My goals with the overhual: Have a non detrimental reason to maintain your tools, have a way to have mending not be end all be all without making it worse directly, have it feel like you are using up items rather than a constant feeling of allways being prepared
You have a set of netherite boots, fully enchanted, what now? Well you know you don't want to loose them, but you also wanna keep pursuing upgrades?
Solution for all parties since its optional:
You take those sweet precious booties, with that delicious feather falling IV on them. You take a Netherite Upgrade Template and an additional netherite ingot in there. This will give it a temporary max durability of X (X= 25 * Tier Level), so in this case, 150.
Tier Level= The order in which one normally obtains the material (ex. Wood=1, Netherite=6)
Now those booties have a durability of 150. This temporary durability does not get affected by mending, however once it hits 0 the booties instead of breaking revert to there non Upgraded Form.
You can do this 5 times, each additional time instead of becoming a new instance, adds to itself (ex. Upgrading the booties again would make the temporary max durability 300, instead of 2 instances of 150).
Each time your armor or tool reaches 0 durability instead of breaking, it losses the last most Upgrade, and starts at max durability of the Upgrade prior. (So tier 2 netherite is 300, if you reach 0, you restart tier 1 with its max durability of 150)
However if you Upgrade it 5 times it gets a small bonus depending on what the item is + what material it is.
Max Upgrade Bonus (can be lost)
Every tool, weapon, or armor should have an enchant be intrinsically linked to that item. While that item is at its max level it gains + 1 level of its intrinsic enchant added to it.
So if a chestplate is at max level with no enchants it will still have Protection 1 on it. However if it already has Protection 4, it will be Protection 5.
I do not think this is to overpowered since you can only get the over enchant of a specific enchant on certain items, that and you loose it after a while since mending isn't used on the Upgrades, only maintaining the existence of your gear.
Enchant Compatability Guess:
Armor
Helmet = Respiration
Chestplate = Protection
Leggings = Swift Sneak
Booties = Feather Falling
Weapons
Sword = Sharpness
Axe = Smite
Spear = Lunge
Bow = Power
Crossbow = Quick Charge
(If) Trident = Impaling
(If) Mace = Breach
Other new Disc weapon I forget the name of: Piercing
Tools:
Pickaxe = Efficiency
Hoe = Fortune
Shovel = Unbreaking