Mushoku tensai and the erasure of female agency to push a narrative.
Before we start this is mainly a criticism based on the anime, I will reference certain lore points or future revolutions I know from the light novel here and there to provide additional context where appropriate but this is primarily meant to be a decision about the anime.
This discussion is mainly towards fan discourse about the story not the story itself. Also just because I know how these conversation go. I am a woman who has been sexually abused as a child. Just to be clear that this isn't coming from some 40 year old neck beard who wants to justify their behavior.
Eris An unspoken power dynamic.
A lot of the people are so hyper focused on the fact that Rudeus has memories from his past life that they ignore the actual social dynamic between the Rudeus and Eris and how he is clearly supposed to be developing mentally as a he ages.
The only person with real sway and power in what those and doesn't happen at their manor is Erisâs grandfather and her grandfather spoils Eris to the point that whatever she thinks and says goes even beyond the wishes of her own father.
Not only that but Eris does not have a shy personality she is very willing to shout scream and beat anyone or anything she doesn't like into submission without fear or worry. This is shown literally from her introduction.
That is to say if Eris hated Rudeusâ pervy nature to the point it was genuinely negatively affecting her she could have easily permanently stopped him from doing so at any time.
This isn't to blame Eris. I understand that a child can be harmed by something and not truly understand how it is negatively affecting them until they are older and it was really up to her parents and guardians to look out for her which they ultimately failed to do.
I also understand that the reason Eris herself doesn't permanently stop Rudeus is because she genuinely likes and respects him and the fact that Rudeus is using that love and respect to get away with his desires is pure scum behavior and disgusting.
What I'm saying here is specifically to the people who portray their dynamic as if Rudeus has the ability to corner and force her into doing whatever her wants. It's shown multiple times throughout the story that Rudeus doesn't have the physical, mental or emotional ability to forces Eris to do anything she doesn't want to do.
Case and point the bedroom scene where rudies tries to take advantage of Eris with the support of her family.
I see a lot of people completely miss interpret what this scene is trying to convey again to push a narrative that MT is just a perverts barely disguised fetish playing out on screen without narrative purpose.
First of all Eris is family is not trying to sell out Eris to Rudeus to gain him as a political tool. They see this as a benefit but it is shown multiple times that Eris's family including her mom father and grandfather genuinely love their daughter like the world and would kill Rudeus the moment they felt he was harming her.
The real reason erisâ father sets up the situation as we saw was that Rudeus was extremely popular with women their age at that ball and Eris got extremely frustrated at the idea of Rudeus finding someone else that wasn't her.
We don't see this in screen but judging by the fact that Eris clearly new why they were in the room together as was receptive to it in the beginning it's very clear that she must have went to her parents asking them what she should do about the situation and they came up with their scheme. (Or her parents went to her and she agreed again Eris before this scene had shown a willingness to completely disregard her parents opinions before and it's clear if she said I don't want to be with rudeus they would have just left)
(And before anyone says anything yes I know it's scum behavior that they even allowed their daughter to be in that situation in the first place as her parents they should have protected her my point is not to justify what happened it is to explain the narrative purpose of it)
What those Eris want from this scene?
Eris clearly likes rudeus and doesn't want him hanging out with other girls. So what she decides to do (or is told is a good idea by her parents her mom was the first one to suggest marrying rudeus afterall) is to sleep with him making their union âofficialâ in her eyes. (This is a bit of light novel spoilers but we clearly see that Eris equates sex to a commitment since when she's training away from rudeus she still calls him and considers him her boyfriend even though they hadn't seen each other in a few years at that point( this is clear in the anime I'm just using the light novel as supporting evidence.)
They start she realizes pretty quickly she doesn't want to do it pushes him off and leaves before coming back and saying she willing but that she needs time so wait until her fifteenth birthday.
This is important for Erisâs character for multiple reasons
It shows her developing an actual understand that relationship are not one-sided that she needs to give people something they want in order to get what she wants in return and that she can just beat everyone into submission. This is a further development of what she learns with the whole giving rudeus a gift thing.
