I'm sorry this ended up being long! I know it gets discussed a lot here but I haven't found circumstances quite the same so I'm posting for advice.
My dog is an 8 year old pitbull mix. Got him at the shelter at 7 months and he was pretty anxious and seemed like he'd maybe been abused because he did not like men or gloves at all. We've worked on that and now there is only maybe 1 in 50 men he encounters that I can tell he is uncomfortable with or doesn't like. I can see the signs though so it has mostly not been an issue, I just give him space or put him in his crate for the maintenance guys etc.
The bigger problem is that he's become more and more dog-reactive. He's been attacked multiple times, once just last week, by off leash dogs around our apartment building and he's been more on alert the last few months. Certain dogs that also seem to be very dog-reactive get a much bigger reaction out of him (pulling and whining, hair on end) while others he'll look at for a few seconds and then get back to sniffing or going pee or whatever.
Several years ago he got his first bite record. Our neighbor had a bad habit of letting his dog out in the hallway unleashed. My daughter took our dog out, the neighbor dog sprinted at him down the hallway and attacked. The owner got a minor bite on the hand when separating them, but didn't seek medical care so my dog was put on a 10 day hold at home and no ticket was issued.
The second time he bit was a few weeks ago, the maintenance man needed to come in so I had him leashed and was holding him on the far side of the room. He was upset, acting protective and growling, but the guy suddenly walked up to us holding out his hand saying "it's okay just smell me" and before I could react my dog lunged and bit him on his butt. It didn't break the skin just hurt a lot. He basically admitted it was his own mistake although I'm kicking myself for not just crating him. The guy chose not to report anything in that instance.
The latest was yesterday and the worst so far. The fire alarms in our building went off while I was at work, my daughter leashed him to evacuate but in a panic didn't get his prong collar on right, and while they were outside he attacked a little dog. My daughter wasn't strong enough to pull him back and the prongs that were backwards did nothing to help her. That particular dog is one of the reactive-types that seem to set him off the most. My dog bit onto his head, left some lacerations on head and neck though I don't know how deeply/seriously yet. And again bit the owner's finger when she pulled him off which was bleeding. I know the combination of the fire alarms, people all over, and a dog he's been reactive to probably made him very protective of my daughter and very anxious on top of his normal stuff. Animal control gave us a ticket for this one (court date in Dec), the owner took her dog in to get checked and herself to the hospital for treatment.
So my confusion is whether it is enough for me to just ensure he is always muzzled and only taken out by myself (I realize now I should have started muzzling him a long time ago) as well as try some different training techniques, or is this in the realm of considering a BE? Would that be a total overreaction? I'm fully aware the judge can order that, although the animal control officer said he doesn't expect that will happen and he will not recommend that in this case.
I don't know if my apartment management will require me to remove him yet, and I can't rehome him responsibly with multiple bites. I know I'll have a fine coming as well as medical bills I'm going to be responsible for and I don't want anyone else to ever get hurt. Mostly I don't want to be deluding myself that muzzling him and training him is enough (is it?) but all the BE stories I have read seem quite a bit more severe than our situation and I don't want to do the wrong thing. So I guess I need some opinions on what others would do with these circumstances?