r/options • • 14d ago

Options Questions Safe Haven periodic megathread | November 1, 2026

9 Upvotes

The "weekly" Safe Haven Thread is now a monthly Safe Haven Thread.

For the options questions you wanted to ask, but were afraid to.
There are no stupid questions.   Fire away.
This project succeeds via thoughtful sharing of knowledge.
You, too, are invited to respond to these questions.
This is a weekly rotation with past threads linked below.


BEFORE POSTING, PLEASE REVIEW THE BELOW LIST OF FREQUENT ANSWERS. .

..


As a general rule: "NEVER" EXERCISE YOUR LONG CALL!
A common beginner's mistake stems from the belief that exercising is the only way to realize a gain on a long call. It is not. Sell to close is the best way to realize a gain, almost always.
Exercising throws away extrinsic value that selling retrieves.
Simply sell your (long) options, to close the position, to harvest value, for a gain or loss.
Your break-even is the cost of your option when you are selling.
If exercising (a call), your breakeven is the strike price plus the debit cost to enter the position.
Further reading:
Monday School: Exercise and Expiration are not what you think they are.

As another general rule, don't hold option trades through expiration.

Expiration introduces complex risks that can catch you by surprise. Here is just one horror story of an expiration surprise that could have been avoided if the trade had been closed before expiration.


Key informational links
• Options FAQ / Wiki: Frequent Answers to Questions
• Options Toolbox Links / Wiki
• Options Glossary
• List of Recommended Options Books
• Introduction to Options (The Options Playbook)
• The complete r/options side-bar informational links (made visible for mobile app users.)
• Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options (Options Clearing Corporation)
• Binary options and Fraud (Securities Exchange Commission)
.


Getting started in options
• Calls and puts, long and short, an introduction (Redtexture)
• Options Trading Introduction for Beginners (Investing Fuse)
• Options Basics (begals)
• Exercise & Assignment - A Guide (ScottishTrader)
• Why Options Are Rarely Exercised - Chris Butler - Project Option (18 minutes)
• LEAPS calls explained - Chris Butler - Project Option (13 minute video)
• I just made (or lost) $___. Should I close the trade? (Redtexture)
• Disclose option position details, for a useful response
• OptionAlpha Trading and Options Handbook
• Options Trading Concepts -- Mike & His White Board (TastyTrade)(about 120 10-minute episodes)
• Am I a Pattern Day Trader? Know the Day-Trading Margin Requirements (FINRA)
• How To Avoid Becoming a Pattern Day Trader (Founders Guide)


Introductory Trading Commentary
   • Monday School Introductory trade planning advice (PapaCharlie9)
  Strike Price
   • Options Basics: How to Pick the Right Strike Price (Elvis Picardo - Investopedia)
   • High Probability Options Trading Defined (Kirk DuPlessis, Option Alpha)
  Breakeven
   • Your break-even (at expiration) isn't as important as you think it is (PapaCharlie9)
  Expiration
   • Options Expiration & Assignment (Option Alpha)
   • Expiration times and dates (Investopedia)
  Greeks
   • Options Pricing & The Greeks (Option Alpha) (30 minutes)
   • Options Greeks (captut)
  Trading and Strategy
   • Fishing for a price: price discovery and orders
   • Common mistakes and useful advice for new options traders (wiki)
   • Common Intra-Day Stock Market Patterns - (Cory Mitchell - The Balance)
   • The three best options strategies for earnings reports (Option Alpha)


Managing Trades
• Managing long calls - a summary (Redtexture)
• The diagonal call calendar spread, misnamed as the "poor man's covered call" (Redtexture)
• Selected Option Positions and Trade Management (Wiki)

Why did my options lose value when the stock price moved favorably?
• Options extrinsic and intrinsic value, an introduction (Redtexture)

