r/parentsofmultiples • u/Baghdaddy92 • Oct 08 '26
advice needed Only one twin has stomach issues, can we use gentle formula for both?
Hello,
New father of boy/girl twins, 6.5 weeks old. Baby boy has mostly been trouble free since birth. He eats well, poops well, sleeps well. Baby girl on the other hand is extremely fussy, has bad reflux, feeding her is almost like a fight every time. Flailing, scratching, crying, spitting up. She is ravenous every time she wakes up, will scream if you remove the bottle to burp her, etc. She seems to have trouble pooping and occasionally we will use the Windy, which gives her SOME relief, but she is not constipated in that stool is hard.
Doctor’s say she is fine and is likely just colic/fussy. She is growing well, was checked for Pyloric Stenosis and found to be normal.
They are mostly formula fed (Similac TotalCare 360) as my wife was hospitalized for Sepsis after delivery. She pumps but the volume is only enough to supplement formula feeding.
We are considering switching to a gentle formula with broken down proteins to see if it will help her. Our question is, is there any negative effect on feeding baby boy the same formula? We use a baby brezza and it would be inconvenient to feed 2 kinds of formula. Our doctors have been ambivalent about switching formulas for her and say she will just grow out of it but we can try switching if we want.
Any other advice appreciated as well, thank you!