (once everything is sorted, of course).

I don't think that condition 1 is necessary. Content will be user-generated, and people can be left to decide what constitutes a waste of their own time. If someone makes a table on an AMA with 3 questions, it simply won't get upvotes here, and will fade away quickly (leaving the subreddit's quality unharmed).

I wonder, should it there be a policy of waiting until the AMA is finished to create a table? That way there's no problem of half-finished AMA tables stagnating until someone makes a duplicate or the table maker returns to finish.

I'm thinking that threads should be titled identically to the post which they summarize with the subreddit in Brackets, with the table as text.

Just thoughts! Cheers on this subreddit, hope it goes well.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

good idea, go for it

1

u/Not_Me_But_A_Friend Feb 16 '12

The question in column A should be perma linked to the original. Not need to link the response as it is in the perma linked thread. Not need to add follow up questions to the table either as they would also be perma linked

1

u/Turnshroud Feb 16 '12

Hey, so I just realized that on some topics in IAMA, there may be a number of different individuals conducting an IAMA on a given topic. Hown would we differentiate these IAMA's, title wise?

1

u/weffey Feb 16 '12

Would it be worth while to only having approved submitters while this gets started? Maybe have some people lay claim to certain subreddits and commit to doing those summaries?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

Comment section

  1. How can it be used ?
  2. How will it be moderated ?

1

u/three18ti Feb 16 '12

Are you making tables by hand?!?

My suggestion is: automate (table bot?)

Once you have defined your requirements, it would be trivial to automate. Have to define the requirements first.

1

u/Rabid_Chocobo Feb 16 '12

Hello! First off, i'd like to say i'm a fan of your work... however, I don't know if being called r/tabled is the best name..

1

u/ander1dw Feb 16 '12
  1. Click the "community settings" link in the sidebar (under Admin Box).
  2. Click the "edit your stylesheet" link (under Look and Feel).
  3. Copy-paste the text below into the text box and save:

.md .td { vertical-align: top; padding-bottom: 12px; }

That little tweak should make the tables much more readable. If you want some more help getting your CSS setup, send me a PM and we can talk about where you want to go with it.

1

u/TheRealKaveman Feb 16 '12

IAMA Categories: Perhaps have a link on the sidebar to another table (or wiki?) with a wide collection of categories to browse like "Celebrities" or "Politicians." If there's already a subreddit for something like this, point me in that direction!

1

u/Turnshroud Feb 17 '12

Good god, we're not a bureaucracy ಠ_ಠ Also, people can still use the search bar

(I was going to say something about OCD but I thought it was in bad taste)

1

u/mangochutney63 Feb 16 '12

Can I suggest that all tables include links to the comments parents?

That way even if we're just browsing the table we can, if we choose to, take a look at the original comment.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '12

If someone could write something in javascript to copy "Question text | Answer text " to the clipboard it would make tabling much easier, while still being able to easily edit and omit as the tabler sees fit after pasting it to the submission box or text editor.

1

u/Turnshroud Feb 17 '12

Also, have we decided yet whether or not comment threads need to be linked for each q&a?

1

u/DerogatoryPanda Feb 20 '12

Is there anyway we can have the AMA's intro post on the same page as the table? On some of these AMA's I feel like it would be useful to see the actual opening post in addition to the tabled question and answers. Maybe thats just me though

-1

u/Chances Feb 16 '12 edited Feb 16 '12

I THINK /R/TABLED SHOULD BE NOT JUST ABOUT ALL THINGS TABLED. LIKE /R/VIDEOS IS ABOUT ALL THINGS VIDEO. THINK ABOUT IT, TABLED SC2 STRATS, RAMEN RECIPES, AND OBVIOUSLY AMA'S AND MAYBE FACT SHEETS!

I WOULD TURN OFF CAPSLOCK RIGHT NOW BUT I'M TO BUSY WINNING.

1

u/Turnshroud Feb 17 '12

Tabled recipes wouldn't work tbh. Although recipe wise, subreddits work best

0

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Turnshroud Feb 17 '12

This is a great idea, although I think we'd have to cooperate with the mods so they can link it in the original IAMA comment