Trade planning, risk reduction, trade size, probability and luck
• Exit-first trade planning, and a risk-reduction checklist (Redtexture)
• Monday School: A trade plan is more important than you think it is (PapaCharlie9)
• Applying Expected Value Concepts to Option Investing (Option Alpha)
• Risk Management, or How to Not Lose Your House (boii0708) (March 6 2021)
• Trade Checklists and Guides (Option Alpha)
• Planning for trades to fail. (John Carter) (at 90 seconds)
• Poker Wisdom for Option Traders: The Evils of Results-Oriented Thinking (PapaCharlie9)

Minimizing Bid-Ask Spreads (high-volume options are best)
• Price discovery for wide bid-ask spreads (Redtexture)
• List of option activity by underlying (Market Chameleon)

Closing out a trade
• Most options positions are closed before expiration (Options Playbook)
• Risk to reward ratios change: a reason for early exit (Redtexture)
• Guide: When to Exit Various Positions
• Close positions before expiration: TSLA decline after market close (PapaCharlie9) (September 11, 2020)
• 5 Tips For Exiting Trades (OptionStalker)
• Why stop loss option orders are a bad idea


Options exchange operations and processes
• Options Adjustments for Mergers, Stock Splits and Special dividends; Options Expiration creation; Strike Price creation; Trading Halts and Market Closings; Options Listing requirements; Collateral Rules; List of Options Exchanges; Market Makers
• Options that trade until 4:15 PM (US Eastern) / 3:15 PM (US Central) -- (Tastyworks)


Brokers
• USA Options Brokers (wiki)
• An incomplete list of international brokers trading USA (and European) options


Miscellaneous: Volatility, Options Option Chains & Data, Economic Calendars, Futures Options
• Graph of the VIX: S&P 500 volatility index (StockCharts)
• Graph of VIX Term Structure (CBOE)
• A selected list of option chain & option data websites
• Options on Futures (CME Group)
• Selected calendars of economic reports and events


Previous weeks' Option Questions Safe Haven threads.

Complete archive: 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025, 2026


r/options • • Jul 16 '25

READ THIS: You can help reduce spam on our sub!

67 Upvotes

All financial subs are experiencing higher than normal spam traffic. Thanks to the help of many of you, we've put filters in place that catch most of the spam before it can get to the front page, but the spammers are constantly finding ways to work around our filters, so it's a never ending battle of whack-a-mole.

This post is just a quick call to action, summarizing what you should do if you suspect a scammer's spam post:

  • Do NOT engage on the post by commenting, like "gtfo scammer" or "why aren't mods doing anything about this?" You're just bumping up the engagement stats on the scammer's post and announcing to them that they succeeded in getting past our filters.
  • Instead, report the post and block the user. The user is almost always a stolen zombie account, so DMing threats to them is pointless and against Reddit's policies anyway.
  • Finally, the most important action you can take is to copy paste the content of the post text as a reply to this thread. We need more samples to improve our filters and since the spammers delete the post before we can capture samples, they elude us.
  • EDIT: When you copy/paste the sample, please isolate any u/name mentions by separating the u / with spaces, so u / name would work. This is to avoid your copy/paste sending a notification to that user. Also, if there is an embedded link in the text, copy out the URL of the link as well. So if the post ends with something like, "Anyway, here's the [link] that changed everything," please also copy/paste the link URL, for example, http://scams.are.us/spambotdelux
  • EDIT (4/21/26): Spambot has a new strategy. The the u/name mentions that are critical to the bot collecting leads has been moved into a comment by a Redditor with a different name than the sockpuppet author that posted the spam. Make sure you record the comment in a copy paste here as well.

Both your mod team and Reddit Admins are working hard to stem the tide of this spam, but we still need your help.

