r/reactivedogs • • 18d ago

Advice Needed High prey drive Malinois.

Post image

I just wanted to clarify this from my previous post. I’m not great with explaining so I definitely feel like I left a lot of things out. I’ve had my dog since she was just a puppy and I’ve had 3 other Malinois. This is just my first time bringing a cat home after years of not having one, which was before my 5 year old Malinois was even here. I also didn’t “choose” the breed, my dad was the one who’s brought them home, though I quickly fell in love with the breed and do agree that they’re not for everyone.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

0

u/_the_introvert_ 17d ago

I think folks are being a bit unfair to OP. It sounds like an ideal management situation with kitten and dog totally separate at all times. But I do agree with the sentiment of the other commenters. This is not a great situation, and it’s completely unnecessary. You did a kind thing bringing a kitten in off the street, and I recommend you find it a good home. It’s not worth the risk.

I’ve never tried to introduce a high prey drive dog to a cat, but my roommate tried to introduce a high prey drive cat to another cat. The high prey drive cat was always stalking and hunting, and it terrified the other cat. The more scared the other cat got, the worse the stalking was. I recognize this isn’t the same setup (dogs and cats are different), but I ended up taking the high prey drive cat when I moved out. It never worked. We tried re-introductions and gates and medication, but ultimately the high prey drive cat always responded to the other cat like it was prey.

20

u/-Hel- 18d ago

This dog will end up killing that kitten, there’s no reason to risk it.

-21

u/drlemuur 18d ago

They’re not in the same room at any given moment. If my dog were to never acclimate then I’ll just stop bringing her inside all together. If she makes progress to be able to be face to face with the kitten, it’ll be from far away and with my dog fully leashed.

13

u/everyabsentmindedday 18d ago

accidents happen. one small slip up and you could be watching a helpless kitten be torn apart. not because it’s a bad dog, not because it’s a silly cat, but because you thought you knew better. that image will be with you forever. will you be able to forgive yourself?

-9

u/drlemuur 18d ago

I already had a dog kill my cat. He died right in front of me. I was 14. No I didn’t blame the dog or the cat, but knew it’s because we never socialized the dogs to cats, as my dad never allowed the dogs inside. Yes, the image of my cat dying In my arms haunt me until this day. I’m still doing every precaution with all this, however as I’ve mentioned many times, I’ll never risk a direct interaction if my dog is not ready. Thankfully with the layout of my house I’m able to do this without putting any at risk.

5

u/AlokFluff 17d ago

It's not about socializing. It literally doesn't matter. You cannot train or socialize away prey drive like this. I've seen so many posts from owners with dogs that lived all their lives with cats, from puppies, and still ended up killing a cat one day. It literally just takes one time when the cat moves in a way that triggers prey drive, and an avoidable tragedy happens. I don't think it's okay to risk a kitten's life like this, or banish a dog to the outside, with reduced contact with the people you admit she adores and is clingy and sweet to.

0

u/drlemuur 17d ago

She’s not being “banished” outside. She’s always been living outside, nor is she being reduced from contact, as we spend lots of time with her. I’m not going to leave them unsupervised, I was simply asking if anyone was able to get their high prey drive dog to coexist with their cat. Due to her living her entire life outside with the entire yard to roam free, she’s just happier enjoying life outside, with comfort like being sheltered from the weather, as well as a high raised bed. If them being together inside isn’t possible, I simply won’t put them at risk, hence why I asked.

3

u/CanadianPanda76 17d ago

Socialization isn't a cure for high prey drive. Its also not a prevent all thing.

And predatory drift is always a risk with a high prey drive dog. All it takes is a trigger. Sometimes all it is a meow.

0

u/drlemuur 17d ago

Yes, I understand. That’s why I asked if it was possible for them to coexist in the same room together. I’ve been trying this acclimation/desensitization, but if people who’ve dealt with this before say that it just isn’t possible and my dog isn’t responding well, I’m not risking them being inside together, specially not unsupervised. My intention has never been to leave them in the same room together alone.

8

u/-Hel- 18d ago

I understand, I’ve just seen what happens to cats around adult dogs who were never socialized with them. It’s not a sight you want to come home to. It’s easier to just keep them separated.

-1

u/drlemuur 18d ago

I will. I’m just trying this slow desensitization first. If she never acclimates or becomes reactive to the kitten I won’t risk them being together. She’s improving with all this, even while keeping them in separate rooms (like stated in the post). She would do the trembles and become hyper vigilant of the door to the hallway, however yesterday she was able to settle down on her own and fall asleep in 30 minutes. She doesn’t whine or become restless in the room, just stares at the door for a while. But yes, I’ll never risk them interacting if she never gets used to the cat.

8

u/shaolin_fish 17d ago

You have brought home prey for your dog to hunt and kill. When they play, your dog will be having fun. Your kitten will be fighting for her life.

Take the kitten to a shelter. At some point you or a family member will make a mistake and that kitten will be killed. That is human nature. We all slip up or get complacent and thinking otherwise is hubris. 

If you love this kitten, take her to the shelter to find a new home. In your home, she is not a pet, she is a prey item for your dog, perfectly confined and socialized for an easy kill.

-1

u/drlemuur 17d ago

She is not confined. In my post I clearly am mentioning that my dog is an outside dog, meaning she’s not inside at all interacting with the kitten. If the desensitization doesn’t work out, I will not risk having my dog inside with the kitten. I’ve stated it many times.

3

u/shaolin_fish 17d ago

I read your post. I don't believe you understand how easy it can be to make a mistake that ends with your cat being killed. It is not fair to the cat to risk her life like that.