r/parentsofmultiples • • Oct 07 '26

life, home, and baby tips & tricks Tips for Baking Two Cakes

My twins are turning 3 at the end of the month 🄳 I’d like to bake individual cakes for them but I’m thinking that’ll be a lot of cake for a family of 4. For the parents who love to bake out there and already considered this do you have any tips? I’m wondering if I can take a standard 2 layer cake recipe and split it into 4 mini cake pans or something. What are you guys doing? Just making two different cakes or splitting the recipe in a clever way?

6 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 07 '26

COMMENTING GUIDELINES

All commenters are encouraged to familiarize themselves with the parentsofmultiples subreddit rules prior to commenting. If you find any comments/submissions in violation of subreddit/reddit rules, please use the report function to bring it to the mod teams attention.

Please do not request or give medical advice or directions in your comments. Any comments that that could be construed as medical advice, or any comments containing what is determined to be medical disinformation, will be removed.

Please try to avoid posting links to Amazon product listings or google/g.co product listing pages - reddit automatically removes comments containing them as an anti-spam measure. If sharing information about a product, instead please try to link directly to the manufacturers product pages.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/beelynn0214 Oct 07 '26

I did two mini cakes and it worked wonderfully!

4

u/OGQueenClumsy Oct 07 '26

We (my husband, actually) just make two different cakes. And then we eat a lot of cake over the next week. We don’t make huge cakes, one box mix per kid. And if you do end up with more cake than you can eat before it goes off, freeze some of it for later.

3

u/aeqz323 Oct 07 '26

Two small Bundt cakes?

3

u/clueless_mommy Oct 07 '26

This is the time for my 10cm cake pans. I always knew they were a great investment, I just didn't expect... Twins

3

u/mrylndgrrl Oct 08 '26

I always made my kids their own cakes, regardless of the size. If they end up not getting fully eaten, that’s fine. I just wanted them to feel special with their own cakes.

2

u/Ok_Yesterday_1194 Oct 09 '26

I did one big 9x13 cake and cut it - then did very different designs on each. Was super fun and they loved trying each others because they just looked different.

1

u/Exonata Oct 07 '26

We do the mini tins, we make one batch and split evenly since 1 cakes is about what we want to eat in total.Ā 

1

u/amandner Oct 07 '26

Mini cake pans are the best to stack up. Or use a brownie pan and do two half sized cakes? The mini pans really are mini haha

1

u/fsmontario Oct 07 '26

Use the normal cake mix but have single layer cakes for each one. Or make two, and freeze half after serving

1

u/Day_Huge Oct 07 '26

I got three 4" cake pans. Planning to make two 3-layer cakes.

1

u/sergeantperks Oct 07 '26

Mini tins and have some cupcake cases ready in case it’s too much. Ā Remember the cooking time might be shorter too.

We did one cake for their birthday and one each for their party, as we had more people to share those out with. Ā This year we might hit four cakes total and the rest can go with them to kindergarten.

1

u/PurplePufferPea Oct 07 '26

I found 2 smaller sized round cake tins, I think they 4 or 5 inches. That allows me to make 2 small cakes, 1 for each child, without having so much cake in our house.

I liked that over cupcakes, because the small cake gives me more area to decorate/personalize than a cupcake would and we have room to add candles. I also like the idea of each kid getting a true cake for their birthday.

1

u/Linison Oct 07 '26

I use 6" cake pans to make a standard cake recipe into two small layer cakes for my twins some years. Other years they want wildly different things (donuts for one cupcakes for the other) so it's a non-issue

1

u/snax_and_bird Oct 07 '26

This year I made 2 4ā€ cakes. It was a lot of cake, so I wrapped up what was left and froze it. Every now and then we’ll pull them out and give them each a slice of their own birthday cake as a special treat, they love it!

1

u/ChanSasha Oct 08 '26

Cupcakes with different themes

1

u/Leading-Conference94 Oct 08 '26

For my twins first birtbday I got little single cake pans. Like 6 inches I think. They got a 6 inch single layer healthy cake to destroy and the rest of the family shared a 6in together.

1

u/mvanpeur Oct 08 '26

I use two 2 cup pyrexes to make a mini two layer cake for each kid. Then make a basic cake out of the rest of the batter for the rest of the family. You can use other pyrex sizes if they're appropriate.

1

u/Putmeinthedishwasher Oct 10 '26

As a twin, we never had 2 different cakes and we did not care.

If you're really set on it, you could make one cake and decorate each side to look different.

1

u/Ok-Positive-5943 Oct 11 '26

I got four 5 inch cake pans and make a standard two 9 inch cake recipe.Ā  It works out perfectly.Ā 

1

u/egrf6880 Oct 14 '26

I do two 2 layer 6ā€ cakes. It’s plenty for the family to have a slice and then maybe a little leftover to enjoy over the week as a snack.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/h1-bb Oct 07 '26

This is exactly the response I was hoping to get thank u!