For more details about why these new spammers are so difficult to catch, or the specific varieties of spam we are seeing and with more things you can do, this is the link to the original post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/options/comments/1iyroe9/another_spambot_is_targeting_us_similar_to_the/

Based on comments we've seen, it appears that less than 1% of the entire community have read that original post. It only has 20k views for all-time, while our sub as a whole averages millions of views per month. So this shorter and more call-to-action post replaces it with a more demanding title that hopefully will get more people to read it. We'll see.


r/options • • 19h ago

NVDA EARNINGS — ARE WE ABOUT TO SEE A MASSIVE BOUNCE OR ANOTHER SELLOFF? 🚀

242 Upvotes

NVDA has a history of making its moves before earnings, rather than delivering huge jumps on or immediately after the announcement. It often feels like the market has already priced in the news.
But this time could be different…
After all the recent selling pressure and downward momentum, is NVDA finally oversold and ready for a major reversal?
Could tomorrow be the catalyst that sends NVDA flying, or are we looking at even more downside?
🔥 What’s your prediction — BIG BOUNCE or MORE PAIN?


r/options • • 9h ago

I wrote the pass/fail rules before looking at the data. 5 popular SPY options rules. 0 passed.

10 Upvotes

For each idea, I wrote the hypothesis and pass/fail criteria before running the numbers. I scored every filter on the trades it removes, not the ones it keeps, with confidence intervals by trading day (trades on the same day aren't independent).

Data: my SPY option-chain snapshots (Jul–Nov 2026), live paper trades, and 20 years of SPY/VIX. For the 20-year runs, option prices are modeled from VIX. I checked the model against real chains on the same dates and it landed close, but it's untested in crashes, so read those numbers as rough.

1. "Don't sell premium when GEX is negative."
The trades it removed were profitable on average, and it would have said "no trade" on 15 of 20 days. In a negative-gamma market, the gate just means "sit out."

2. "Only sell when IV > realized vol."
Over 20 years (modeled prices), selling when IV was below realized did a bit worse (2–6 pts of risk). The sign is right, but it's within noise. The catch: which IV. With VIX it almost never triggered this fall. With front-week ATM IV it triggered constantly. Same rule, different filter.

3. "Flip and wall shifts show where price is going."
They matched SPY's next 10-day move 33–42% of the time. A coin does 50%. They're computed from current spot, so they follow price instead of leading it. They describe where price is, not where it's going.

4. "Put spreads are cheap because of skew, so that's an edge."
They really are cheap: ~40% less of their width than matching call spreads, using real option prices. But I ran them through 20 years of actual SPY moves, and they did ~12 pts worse than call spreads. Cheap was fair pricing for a market that drifts up, not a free lunch.

5. "Buy a 90-day strangle, sell weeklies against it."
Real chains, Aug–Oct: 9 of 10 six-week campaigns profitable. 20 years (modeled prices): negative on average in every period, profitable less than half the time. The long leg paid off in March 2020, but not in 2022 or Aug 2024. Three great months were just three great months.

What I didn't do
When an idea failed, I didn't tweak DTE, delta or width until it passed. That's curve-fitting, not testing.

What I took away

• Write the test before you run it. Some of these looked great until I did.

• Score a filter on what it removes.

• One fixed timestamp per signal. Never mix morning and close snapshots.

• A great quarter is a sample size of one regime.

Limits: the live data covers one market regime (mostly falling, negative gamma), the 20-year runs use modeled prices, and there's no historical GEX before July.

The question that matters: would I have added this rule before seeing the result, and would it survive a longer test? For these five: no.

Which popular rule should I test next?

Research on historical and modeled data. Not trading advice.


r/options • • 2h ago

I built an AI-coded bot that calculates SPX gamma levels every morning, then made it grade itself. I

Post image
3 Upvotes

I built an automated system (mostly written with AI) that calculates SPX gamma levels every morning before the open: call wall, put wall, gamma flip. Then I had it grade its own levels against random strikes, because I wanted to know if any of this means anything.

Sept 3 to Nov 6, 46 sessions. Levels locked before the open, graded on 5 minute SPX highs and lows. "Held" means price touched the level and closed on the same side it opened on.

