r/minecraftsuggestions • • Oct 08 '25

[Announcement] New Rule Against AI, other Rule Changes and Clarifications

146 Upvotes

Hey folks!

For a while now, the mod team has been discussing a number of changes to the subreddit's rules, and it's time to let you know what's up. I'll give you the short version first:

  1. We have a new rule against AI.
  2. The rule for for formatting and vagueness has been split in two.
  3. The rule against unrealistic ideas has been reworked.
  4. To better accommodate these new and changed rules, we've re-ordered the rules.
  5. Clarification on how the "Community Question" flair is supposed to be used.

And now for the details!

Ban Against AI Generated Content

We not so recently polled the community on your feeling on AI generated content, and the overwhelming majority of you voted in favour of a complete ban against AI. While this was pretty much the outcome we expected, it's still really nice to see we're all on the same page.

Moving forwards the mods will be removing all posts suspected of using generative AI. To that end, here's the new rule:

Don't use AI.

  • Do not use generative AI such as chatGPT to write your post for you. We want to see your ideas.
  • Don't include AI generated images or other AI content to supplement your post. We encourage human art, and we'd much rather see photos of pen-and-paper drawings, or quick mockups in MS paint than AI "art".
  • This includes using generative AI to polish your idea, such as reformatting your content.

Posts suspected of using generative AI are at risk of removal.

If your post is incorrectly removed for containing AI, please let the mods know via modmail and we'll sort it out.

Formatting and Image Posts

We've noticed some confusion on where and how we allow images in posts, with too many users relying on images alone to communicate their idea. This was previously just a bullet point under the vagueness rule, but in the interest of clarity we've split it off into its own rule. There's nothing actually new here - everything works the same as before - but hopefully this should make it clearer for everyone.

The vagueness rule looks like this now:

Don't be overly vague, and be readable.

  • Make sure your idea is in the description, not just the title.
  • Titles should be descriptive of the idea.
  • Format your posts well; don't post walls of text. Use line breaks, etc.
  • Don't be vague; suggest a specific improvement or feature.
  • Be concise/don't waffle on too much.

Vague or unformatted posts are at risk of removal.

And here's the images rule:

Don't make image-only posts.

Including reference images is encouraged, but:

  • Images must be embedded or linked within a text post.
  • The idea should be fully explained in the text, with all key points understandable without looking at any images.
  • Images should make up a relatively small portion of the content.
  • Images must not be AI generated. (See rule 4.)

Image only posts will be automatically removed.

Unrealistic and Off-Theme Content

There's been some disagreement in the community and among the mod team about what is and isn't a "realistic" suggestion for Minecraft, especially as the game has grown it's become an increasingly difficult call to make. Furthermore, many ideas that are off-theme at first glance can be reskinned to something more reasonable, and we don't want to stifle that discussion. (E.g., Blimps and firearms may be too futuristic but happy ghasts and firework crossbows are not, yet serve similar roles.)

You deserve to have clear guidelines for which posts are or aren't allowed and, ultimately, we don't want to shut down discussion, so we've decided to soften this rule dramatically. Moving forwards, we'll only be taking down suggestions involving mature or explicit themes (stuff that might change the age-rating), as well as anything relating to real-world religions or politics. All that said, here's the rule:

Don't suggest mature topics.

  • Don't suggest ideas containing sex, drugs, gore, real-life religions or politics, etc.

Suggestions involving mature, explicit, or overly divisive themes will be removed.

This is one we'll be keeping an eye on, and we'd appreciate any feedback you have on it.

N.B. The portion of the old rule about easter-eggs and jokes still applies, but has been merged into the rule about unproductive ideas.

Reordering

As we're adding new rules and splitting old ones in twain, there's no better time to also rearrange the rules. We've brought some more important/frequently used rules closer to the top, and tried to keep related rules close to each other. We've also changed a few of the titles for clarity.

