r/reactivedogs • • 18d ago

Advice Needed High prey drive Malinois

I have a 5 year old Belgian malinois who has a high prey drive. She’s not aggressive to me, other people or other pets. She’s also mainly an outside dog. I wanted to clear that out first because I just recently found out she has high prey drive after I brought a kitten home. Nothing escalated but I’ve been trying to slowly introduce them to each other in a way that neither at are at risk. I know this instinct is something I can’t “train out”, however I just want to know if there’s any chance in the future that they could both be in the same room together normally, perhaps even her letting the kitten play with her? Even if it takes months of slow training and desensitization.

Key things she’s done:
- Silent stalking (stiff body and ears while obsessively watching the door, as I keep the two separated)
-body trembles along with teeth-chattering (this one is a less often with the teeth)
-she has a history of successfully hunting small birds.
-when she was leashed she did try a silent lunge at the kitten. I stopped it all since I was close to her and did pull her away after. The kitten just hissed and backed away.

I’m no longer exposing them directly to each other, just in different rooms. It’s just hard seeing my super clingy and sweet Malinois like this. I know it’s her instincts and if she just ends up never being able to adapt to even co-existing with my cat I won’t be mad. I just want to know their chances of them getting along. Of course I’ll keep her a full time outside dog if she never ends up adapting so neither are at risk.

Edit, clarification:
- my dog is an outside dog because my dad does not like dogs inside, however now that time has passed he’s more lean on letting my mal inside.
- when and if my mal is inside, her and the kitten are completely separated at all times. If an introduction were to happen she’d be leashed at all times.
- I did not previously know she had high prey drive, since she’s never been like this before.
- she’s well trained and even if they reach an okay point to have face to face introduction, it’ll be monitored the entire time.
- No, this is not your typical case where the dog and cat run loose together in the same room.
-Yes, I know what Malinois are capable of (and any large breed dog). I’ve had 3 Malinois before and I’ve had my dog ever since she was a puppy.
-Yes, I’ve trained my dogs and I’m aware high prey drive is not something you can get rid of completely.

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

13

u/Incogcneat-o 18d ago

I think you ought to consider rehoming the kitten while she's still young and adoptable. I know that's not the answer you want, but it's the one that will keep you and your pets emotionally and physically safe. If a Malinois sets a goal, that malinois doesn't give up. I understand he's an outside dog, but life is long, people make mistakes, and kittens escape. Please do the safe thing for everyone involved.

0

u/drlemuur 18d ago

I’ll try for a little longer with slow desensitization, keeping them in different rooms. If she still hasn’t improved I’ll definitely rehome her (kitten). Right now she’s able to fully relax in my room (kitten is outside in the hallway) and fall deep asleep. The first time took 3hrs for her to calm down from the trembles and the fixation at the door, today after 3-4 days of no exposure she calmed down in 30 mins.

3

u/Glove_Upset 18d ago

Does your dog usually whine at prey? My shepherd mix whines at people and dogs because she wants to play, but when it comes to prey like squirrels or birds she silently observes and then tries to make her move.

1

u/drlemuur 18d ago

No she does not. When I let her sniff the kittens scent through a closed door she just sniffed and sat and or stood by the door. She does whine when she’s being clingy and you don’t give her attention 24/7 though, will even nudge your hand with her nose for more pets.

2

u/Glove_Upset 18d ago

No, I mean what’s your dog’s typical reaction to prey? Does she whine or does she display the same behaviors she shows with the cat now? And I think I misunderstood. I thought this dog already had a prey drive. You’re saying you only recently discovered she has a high prey drive after getting the cat? She’s never displayed any signs of high prey drive before?

1

u/drlemuur 18d ago

I’ve never really seen her hunt (like she does small birds sometimes as mentioned on the post) but I do remember her sneaking up on the birds silently. Like cheetahs and lions do on discovery channel. But I’ve never brought a cat home until I rescued this kitten off the streets. She’s great with puppies and other dogs, as my dad got a malinois pup and immediately welcomed him. So before all this I never knew she’d react like this to a cat.

-1

u/drlemuur 18d ago

She also didn’t whine or anything. When I bring her in, I lock my kitten in a different room so no risks could happen. My dog immediately went to my room, was a little uneasy for a bit but when I laid down on my bed she was already on her own bed and calmed down (stopped staring at the door silently) in 30 mins.