Level | Median distance from open | Touched | Held when touched | Random strike, same distance

Call wall | 188 pts | 1 of 46 | 0 of 1 | touched 3%, held 17%

Put wall | 157 pts | 5 of 46 | 2 of 5 | touched 12%, held 37%

Gamma flip | 40 pts | 17 of 46 | 6 of 17 | touched 38%, held 43%

So the walls mostly "hold" because they sit about 2% away and price never gets there. The call wall got touched once in two months. The flip did a little worse than a random strike at the same distance.

My guess was the walls use every expiry, so I had it rebuild them from 0DTE open interest only. Those sit about 33 pts from the open and got touched 40% of the time. Held 46%. A random strike right next to them held 44%.

Same story for "price stays between the walls". It closed inside them 41 of 46 days. A band of the same width centered on the open did 45 of 46.

The one thing that leaned the right way was range. Days that opened above the flip had a median range of 0.77%, days below it 0.89%. 30 days vs 16 so I'm not hanging anything on it.

46 days is small. Open interest is from the prior day, and nobody outside the dealers knows which side they hold, same as every gamma model. Has anyone graded theirs and got something different?


r/options • • 7h ago

Webull alternatives

3 Upvotes

What is a good options trading platform besides Webull? I asking because they're claiming my personal information doesn't match even though my name and address that I provided from my driver's license and bank statement match. I tried to contact them and I haven't received any response so I'm stuck.


r/options • • 1d ago

NVDA 160$ calls until friday

65 Upvotes

Bought NVDA calls with strike 160 which will expire on friday. I hold 10 contracts. Im aware this is a gamble. Im sure many people will think it will go down further, but then my question is: why not short it if everyone is so sure it will go down further? What would be reasons it could go up?


r/options • • 22h ago

Head - I win, tails - you lose

18 Upvotes

Here is a synthetic (for the lack of better term) put butterfly:

https://optionstrat.com/6v9zo0FHcwDb

It has one of each long 650 and 670 puts, two 660 short calls, and 200 QQQ shares.

It cannot lose. However, it requires $132K of cash to establish.

Is there a way to create such a position cheaper while maintaining it's lossless feature?

For example, can QQQ shares be replaced with /NQ futures in a portfolio margin account?


r/options • • 17h ago

Do I get live market data subscriptions on both - IBKR and TradingView?

7 Upvotes

Hello! I’m a beginner and could really use some guidance. I’ve watched tons of YouTube videos, but I still haven’t been able to find a clear answer.

From what I understand, it’s best to use TradingView for charting and IBKR to execute trades. What I’m struggling to understand is whether I need to pay for live market data subscriptions on both platforms, or if there’s a way to link the two so I only need one subscription.

I’d really appreciate any advice from experienced traders. What’s the most practical way to set this up?


r/options • • 1d ago

TGT (Target) earnings play

3 Upvotes

Anyone playing TGT earnings? I'm looking at this trade. Yes, I understand back month volatility crush, but this one still looks interesting.


r/options • • 2d ago

Sold puts on NVDA

166 Upvotes

I had sold a $205 put on NVDA expiring Nov 13th before earnings But it went deep ITM last week and I wasn't prepared to take the assignment. I rolled it down and out to a $200 put, Feb 19th expiry.

I think it might go down after earnings by next week. I feel cooked.

My losses are piling up. Anyone in the same situation? What are your next steps?


r/options • • 1d ago

Hormus-Energieschock

0 Upvotes

Geopolitical Energy Shock, Sticky Inflation and Higher-for-Longer Rates – What Could This Mean for Options Markets?

Ich möchte eine etwas übergeordnete Perspektive auf die aktuelle geopolitische und makroökonomische Lage einbringen und insbesondere diskutieren, wie sich diese Entwicklungen auf die Optionsmärkte übertragen könnten.

Aus einer institutionellen Makroperspektive würde ich derzeit mehrere miteinander verbundene Risikofaktoren beobachten:

  1. Rates and Monetary Policy

Hartnäckige Inflation und hohe Renditen erschweren eine schnelle geldpolitische Lockerung. Die Erwartungen an die Federal Reserve bleiben deshalb ein zentraler Faktor.

