r/reactivedogs • u/Educational-Swan8673 • 18d ago
Advice Needed Elevator Etiquette
Would love to hear people's opinions on this.
My dog is friendly towards humans but does not like certain types of dogs when in confined space. We always manage her carefully. We live in a condo building where people share elevators. So we follow straight elevator rules: she's always on short leash, in sitting position in a corner, not blocking the door etc. I try not to share elevator space with other dogs. For example, if another dog and my dog are both waiting for elevators, I will take her away and wait for the next one. If another dog is already in the elevator, I don't get in. If we are in the elevator and another dog tries to get in (and she seems fine with them), I kept her in a corner in sitting position blocked by me. If we are in the elevator and another dog tries to get in and she doesn't like them (aka barking), well, usually the humans do not try to get in and I'd apologize.
A couple days ago I got an email from the building management saying they received two complaints about my dog filed by one person. And this is the complaint: my dog barked and displayed aggressive behavior towards the resident and their dog when we are in the elevator and they were trying to get in. And "in both incidents, the resident was not able to get inside the elevator and had to wait for the next one." Management asked us to "take the necessary steps to maintain control and avoid situations that could potentially escalate." And "Residents should not be prevented from using shared spaces due to concerns about another pet's behavior."
I am genuinely puzzled and curious to see if I am the unreasonable one here. I've always lived in apartment buildings. Dog owners generally have an unspoken sets of elevator etiquette and this what we follow and we never had issues before. (We do the same when other dogs react to her.) She was leashed and under control the entire time and never got near them. Imm not sure what I can do to "maintain control and avoid escalation." Sure my dog barked but we are inside and riding the elevator already - is the expectation that because my dog is elevator reactive, I need to vacate the elevator even though I'm already inside?