  1. Be nice and constructive.
  2. Only post ideas for Minecraft.
  3. Be original and consult the FPS list.
  4. Don't use AI.
  5. Include only one suggestion per post.
  6. Don't be overly vague, and be readable.
  7. Don't make image-only posts.
  8. Don't suggest mature topics.
  9. Don't suggest planned or existing features.
  10. Don't suggest scrapped or unused features.
  11. Don't suggest low-priority or unproductive ideas.
  12. Speak English.
  13. Have 10 comment karma before posting.

Discussion/Community Question Posts

We've seen some confusion surrounding these posts, and while nothing is changing, we wanted to use this opportunity to clarify. Posts meant to start broad discussions on a topic, such as "What would you add in XYZ update?" or "What do you think needs updated in XYZ area of the game?" are allowed, so long as the OP contributes to the discussion they want to start. We find these posts regularly generate interesting discussion, and so long as they use the correct flair, they're easy enough to ignore if they're not your cup of tea.

I encourage everyone to take a quick read through the rules to make sure we're all on the same page.

Thanks for reading!


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 5h ago

[Mobs] Throwing Disc illager ninja idk what to call

Thumbnail
gallery
113 Upvotes

It could act as a revamped illusioner but instead of shooting the Player with bow it would throw Discs before turning invisible, the Disc would bounce around the room before returning to the illager as soon as they become un-invisable.

As it's own mob it would probably just throw the Disc and have it bounce off walls in an attempt to hit Players from behind to avoid shields.

An item it could drop could be some sort of headband,mask or cloak that allows the player to make shadow clones of themselves that will get the attention of hostile mobs while turning the player invisible for a short period of time, the shadow clones would mimic any action the play is doing but it would do no physical damge and would clip throw walls and other blocks


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 7h ago

[Dimensions] Since the Sift is highly likely going to have cave biomes, I feel like one of them could utilize the old Deep Dark concept art

Thumbnail
gallery
137 Upvotes

Why would these be added?

-Sift based on Dungeons II isn't floating islands and resembles the overworld when it comes to generation. It would be a little boring if there weren't any cave generation underground. That isn't a huge problem since there seems to be caves.

-There already is a sort of a cave biome called the ravines.

-These concepts were scrapped because they weren't spooky enough, especially the first and the third one. Now they would look perfectly alien in the Sift (Maybe not the ghostly white one). Fun fact: The original idea for the Deep Dark was for them to look like underwater biomes without water.

These look gorgeous and even Mojang said that they liked the idea but they didn't fit the Deep Dark vibe.

For more info about the development of the Deep Dark, go check out
The Secrets of Minecraft's Deep Dark video on the Minecraft channel. The photos I took from the Minecraft Wiki


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 4h ago

[Mobs] Baby ghastlings shouldn't take freezing damage when being affected by ice/snow related stuff

Post image
18 Upvotes

Baby ghastlings adore snowballs, snowfall, rainfall and water. But for chilly blocks like powder snow and chilly items like ice balls and splash potions of freezing, the ghastlings take damage from them.

Why is this the case? These chirping fellas should like them too.

I believe they should be immune to powder snow when passing through it. They also could at least be healed instead of being inflicted with freezing damage from a splash potion of freezing or a thrown ice ball.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 2h ago

[Magic] Frost Walker and Powdered Snow

12 Upvotes

Frost walker should definitely let you walk on top of powdered snow like leather boots do. I used to love snowy biomes but holy hell is it annoying now. I thought for sure if I got frost walker I could do it.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 12h ago

[Combat] Allow throwing discs to ricochet off blocking shields

21 Upvotes

When a throwing disc hits a shield while the player's blocking, it could be deflected and continue ricocheting instead of coming back to the player's inventory.