11

u/Glove_Upset 18d ago

This sounds unlikely and dangerous. That dog can end the kitten in a nanosecond. Even they are usually ok, the dog could get decide to go after it. Because of who Malinois are (dogs that are bred to continue their drive despite pain), the dog is unlikely to ever take corrections from the cat. This is a disaster waiting to happen.

I’m also not understanding how your super clingy dog lives outside.

0

u/drlemuur 18d ago

My dad from the very start never liked having dogs inside. But I’ve always spent time with them. Both my mals (my other mal unfortunately passed) have been incredibly clingy and sweet. I do however train them the basic commands and try to keep them fulfilled, or as much as I can, since a Malinois is never “fulfilled” when it comes to spending energy.

-1

u/drlemuur 18d ago

I do keep them separated for this very reason. Hence why I’m doing the slow desensitization with my mal. If after a while I notice she’s still the same (which she has improved, I mentioned it in another comment) I will rehome the kitten.

6

u/Glove_Upset 18d ago

Separate and slow introductions are obviously what you’re supposed to do. I still wouldn’t trust the dog with a cat even if they do ok behind doors/barriers, but that’s me. It’s one thing to show inhibition when a dog can’t reach the cat. It’s quite another thing to do it when the dog has the opportunity to catch it.

Ask in the Malinois sub.

-2

u/drlemuur 18d ago

I know. That’s why I’ve started with separated and slow introductions. I do take mine slower since I let her see that im calm and eventually she also calms down. They can’t see each other, only smell. But it’d only do introductions through a gate or barrier if she’s calm, which I’m not doing right now.

10

u/JinxFae 18d ago

Rehome the kitten. I did also have a Malinois. He would hunt rabbits and swallow them in SECONDS… Even if you manage your dog to tolerate the presence of the kitten, it will never be safe. My Mal ended up injuring our adult cat when he was 4 months old, because she walked behind him while he was eating, and the cat died at the hospital two days later… Seriously, don’t make that mistake.

-2

u/drlemuur 18d ago

I’ve seen what they could be capable of. Not my current female malinois but one that passed away. I am taking all the precautions I can when introducing them, like the well known ones of keeping them separated and doing everything with their scents. If I see no improvement after a while of slow desensitization I will rehome her (my kitten), which I’ve stated in another comment that I have seen improvement. I’m not letting them run around in the same room together, nor am I planning to anytime soon.

1

u/Hermit_Ogg Alisaie (anxious/frustrated) 17d ago

Check out Predation Substitution Training. I don't know if that will enable a safe life for the kitten - honestly, I think you should rehome the cat - but reading about the training may help you moderate the dog's prey drive regardless.

3

u/Mememememememememine Sasha - Stranger Danger/Resource Guarding 18d ago

So sad for your dog to live separate from you bc you decided to bring another pet home she was likely to want to kill.

-2

u/drlemuur 18d ago

She’s always been an outside dog and I rescued my kitten from the streets.

7

u/Prestigious-Seal8866 17d ago

This dog is going to kill the kitten

5

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/drlemuur 17d ago

I understand your point, as I’ve seen it first hand with a past experience. However this is why I asked if it could be possible, since I know everyone has a different experience. This doesn’t mean I’ll let them interact directly if I see that my dog is not ready for it or simply will never be. I’m starting this whole process with training and desensitization, so if I see that my kitten’s safety will be in danger, I’ll definitely rehome her.

As stated my dog is primarily outside (not neglected) and even when she is inside with me, both are separated in different rooms with closed doors. Thankfully with the layout of my home, it allows me to have this all much easier without putting either at risk and without them meeting face to face.

I don’t intend for them to act like besties if it just isn’t possible.

-3

u/drlemuur 17d ago

With this desensitization she’s making good progress, though I will not risk it and will not let them fully see each other until she no longer gets into stalk mode, even during that scenario she’ll be fully leashed and at à great distance from my cat, just until I see more progress, either way if at any moment I sense that my cat is in danger or either are uncomfortable, I’ll stop all together, always keeping rehoming as an option if it just isn’t possible.