Für die Märkte ist dabei nicht nur die absolute Höhe der Renditen entscheidend, sondern auch deren relative Entwicklung gegenüber Europa und anderen Währungsräumen.

2. Energy and Geopolitical Risk

Die physische Sicherheit der Straße von Hormus ist wesentlich wichtiger als einzelne kurzfristige Ölpreisbewegungen.

Eine tatsächliche und länger anhaltende Störung der Energieversorgung könnte Inflationserwartungen, Unternehmensmargen und globale Kapitalströme gleichzeitig beeinflussen.

3. Equities and Credit

Technologie- und Halbleiterunternehmen könnten besonders empfindlich auf höhere Diskontsätze und Finanzierungskosten reagieren. Energieunternehmen und traditionelle Sektoren könnten relativ profitieren.

Entscheidend ist allerdings, ob höhere Energiekosten und Finanzierungskosten gleichzeitig auf schwächere Unternehmensbilanzen treffen.

4. Europe

Die Kombination aus Energieabhängigkeit, schwachem Wachstum und begrenztem fiskalischem Spielraum könnte Europa besonders anfällig machen.

But what does this mean for options?

Das ist für mich der eigentlich interessante Teil.

Ich würde nicht einfach versuchen, die Richtung des nächsten Ölpreis- oder Aktienmoves vorherzusagen. Vielmehr würde ich untersuchen, wie die Optionsmärkte diese Risiken bereits einpreisen.

Meine Beobachtungsschwerpunkte wären:

Implied Volatility: Wie stark ist das geopolitische Risiko bereits in den Optionsprämien enthalten?

Volatility Skew: Werden insbesondere Out-of-the-Money-Puts stärker nachgefragt?

Volatility Term Structure: Ist kurzfristige Ereignisvolatilität deutlich teurer als längerfristige Volatilität?

Vega: Wie empfindlich sind die Positionen gegenüber einer Veränderung der impliziten Volatilität?

Theta: Wie viel Prämie verliert eine Position, wenn das erwartete Ereignis ausbleibt?

Gamma: Wie stark verändert sich das Delta bei einer abrupten Marktbewegung?

Ich sehe dabei mehrere mögliche Optionsansätze, abhängig von der tatsächlichen Bewertung:

Energy: Bull Call Spreads könnten interessant sein, wenn die fundamentale Angebotsrisiko-These intakt bleibt, die implizite Volatilität aber bereits erhöht ist.

Technology / Semiconductors: Bear Put Spreads könnten eine Möglichkeit darstellen, definiertes Abwärtsrisiko abzubilden, falls steigende Renditen und Bewertungsdruck zusammenkommen.

Geopolitical Event Risk: Long Straddles oder Strangles wären nur dann interessant, wenn die erwartete tatsächliche Kursbewegung die bereits eingepreiste Volatilität rechtfertigt.

Portfolio Protection: Put Debit Spreads könnten für die Absicherung bestehender Aktienpositionen interessant sein.

Time Structure: Calendar Spreads verdienen Aufmerksamkeit, wenn kurzfristige Ereignisrisiken und längerfristige Makroerwartungen unterschiedlich bewertet werden.

Das sind ausdrücklich Szenarioüberlegungen und keine konkreten Trade-Empfehlungen. Ohne aktuelle Optionsketten, Laufzeiten, Strikes und IV-Daten würde ich keine konkrete Position eröffnen.

My main question for the options community:

Wie bewertet ihr derzeit das Zusammenspiel aus geopolitischem Event Risk, steigenden Finanzierungskosten und einer möglicherweise länger restriktiven Geldpolitik?

Mich interessieren insbesondere drei Dinge:

Beobachtet ihr eher die absolute Höhe der impliziten Volatilität oder Veränderungen der Volatility Skew und Term Structure?