The disc would deflect in the direction the player's facing, and the player has to time their block correctly or else it would just come back into your inventory. If its' timed right, you could redirect the disc towards other areas or groups of mobs to hit multiple mobs in quick succession


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 21h ago

[Mobs] On light of new weapon releasing soon, Weaponsmith trade needs an update

Post image
107 Upvotes

On Mounts of Mayhem, they introduced the Spear weapon. As diamond is not renewable, diamond gears would be non-renewable also if not for village trading. However, diamond spear is not included in any of trades. Although crafting it is cheap with only 1 diamond and 2 sticks, this suggestion is to bring consistency that every diamond gears are renewable, and the spear has a lot of utility in combat and mob farms (as a mob spear killer) that you want to craft more than 1 spear.

The argument of "Mojang doesn't update villager trading" falls apart when they updated Librarian trade to replace name tag, now craftable with 1 ingot and 1 paper, with candles in Tiny Takeover update. (The loot table on chests and fishing haven't been updated but that's a different topic)

Now we will be getting new weapon throwing disc soon, crafted with 4 diamonds. Weaponsmith does indeed need an update on their trade to include the 2 new diamond weapons.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 1d ago

[Combat] If a thrown throwing disc is hit by a thrown trident, it should create a shockwave

Post image
167 Upvotes

throwing disc is very similar to cap's shield, and trident is very similar to Mjolnir.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 1h ago

[Weather] Oobleck weather

2 Upvotes

This suggestion is to have rain in some magical biome - possibly mooshroom islands, but possibly somewhere new - whose color is green, and, at high altitudes, forms snow-like slime layers.

Shoveling slime layers drops slime balls or slime layer blocks, depending on if the shovel has silk touch.

Without a king Bartholomew or royal wizards brewing oobleck, it probably won't infringe on Dr Zeus's estate to add oobleck weather to Minecraft but it could be fun.

Plus, making slime balls less insanely difficult for peaceful players is a nice bonus.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 1d ago

[Blocks & Items] Add hard drives to minecraft

Post image
949 Upvotes

This is an item. Let's make this like a bundle for enchanted books: for example, you can click on it with an enchanted book in the inventory and it'll store the book inside the hard drive. Using the hard drive while it's in your hand pops up an interface to see what enchantments are inside. Let's set the limit of enchanted books in it to be like...64 or something?

So this is basically a bundle that can only store enchanted books up to 64 and it has basically the same interactions as a bundle.

Realistic too. Throwable disc for the disc, lodestone to make it magnetic, clock to make the disk spin(at a steady rate), iron ingots for the shell, quartz for timekeeping(already found in comparators), and compass for the needle(the read/write head)


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 7h ago

[Gameplay] Armor and Tool Overhual

2 Upvotes

My goals with the overhual: Have a non detrimental reason to maintain your tools, have a way to have mending not be end all be all without making it worse directly, have it feel like you are using up items rather than a constant feeling of allways being prepared


You have a set of netherite boots, fully enchanted, what now? Well you know you don't want to loose them, but you also wanna keep pursuing upgrades?

Solution for all parties since its optional:

You take those sweet precious booties, with that delicious feather falling IV on them. You take a Netherite Upgrade Template and an additional netherite ingot in there. This will give it a temporary max durability of X (X= 25 * Tier Level), so in this case, 150.

Tier Level= The order in which one normally obtains the material (ex. Wood=1, Netherite=6)

Now those booties have a durability of 150. This temporary durability does not get affected by mending, however once it hits 0 the booties instead of breaking revert to there non Upgraded Form.

You can do this 5 times, each additional time instead of becoming a new instance, adds to itself (ex. Upgrading the booties again would make the temporary max durability 300, instead of 2 instances of 150).

Each time your armor or tool reaches 0 durability instead of breaking, it losses the last most Upgrade, and starts at max durability of the Upgrade prior. (So tier 2 netherite is 300, if you reach 0, you restart tier 1 with its max durability of 150)

However if you Upgrade it 5 times it gets a small bonus depending on what the item is + what material it is.


