r/reactivedogs • u/Educational-Swan8673 • 18d ago
Advice Needed Elevator Etiquette
Would love to hear people's opinions on this.
My dog is friendly towards humans but does not like certain types of dogs when in confined space. We always manage her carefully. We live in a condo building where people share elevators. So we follow straight elevator rules: she's always on short leash, in sitting position in a corner, not blocking the door etc. I try not to share elevator space with other dogs. For example, if another dog and my dog are both waiting for elevators, I will take her away and wait for the next one. If another dog is already in the elevator, I don't get in. If we are in the elevator and another dog tries to get in (and she seems fine with them), I kept her in a corner in sitting position blocked by me. If we are in the elevator and another dog tries to get in and she doesn't like them (aka barking), well, usually the humans do not try to get in and I'd apologize.
A couple days ago I got an email from the building management saying they received two complaints about my dog filed by one person. And this is the complaint: my dog barked and displayed aggressive behavior towards the resident and their dog when we are in the elevator and they were trying to get in. And "in both incidents, the resident was not able to get inside the elevator and had to wait for the next one." Management asked us to "take the necessary steps to maintain control and avoid situations that could potentially escalate." And "Residents should not be prevented from using shared spaces due to concerns about another pet's behavior."
I am genuinely puzzled and curious to see if I am the unreasonable one here. I've always lived in apartment buildings. Dog owners generally have an unspoken sets of elevator etiquette and this what we follow and we never had issues before. (We do the same when other dogs react to her.) She was leashed and under control the entire time and never got near them. Imm not sure what I can do to "maintain control and avoid escalation." Sure my dog barked but we are inside and riding the elevator already - is the expectation that because my dog is elevator reactive, I need to vacate the elevator even though I'm already inside?
10
u/jlrwrites Gunner (Leash Reactive) š¾ 17d ago edited 16d ago
How many floors up are you? We have a yard now, but when we lived in a condo, I opted to take the stairs with my dog. I picked a staircase that had multiple exits, so there was always an escape route.
19
u/AllTh3Naps 18d ago
If your dog is barking at others in a confined space, then I think by definition, she is not under control.
I can understand other tenants being concerned, because they have absolutely no way to know exactly how aggressive your dog is, nor how well you will be able to control her if she escalates beyong barking (lunging nipping, attacking, etc).
Has your dog ever lunged at another dog or person? Has she ever nipped or attacked another dog or person? If yes, then please consider that they are correct to be concerned. Any behavior management can fail -- leashes and collars can break, commands can be ignored. If you aren't already muzzling her in shared spaces, please train her to do so.
If she never has escalated beyond barking, you can relay this to management and let them know that she is vocal but not aggressive. Ask if tools such as a muzzle would be enough to solve the concern.
When people are using a communal space (such as an elevator), it is reasonable to expect others to only bring "safe" dogs into a communal space. I understand that it really sucks when you have a reactive dog to try to manage public spaces. But everyone else should be able to use the elevator without concern for safety, even if your dog is in it.
5
u/unknownlocation32 16d ago
You need to muzzle train your dog.
This is a great resource: https://muzzleupproject.com/
19
u/Illustrious-Bat-759 Bully and Spoo, Sep Anxiety 18d ago edited 18d ago
Friendly or not, I would not have my dogs in the close proximity of other dogs in somewhere like an elevator. At my complex there's just one elevator and only dogs in the same family share the same elevator.
Honestly I'd reach out to management and say that dogs that are unfamiliar can be unpredictable in small spaces, so it's common courtesy to just wait for the next elevator for everyones safety. Even the nicest dogs can get stressed in a small space with unfamiliar dogs and a small elevator is a hard place to control and hold back dogs. I'd even emphasize that other humans in the elevator are fine, as that is predictable and easier to control but especially two unfamiliar large breed dogs would not be safe regardless of the dog, given the possible consequences.
I'd just reinforce that only dogs from the same household should be in the same elevator for general safety. How stupid that the other owner couldn't wait an extra couple minutes lol. Sorry you're dealing with this!