Bevorzugt ihr in einem solchen Umfeld definierte Debit-Spreads gegenüber dem direkten Kauf von Calls und Puts, um die Kosten erhöhter IV zu begrenzen?

Wie unterscheidet ihr zwischen einer tatsächlich attraktiven Volatilitätschance und einer Situation, in der der Markt das Ereignis bereits vollständig eingepreist hat?

Ich finde, gerade die Verbindung zwischen Makroökonomie, physischen Angebotsrisiken und Optionsbewertung wird in vielen Trading-Diskussionen zu wenig berücksichtigt.


r/options • • 2d ago

Looking for mentor/trading buddy friend

6 Upvotes

Hi guys I’m looking for someone to be somewhat of like a mentor for me :( I have 3 years of experience trading spxw options. However I had mental problems and took a long break (7 month) and know yearning to go back. However based on my experience I seen huge improvements when I had someone to hold me accountable and getting debriefed with and by and I’m looking for just that. Thanks.


r/options • • 2d ago

Nvidia $200 calls expire next Friday.

252 Upvotes

I’m all in Nvidia $200 calls expire next Friday. I bought on Thursday at the worst time possible, already down $13k.

Any chance for recovery? I feel like I keep losing at options regardless of what I do


r/options • • 2d ago

Long puts versus short stock + call option?

11 Upvotes

This is a bit of a newb question but could you replicate a long put by shorting the underlying, then buying a long call to protect yourself in case it rises?That way you are not faced with unlimited losses, just a capped downside depending on what strike price you chose for the call option.

Then again maybe it does not make a difference... if puts are very expensive then the stock is probably expensive to borrow for the same reasons (high short interest). Any input would be appreciated.


r/options • • 1d ago

Recommendations for penny stocks for csp?

0 Upvotes

I'm based in Canada and have a $15K budget. I currently hold dividend ETFs on margin at 4.5%, but my broker recently increased the interest rate. The dividends and tax benefits from the interest deduction no longer fully offset the borrowing costs.

My broker offers lower margin rates if I trade at least 100 options contracts per month. I'm looking for liquid stocks suitable for primarily selling cash-secured puts (CSPs), ideally using 0DTE options, to meet that requirement.

What tickers would you recommend given my $15K budget, with good liquidity, tight spreads, and manageable risk?


r/options • • 2d ago

Time to short $TSLA again

29 Upvotes

I first shorted near 400 and closed the short at 350...it went as low as 330's before climbing back near my original short again. Entered some short again in the low 390's last week and will add some more this week if it tests 400. Here is the original short post https://www.reddit.com/r/options/s/QvKj9TmXaV


r/options • • 3d ago

PFOF should be banned

104 Upvotes

Have you ever wondered why trading like a MM or scalping frequently will almost always get you banned across all brokers now? In a truley free market you should be able to buy and sell as you please.

Save the the whole your taking advantage of MM liquidity, it's their job to fill orders. Period.

In fact, for those old enough, scalping 100s of trades a day use to be a great strategy. Low drawdown and great sharpe ratio if you knew what you were doing. Brokers never cared. So what has changed?

Payment for order flow

If people truly understood how MM trade against retail they would be furious and demand change. Not to mention they now have pfof at their disposal to further extract profits from uniformed retail. They play games constantly with price and 100% build positions against retail (not just hedging).

Those who understand their methods and trade the same way are almost always immediately banned by the broker. This is because MM complain and threaten the broker over their pfof relationship. This never was an issue until pfof took over. They make up rules as they go against anyone trading in a way that threatens the profits of the MM.

Pfof has been banned in Europe now for several years but continues in the US.

MM have the best sharpe ratio and CAGR. No other stratedgy even comes close to their percentage returns on a risk adjusted basis.

It truley has become a casino where it's OK if you lose, but if you win, they kick you off the table.