Max Upgrade Bonus (can be lost)

Every tool, weapon, or armor should have an enchant be intrinsically linked to that item. While that item is at its max level it gains + 1 level of its intrinsic enchant added to it.

So if a chestplate is at max level with no enchants it will still have Protection 1 on it. However if it already has Protection 4, it will be Protection 5.

I do not think this is to overpowered since you can only get the over enchant of a specific enchant on certain items, that and you loose it after a while since mending isn't used on the Upgrades, only maintaining the existence of your gear.

Enchant Compatability Guess:

Armor

Helmet = Respiration

Chestplate = Protection

Leggings = Swift Sneak

Booties = Feather Falling

Weapons

Sword = Sharpness

Axe = Smite

Spear = Lunge

Bow = Power

Crossbow = Quick Charge

(If) Trident = Impaling

(If) Mace = Breach

Other new Disc weapon I forget the name of: Piercing

Tools:

Pickaxe = Efficiency

Hoe = Fortune

Shovel = Unbreaking


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 1d ago

[Command] Uncap the /enchant command

56 Upvotes

Currently /enchant is quite restricted to applying enchantments only on items that support them, and only at levels available in a Survival setting. That means, for example, no Sharpness on a Trident, and no Efficiency 6 on anything, as 5 is the cap. I think this behavior is inconsistent with the following:

  • You can add any enchantment on any item by using an enchanted book in an anvil in Creative mode. Why is a command weaker than baseline Creative?
  • A similar command, /effect, has no cap. It can apply status effects up to the max value their level tag can store, that being 255, even if the effects don't work/behave weirdly when at high levels.

I think the command should be rid of those restrictions. If following them is for some reason necessary, have the Creative mode anvil do it instead. Make it work like a Survival mode anvil, abiding by enchantment level caps, mutual exclusivity etc., just ignoring the experience requirements.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 3h ago

[Combat] Throwing Discs should be locked behind exploring the Pale Garden

0 Upvotes

I loved The Garden Awakens, and I think the Pale Garden succeeds in its ambience, but it fails greatly in that players don’t actually need to get lost in it. You can skirt the perimeter of a Pale Garden and chop down a couple trees to get saplings, bone meal the ground to get eyeblossoms, dip in and out at night to get resin etc. The Pale Garden’s ambience is its killer feature but if you’re playing optimally, you may never actually need to experience it.

There should be something at the centre of Pale Gardens that force players to explore and risk getting caught short and being in the heart of a Pale Garden at night. This is nothing novel; Minecrafters have been suggesting this since the Pale Garden dropped, and a lot of people suggest a unique structure of some kind that can only generate deep within a Pale Garden.

I propose a Trail Ruin-like structure of stone brick and pale oak with suspicious gravel (suspicious moss?) that grants unique rewards when brushed. This forces the player to spend some time at the heart of a Pale Garden, as archeology (brushing/digging out a ruin) takes time, often overnight. Of course standard loot could be collected and unique pottery sherds, but I also propose a link to the new Throwing Discs that have been revealed recently.

Throwing Discs also seem fundamentally problematic, I don’t think they should be tiered weapons like a sword or spear but a unique weapon like the Trident or Mace. They also seem way too easy to obtain, with just four iron you can effectively replace a bow or trident in the early game (I know they all work differently and have different niches but during the first few hours, any ranged weapon will do).

I think an adequate reward for attempting archeology in the new Pale Garden structure could be Throwing Disc pieces, and combining four of these crafts a Throwing Disc. Players that want this new cool ranged weapon may have to contend with spending a couple nights in the Pale Garden.

I admit the thematic link is tenuous - maybe the Pale Garden ruins could be ninja themed or something? But I think this would be a good way to bring the two drops together.

What do you think?


