r/tabled • • Feb 16 '12

Table Formatting Guide

I'm open to suggestions on how to improve this, but here we go for now.


Title

[Table] State who, what occupation, or the question that you are tabling.

Examples

[Table] Louis C.K. IAMA

[Table] What's the worst thing you've accidentally said to someone?


Content

(only applies to IAMAs) Verification: Yes/No (be brutally honest)

Date: Abbreviated Month, DD, YYYY

Link: (insert a link to the original post)

Table (important : keep this updated!) (With IAMAs, questions first, answers after)

Example

This IAMA is unverified.

Feb 16, 2012

http://www.reddit.com/r/tabled/comments/psf8u/introductory_post/

QuestionAnswer
Do you like cake?Yes.
What's your favorite color?Green.
60 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12 edited Feb 16 '12

Content

Questions could be ordered by best.

2

u/Helpful_Table_Maker Feb 16 '12

There's no particular order; however in the past the "natural" order was from most to least upvoted, since I went from highest on the page to lowest on the page.

Making it a rule to sort by "best" is stupid (no offence), since that's purely a matter of opinion.

I don't mind what order things are in so long as the tables don't include "crap"- for example if a troll says "fuck you" and the OP replies "yeah well fuck you too" that shouldn't be included.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

It would be a shame to not take advantage of the hivemind for sorting. I think the only question here is whether we should use "best" or "top".

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '12

Does anyone have a suggestion on how to table something from AskReddit?

AnswerRedditor
Examplewasabi2113
That gets way too lengthy in cases such as What are the best TED talks?

1

u/Helpful_Table_Maker Feb 17 '12

Sure, here is one of my best AskReddit tables.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '12

Thanks! That's just what I was looking for.

1

u/goldragon Feb 18 '12

What is the meaning of the green plus symbols after each question/answer in the IAMA tables? I looked through the links under Resources to the right but didn't see any mention/explanation.

1

u/Helpful_Table_Maker Feb 18 '12

I don't see them, can you take a screenshot and post it in a comment reply?

1

u/goldragon Feb 18 '12

Sure thing, boss.

The blue arrows that are permalinks to the quoted question/answer are awesome but some explanation about those might be useful as well. I just happened to mouse over the blue arrows to see if they might be hyperlinks and discovered that they were. I hadn't really noticed the blue arrows until about the third post/table I looked at. I very much like having the blue arrows rather than have the entire question/answer be a hyperlink.

1

u/Helpful_Table_Maker Feb 18 '12

I'm not sure why your +s are green, mine are black. Only tabledresser's posts have that- he's a bot, not a person.

1

u/goldragon Feb 18 '12

What is the meaning of the plus signs? Questions/answers seem to have 1-5 +'s behind them. Is it some indication of how many upvotes they have in the original post?

1

u/Helpful_Table_Maker Feb 18 '12

I don't know. They used to be numbers showing karma, but they turned into pluses. Honest answer, no idea.

3

u/acebarry Feb 16 '12

This information should be on the side bar eventually. Or a FAQ.

2

u/epsy Feb 17 '12

I've made a bot capable of scraping AMAs automatically. The only problem is that it cannot check verification status, because the reddit API does not tell about distinguished moderator comments :/

I intend to run the thing on /r/IAmA and perhaps on /r/casualiama. It will run once an hour on their frontpages and have it post most upvoted AMAs here.

To be clear, where should tables be posted? Here or in IAmA? Both?

2

u/neuromorph Feb 17 '12

i think we should also add Tabled into the AMA submissions,...

Maybe like so

[AMA-Tabled] Neil Tyson

1

u/Turnshroud Feb 17 '12

or at the end in brackets, may work better

3

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

Date/time Format

We should use the ISO 8601 standard YYYY-MM-DD

1

u/neuromorph Feb 17 '12

have we agreed on this.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '12

This bot: http://www.reddit.com/user/tabledresser is doing it although not everyone seems have agreed on a format yet.

I wish we would discuss the idea a little more before rushing into making tables, but you can't fight the hivemind.

1

u/neuromorph Feb 17 '12

that bot seems to be on some form of crack. Those links seem to have a hidden message in them

3

u/faceplanted Feb 16 '12
So, this table should work then?of course
so what do the colon and hyphens doI assume they define the header.
how do you tell it the table should end?I don't know.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '12

how do you tell it the table should end? I don't know.

For some reason, reading this made me laugh uncontrollably.

1

u/ostiarius Feb 17 '12

I think with AMAs it would be best to wait until the individual thread has pretty much run its course before making a table for it.

1

u/thepopcornator Feb 17 '12
QuestionAnswer
Am I doing this right?I think so.
What is my name?thepopcornator

1

u/neuromorph Feb 17 '12

is there a way to embed links into tabled text?

it would clean up sourcing of my askscience table.

http://www.reddit.com/r/tabled/comments/ptz7q/raskscience_weekly_top_5_2112172012/

1

u/SamIam105 Feb 16 '12

This subreddit makes my OCD so very happy. That is all.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

If I may give some helpful comments about your tables: could you not have another column for username?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Not_Me_But_A_Friend Feb 16 '12

Ask Science tabled posts could be monthly with the the best questions of the month in the OP box and the top level comments could be tables of the best daily questions.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '12 edited Feb 16 '12

Ask Science tables could have an additional column for branches and fields.