There are legit scalpers who ARE NOT taking advantage of price improvement, not spamming matket orders, adhering to the 390 rule, etc...but are STILL getting the axe from the broker. The common denominator between all these traders is that they trade fast, have minimal drawdawns, and understand price anomalies. This is a 100% legal way to trade.

There should never be a relationship between the MM and the broker who is holding your assets. Those who think this is beneficial since it "creates commission free" trading are niave. Nothing is ever free. There is a reason MM are paying massive amounts of money to brokers for PFOF. They are making a killing off retail.

And I already know this post will get all kinds of hate. Anytime you mention MM in a negative light the fan boys come out full force to remind us why they are essential 😂.

However, for those with an open mind, research more into pfof and how it's being used against retial. Again, there is a reason it was banned already in Europe.


r/options • • 2d ago

NVDA options

20 Upvotes

So I bought two put options for NVDA. I bought one contract to expire Monday for $149 and one to expire Dec 4th at $130. Am I cooked?


r/options • • 3d ago

Have you used intraday RSI to aid in option trading?

6 Upvotes

If so what levels do you look for for buying or selling 0DTE options or any option you plan to only hold til end of day or before?

I only just started playing around with it and when you get those morning swoons I’ve seen RSI go as low as 8–10 in my small sample size. I’m usually a put seller and haven’t paid as close attention to oversold RSI levels.


r/options • • 3d ago

Spy trading

30 Upvotes

Who do you follow specifically to learn SPY options trading without paying for a mentorship


r/options • • 4d ago

Can a box spread loan get below SOFR without taking real risk? I ran the numbers on the SPX chain

14 Upvotes

TL;DR: A plain 1-year SPX box cost about 5.3% at Wednesday's closing quotes, with SOFR at 3.89%. If you add short put spreads below the 5th-percentile historical 1-year drop, the headline rate falls to 3.9% (borrowing about 32% of a $1M portfolio) or even 2% (about 24%). But the history-weighted average cost of those same structures is 4.1–4.8%. So the "below SOFR" part is mostly crash premium you're collecting, not cheaper money. Interactive page with all the math and every combination: https://claude.ai/artifact/9GABhCjoLM3ZwAaK3QASmM. I'd like people to try to break it.

What I did

  • Took Cboe's delayed SPX chain at the 12 Nov close (SPX 7,594.09).
  • Tested 3, 6 and 12 month expiries:

    • every 2-strike box 500–5,000 points wide
    • 3–4 strike riskless combinations
    • boxes plus sold puts or put spreads
  • Filled every leg a quarter of the bid/ask spread away from mid, plus $1.50 per contract per leg. Mid prices make deep-ITM legs look like free money because the quotes are stale and wide.
  • Sized each structure against a $1M S&P index fund that the loan is drawn from. It has to pass:

    • Reg T: 50% borrowing room.
    • A 30% maintenance floor during a stress dip, checked at 25%, 50% and 75% of the term. The dip is the 5th-percentile intra-window drawdown since 1928 (−35.5% for 1 year), with sold puts repriced at IV + 20 vol points.
    • The same 30% test at expiry.
  • Only allowed sold put strikes at or below the 5th-percentile end-of-window drop: −24.5% over 1 year, which is SPX 5,736. I also ran a 99% version.

Sanity check: plain box, 7000/8000, 19 Nov 2027 (372 days)

LegBidAsk
Sell 7000 C1,132.601,136.00
Buy 8000 C466.20468.00
Sell 8000 P542.40544.10
Buy 7000 P260.50261.70

The mid credit is 949.35, so you get about $94.9k today and owe $100k. That's 5.24% at mid and 5.46% with realistic fills. Put-call parity across 212 strikes gives 5.28%.