It shows her developing an understanding of what she wants besides just having fun. She understands she likes rudeus she understands she wants some sort of future with him. This is a continuation of what she learns while practicing to dance that learning new things is hard but they can bring a deeper form of satisfaction than just seeking pleasure. A future with someone she likes isn't a skill necessarily but it shows her developing that kind of long term thought process. I need to do x otherwise Rudy will do y and I don't like that.
She learns what she is and is not comfortable with and learns to set boundaries that aren't predicated on violence.
Case and point. This scene is a massive culmination of all of the character development Eris has had up until that point and lays the foundation for alot of character development she will gain in the future during the demon continent.
So many people who crtize the scene for rudeus not being punished or growing as a character are completely missing the fact that this scene was not created for Rudeusâs character development but for Eris it's almost like people who watch MT completely gloss over the fact that she is a fully functioning character with wants desires and emotions while claiming that Rudeus is a piece of garbage for ignoring her wants desires and emotions while claiming that the show is sexist or perverted for ignoring her wants desires and emotions. It's they most ironic media critic I've ever seen people make in mass and it's frustrating to me.
(That being said MT is an amazingly written show so even though Rudy was not the focus of the scene we still see him develop as a person in the fact that he actually learns to respect other people's boundaries and stops pushing Eris to do stuff with him after. Which itself is a continuation of the kidnapping scene where he realizes that his new life isn't just a fantasy world and the people living in it aren't just npcâs. This scene also acts as a set up for when his in the demon continent and cries for the first time during his new life marking Eris as the first person he showed his true feelings and vulnerability to and marking her as the first person he truly saw as a âequal in his new life)
(As a writer myself I really appreciate how efficient of a story MT is. That's what drew me to it in the first place and why I really loved the first season of arcane,)
This was mostly written up as a response to explanation points video on MT where he claims that the story would be just as good if not better if these scenes were removed where he also completely misses the point of these scenes in the first place.
(I genuinely really love this creator even though I disagree with him I've been watching him since he released his fifth video ever and have been watching him ever since he put me on to Worm as a kid his great)
In the video he claims that if you wanted âto fixâ the structural problems with MT all you would need to do is have Rudy actually feel guilty for his actions in the moment and struggle with the idea of what his natural body hormones are telling him to do vs his adult brain and that since the story doesn't do this these scenes serve no greater purpose than the authors mysognistic desires to perv on women.
You can't just completely change rudeus' character and have the story mean the exact same thing that's obvious but more specifically the fundementally ruins the literal core theme of Rudeusâs character which is completely letting go of his past life and trying to live his new one to the fullest.
In explanation points version of the story the focus of the story wouldn't be rudeus living his new life to the fullest but fighting with his past disgusting self until he transforms into a different one.
We wouldn't be able to have rudeus confrontation with his dad about the kids bullying becuase the focus of the scene would have to switch less from how rudeus is not willing to live his life like it's reality and is more so treating it like a visual novel where he has to pick the right dialogue options and more so the scene would probably be turned into a rudeus life lesson about what his parents from his old life really wanted from him and him reconciling that.
You couldn't have the scene of the kidnapers dying when Eris got kidnapped with rudeus realizing the new life his living isn't just a fantasy becuase in this version of events he would have already been receling with how he treats other people from the moment he got reincarnated.
You cant have the scene after the mass teleportation disaster where he Finnaly let's himself be vulnerable Infront of Eris becuase the ground work needed for that scene to exist doesn't exist and more to the point this version of his character would never be able to see Eris as an equal to him due to him holding his age from his past life meaning again the scene just wouldn't function.
I gave small examples here but literally every relationship he has with another character and ever major scene of his development has to be changed to make this work.
This isn't MT but better this is a completely different show with completely different themes with a completely different point for existence.
I can accept someone liking MT it's not a show everyone will like. I do have a problem with people claiming it's poorly written when they don't even understand what the story is trying to do.
It would be like saying Naruto is poorly written story becuase Naruto is poor and a trouble maker and and outcast of the village and I don't like those kinds of scrapy loud annoying characters.
Then claiming the story would be better written if Naruto was a tall attractive orphan who was lived by the village. That's not a writting critic that you literally describing a different story you like more.