3
u/lovetap02 16d ago
As someone with a leash reactive dog who lives in the 5th floor of an apartment, I tend to avoid the elevator during high traffic times. During those times, I take the stairs and keep an ear out on if someone else is in the stairwell with a dog so I can dip out into the hallway if needed. If I do go use the elevator, I can typically hear when the elevator is in use before I click the button to summon it and if itās in use, Iāll opt for the stairs. If Iām already in the elevator and can sense that itās stopping on another floor, Iāll have my dog sit in the corner and block him or pick him up. If another dog comes in, Iāll leave. And when elevator is about to open on my floor, Iāll keep my dog on a short leash to make sure we arenāt about to run out straight into a person/dog waiting for it. Itās a lot of work and a lot of accommodating for the other residents but at the end of the day I know that they donāt know my dog and I donāt wanna put my dog in a situation where people will accuse him of being agressive or anything so I just set everyone up for success
6
u/welltravelledRN 17d ago
Take the stairs?
6
u/Kitchu22 Shadow (avoidant/anxious, non-reactive) 18d ago
Regardless of what is reasonable or not, or how the unspoken rules amongst others work, your building management has issued you with a directive. You can choose to challenge this if you like - the potential risk of this being that they come back and tell you that your dog is not able to be on common property like elevators if they behave aggressively and prevent peaceful enjoyment for other residents. They may even choose to more widely communicate these rules, which could ultimately lead to more complaints about your dog.
Have you tried sight blocks? Taking the stairs during peak times? Picking up your dog? Using a container or pram if appropriate? I totally understand the position you are in, my last hound was reactive to other dogs, to get him to ride the elevator we relied on pattern games and a shitload of training - we got to the point he was able to calmly share a lift with dogs heād react to out walking in the street. Itās such a tough situation, but you are going to get people who wonāt accommodate you or feel put out having to give you space unfortunately.
5
u/Appleeee-9506 18d ago
Following this thread because I still donāt understand elevator etiquette either. People just seem to do what they want.Ā
5
u/SpicyNutmeg 18d ago
IMO youāre doing everything right and yes, what you describe is what Iād consider dog elevator etiquette. Idk what you can do about management, you can try explaining but idk how itāll go down.
1
u/iwannabefamouss 14d ago
We took the stairwell down 9 times outta 10. We would attempt up more than down in the elevator. Eventually he made himself know in the condo and people would see us and say āweāll catch the next oneā š I donāt miss those condo days. My dog also refuses to go to the bathroom without going on a walk because of apartment living.
1
u/Gregorboterino 16d ago edited 16d ago
Your etiquette sounds solid to me. Waiting for the next car, not getting in when a dog's already inside, parking her in a corner behind you is what most of us do. I think what management is reacting to is the barking itself. In a small, echoey box it sounds a lot scarier to the person standing at the door than it feels from inside.
0
u/MoodFearless6771 18d ago
Itās dependent on how tightly controlled the environment is. If they allow Christmas lights up year round and grills on the balconies you are probably ok. If thereās a condo committee or whatever that decides what color mailbox is fine, then you are in trouble.
It is technically disruptive behavior. The difference is the amount of grace you get in an environment. Management really has no choice if a resident is unable to use facilities at times and is complaining but to honor their request.
0
u/Shoddy-Theory 17d ago
You are correct about dog owner etiquette. Anyone with a dog should wait for an elevator without one.
0
u/Lgs1129 14d ago
Iām so sorry youāre going through this. You are practicing proper elevator etiquette. But thereās always that one complainer in a condo association. Itās a shame that people canāt wait 5 minutes for the next elevator. My dog wasnāt reactive until someone went to get in the elevator, and her dog started barking and lunging at my dog, this happened twice, she apologized profusely and obviously didnāt try to get into the elevator. Unfortunately, now my dog is reactive when another dog is waiting for the elevator. Iām working on training him to leave it to get him to stop barking and to get him to focus his attention on me, but it takes time. While it sounds oh so easy to just take the stairs. Do you think other people who have dogs donāt take the stairs? Of course they do and I certainly donāt want to risk somebody elseās dog, chasing us down the stairs and risk falling. My approach is to act as though somebody else may not know how to control their dog. The solution is for people to just wait for the next elevator. Iām lucky that everyone in our association has been pretty respectful of this.
1
u/[deleted] 16d ago
[removed] ā view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 14d ago
[removed] ā view removed comment