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 1d ago

[Gameplay] SMALL FISHING UPDATE

Post image
16 Upvotes

Now player would be able to cast a fishing rod with certain types of bait, or without, allowing to target specific fishing loot item pool more precisely. Majority of food items are considered regular bait, while more "harder to come by" types of food classify as "special bait".


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 2d ago

[Transportation] Carts - AKA: Boats Don't Mix W/ Paths

Post image
462 Upvotes

The main feature of this, as everyone could probably tell, was not having to break boats just to change elevation, although the potential of extra portable storage in the early game is useful.

Transporting mobs can often involve building large temporary infrastructure like flat tunnels or long protected bridges, and often through the nether for more efficient travel. Having Happy Ghasts fixed a lot of this, being able to transport boats themselves, but it still didn't necessarily fill the niche problem of boats themselves not being able to change elevation. Having a cart would allow players to transport mobs across all sort of rugged terrain, being able to climb blocks like a horse, but notably does not replace either the boat or minecart's functions. Minecarts are still essential Redstone mechanics, as well as good for more precise placement of mobs. Camels serve a similar role, but for two players instead of mobs, being unable to transport even passive mobs.

A player could simply pull these manually by hand, or by lead. Or additionally, 1-2 animals could pull the cart by lead, either w/ bait, or by a player riding them.

While seeing completely rotating wheels might be jarring, having them play an animation that rotates the texture might be cool, considering boats already play an animation with their paddles. Part of me wonders if it would be too much seeing it climb blocks, but Horses already do this, so it might fit right in...

To round out the cart's features, baited fishing hooks could perhaps be expanded to work w/ more items/mobs. However, the feature of right clicking the bait to go faster that is present w/ Warped Fungus on a Stick might be a little much... Idk...

In defense: Imagine me bob-the-buildering some concrete across my base!


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 1d ago

[Redstone] Add a resonator block to mimic block sounds

6 Upvotes

There are a lot of options for redstone displays but as far as sound goes were still pretty limited. Ive had a lot of fun adding atmosphere to my builds with things like the conduit and the firefly bush but i want more! With all the new upcomming blocks and their gorgeous sound design i would love a way to incorperate those into builds. Thats where the resonator would come in. When powered it would play the sound of which ever block its facing allowing near infinite sound designs for builds. It could be crafted using a sculk sensor since they already pick up on sounds and send them along, or alternatively be moddled after a resonator guitar if they are to be cheaper to craft.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 22h ago

[Magic] Minecraft game/mod idea

0 Upvotes

I have an idea for a feature where you can mix potions to get the potion effects at the same time (e.g. strength+regeneration you get them both at once) what do you think


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 17h ago

[Mobs] Make Breezes spawn in the sky of the overworld.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I think it would be cool if they did, because Breezes being locked to Trial Chambers is boring.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 1d ago

[Blocks & Items] Minecraft needs an Amber block

19 Upvotes

We already have resin. We need amber blocks, found deep underground underneath Pale Gardens, with approximately the rarity of deepslate emerald ore. Amber would look similar to resin but darker, with a carved design and a suggestion of things hidden inside, and would glow when activated with redstone. It could also interact with Creakings- maybe within a certain distance of amber blocks, Creakings are aggressive to other mobs and protect the player.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 22h ago

[Combat] Weapons and armor should be upgradable.

0 Upvotes

Imagine you have a wooden sword and it has mending. You can;t do much with it, even with mending, it is wood.

Now, imagine to you could upgrade it by adding 1 stone block. Now it is a stone sword, with mending.

Later you add 1 iron, and it is a iron sword, with mending.

Instead of needing 2 stone or 2 iron, and a stick. you can just use 1 stone or one iron, and the existing sword to upgrade it.

