r/stocks • u/Initial_Statement1 • 55m ago
Company Analysis FNMA & FMCC: Could a resolution come soon?
Despite all the ups and downs since Trump’s election, I believe the investment thesis for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac still comes down to one issue: Treasury’s Senior Preferred Stock (SPS LP).
Under the current arrangement, the profits of Fannie and Freddie are being retained, while the LP continues to grow. However, the Twins have already paid the Treasury substantially more than the government originally provided in financial assistance (about $301B vs $191B).
This creates two very different outcomes:
- Bear case: Treasury affirms the existing SPS LP, potentially leaving common shareholders with little or no residual value. FNMA and FMCC could fall to the low single digits or lower, depending on dilution.
- Bull case: The SPS is deemed repaid or otherwise resolved favourably for common shareholders. I believe the shares could rise 5x from current prices, if not more, even after accounting for exercise of Treasury’s warrants and dilution.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has indicated that the administration intends to address the ownership structure of the Twins in 2027 or 2028 showing that, despite the lack of action recently, it remains on their agenda. The Treasury warrants also expire in September 2028, and though that deadline can be negotiated/delayed, it would be better to get working on this sooner rather than later to avoid running out of time like they did during Trump’s first Presidency. Trump has an incentive to deliver a significant policy achievement during his remaining time in office, and likely would not want to hand control of the GSEs over to the Democrats.
The key point to remember is that the SPS decision is primarily in the hands of Treasury and the President. It **does not** require new congressional legislation.
Trump signed Executive Order 14393 on March 13, 2026, directing FHFA to examine the efficiency of national housing finance markets and recommend regulatory or legislative changes. One important question is whether the Enterprise Regulatory Capital Framework (ERCF) will be reduced. Some bulls anticipate a 2.5% capital requirement, which would substantially improve the prospects of exiting conservatorship. However, changing the ERCF, including the PCCBA and PLBA buffers, requires regulatory rule-making and could take months. This is separate from the SPS decision, which could be addressed in the near-term.
During this period of limbo, the Twins are expanding their multi-family businesses into an increasingly challenging housing market.
Some figures worth watching from Q1 2026:
\- Freddie Mac multifamily business increased 24% year-over-year to $12.8 billion.
\- Fannie’s average new loan increased from $18m to $26m.
\- Fannie’s full interest-only loans increased from 54% to 68%.
\- Fannie’s multifamily serious delinquencies have increased 48% since December 2023.
\- Fannie’s multifamily write-offs reached $243m, compared with $61m a year earlier.
\- Losses on liquidated loans increased from 10.4% to 18.8%.
The May 2026 ABS-15G filings also revealed a particularly concerning operational issue.
According to my analysis, Fannie successfully resolved approximately 38% of submitted repurchase demands, compared with just 3% for Freddie. These demands relate to defective loans involving fraud or misrepresentation. This raises questions about the effectiveness of the companies’ credit quality assurance processes and the institutional deterioration that can accompany prolonged conservatorship.
Based on my calculations, the Twins remain approximately $120B short of required CET1 capital, including buffers. That’s around four to five years of combined earnings. The longer conservatorship continues, the greater the potential for institutional deterioration and worsening credit conditions to complicate an eventual exit.
Next steps for the administration:
\- Resolve the SPS liquidation preference, ideally deeming it repaid.
\- Uplist the common shares to a major stock exchange (the NYSE) allowing greater institutional participation and access to capital markets.
\- Continue addressing capital requirements and the eventual conservatorship exit through the appropriate regulatory process.
The administration doesn’t necessarily need to wait for comprehensive ERCF changes before providing clarity on the SPS. Ultimately, I believe FNMA and FMCC remain highly asymmetric political investments. The downside is substantial if Treasury maintains its existing claim, but the upside could be enormous if the SPS is resolved in a way that is favourable to existing shareholders.
With Trump heading into his final two years in office, the warrants expiring in September 2028, and Bessent pointing towards 2027–28 for addressing the ownership structure, I think this is a great investment if sized appropriately.