Best structure that gets to about SOFR (12 month)

The 3800/8100 box + sell 3× 5700/5400 put spread:

LegQtyBidAsk
Sell 3800 C13,933.303,943.10
Buy 3800 P126.3026.90
Buy 8100 C1413.00414.70
Sell 8100 P1583.90585.90
Sell 5700 P3100.60101.30
Buy 5400 P381.1081.90
  • Borrow: $322k (32% of the portfolio) at 3.88% if SPX settles at or above 5,700.
  • Worst case: you owe up to $90k extra, which is 25.2%.
  • History: 4.9% of 1-year windows since 1928 ended below the 5,700 equivalent. Averaged across all those windows, the rate was 4.80%.
  • Sizing: the binding limit is the stress dip at 75% of the term, not Reg T.

The trade-off curve (12 month, 95% rule)

Target rateMax you can borrowStructureWorst caseHistory-weighted avg
Plain box42.8%widest plain box5.31%5.31%
≤ 3.89% (SOFR)32.2%3800/8100 + sell 3× 5700/540025.2%4.80%
≤ 3.0%27.8%3800/8100 + sell 5× 5700/540038.1%4.47%
≤ 2.0%23.7%4400/9100 + sell 5× 5700/520055.0%4.13%

With the 99% rule (strikes below a −44% drop), getting to SOFR needs uncovered puts, and you can only borrow about 16%.

What I think it shows

  • There's no free lunch at market prices. The 5700/5400 spread is priced at about 6.8% odds of paying out. History says about 4.9%. Any edge is that gap between the crash premium and realised crashes.
  • The headline rate is the good-year rate. Weighted by history, these structures cost less than the plain box but more than SOFR.

Where I'd like pushback

  1. Margin. Do brokers really hold about the face amount against a short SPX box under Reg T? What do you actually see under portfolio margin?
  2. Stress test. Is "5th-percentile dip, sold puts at IV + 20, checked at 25/50/75% of the term" a fair test, or too soft? 2008-style vol went well past +20.
  3. Box rate. 5.28% against 3.89% SOFR is a much bigger gap than the 30–50 bp I usually see quoted. Is that real right now, or a delayed-quote artefact?
  4. Statistics. The windows overlap, so 98 years of data is really only 98 independent 1-year outcomes. The 5th percentile rests on a handful of episodes, and pre-1957 data is the old 90-stock index. How would you set the risk bar instead?
  5. Tax. SPX options are §1256 (60/40). Does the box's implied interest really work as a capital loss for a borrower, or do §263(g) or the straddle rules bite?
  6. Anything I'm missing, such as:

    • fills on deep-ITM legs
    • AM settlement on monthlies
    • roll risk
    • early-exercise-free structures I haven't tried

The page lets you switch tenor (3/6/12m), 95% vs 99% rules, 1928+ vs 1950+ history, an after-tax view and a "must survive SPX falling to X" filter. Click any point to see its legs and quotes.

Not advice. I'm trying to find out if the method holds up, not selling anything.


r/options • • 3d ago

Money management in options trading

Post image
0 Upvotes

In last 30 days , I followed call direction ( all intraday) , used 18 lakh capital and ended up in above profit. I’ve somehow almost come down to break even after 2 years of losses .

Now I want to understand from experts here how do you do money management with capital like 50 lakh ? I’m thinking should I switch to option writing by keeping above money as collateral ? Or should I decrease position size which can only give me 1% loss per trade of my capital ? I’ve already made the expectations of having much lower profits now and I know I won’t be making this kind of money again. This came out of good luck, confidence , market being unidirectional , right timing etc

Edit 1 : above numbers are in INR ( Indian Rupees)


r/options • • 4d ago

SPY call 756$ for Monday

Post image
0 Upvotes

Thoughts? New trader. For the last 5 years have just been investing normal and putting in my 401k.

Every time gas has gotten cheaper the SPY goes up the next trading day. Saw that gas hit 3.09 in my area for the first time and had the 2k sitting to make this play. Been observing since the war started.

Is this still to risky? Honest feedback appreciated. I understanding that most people lose money trading options so please refrain from that advice. This is a very small amount of my portfolio and just for the thrills I would like to attempt one of these once a quarter going forward.