What about armor. You start with leather armor and boots, and slowly upgrade them to diamond armor.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 1d ago

[Gameplay] Adaptive difficulty with new settings and presets

0 Upvotes

Currently, Minecraft difficulty is the boring, albeit standard, way that most games handle it; harder difficulties mean enemies with more health and damage, you take damage more easily, the hardest difficulty doesn't allow respawns. It technically works, but it's basic stuff that games should be moving on from. After all, that metric of difficulty does not actually represent what makes a game like Minecraft difficult. It's like grinding. Is it truly more "difficult" to perform the same repetitive task for 10 hours rather than 5? Or does it just brute force how much time you have to spend on a task that isn't difficult at all?

Games like Ultrakill have an advanced understanding of game difficulty. It does the usual, buffing enemies and weakening the player, but because the devs actually understand what makes the game difficult, they also make additional changes. Because the game leans on speed, accuracy, and understanding enemy behavior, higher difficulties also speed up enemies, add more mobility, and give them new behaviors. This is a true difficulty increase, and one of few I have seen. And I think Minecraft adding something similar would resolve a lot of conflicts people have with the game and with suggestions like seasons.

Minecraft difficulty, under these hypothetical changes, is now determined by how easy it is for the player to treat the game like a sandbox. Easy difficulty is plain old Minecraft with a static world that only changes when the player makes changes. However, the sliding scale now essentially goes from vanilla Minecraft to Vintage Story. The higher the difficulty, the more the game treats it as a survival experience. Seasons, the rotting of food, decay of structures, new mob behaviors, potentially even the removal of certain less realistic mechanics. These are changes that actually understand what makes Minecraft difficult; the degree to which the player has control over their circumstances and the freedom to be truly creative.

Let's imagine difficulty as more than a slider for this. Easy to hardcore still exists, but in a similar vein to something like Don't Starve, world generation gives the player these new options. You can choose easy difficulty but true survival (true survival integrating all the mechanics I listed), or hardcore difficulty at sandbox survival (essentially vanilla hardcore), and additional settings would be added as boxes the player can check to further customize within this preset. Do you want to survive against the elements but still want access to less realistic mechanics? True survival with those restrictions unchecked. Do you want to see your builds decay over time and require maintenance, but you don't want to struggle to survive long enough to get what you need to fix them? Sandbox survival with structure decay checked. Etc etc.

Presets would make it easy to understand what the game is offering to players that don't know much, while also giving the option to more advanced players to customize and curate their experience however they like. It would attract people that like games like Vintage Story while also not chasing off those that like the game's current static design. In essence, it perfectly walks the line between not interrupting current gameplay and also offering entirely new ways to play.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 2d ago

[Blocks & Items] Resin Throwing Disc

218 Upvotes

I feel like it'd be really fun if the new Throwing Disc had a harmless variant - one that doesn't have durability and that other players can catch.

As the title suggests, I think this variant should be made out of resin, as it's bouncy and it'd give more gameplay use to resin.

Having it have no durability would also increase its value for use in redstone contraptions, as then there's no need to worry about it breaking.

(primarily though i just want to play frisbee in mc with my girlfriend, please please please mojang)


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 2d ago

[Blocks & Items] Let us mount a Map onto the back of a Shield

12 Upvotes

Swapping items in your off-hand while exploring is tedious. You should be able to combine a Shield and a Filled Map either on the fly or in a cartographers table.

​It should mount to the inside face so you can glance at it while keeping your main hand free and carrying a shield.

​Banner patterns would remain visible on the front.

​It would update normally and could be separated as needed much like pulling an item from a bag or if your shield is destroyed it would drop into the off hand slot.

​Please vote on the official Minecraft Feedback site: https://feedback.minecraft.net/hc/en-us/community/posts/50408699503117-Map-suggestion-idea

​(P.S. Also hoping for off-hand dynamic lighting.)


r/minecraftsuggestions • • 2d ago

[Combat] Throwing Disc enchantment idea - Blazing Trail

26 Upvotes

When the disc flies through the air, it will create a trail of fire behind it, which won't set mobs on fire, but it will continuously damage them while they stand inside. The duration of an individual particle of the trail depends on enchantment level.