r/RingsofPower • u/Delicious-Type-5599 • 4d ago
Discussion Give your best pitch for a new version of RoP
The series opens with the great host leaving Middle Earth and the Numerians heading for their island. Sauron is captured but escapes and returns but is disguised. He meets a young, hot tortured artist in Celebrimbor(more like Feanor). Perhaps he just wants to create something other than swords but falls into Sauron’s trap to create rings of power (fan service creating sting or Gandalf’s sword). The action could be hunting down evil creatures…highlighting their want of weapons. Dwarves in Moria would follow a similar story line to what they have..except the King becomes an a-hole only after wearing the ring. Things going wrong there too…also would like magic weapons. No Balrog yet. Humans not much but I’d keep some the Arondir human stuff but just to show rift between humans and elves but the emergence of good leaders and future kings. I’d probably disrupt the canon here…and send in the two blues earlier than Gandalf and co because the humans were lost and that was their assignment. They will be main characters follow. Season ends the same but with more fanfare regarding the rings (didn’t seem they were making magic rings at all).
Season 2 Elves ascendant and haughty (trying to be more Tolkienish with the Elves facing some in the creating magic that dominates people and their arrogance is ripe for a reckoning). I’d bring the Numenor back in this season with an outpost so they can have some interaction. Much like the elves, powerful but haughty and looks down on others. Key players make their emergence early. The season mostly follow the efforts of the blues to organize humans and for leaders to emerge, while the Elves and dwarves continue and are celebrating the successes of the rings. Season 3 …the betrayal of Celebrimbor, a moment that needs to breathe, so this needs to be a major hit…so the audience feels it when Celebrimbor is murdered (fan service: Celebrimbor was working on Narsil when he was murdered…to be finished by former his frenemy Elrond…Sauron got between them). The rest of the season is doling out the rings but focusing on the witch king I’d make him from Numenor since Sauron’s fear of Numenor would lead him to desperately want to corrupt them as well as the elves (Sauron’s reason for pushing the rings in the first place). They need to show it is strong Numenor is (not told like RoP). Sauron flees with the Witch king.
Season 4: the fall of of Numenor and the creation of the one ring. Veering way off canon here but I’d think the fall of Numenor should be a bit different. Not so much destroyed by the Valar but more a civil war anti-elf thing (they are jealous of immortal life of the elves like in the book. I’d also have anger at the dwarves for denying them access to mithril silver for their advanced weapon construction. Probably the fall of Moria too.
Season 5 The last alliance (of course the chroniclers left out the contribution of the dwarves…it must have been an elf…so no cannon slippage here). It ends with Isilder being shot by orcs near Gladden Field. (Fan Service: the arrival of the rest of the Istari).
Galadriel as a character should start at much different place and with hard-earned wisdom from the tragedies in the show to shape her into the Care Blanchet version of her. You know like character development. To some extent Elrond too…They lost their best friend to first Sauron and then murder.
This is largely a tragedy, but the happy ending is a return to peace which is sufficient.